Judiciary Exams Exam  >  Judiciary Exams Notes  >  Important Acts and Laws for Judiciary Exams  >  Grounds for Judicial Review of Administrative Actions

Grounds for Judicial Review of Administrative Actions | Important Acts and Laws for Judiciary Exams PDF Download

Introduction

The doctrine-ultra-vires forms the cornerstone of administrative law, serving as the basis for judicial review to oversee administrative actions. It pertains to actions taken in an excessive manner or beyond the authority of the acting party.

Grounds for Judicial Review of Administrative Action in India

  • Discretionary powers granted to administrative authorities should be exercised reasonably, as per the Wednesbury Test. For instance, in cases like Associated Provincial Pictures House v. Wednesbury, courts emphasized that discretionary powers must be used with care and based on valid reasons. It's essential for decisions to be lawful and without procedural flaws.
  • Similarly, in Roberts v. Hopwood, the court found the decision to pay above-average wages unreasonable due to legal obligations. In R v. Broadmoor Special Hospital Authority, the court allowed random searches on patients without consent for medical research purposes.
  • In Neha Jain v. University of Delhi, the court outlined review criteria, including checking for malice, jurisdictional overreach, discrimination, reasonableness, constitutional compliance, and legal support.

Question for Grounds for Judicial Review of Administrative Actions
Try yourself:
What is the purpose of the doctrine-ultra-vires in administrative law?
View Solution

Understanding Procedural Impropriety

  • Procedural impropriety refers to the failure to adhere to proper procedures and regulations, including the principles of natural justice.
  • It serves as a basis for reviewing administrative actions in terms of procedural correctness.

Case Example: Bradbury vs Enfield London Borough Council

  • In this case, the council neglected essential public policy requirements, leading to a breach of procedural standards.
  • The court ruled against the council for not meeting the necessary procedural demands.

Case Study: Ridge vs Baldwin

  • The court emphasized the importance of upholding procedural fairness in all administrative actions.
  • It highlighted the mandatory nature of following the principles of natural justice under all circumstances.

Legal Precedent: Aylesbury Mushroom Case

  • This case established the fundamental right for individuals affected by judicial or administrative decisions to be given a chance to present their case and be heard.
  • The principle of natural justice must be upheld when people's interests are at stake in such proceedings.

Understanding Proportionality

  • Definition: Proportionality in administrative actions refers to the idea that the measures taken should align with the intended outcomes. It involves striking a balance between means and ends, ensuring reasonableness and scrutiny by the courts.

Legal Precedents

  • Sardar Singh vs Union of India: The judiciary deemed the military's actions as arbitrary and the penalties as excessively harsh, showcasing how this doctrine aids in evaluating discretionary powers of the executive branch.
  • Management K Tea Estates vs Mazdoor Singh: The Supreme Court emphasized that the doctrine of proportionality must be applied universally to assess administrative decisions.

Understanding Illegality

  • Illegality refers to when an entity exceeds the authority vested in it.
  • A decision made by a public entity may be deemed illegal if the decision-maker:
    • Acts beyond its designated powers, known as 'ultra vires'.
    • Incorrectly interprets or applies the law.
    • Wrongly exercises a power or uses it for an improper purpose.
  • Illegality serves as a basis for the judicial review of administrative actions.
  • In the case of R (RWE Npower Renewables Ltd) v Milton Keynes Council, the court established that an irrational decision must be so unreasonable that no reasonable person, after careful consideration, would have made it.

Question for Grounds for Judicial Review of Administrative Actions
Try yourself:
What does procedural impropriety refer to?
View Solution

The document Grounds for Judicial Review of Administrative Actions | Important Acts and Laws for Judiciary Exams is a part of the Judiciary Exams Course Important Acts and Laws for Judiciary Exams.
All you need of Judiciary Exams at this link: Judiciary Exams
207 docs|219 tests

Top Courses for Judiciary Exams

FAQs on Grounds for Judicial Review of Administrative Actions - Important Acts and Laws for Judiciary Exams

1. What are the grounds for judicial review of administrative action in India?
Ans. The grounds for judicial review of administrative action in India include procedural impropriety, proportionality, and illegality.
2. What is procedural impropriety in the context of judicial review of administrative actions?
Ans. Procedural impropriety refers to situations where the administrative authority has not followed the proper procedure in making a decision, such as failing to provide a fair hearing or not following the rules of natural justice.
3. How is proportionality considered as a ground for judicial review of administrative actions in India?
Ans. Proportionality is a ground for judicial review where the court assesses whether the administrative action is proportionate to the objective it seeks to achieve, ensuring that the decision is not arbitrary or excessive.
4. Can you explain the concept of illegality as a ground for judicial review of administrative actions in India?
Ans. Illegality refers to situations where the administrative authority acts beyond its powers or in a manner that is not authorized by law, making the decision unlawful and subject to judicial review.
5. Why is it important for administrative actions to adhere to the grounds for judicial review in India?
Ans. It is important for administrative actions to adhere to the grounds for judicial review in India to ensure accountability, fairness, and legality in the decision-making process, ultimately upholding the rule of law.
Explore Courses for Judiciary Exams exam

Top Courses for Judiciary Exams

Signup for Free!
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days! Learn & Practice with 1000+ FREE Notes, Videos & Tests.
10M+ students study on EduRev
Related Searches

mock tests for examination

,

Grounds for Judicial Review of Administrative Actions | Important Acts and Laws for Judiciary Exams

,

Previous Year Questions with Solutions

,

Summary

,

video lectures

,

Extra Questions

,

Important questions

,

Free

,

pdf

,

shortcuts and tricks

,

study material

,

Grounds for Judicial Review of Administrative Actions | Important Acts and Laws for Judiciary Exams

,

Sample Paper

,

Exam

,

Viva Questions

,

Semester Notes

,

ppt

,

MCQs

,

Objective type Questions

,

practice quizzes

,

past year papers

,

Grounds for Judicial Review of Administrative Actions | Important Acts and Laws for Judiciary Exams

;