CLAT PG Exam  >  CLAT PG Notes  >  Family Law  >  Cheat Sheet: Muslim Law: Marriage, Divorce, and Maintenance

Cheat Sheet: Muslim Law: Marriage, Divorce, and Maintenance

1. Marriage (Nikah) Under Muslim Law

1.1 Nature and Definitions

AspectDescription
Legal NatureContract (aqd) for purposes of legalizing sexual intercourse and procreation of children
Abdul Kadir v. Salima (1886)Marriage is not a sacrament but a civil contract
EssentialsProposal (ijab), acceptance (qubul), free consent, competent parties, valid consideration (dower)
Shia ViewPresence of witnesses not essential; temporary marriage (muta) permitted
Sunni ViewPresence of two male or one male and two female witnesses mandatory; muta prohibited

1.2 Capacity to Marry

CategoryRule
AgePuberty (15 years presumed); guardian can contract marriage of minor but repudiation option (khyar-ul-bulugh) available on attaining puberty
Soundness of MindPerson of unsound mind cannot contract marriage; guardian may contract with court permission
Guardian (Wali)Order: father, paternal grandfather, brother, paternal uncle; mother not recognized as wali under Sunni law but recognized under Shia law

1.3 Prohibited Degrees

1.3.1 Absolute Prohibitions

  • Consanguinity: mother, grandmother, daughter, granddaughter, sister, niece, aunt
  • Affinity: wife's mother, son's wife, wife of lineal ascendant, wife of lineal descendant
  • Fosterage: same prohibitions as blood relations apply to milk relations

1.3.2 Relative Prohibitions

ProhibitionDetails
Two Sisters SimultaneouslyMan cannot marry two sisters at same time or wife and her aunt
Fifth WifeMaximum four wives at a time; fifth marriage void
Wife in IddatMarriage to woman undergoing iddat period is irregular (fasid)
Absence of Witnesses (Sunni)Marriage without proper witnesses is irregular, not void
Interfaith MarriageMuslim man can marry kitabiya (Christian/Jew) but not idolatress; Muslim woman cannot marry non-Muslim

1.4 Classification of Marriages

TypeCharacteristics
Sahih (Valid)All legal requirements met; creates full rights and obligations including inheritance, legitimacy, dower
Batil (Void)Marriage within prohibited degrees; no legal effects; cohabitation does not validate
Fasid (Irregular)Marriage with relative prohibitions; becomes valid upon removal of irregularity; children legitimate if consummated
Muta (Temporary)Fixed-term marriage; valid only in Shia law; children legitimate; wife entitled to agreed consideration

1.5 Dower (Mahr)

ConceptDetails
DefinitionSum of money or property promised by husband to wife as effect of marriage
Legal NatureWife's absolute right; debt on husband; not consideration but effect of marriage
Mahr-i-Muajjal (Prompt)Payable on demand before or after consummation; wife can refuse conjugal rights until paid
Mahr-i-Muwajjal (Deferred)Payable on dissolution of marriage by death or divorce
Proper DowerAmount specified in contract; minimum no limit, maximum no limit
Unspecified DowerMahr-ul-mithl determined by status, age, beauty, fortune, intellect of wife and financial position of husband's family

1.5.1 Wife's Remedies for Dower

  • Refuse to enter matrimonial home until prompt dower paid (right of retention over person)
  • Refuse consummation until prompt dower paid
  • Retain husband's property in her possession until dower paid (right of retention over property)
  • Sue for recovery as unsecured debt
  • Claim deferred dower upon divorce or husband's death

2. Dissolution of Marriage

2.1 Modes of Dissolution

ModeDescription
By Husband (Talaq)Unilateral right of husband to dissolve marriage by pronouncement
By Wife (Khula, Talaq-i-Tafweez)Wife-initiated dissolution with or without husband's consent
By Mutual Consent (Mubarat)Both parties desire separation
Judicial (Faskh)Court dissolves marriage on specific grounds
By Operation of LawLian (mutual allegation of adultery), apostasy

