Bessel's Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

Physics for IIT JAM, UGC - NET, CSIR NET

Created by: Akhilesh Thakur

Physics : Bessel's Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

The document Bessel's Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev is a part of the Physics Course Physics for IIT JAM, UGC - NET, CSIR NET.
All you need of Physics at this link: Physics

Bessel Functions of Nonintegral Order 

These different approaches are not exactly equivalent. The generating function approach is very convenient for deriving two recurrence relations, Bessel’s differential equation, integral representations, addition theorems, and upper and lower bounds. However, you will probably have noticed that the generating function defined only Bessel functions of integral order, J0 ,J1 ,J2 , and so on. This is a limitation of the generating function approach that can be avoided by using the contour integral instead, thus leading to foregoing approach (3). But the Bessel function of the first kind, Jν (x ), may easily be defined for nonintegral ν by using the series (Eq. (11.5)) as a new definition.
The recurrence relations may be verified by substituting in the series form of Jν (x ). From these relations Bessel’s equation follows. In fact, if ν is not an integer, there is actually an important simplification. It is found that Jν and J−ν are independent, for no relation of the form of Eq. (11.8) exists. On the other hand, for ν = n, an integer, we need another solution. 

ORTHOGONALITY

If Bessel’s equation, Eq. (11.22a), is divided by ρ , we see that it becomes self-adjoint, and therefore, by the Sturm–Liouville theory, Section 10.2, the solutions are expected to be orthogonal — if we can arrange to have appropriate boundary conditions satisfied. To take care of the boundary conditions for a finite interval [0,a ], we introduce parameters a and ανm into the argument of Jν to get Jν νm ρ/a ).Here a is the upper limit of the cylindrical radial coordinate ρ . From Eq. (11.22a),

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

Changing the parameter ανm to ανn , we find that Jννn ρ/a ) satisfies

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

Proceeding as in Section 10.2, we multiply Eq. (11.45) by Jννn ρ/a ) and Eq. (11.45a) by Jννm ρ/a ) and subtract, obtaining

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

Integrating from ρ = 0 to ρ = a , we obtain

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

Upon integrating by parts, we see that the left-hand side of Eq. (11.47) becomes F

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

This gives us orthogonality over the interval [0,a ].


 Normalization

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

Bessel Series

If we assume that the set of Bessel functions Jννm ρ /a ))(ν fixed, m = 1, 2, 3,...)is complete, then any well-behaved but otherwise arbitrary function f(ρ ) may be expanded in a Bessel series (Bessel–Fourier or Fourier–Bessel)

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev


Example 11.2.1 ELECTROSTATIC POTENTIAL IN A HOLLOW CYLINDER 

From Table 9.3 of Section 9.3 (with α replaced by k ), our solution of Laplace’s equation in circular cylindrical coordinates is a linear combination of

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

The particular linear combination is determined by the boundary conditions to be satisfied.
Our cylinder here has a radius a and a height l . The top end section has a potential distribution ψ(ρ, ϕ ). Elsewhere on the surface the potential is zero. The problem is to find the electrostatic potential

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

everywhere in the interior.
For convenience, the circular cylindrical coordinates are placed as shown in Fig. 11.3.
Since Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRevThe z dependence becomes sinh kz, vanishing at z = 0. The requirement that ψ = 0 on the cylindrical sides is met by requiring the separation constant k to be 

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

where the first subscript, m, gives the index of the Bessel function, whereas the second subscript identifies the particular zero of Jm .
The electrostatic potential becomes

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

Equation (11.56) is a double series: a Bessel series in ρ and a Fourier series in ϕ .
At z = l, ψ = ψ(ρ, ϕ ), a known function of ρ and ϕ . Therefore

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

The constants amn and bmn are evaluated by using Eqs. (11.49) and (11.50) and the corresponding equations for sin ϕ and cos ϕ (Example 10.2.1 and Eqs. (14.2), (14.3), (14.15) to (14.17)). We find 14

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

These are definite integrals, that is, numbers. Substituting back into Eq. (11.56), the series is specified and the potential ψ(ρ, ϕ , z) is determined.

