CLAT PG Exam  >  CLAT PG Notes  >  Constitutional Law  >  Cheat Sheet: Making of the Indian Constitution

Cheat Sheet: Making of the Indian Constitution

1. Historical Background

1.1 Pre-Independence Developments

Year/ActKey Features
Government of India Act, 1935Provided federal structure; Provincial autonomy; Separation of powers; Influenced constitutional framework significantly
Cabinet Mission Plan, 1946Proposed framework for constituent assembly; Three-tier federal structure; Rejected partition initially
Indian Independence Act, 1947Partition of India; Establishment of two dominions; Constituent Assembly became sovereign body

1.2 Demand for Constituent Assembly

  • M.N. Roy first proposed Constituent Assembly in 1934
  • Congress adopted demand in 1935
  • August Offer, 1940: British agreed in principle
  • Cripps Mission, 1942: Proposed elected constituent assembly

2. Constituent Assembly Formation

2.1 Composition and Structure

AspectDetails
Total Members (Initially)389 members (296 from British India; 93 from Princely States)
After Partition299 members (229 from British India; 70 from Princely States)
Election DateJuly-August 1946
First Meeting9 December 1946
Interim PresidentDr. Sachchidananda Sinha (temporary chairman)
PresidentDr. Rajendra Prasad (elected 11 December 1946)
Vice PresidentH.C. Mukherjee (later V.T. Krishnamachari)
Constitutional AdviserB.N. Rau

2.2 Key Members and Roles

MemberRole/Contribution
Dr. B.R. AmbedkarChairman of Drafting Committee; Principal architect of Constitution
Jawaharlal NehruMoved Objectives Resolution (13 December 1946); Chairman of Union Powers Committee
Sardar Vallabhbhai PatelChairman of Advisory Committee on Fundamental Rights, Minorities and Tribal Areas
Alladi Krishnaswami AyyarMember of Drafting Committee; Expert on constitutional law
K.M. MunshiMember of Drafting Committee
N. Gopalaswami AyyangarMember of Drafting Committee
B.L. MitterMember of Drafting Committee (later replaced by N. Madhava Rau)

3. Working of Constituent Assembly

3.1 Timeline and Sessions

Event/DateSignificance
9 December 1946First session; Sachchidananda Sinha presided
11 December 1946Rajendra Prasad elected President
13 December 1946Objectives Resolution moved by Nehru
22 January 1947Objectives Resolution adopted
29 August 1947Drafting Committee appointed (7 members)
4 November 1947Draft Constitution submitted by Drafting Committee
26 November 1949Constitution adopted
26 January 1950Constitution came into force (Republic Day)
Total Sessions11 sessions over 2 years, 11 months, 18 days
Total Days of Sittings165 days

3.2 Important Committees

CommitteeChairman
Drafting CommitteeDr. B.R. Ambedkar
Union Powers CommitteeJawaharlal Nehru
Union Constitution CommitteeJawaharlal Nehru
Provincial Constitution CommitteeSardar Vallabhbhai Patel
Advisory Committee on Fundamental Rights, Minorities and Tribal AreasSardar Vallabhbhai Patel
Committee on Chief Commissioners' ProvincesB. Pattabhi Sitaramayya
Steering CommitteeDr. Rajendra Prasad
Rules of Procedure CommitteeDr. Rajendra Prasad
States Committee (Negotiating Committee)Jawaharlal Nehru

3.3 Process of Constitution Making

  • Objectives Resolution formed philosophical foundation
  • B.N. Rau prepared initial draft after studying world constitutions
  • Draft circulated for public comments and provincial legislature feedback
  • Drafting Committee considered 7,635 amendments
  • First reading: General discussion on principles (November 1947)
  • Second reading: Clause-by-clause consideration (November 1948-October 1949)
  • Third reading: Final amendments and adoption (November 1949)
  • 284 members signed final document on 24 January 1950

