Class 8 Civics Chapter 2 Notes - Understanding Secularism

Introduction to Secularism

In a country like the United States, imagine being a Hindu or Muslim living in an area where Christian fundamentalism is very strong. Despite being a US citizen, you find it hard to rent a house because of your religion. If you complain about this discrimination and are told to go back to India, you might feel very angry. This anger could lead to two reactions:

1. Retaliation: You might argue that Christians should be treated the same way in areas where Hindus or Muslims are in the majority. This response is about getting even.
2. Fighting for Justice: Alternatively, you might believe that no one should be discriminated against based on their religion and work towards ending such discrimination. This approach aligns with the idea of secularism.

Secularism aims to prevent religious domination and ensure justice for everyone, regardless of their religion.

Historical Context of Discrimination

Throughout history, discrimination and persecution based on religion have been widespread:

• Nazi Germany: Jews were persecuted and killed under Hitler’s regime.
• Modern Israel: The Jewish State of Israel has been criticized for its treatment of Muslim and Christian minorities.
• Saudi Arabia: Non-Muslims face restrictions on building places of worship and public religious gatherings.

These examples show how religious domination can lead to discrimination and persecution.

What is Secularism?

Secularism refers to the separation of religion from State power. It means that the State does not officially recognize or support any religion.

Secularism: Separation of Religion from State.

 This separation is crucial for:

1. Preventing Religious Domination: Ensures no single religion can dominate others through State power.
2. Protecting Individual Freedom: Allows individuals to follow, change, or reinterpret their religion without State interference.

In India, the Constitution ensures that the State is secular, meaning it:

1. Prevents Religious Domination: Ensures that one religious community does not dominate another or dominate within its own community.
2. Avoids Enforcing Religion: The State does not enforce any religion or take away religious freedom.
3. Prevents Discrimination: The State does not discriminate based on religion.

Why is it Important to Separate Religion from the State?  

In a democratic society where multiple religions coexist, the separation of religion from the State is crucial to prevent the majority religion from using government power to discriminate against minority communities.

Jews were persecuted and killed under Hitler’s regime.

Here are key reasons why this separation is essential:

1. Ensures Democratic Functioning: It helps a country maintain its democratic principles by ensuring no religion dominates others through State support.

2. Protects Minority Rights: Separation safeguards minorities from the tyranny of the majority, preventing discrimination and protecting the Fundamental Rights of all citizens.

3. Promotes Religious Freedom: It allows individuals to freely practice, change, or reinterpret their religion without fear of State intervention or coercion.

4. Prevents Religious Violence: By keeping religion separate from governance, the State reduces the potential for religious violence and conflict.

Examples:

• Abolition of Untouchability: The Indian government intervened to abolish untouchability, a discriminatory practice within Hinduism, thereby ensuring equality for lower castes.
• Support for Religious Schools: The State permits religious communities to establish schools but does so without giving preferential treatment to any particular religion.

What is Indian Secularism?  

The Indian Constitution mandates that the State must be secular to ensure the following:

• No religious community dominates another.
• Within a religion, no group dominates others.
• The State neither promotes nor restricts religious freedom.

Key Features of Indian Secularism:

• Non-alignment with Religion: The Indian State maintains a distance from religious practices. For instance, government institutions like courts, schools, and offices do not display or promote any religion.
• Religious Freedom in Schools: Government schools are prohibited from promoting any specific religion, including through prayers or celebrations. However, private schools are not bound by this rule.
• Example: In a government school, students cannot celebrate religious festivals as this violates the policy of equal treatment of all religions. Such celebrations can be done outside the school premises. 

Strategies of Indian Secularism:

• Non-Interference: The State allows religious communities to follow their practices without interference. For example, Sikhs are exempted from wearing helmets as wearing a turban is an integral part of their faith.
• Intervention: The State can intervene in religious matters when necessary, such as banning untouchability within Hinduism, which discriminated against lower castes, to uphold Fundamental Rights.
• Example: The abolition of untouchability was an instance where the State intervened to prevent religious-based discrimination.

State Support: The Constitution allows religious communities to set up their schools and colleges, with the State offering financial aid on a non-preferential basis.

Comparison with Other Secular Democracies:

• In countries like the United States, the Constitution strictly separates religion from the State. For example, the U.S. First Amendment prevents the government from promoting any religion.
• Difference in Indian Secularism: Unlike the U.S., Indian secularism allows the State to intervene in religious matters, as long as it upholds Constitutional principles and aims to protect individual rights.

Importance of Secularism in India:

• The Indian Constitution upholds secularism to ensure equality, protect religious freedom, and prevent discrimination. While violations of these principles may occur, the Constitution provides a framework for addressing them. Awareness of these rights empowers citizens to take action against such violations.

These principles of secularism form the foundation of India's democratic structure and ensure the peaceful coexistence of diverse religious communities.

Some Important Terms

• Secularism: It refers to the separation of religion from the State.
• Coercion: Forcing someone to do something. In the chapter, the term refers to the force used by a legal authority such as the State.
• Freedom to interpret: It refers to the freedom that all persons shall have to understand things in their own way. In the chapter, it refers to individual liberty to develop their own understanding and meaning of the religion they practice.
• Intervene: In the chapter, the term refers to the State’s efforts to influence a particular matter by the principles of the Constitution.

FAQ's

Q.1. What is a ‘Democratic country’?

Ans. A political system for choosing and replacing the government through free and fair elections. The active participation of the people, as citizens, in politics and civic life.

Q.2. What is a ‘Minority group’?

Q.3. What is the ‘Constitution’?