Banker’s Rights – Right of lien

Table of Contents
1. Introduction
2. Types of Lien
3. Features of a Banker's Lien
4. Conditions and Limits for Exercising Lien
5. Procedure and Duties of the Banker
6. Comparison: Lien, Pledge and Mortgage
7. Practical Examples and Applications
8. Conclusion
View more

Introduction

• Lien is the right of a creditor to retain the possession of goods or securities belonging to the debtor until the debt or obligation is discharged.
• The right of lien does not by itself include the right to sell the goods or securities; sale arises only where law or contract gives a further right or where the lien is equivalent to an implied pledge.
• Instruments and documents on which lien commonly operates include bills of exchange, cheques, promissory notes, share certificates, bonds and debentures when these are in the creditor's lawful possession.
• Deposits are not subject to lien because they are neither goods nor securities in the usual sense.

Types of Lien

Particular Lien

• A particular lien gives the creditor the right to retain only those goods or securities for which the particular debt or charges have arisen; it does not extend to other debts of the same debtor.
• Example: A laptop repairer may retain the specific laptop until the repair charges for that laptop are paid, but cannot retain other items of the same customer for those charges.

General Lien

• A general lien permits the creditor to retain the goods or securities until all amounts due from the debtor to that creditor are paid. It is not restricted to the particular debt relating to the specific goods.
• This form of lien is typically recognised for bankers, factors and certain professional agents such as attorneys and policy brokers.

Banker's Lien

• A banker ordinarily possesses a general lien on all goods and securities lawfully in its possession for any debt or balance due from the customer.
• To exercise lien effectively, the bank must have lawfully obtained possession of the relevant goods or securities.
• A bank should not sell securities without first giving the customer a reasonable notice; sale without notice is generally unlawful unless there is a prior contractual right or other legal justification.

Features of a Banker's Lien

• No special contract required: A banker's general lien arises by operation of law from the relationship and possession; a separate contractual clause is not necessary for its creation in many ordinary banking relationships.
• Implied pledge and right of sale: A banker's general lien may be treated as an implied pledge; where it effectively forms an implied pledge, a right to sell the pledged securities may be available after compliance with notice and other requirements.
• Possession and ownership: Possession of goods or securities may pass to the bank for the purpose of lien, but ownership remains with the customer unless and until the bank acquires title through lawful sale or other process.
• Limitation law: The law of limitation may restrict judicial remedies, but does not automatically extinguish the underlying debt; the bank's rights to recover may survive limitation in certain respects, subject to specific legal rules.
• No criminality in lawful exercise: When a banker exercises a lawful lien, that action is not a criminal offence because it is a civil remedy arising from the creditor-debtor relationship.
• Conversion to particular lien: If it is clearly indicated that a security was received only for a specified debt, the general lien may be converted into a particular lien limited to that debt.

Conditions and Limits for Exercising Lien

When Lien Can Be Exercised

• The right of general lien is available to a bank when acting in its capacity as banker and when it has lawful possession of the goods or securities.
• Lien may be exercised on goods and securities standing in the name of the borrower or in the name of a guarantor so long as lawful possession exists.
• A bank may apply lien in respect of other dues of the same customer on goods and securities remaining in its possession, even though those goods may previously have been concerned with a separate loan.
• The bank should give a reasonable notice to the customer before a sale; sale without such notice is generally unlawful unless an express contractual right permits otherwise.

When Lien Cannot Be Exercised

• Where there is a contract between the banker and the customer that is inconsistent with the exercise of a lien, the contract governs and the lien cannot be exercised contrary to that agreement.
• Where the goods or securities are held by the bank as a trustee or as an agent, the bank cannot exercise a lien over such property because it is not held as security for the bank's own debt.
• Where goods or documents are entrusted to the bank for a specific purpose (for example, to be used for a particular transaction), the bank cannot appropriate them to other debts.
• Where goods or securities are owned by more than one person and the loan is granted to only one of those owners, the banker generally cannot exercise lien against the share of the co-owners who are not indebted.
• Where items are deposited purely for safe custody, the bank does not acquire a lien by mere custody; exercise of lien requires that they be held in a manner consistent with creating a security.
• Where documents (such as bills of exchange) are provided with specific instructions to apply proceeds to a particular purpose, the bank must follow those instructions and cannot exercise lien for other debts.
• Where shares or securities are given to the bank solely for sale and the sale proceeds are to be applied for a specified purpose, the bank cannot use them to satisfy unrelated debts.
• Where valuables or documents are left with the bank by mistake or through the bank's negligence, the bank cannot claim a lien on such items to satisfy debts.
• Where securities are handed over to the bank to secure a loan but the loan has not yet been granted, the bank cannot exercise lien until the security relationship is actually created.

Procedure and Duties of the Banker

• Before exercising the right of lien, the bank should confirm the amount due and ensure that possession of the relevant goods or securities is lawful.
• The bank should give the customer a reasonable notice specifying the intention to realise the securities, unless an existing contractual right allows immediate action.
• On sale of securities in exercise of lien, the bank must apply the proceeds first to costs of sale, then to the debt for which the lien is exercised, and return any surplus to the customer.
• The bank must act in good faith, take steps to obtain a fair price on sale and avoid causing unnecessary loss to the customer.

Comparison: Lien, Pledge and Mortgage

• Lien arises from possession; it gives the right to retain goods until debt is paid; title does not pass and sale is not automatic unless law or contract permits.
• Pledge involves delivery of goods as security for a debt; the pledgee has a right to sell the pledged goods after notice if the debt is not paid.
• Mortgage creates a charge on immovable property or specified assets; the mortgagee's remedies and rights depend on the terms and statutory law and normally require formalities for enforcement.

Practical Examples and Applications

• Example 1: A customer lodges share certificates with a bank to obtain an overdraft. If the customer defaults, the bank may exercise lien on the certificates, give notice and sell them to recover the overdraft, subject to contractual terms.
• Example 2: If a customer deposits antiques for safe custody only, and there is no security arrangement, the bank cannot exercise lien over those antiques to recover unrelated dues.
• Example 3: A bill of exchange handed to the bank with instructions that proceeds must be applied to pay a particular supplier cannot be appropriated by the bank for the customer's other debts.

Conclusion

• Banker's lien is an important protective right allowing banks to retain possession of certain instruments and securities until legitimate dues are paid, but it must be exercised lawfully, in good faith and within the limits set by contract and by the circumstances in which the goods were received.
• The banker must distinguish between property held as security and property held for custody or for a specific purpose, give reasonable notice before sale, and account for any surplus after satisfying the debt and costs.