 

Continuum Form

The Bessel series, Eq. (11.51)  apply to expansions over the finite interval [0,a ].If a →∞, then the series forms may be expected to go over into integrals.
The discrete roots ανm become a continuous variable α . A similar situation is encountered in the Fourier series,
For operations with a continuum of Bessel functions, Jν (αρ ), a key relation is the Bessel function closure equation,

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

This may be proved by the use of Hankel transforms.  An alternate approach, starting from a relation similar to Eq. (10.82), is given by Morse and Feshbach.
A second kind of orthogonality (varying the index) is developed for spherical Bessel functions.

NEUMANN FUNCTIONS,BESSEL FUNCTIONS OF THE SECOND KIND

From the theory of ODEs it is known that Bessel’s equation has two independent solutions.
Indeed, for nonintegral order ν we have already found two solutions and labeled them Jν (x ) and J−ν (x ), using the infinite series (Eq. (11.5)). The trouble is that when ν is integral, Eq. (11.8) holds and we have but one independent solution. A second solution may be developed by the methods of Section 9.6. This yields a perfectly good second solution of Bessel’s equation but is not the standard form.

 

Definition and Series Form 

As an alternate approach, we take the particular linear combination of Jν (x ) and J−ν (x )

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

This is the Neumann function (Fig. 11.5).15 For nonintegral ν, Nν (x ) clearly satisfies Bessel’s equation, for it is a linear combination of known solutions Jν (x ) and J−ν (x ).

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

FIGURE 11.5 Neumann functions N0 (x ), N1 (x ), and N2 (x ).

Substituting the power-series Eq. (11.6) for n → ν (given in Exercise 11.1.7) yields

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

for ν> 0. However, for integral ν, ν = n, Eq. (11.8) applies and Eq. (11.60) becomes indeterminate. The definition of Nν (x ) was chosen deliberately for this indeterminate property. Again substituting the power series and evaluating Nν (x ) for ν → 0 by l’Hôpital’s rule for indeterminate forms, we obtain the limiting value

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

for n = 0 and x → 0 , using

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev(11.63)

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

Equations (11.62) and (11.64) exhibit the logarithmic dependence that was to be expected.
This, of course, verifies the independence of Jn and Nn .


Other Forms

As with all the other Bessel functions, Nν (x ) has integral representations. For N0 (x ) we have

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

These forms can be derived as the imaginary part of the Hankel representations of Exercise 11.4.7. The latter form is a Fourier cosine transform.
To verify that Nν (x ), our Neumann function (Fig. 11.5) or Bessel function of the second kind, actually does satisfy Bessel’s equation for integral n, we may proceed as follows.
L’Hôpital’s rule applied to Eq. (11.60) yields

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

Multiplying the equation for J−ν by (−1)ν , subtracting from the equation for Jν (as suggested by Eq. (11.65)), and taking the limit ν → n, we obtain

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev (11.68)

It is seen from Eqs. (11.62) and (11.64) that Nn diverges, at least logarithmically. Any boundary condition that requires the solution to be finite at the origin (as in our vibrating circular membrane (Section 11.1)) automatically excludes Nn (x ). Conversely, in the absence of such a requirement, Nn (x ) must be considered.
To a certain extent the definition of the Neumann function Nn (x ) is arbitrary. Equations (11.62) and (11.64) contain terms of the form an Jn (x ). Clearly, any finite value of the constant an would still give us a second solution of Bessel’s equation. Why should an have the particular value implicit in Eqs. (11.62) and (11.64)? The answer involves the asymptotic dependence developed in Section 11.6. If Jn corresponds to a cosine wave, then Nn corresponds to a sine wave. This simple and convenient asymptotic phase relationship is a consequence of the particular admixture of Jin Nn .

 

Recurrence Relations

Substituting Eq. (11.60) for Nν (x ) (nonintegral ν ) into the recurrence relations (Eqs. (11.10) and (11.12) for Jn (x ), we see immediately that Nν (x ) satisfies these same recurrence relations. This actually constitutes another proof that Nν is a solution. Note that the converse is not necessarily true. All solutions need not satisfy the same recurrence relations. 