4. Objectives Resolution

4.1 Content and Significance

AspectDetails
Moved ByJawaharlal Nehru on 13 December 1946
Adopted On22 January 1947
SignificanceFormed ideological foundation; Reflected in Preamble

4.2 Key Declarations

  • India to be Independent Sovereign Republic
  • All power and authority derived from the people
  • Guarantees of justice (social, economic, political), equality, freedom
  • Adequate safeguards for minorities, backward and tribal areas
  • Maintain integrity of territory
  • Desire to promote world peace and welfare of mankind

5. Sources and Influences

5.1 Constitutional Borrowings

Country/DocumentFeatures Borrowed
Government of India Act, 1935Federal scheme; Office of Governor; Judiciary; Public Service Commissions; Emergency provisions
British ConstitutionParliamentary system; Rule of law; Legislative procedure; Cabinet system; Bicameralism
US ConstitutionFundamental Rights; Judicial review; Independence of judiciary; Impeachment; Removal of judges; Preamble language
Irish ConstitutionDirective Principles of State Policy; Nomination of members to Rajya Sabha; Method of Presidential election
Canadian ConstitutionFederation with strong Centre; Residuary powers to Centre; Advisory jurisdiction of Supreme Court
Australian ConstitutionConcurrent List; Freedom of trade and commerce; Joint sitting of Parliament
Weimar Constitution (Germany)Suspension of Fundamental Rights during emergency
French ConstitutionPrinciples of Liberty, Equality, Fraternity in Preamble; Republican character
Soviet Constitution (USSR)Fundamental Duties; Ideals of justice (social, economic, political) in Preamble
Japanese ConstitutionProcedure established by law (Article 21)
South African ConstitutionAmendment procedure; Election of Rajya Sabha members

6. Nature and Features Envisaged

6.1 Basic Structure

  • Federal system with unitary bias
  • Parliamentary form of government
  • Sovereign, Socialist, Secular, Democratic, Republic
  • Written and elaborate Constitution (longest in world at adoption)
  • Combination of rigid and flexible amendments
  • Independent judiciary with judicial review
  • Single citizenship despite federal structure
  • Universal adult franchise (21 years, later amended to 18 years)

6.2 Original Constitution Statistics

ElementCount at Adoption
Parts22
Articles395
Schedules8
Words (approx.)145,000
Cost of Constituent Assembly₹64 lakhs

7. Enactment and Commencement

7.1 Adoption Process

DateEvent
26 November 1949Constitution adopted; 284 members signed
26 November 1949Provisions relating to citizenship, elections, provisional parliament came into force immediately
26 January 1950Remaining provisions came into force; Date chosen to honor Purna Swaraj declaration (1930)

7.2 Articles Enforced Immediately (26 November 1949)

  • Article 5: Citizenship at commencement
  • Article 6: Rights of citizenship of persons migrating to India from Pakistan
  • Article 7: Rights of citizenship of migrants to Pakistan
  • Article 8: Rights of citizenship of persons of Indian origin residing abroad
  • Article 9: Persons voluntarily acquiring foreign citizenship cease to be citizens
  • Article 60: Oath of President
  • Article 324: Superintendence of elections by Election Commission
  • Article 366: Definitions
  • Article 367: Interpretation
  • Article 379: Temporary provision for Jammu & Kashmir
  • Article 380: Temporary provision for Saurashtra and Travancore-Cochin
  • Articles 388, 391, 392, 393: Temporary and transitional provisions

8. Key Debates and Controversies

8.1 Major Discussion Points

IssuePositions
Language QuestionHindi vs. Hindustani vs. English; Compromise: Hindi in Devanagari script as official language, English to continue for 15 years
Fundamental Rights vs. DPSPJusticiable rights vs. non-justiciable directives; Balance achieved through separate parts
Uniform Civil CodePlaced in DPSP (Article 44) as non-enforceable directive rather than fundamental right
Reservation for MinoritiesSeparate electorates rejected; Reservation in legislature initially provided but later abolished
Powers of PresidentNominal head vs. executive powers; Resolved through parliamentary system model
Centre-State RelationsStrong Centre model adopted for unity and integrity; Emergency provisions included

