Passage - 1
Directions: Answer the given question based on the following passage:
Apathy in addressing community matters has held us back from making progress which is otherwise within our reach. We see serious problems around us but do not try to solve them. We believe as if the problems do not exist or as if they belong to someone else. On the other hand, in the West, people approach societal problems proactively. There are several examples of our apathetic attitude. For instance, all of us are aware of the problem of drought in India. More than four decades ago, Dr. K. L. Rao, an irrigation expert, suggested the creation of a water grid connecting all the rivers in north and south India to solve this problem. Unfortunately, nothing has been done about this. The story of power shortage in Bangalore is another instance. In 1983, it was decided that a power plant would be built to meet Bangalore's power requirements. Sadly, we have not yet started it. The Milan subway in Bombay has been in a deplorable state for the last four decades, and no action has been taken.
We Indians would do well to remember Thomas Hunter's words that idleness travels very slowly and poverty soon overtakes it. What could be the reason for our apathy? We were ruled by foreigners for over a thousand years. So, we have always believed that public or societal issues belong to some foreign ruler and that we have no responsibility to solve them. We have got used to just executing someone else's orders. "We are what we repeatedly do," said Aristotle. Having waited for some foreigner to tell us what to do over the last thousand years, the decision-makers in our society are not used to taking decisions on their own. They look to somebody else to take their decisions for them. Unfortunately, there is no body to look up to, and this is our tragedy.
Question for Reading Comprehension for CAT - 5
Try yourself:What, according to the author, is the attitude of Indians that comes in the way of India`s progress?
Explanation
All the above traits and factors contribute, and come in the way of India`s progress, as it takes all factors into consideration. This is the correct answer.
Report a problem
Question for Reading Comprehension for CAT - 5
Try yourself:"We see serious problems around us but do not try to solve them. We believe as if the problems do not exist or as if they belong to someone else." What does author appear to suggest?
Explanation
Ostrich is a bird that buries its head in sand when it sees a storm coming, hoping it will blow over without causing it any harm. The author is attributing the same attitude to Indians as according to the author Indians also ignore a problem and wait for someone else to come and solve it instead of taking a proactive attitude and doing something about it themselves.
Report a problem
Question for Reading Comprehension for CAT - 5
Try yourself:What, accordingly to the passage, is our tragedy?
Explanation
According to the author we are not free to take our decisions by ourselves after a thousand years of being ruled by foreigners. Thus, we can consider ourselves as standing at the cross-road of past and future without an able leadership to look up to or guide us out of the trouble we are in now. Thus, this is the correct answer.
Report a problem
Question for Reading Comprehension for CAT - 5
Try yourself:Why, according to the author, are Indians apathetic?
Explanation
Indians are apathetic because they have become accustomed to taking orders from others repeatedly, like slaves take orders from their masters. Having been ruled for over thousand years by foreigners of all descriptions, Indians have lost the drive that makes one decisive. It is because of this that they are reluctant to take any decision of their own. To buttress the point author has quoted Aristotle, who said, "We are what we repeatedly do." This is the answer to the question.
Report a problem
Question for Reading Comprehension for CAT - 5
Try yourself:Why does the writer draw our attention to what Thomas Hunter had said? What are his fears?
Explanation
Yes, if we continued to move at this slow pace like that of an idler, there are distinct possibilities of poverty over taking us as it moves faster than idleness. This is his fear to which our attention is drawn by way of that quote from Thomas Hunter.
Report a problem
Question for Reading Comprehension for CAT - 5
Try yourself:What leads to the conclusion that Indians have a tendency to disown their problems as their own?
Explanation
This is absolutely true and the author minces no words in saying that we believe problems which do not exist, or even if they exist, they belong to someone else. This clearly shows that we have a tendency of disowning our own problems. This is the most appropriate answer.