Wronskian Formulas 

From Section 9.6 and Exercise 10.1.4 we have the Wronskian formula17 for solutions of the Bessel equation,

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev         (11.69)

in which Aν is a parameter that depends on the particular Bessel functions uν (x ) and vν (x ) being considered. Aν is a constant in the sense that it is independent of x . Consider the special case

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

Since Aν is a constant, it may be identified at any convenient point, such as x = 0. Using the first terms in the series expansions (Eqs. (11.5) and (11.6)), we obtain

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

Substitution into Eq. (11.69) yields

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

using Eq. (8.32). Note that Aν vanishes for integral ν , as it must, since the nonvanishing of the Wronskian is a test of the independence of the two solutions. By Eq. (11.73), Jand J−n are clearly linearly dependent.
Using our recurrence relations, we may readily develop a large number of alternate forms, among which are

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

Many more will be found in the references given at chapter’s end.
Wronskians were of great value in two respects: (1) in establishing the linear independence or linear dependence of solutions of differential equations and (2) in developing an integral form of a second solution. Here the specific forms of the Wronskians and Wronskian-derived combinations of Bessel functions are useful primarily to illustrate the general behavior of the various Bessel functions. Wronskians are of great use in checking tables of Bessel functions. 

 

Example 11.3.1 COAXIAL WAVE GUIDES

We are interested in an electromagnetic wave confined between the concentric, conducting cylindrical surfaces ρ = a and ρ = b. To go from the standing wave of these examples to the traveling wave here, we let A = iB, A = amn ,B = bmn in Eq. (11.40a) and obtain

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

For the coaxial wave guide one generalization is needed. The origin, ρ = 0, is now excluded (0 <a ≤ ρ ≤ b). Hence the Neumann function Nm (γ ρ ) may not be excluded. Ez (ρ ,ϕ ,z,t ) becomes

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

With the condition

Hz = 0,                        (11.80)

we have the basic equations for a TM (transverse magnetic) wave.

The (tangential) electric field must vanish at the conducting surfaces (Dirichlet boundary condition), or

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

These transcendental equations may be solved for γ(γmn ) and the ratio cmn /bmn .From Example 11.1.2,

Bessel`s Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics, UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

Since k2 must be positive for a real wave, the minimum frequency that will be propagated (in this TM mode) is

ω = γc,         (11.84)

with γ fixed by the boundary conditions, Eqs. (11.81) and (11.82). This is the cutoff frequency of the wave guide.
There is also a TE (transverse electric) mode, with Ez = 0 and Hz given by Eq. (11.79).
Then we have Neumann boundary conditions in place of Eqs. (11.81) and (11.82). Finally, for the coaxial guide (not for the plain cylindrical guide, a = 0), a TEM (transverse electromagnetic) mode, Ez = Hz = 0, is possible. This corresponds to a plane wave, as in free space.
To conclude this discussion of Neumann functions, we introduce the Neumann function Nν (x ) for the following reasons:

1. It is a second, independent solution of Bessel’s equation, which completes the general solution.

2. It is required for specific physical problems such as electromagnetic waves in coaxial cables and quantum mechanical scattering theory.

3. It leads to a Green’s function for the Bessel equation.
4. It leads directly to the two Hankel functions .

Dynamic Test

Content Category

Related Searches

Summary

,

UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

,

mock tests for examination

,

UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

,

Objective type Questions

,

Extra Questions

,

ppt

,

Sample Paper

,

video lectures

,

shortcuts and tricks

,

MCQs

,

Important questions

,

Exam

,

Bessel's Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics

,

Previous Year Questions with Solutions

,

past year papers

,

Semester Notes

,

Bessel's Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics

,

practice quizzes

,

Viva Questions

,

Bessel's Special Function (Part - 2) - Mathematical Methods of Physics

,

Free

,

study material

,

pdf

,

UGC - NET Physics Physics Notes | EduRev

;