2.2 Talaq (Husband's Unilateral Divorce)

2.2.1 Classification of Talaq

TypeProcedure
Talaq-ul-Sunnat (Approved)Ahsan: single pronouncement during tuhr (period of purity), followed by abstinence during iddat; revocable until iddat expires
Talaq-ul-Sunnat (Approved)Hasan: three pronouncements in three successive tuhrs without intercourse; revocable until third pronouncement
Talaq-ul-Biddat (Irregular)Triple talaq in one sitting or single irrevocable pronouncement; effective immediately but sinful; abolished by Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Marriage) Act, 2019
Talaq-e-Tafweez (Delegated)Husband delegates power to pronounce talaq to wife or third party; wife exercises at her discretion

2.2.2 Triple Talaq - Legal Position

  • Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Marriage) Act, 2019: pronouncing triple talaq is void and illegal
  • Offence: cognizable, non-bailable; imprisonment up to 3 years and fine
  • Shayara Bano v. Union of India (2017): triple talaq declared unconstitutional and violative of Article 14
  • Wife entitled to subsistence allowance for herself and dependent children

2.2.3 Essential Requirements for Valid Talaq

  • Free consent: talaq under coercion, intoxication, or jest is invalid
  • Intention to dissolve marriage permanently required
  • Soundness of mind: insane person cannot pronounce valid talaq
  • Age: minor cannot pronounce talaq
  • Communication to wife not essential for validity but required under Muslim Family Laws Ordinance, 1961 (applied in India)

2.3 Contingent and Conditional Talaq

TypeExample & Effect
Talaq-ul-Taalik (Contingent)Divorce effective on occurrence of specified contingency (e.g., "if I marry again"); valid if contingency occurs
Conditional TalaqSubject to condition precedent; valid only if reasonable and not opposed to public policy
Constructive TalaqWife given option to divorce herself if certain acts done by husband; treated as talaq-e-tafweez

2.4 Wife-Initiated Dissolution

2.4.1 Khula (Divorce by Wife with Husband's Consent)

AspectDetails
DefinitionWife purchases her release from marriage bond by returning dower or other consideration
Husband's ConsentRequired; wife offers consideration, husband accepts and releases her
EffectIrrevocable dissolution; no iddat-related reconciliation rights
ConsiderationWife may return whole or part of dower or give other property; cannot exceed dower amount
Court InterventionIf husband refuses, wife may approach court under Dissolution of Muslim Marriages Act, 1939

2.4.2 Mubarat (Mutual Consent Divorce)

  • Both parties desire separation due to mutual aversion
  • Initiative from either party; acceptance by other completes divorce
  • Irrevocable; no reconciliation possible even during iddat
  • No consideration necessary but may be agreed upon

2.5 Judicial Divorce (Dissolution of Muslim Marriages Act, 1939)

Ground (Section 2)Details
(i) Whereabouts UnknownHusband's whereabouts unknown for 4 years
(ii) Failure to MaintainHusband failed to provide maintenance for 2 years
(iii) ImprisonmentHusband sentenced to 7 years or more imprisonment
(iv) Failure of Marital ObligationsHusband failed to perform marital obligations for 3 years without reasonable cause
(v) ImpotenceHusband impotent at time of marriage and continues to be
(vi) Insanity/Leprosy/VDHusband insane for 2 years, suffering from leprosy or virulent venereal disease
(vii) Child Marriage RepudiationWife married before 15, repudiated before 18 (provided marriage not consummated)
(viii) CrueltyHusband treats her with cruelty (physical/mental abuse, forced immoral life, disposes her property, obstructs religious practice, polygamy with unequal treatment, any other valid ground)

2.5.1 Additional Points on Judicial Divorce

  • Wife retains full dower amount if decree granted
  • Court may attempt reconciliation before granting decree
  • Decree becomes effective from date of pronouncement
  • No requirement of mutual consent unlike Hindu law