Report a problem
Passage - 2
Directions: Answer the given question based on the following passage:
The most remarkable achievement in post-constitution India is the exercise of the power of the judicial review by the superior courts. So long as this power is wielded by the courts effectively and fearlessly, democracy will remain ensured in India and, with all its shortcomings, the Constitution will survive. The numerous applications for the constitutional writs before the High Courts and the Supreme Court and their results testify to the establishment in India of 'limited government', or, 'the government of laws, not of men', as they call it in the United States of America. The Supreme Court has well performed its task of protecting the rights of the individual against the executive, against oppressive legislations and even against the Legislature itself, when it becomes overzealous in asserting its privileges not only against the individual citizens but even against the judges.
At the same time, it should be observed that neither the guarantee of the Fundamental Rights nor its adjunct 'Judicial Review' could have full play during the first quarter of a century of the working of our Constitution owing to their erosion by Proclamations of Emergency over a substantial period of time. It is true that the Emergency provisions are as much a part of the Constitution of India as any other, and that history has proved the need for such powers to meet extraordinary situations, but, broadly speaking, if the application of the Emergency provisions overshadows the other features of the Constitution, the balance between the 'normal' and 'emergency' provisions is palpably destroyed. Even, apart from Emergency, there has been an astounding erosion of Fundamental Rights owing to multiple amendments of the Constitution.
The means to prevent any such conflict between competing interests is to process all proposals for constitutional amendments through an expert and objective machinery, which would ensure the progressive adaptation of the Constitution to the Copernican changes in the social, economic and political background.
Question for Reading Comprehension for CAT - 5
Try yourself:What, according to the passage, is the biggest concern of the author?
Explanation
The survival of India as a democratic nation will be ensured if the power of judicial review is exercised effectively and fearlessly. This is the prime condition. This apparently is the prime concern of the author - ''So long as this power is wielded by the courts effectively and fearlessly, democracy will remain ensured in India ...'' Option 4 is correct.
Report a problem
Question for Reading Comprehension for CAT - 5
Try yourself:By exercising which power can the continuation of democracy in India be ensured?
Explanation
It is by effectively and fearlessly exercising the power of judicial review that the superior courts can ensure survival of democracy and of the Constitution of India. This is exactly what the author has averred - So long as this power is wielded by the courts effectively and fearlessly, democracy will remain ensured in India and, with all its shortcomings, the Constitution will survive.
Option D is the correct answer.
Report a problem
Question for Reading Comprehension for CAT - 5
Try yourself:According to the author, the balance between the `normal` and `emergency` provisions is palpably destroyed
Explanation
Option D is the correct answer as author wants to balance. He has no quarrel with emergency provisions, except when these powers tend to alter the basic features of the Constitution. It is mentioned in the passage - '...broadly speaking, if the application of the Emergency provisions overshadows the other features of the Constitution, the balance between the 'normal' and 'emergency' provisions is palpably destroyed.'
Report a problem
Question for Reading Comprehension for CAT - 5
Try yourself:What possible dangers does the author envisage when an institution becomes overzealous in asserting its privileges?
Explanation
The author clearly mentions the fact that legislature is often overzealous in asserting its privileges not only against individual citizens, but also against judges. There is a strong possibility that it could lead to clashes between the two which would be hugely detrimental to the interest of democracy. Option 4 is the correct answer.
Report a problem
Question for Reading Comprehension for CAT - 5
Try yourself:Reading of the passage leads to the conclusion that the author is of the view that
Explanation
Option A is true. The author gives a clear indication of this as he points to the role played by the Supreme Court in upholding Fundamental Rights of individuals and striking down oppressive legislation. The answer can be inferred from, 'The Supreme Court has well performed its task of protecting the rights of the individual against the executive, against oppressive legislations and even against the Legislature itself, when it becomes overzealous in asserting its privileges not only against the individual citizens but even against the judges.'
Option B is also true. The passage states, 'So long as this power is wielded by the courts effectively and fearlessly, democracy will remain ensured in India and, with all its shortcomings, the Constitution will survive.'
Thus, option D is the answer.
Report a problem
Question for Reading Comprehension for CAT - 5
Try yourself:The author talks about `competing interests`. What are they?
Explanation
Yes, author wants to strike a balance between normal and emergency provisions so that the basic features of the Constitution are not destroyed. This is the correct answer.
Report a problem