9. Women and Minority Representation

9.1 Women Members

  • Total women members: 15
  • Notable members: Sarojini Naidu, Vijaya Lakshmi Pandit, Rajkumari Amrit Kaur, Sucheta Kripalani, Hansa Mehta, Durgabai Deshmukh, Renuka Ray
  • Contributed significantly to debates on Fundamental Rights, DPSP, and women's rights

9.2 Minority Community Representation

  • Dr. B.R. Ambedkar represented Scheduled Castes
  • Jaipal Singh Munda represented tribal communities
  • Muslim members included Maulana Abul Kalam Azad, Dr. Zakir Hussain
  • Christian representation: Frank Anthony, H.C. Mookherjee
  • Parsi representation: H.P. Modi

10. Criticisms and Assessments

10.1 Contemporary Criticisms

  • Not directly elected by people but indirectly through provincial legislatures
  • Dominated by Congress party; Limited opposition representation
  • Muslim League boycotted initially; inadequate Muslim representation after partition
  • Borrowed heavily from other constitutions; labeled as "borrowed constitution"
  • Too lengthy and complex; could have been more concise

10.2 Tributes and Recognition

  • Dr. Ambedkar: Acknowledged as Chief Architect; received Bharat Ratna (1990)
  • Granville Austin: Called it "perhaps the greatest political venture since that of Philadelphia"
  • Sir Ivor Jennings: Praised as "first essay in large-scale constitution-making by Indians themselves"
  • Constitution Day (Samvidhan Divas) declared on 26 November 2015

11. Important Constitutional Provisions at Adoption

11.1 Part-wise Distribution (Original)

PartSubject Matter
Part IUnion and its Territory
Part IICitizenship
Part IIIFundamental Rights
Part IVDirective Principles of State Policy
Part VThe Union
Part VIThe States
Part VIIStates in Part B of First Schedule (Repealed)
Part VIIIUnion Territories
Part IXPanchayats (Added by 73rd Amendment, 1992)
Part XScheduled and Tribal Areas
Part XIRelations between Union and States
Part XIIFinance, Property, Contracts and Suits
Part XIIITrade and Commerce within India
Part XIVServices under Union and States
Part XVElections
Part XVISpecial Provisions for Certain Classes
Part XVIIOfficial Language
Part XVIIIEmergency Provisions
Part XIXMiscellaneous
Part XXAmendment of Constitution
Part XXITemporary, Transitional and Special Provisions
Part XXIIShort Title, Commencement and Authoritative Text in Hindi

12. Special Features and Innovations

12.1 Unique Aspects

  • Blend of parliamentary sovereignty (British) and judicial supremacy (American)
  • Directive Principles as conscience of Constitution
  • Single integrated judiciary for Union and States
  • Emergency provisions more comprehensive than any other constitution
  • Detailed provisions for administration of scheduled and tribal areas
  • Secular state with protection for religious minorities
  • Article 370: Special status for Jammu & Kashmir (original provision)
  • Abolition of untouchability (Article 17)
  • Protection of cultural and educational rights of minorities (Articles 29-30)
The document Cheat Sheet: Making of the Indian Constitution is a part of the CLAT PG Course Constitutional Law.
All you need of CLAT PG at this link: CLAT PG
Explore Courses for CLAT PG exam
Get EduRev Notes directly in your Google search
Related Searches
Free, mock tests for examination, Exam, Semester Notes, ppt, Summary, past year papers, Important questions, MCQs, study material, Sample Paper, video lectures, Previous Year Questions with Solutions, shortcuts and tricks, Cheat Sheet: Making of the Indian Constitution, practice quizzes, Objective type Questions, Extra Questions, Cheat Sheet: Making of the Indian Constitution, Viva Questions, pdf , Cheat Sheet: Making of the Indian Constitution;