2.6 Ila and Zihar

ConceptLegal Effect
IlaHusband's oath to abstain from sexual intercourse with wife; if abstinence continues for 4 months, wife entitled to judicial divorce
ZiharHusband compares wife to mother or other prohibited relative; must expiate by freeing slave, fasting 60 days, or feeding 60 poor persons before resuming marital relations

2.7 Effects of Dissolution

EffectConsequence
DowerEntire dower (prompt + deferred) becomes payable immediately in talaq; in khula, wife returns agreed amount
Iddat PeriodWife must observe waiting period before remarriage
Maintenance During IddatHusband liable to maintain wife during iddat period
Custody of ChildrenMother entitled to custody (hizanat) subject to age limits and conditions
Remarriage (Halala)After third talaq, parties cannot remarry unless wife marries another man, consummates, and is divorced by him

2.8 Iddat (Waiting Period)

CircumstanceDuration
After Divorce (Regular Menses)Three menstrual courses (three tuhrs)
After Divorce (No Menses)Three lunar months
After Divorce (Pregnant)Until delivery of child
After Death of Husband (Not Pregnant)4 months 10 days
After Death of Husband (Pregnant)Until delivery or 4 months 10 days, whichever is longer
After ConsummationIddat mandatory
Before ConsummationNo iddat for divorce; iddat required for death

3. Maintenance Under Muslim Law

3.1 Wife's Right to Maintenance

AspectRule
During MarriageHusband's absolute obligation to maintain wife; includes food, clothing, lodging
Wife's DutyWife must be obedient and allow cohabitation; disobedient wife (nashiza) forfeits maintenance
QuantumAccording to husband's means and status; no fixed amount
StandardWife entitled to live in manner she was accustomed to in father's house or husband's own standard, whichever is higher
During IddatHusband must maintain wife during entire iddat period following divorce
After IddatUnder traditional Muslim law, no maintenance after iddat; modified by Muslim Women Act, 1986

3.2 Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Divorce) Act, 1986

3.2.1 Key Provisions

SectionProvision
Section 3(1)(a)Reasonable and fair provision and maintenance within iddat period
Section 3(1)(b)Mahr amount to be paid if not already paid
Section 3(1)(c)Return of all properties gifted by wife, relatives, or friends
Section 4Magistrate may order relatives (who would inherit) to pay maintenance if husband unable; if no relatives, State Wakf Board to pay
Section 5Mahr deemed to be within iddat period for purposes of Section 125 CrPC applicability

3.2.2 Landmark Cases on Muslim Women Act, 1986

CasePrinciple
Mohd. Ahmed Khan v. Shah Bano (1985)Divorced Muslim woman entitled to maintenance under Section 125 CrPC beyond iddat period; triggered enactment of 1986 Act
Danial Latifi v. Union of India (2001)1986 Act constitutional; "reasonable and fair provision" under Section 3(1)(a) includes maintenance for entire life or until remarriage; husband must make provision within iddat for post-iddat period
Shamima Farooqui v. Shahid Khan (2015)Muslim divorced wife can claim maintenance under both 1986 Act and Section 125 CrPC; remedies not mutually exclusive after Danial Latifi

3.3 Maintenance Under Section 125 CrPC

AspectDetails
ApplicabilityApplies to all religions including Muslims; secular provision
Who Can ClaimWife (including divorced wife unable to maintain herself), children, parents
Conditions for WifeUnable to maintain herself; not living in adultery; husband with sufficient means neglects or refuses maintenance
QuantumMaximum Rs. 10,000 per month (as amended); court determines based on needs and husband's income
Divorced Muslim WomanCan claim maintenance beyond iddat under Section 125 CrPC read with Danial Latifi judgment
DisentitlementWife living in adultery, refuses to live with husband without sufficient reason, parties living separately by mutual consent

3.4 Maintenance of Children

CategoryRule
Father's ObligationFather must maintain children until sons attain majority, daughters marry
Son's Age LimitUntil attainment of majority (18 years); if physically/mentally infirm, obligation continues
Daughter's MaintenanceUntil marriage regardless of age; father's obligation ceases upon marriage
Illegitimate ChildrenFather not liable; mother must maintain
Mother's ObligationMother liable only if father unable to maintain and mother has means
StandardAccording to father's means and status of family

3.5 Maintenance of Parents and Relatives

RelationLiability
ParentsChildren (sons and daughters) must maintain indigent parents unable to maintain themselves from their own property
PrioritySon primarily liable; daughter liable if son unable
Poor RelativesUnder Hanafi law, relatives who are entitled to inherit are liable to maintain poor relations in same proportion as they would inherit
Under Section 125 CrPCParents can claim maintenance from children; children from parents

3.6 Right of Wife to Separate Residence

  • Wife entitled to separate residence if husband maintains other wives in same house without her consent
  • Husband cannot compel wife to live with co-wives or relatives
  • Refusal to live in joint family does not make wife disobedient
  • Residence must be suitable according to wife's status and husband's means
  • If husband fails to provide suitable residence, wife can refuse cohabitation without losing maintenance

4. Custody of Children (Hizanat)

4.1 Principles of Custody

PrincipleDescription
Welfare ParamountBest interest and welfare of child is paramount consideration
Mother's PreferenceMother has preferential right during tender age; child needs mother's care
Father's RightFather is natural guardian for property and person after custody age limits
Religion FactorChild should be brought up in father's religion

4.2 Age Limits for Mother's Custody

School/Child's GenderAge Limit
Hanafi Law - SonUntil age 7 years
Hanafi Law - DaughterUntil age of puberty (approximately 9 years)
Shia Law - SonUntil age 2 years
Shia Law - DaughterUntil age 7 years
Maliki LawChild can choose parent after puberty

4.3 Conditions for Mother's Custody

  • Mother must be of sound mind
  • Mother must not be leading immoral life
  • Mother should not have married a stranger (non-mahram) - Hanafi view
  • Mother must not neglect child's proper upbringing and education
  • Mother must be trustworthy and capable of taking care of child
  • Remarriage to relative within prohibited degrees does not disqualify mother - Shia view

4.4 Order of Persons Entitled to Custody

4.4.1 After Mother

Priority Order (Hanafi)Relation
1Mother's mother (maternal grandmother) and her mother
2Father's mother (paternal grandmother) and her mother
3Full sister
4Uterine sister
5Full sister's daughter
6Maternal aunt, then paternal aunt
7Father (after female relations exhausted or disqualified)

4.5 Guardianship (Wilayat)

TypeDetails
Natural GuardianFather, then father's father (paternal grandfather); mother not recognized as natural guardian under Hanafi law
Father's PowersGuardian of person and property during minority; can contract marriage of minor child
Testamentary GuardianFather can appoint guardian by will; mother can appoint under Shia law
Court-Appointed GuardianUnder Guardians and Wards Act, 1890; court considers welfare of child
Shia Law ExceptionMother recognized as natural guardian after father and paternal grandfather

4.6 Statutory Provisions

Act/ProvisionRelevance
Guardians and Wards Act, 1890Applies to Muslims; court appoints guardian considering welfare; paramount consideration is child's welfare
Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956Not applicable to Muslims
Section 125 CrPCParents liable to maintain children; custodial parent can claim maintenance
Section 488 CrPC (Old)Now replaced by Section 125 CrPC

4.7 Recent Judicial Trends

  • Courts prioritize child welfare over rigid age limits prescribed in personal law
  • Mother's remarriage not automatic ground for transfer of custody; welfare test applied
  • Courts can extend mother's custody beyond traditional age limits if in child's best interest
  • Father's access and visitation rights protected even when mother has custody
  • Child's preference considered when child is of sufficient age and understanding

5.1 Legitimacy

ConceptRule
Child of Valid MarriageLegitimate if born during marriage or within period of gestation after dissolution
Period of GestationMinimum 6 months from marriage; maximum 2 years (Hanafi) or 10 months (Shia) from separation
PresumptionChild born to married woman presumed legitimate unless non-access proved
AcknowledgmentFather can acknowledge paternity of child of unknown parentage; once acknowledged, irrevocable
Conditions for AcknowledgmentAcknowledger of age of acknowledged child possible; acknowledged person's parentage unknown; acknowledged person accepts if of age
Fasid Marriage ChildChild of irregular marriage legitimate if born after consummation

5.2 Parentage and Paternity

  • Legitimate child entitled to father's name, maintenance, inheritance
  • Legitimacy established by birth during valid or irregular marriage
  • Acknowledgment of paternity validates child's status for all purposes
  • Husband can disclaim paternity only through lian (mutual oath of adultery)
  • Illegitimate child has no legal relationship with father; inherits only from mother

5.3 Concepts Related to Dissolution

TermDefinition
Revocable Talaq (Raji)Husband can revoke talaq during iddat period; reconciliation possible
Irrevocable Talaq (Bain)Cannot be revoked; parties cannot reunite except through fresh marriage with new contract and dower
Talaq Bain SughraLesser irrevocable talaq; parties can remarry with fresh contract
Talaq Bain KubraGreater irrevocable talaq (after third talaq); parties cannot remarry unless wife marries another, consummates, and is divorced
HalalahIntervening marriage required after third talaq before parties can remarry each other; must be bona fide marriage

5.4 Key Maxims and Principles

  • Quod non est consentaneum (that which is not reasonable is not lawful) - applied to restrict arbitrary talaq
  • Marriage is civil contract but creates religious and social obligations
  • Wife is not chattel but equal partner with distinct legal personality
  • Dower is wife's property; husband has no right over it
  • Child's welfare paramount in custody matters over personal law prescriptions
  • Personal law subject to constitutional morality and fundamental rights

6. Reform Legislation and Constitutional Validity

6.1 Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Application Act, 1937

AspectProvision
Section 2Shariat applies to Muslims in matters of marriage, divorce, maintenance, dower, guardianship, gifts, waqf, succession
ApplicabilityApplies to all Muslims in India except state of Goa
CustomOverrides customs inconsistent with Shariat; parties can opt out of customary law

6.2 Dissolution of Muslim Marriages Act, 1939

  • Codifies grounds for judicial divorce available to Muslim women
  • Supplements traditional law which gave limited rights to women
  • Based on Hanafi law but available to all Muslim women in India
  • Does not affect woman's right under other laws (Section 125 CrPC)

6.3 Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Marriage) Act, 2019

SectionProvision
Section 3Triple talaq void and illegal
Section 4Offence: imprisonment up to 3 years and fine; cognizable and non-bailable
Section 5Magistrate may release accused on bail after hearing wife; can impose conditions
Section 6Offence compoundable at instance of wife on terms and conditions determined by Magistrate
Section 7Wife entitled to subsistence allowance for herself and dependent children from husband
Section 8Wife entitled to custody of minor children; Magistrate determines custody arrangement

6.4 Constitutional Challenges and Judicial Review

Case/PrincipleSignificance
Article 13Personal laws not "laws in force" for Article 13; but subject to fundamental rights scrutiny
Article 14Triple talaq violates equality before law and equal protection
Article 15Gender discrimination in personal laws challengeable
Article 21Right to live with dignity; arbitrary divorce violates human dignity
Article 25Freedom of religion subject to public order, morality, health; not absolute
Article 44Directive Principle: Uniform Civil Code for all citizens; not enforceable but guides legislation

6.5 Landmark Supreme Court Judgments

CaseKey Holding
Mohd. Ahmed Khan v. Shah Bano (1985)Muslim divorced woman entitled to maintenance under Section 125 CrPC beyond iddat; maintenance secular not religious obligation
Danial Latifi v. Union of India (2001)Muslim Women Act, 1986 constitutional; reasonable and fair provision includes post-iddat maintenance; must be paid within iddat
Shayara Bano v. Union of India (2017)Triple talaq unconstitutional; violates Articles 14, 21; not integral to Islam; 3:2 majority struck down practice
Shamima Farooqui v. Shahid Khan (2015)Muslim divorced woman can seek maintenance under both 1986 Act and Section 125 CrPC; remedies not mutually exclusive
Mohd. Hanif v. Pathummal (2018)Mahr is immediate debt on husband; wife can refuse to enter matrimonial home until prompt dower paid

7. Procedural and Practical Aspects

7.1 Registration of Muslim Marriages

  • Not compulsory under Muslim personal law but states have enacted registration laws
  • Muslim Marriages and Divorces (Registration) Act in some states makes registration mandatory
  • Registration is evidence of marriage; non-registration does not invalidate marriage
  • Nikahnama (marriage contract document) serves as proof of marriage and dower terms

7.2 Notice Requirements for Talaq

RequirementDetails
Muslim Family Laws Ordinance, 1961Notice to Union Council/Chairman required within 30 days of talaq; applied in India through judicial interpretation
Notice to WifeCopy of notice to be sent to wife; without notice, talaq not effective
Reconciliation Period90 days for reconciliation attempts after notice given
Legal EffectTalaq takes effect only after 90-day period expires
PenaltiesFailure to give notice may attract penalty; talaq without notice void

7.3 Maintenance Procedure Under Section 125 CrPC

StepProcess
PetitionFiled before First Class Magistrate or Metropolitan Magistrate
JurisdictionWhere person entitled to maintenance resides
Proof RequiredMarriage, inability to maintain self, husband's means and neglect
Interim MaintenanceCourt may grant pending final order
QuantumBased on needs of wife and means of husband; maximum Rs. 10,000 per month
AppealTo Sessions Court within 30 days
EnforcementWarrant of attachment, recovery as fine, imprisonment for default

7.4 Suit for Recovery of Dower

  • Filed in civil court of competent jurisdiction
  • Limitation: 3 years from date of demand or from date of divorce/death for deferred dower
  • Dower is unsecured debt; wife ranks with other unsecured creditors
  • Wife can claim retention over husband's property in her possession
  • Dower decree executable against husband's estate after his death

7.5 Proof of Marriage

MethodDescription
NikahnamaMarriage contract document signed by parties and witnesses; best evidence
Marriage CertificateIf marriage registered; conclusive proof
Oral EvidenceTestimony of parties, witnesses present at nikah
PresumptionLong cohabitation as husband-wife raises presumption of valid marriage
Documentary EvidenceJoint photographs, correspondence, bank accounts, residence proof showing marital relationship

7.6 Defenses in Maintenance Proceedings

  • Wife living in adultery
  • Wife refuses to live with husband without sufficient reason
  • Parties living separately by mutual consent
  • Wife has sufficient means to maintain herself
  • Husband has no sufficient means
  • Under Muslim Women Act, 1986: dower or properties already paid/transferred constitute reasonable provision
The document Cheat Sheet: Muslim Law: Marriage, Divorce, and Maintenance is a part of the CLAT PG Course Family Law.
All you need of CLAT PG at this link: CLAT PG
Explore Courses for CLAT PG exam
Get EduRev Notes directly in your Google search
Related Searches
Extra Questions, Important questions, and Maintenance, study material, Sample Paper, Cheat Sheet: Muslim Law: Marriage, Semester Notes, Exam, and Maintenance, Divorce, video lectures, past year papers, Cheat Sheet: Muslim Law: Marriage, Viva Questions, Previous Year Questions with Solutions, ppt, Divorce, mock tests for examination, shortcuts and tricks, MCQs, Free, practice quizzes, pdf , and Maintenance, Cheat Sheet: Muslim Law: Marriage, Divorce, Objective type Questions, Summary;