CLAT PG Exam  >  CLAT PG Notes  >  Tax Law  >  Cheat Sheet: Work contract in GST and GST Council

Cheat Sheet: Work contract in GST and GST Council

1. Work Contract under GST

1.1 Definition and Scope

TermMeaning
Works ContractContract for building, construction, fabrication, completion, erection, installation, fitting out, improvement, modification, repair, maintenance, renovation, alteration or commissioning of immovable property wherein transfer of property in goods is involved in execution of such contract
Composite SupplyWorks contract is treated as composite supply comprising supply of goods and services
Principal SupplyIn works contract, service element is the principal supply

1.2 Constitutional and Legal Framework

ProvisionDetails
Article 366(29A)(b)Inserted by 46th Constitutional Amendment Act, 1982; deems works contract as sale of goods for purpose of levy of sales tax
Section 2(119) CGST ActDefines "works contract" under GST regime
Section 7 CGST ActWorks contract is a supply of service
Entry 6, Schedule IIExplicitly classifies works contract as supply of services

1.3 Classification and Tax Treatment

AspectTreatment
Nature of SupplyComposite supply of works contract service where service element predominates
Tax LeviableTax on entire contract value as service; no separate tax on goods portion
SAC Code9954 - Construction services
HSN CodeNot applicable as treated as service

1.4 GST Rates on Works Contract

Type of Works ContractGST Rate
Construction of residential apartments (other than affordable)5% without ITC or 1% with ITC (w.e.f. 01.04.2019)
Construction of affordable residential apartments1% without ITC (w.e.f. 01.04.2019)
Construction services for government/government entity12%
Construction of commercial/industrial buildings18%
Construction of roads, bridges, tunnels, railways12%
Maintenance and repair services18%
Original works - purely labour contracts12%

1.5 Input Tax Credit (ITC)

  • ITC available on inputs and input services used in execution of works contract
  • ITC on capital goods subject to Section 16 and Section 17 restrictions
  • ITC not available when composition scheme opted under Notification 11/2017 for real estate sector
  • Reversal of ITC required under Section 17(5) for blocked credits
  • Section 17(5)(c) and (d) - ITC blocked on works contract services for construction of immovable property (except plant and machinery)

1.6 Valuation of Works Contract

MethodApplication
Transaction ValuePrice actually paid or payable as per Section 15
Goods and Services SegregationNot required as entire contract value taxed as service
Inclusive ofCost of goods, labour charges, profit margin, any amount charged for anything done by supplier
ExcludesDiscounts as per trade practice, amount separately charged as pure sale of goods

1.7 Place of Supply Rules

ScenarioPlace of Supply
Works contract relating to immovable propertyLocation of immovable property - Section 12(3)(a) IGST Act
Interstate supplyIGST applicable
Intrastate supplyCGST + SGST applicable

1.8 Time of Supply

  • Date of issue of invoice or last date on which invoice should be issued - whichever is earlier
  • Invoice to be issued within 30 days from date of supply of service
  • Date of receipt of payment - if payment received before invoice
  • Date of completion of supply - in continuous supply contracts
  • Due date of payment as per contract terms for advance payments

1.9 Key Case Laws

CasePrinciple
Gannon Dunkerley & Co. v. State of Rajasthan (1993)Works contract involves both sale of goods and rendering of services; divisible contract
Builders Association of India v. UOI (1989)Upheld constitutional validity of Article 366(29A)(b) relating to works contract
Larsen & Toubro v. State of Karnataka (2013)Transfer of property in goods essential element of works contract

1.10 Special Provisions

  • Sub-contractor to main contractor - main contractor liable for GST on entire contract value
  • Pure labour contracts without supply of goods - taxed as manpower supply service at 18%
  • Transfer of business assets rule - if goods not consumed, transfer attracts GST
  • Section 142(11) - Penalty for non-payment on residential apartments
  • Anti-profiteering provisions applicable to ensure rate reduction benefit passed to consumers

2. GST Council

2.1 Constitutional Basis

ProvisionDetails
Article 279AProvides for constitution of GST Council; inserted by 101st Constitutional Amendment Act, 2016
Clause (1)Mandates establishment of GST Council within 60 days from commencement of 101st Amendment
Date of ConstitutionSeptember 12, 2016
NatureConstitutional body with recommendatory powers

2.2 Composition of GST Council

PositionDetails
ChairpersonUnion Finance Minister of India
MembersUnion Minister of State in charge of Revenue or Finance
MembersMinister in charge of Finance or Taxation or any other Minister nominated by each State Government
Total Members33 members (1 Union Finance Minister + 1 MoS + 31 State/UT representatives)
UT RepresentationUTs with legislature have representation

2.3 Voting Pattern and Quorum

AspectRequirement
Quorum50% of total members (Article 279A(5))
Voting Weightage - Centre1/3rd of total votes cast
Voting Weightage - States2/3rd of total votes cast
Decision MakingDecisions taken by majority of not less than 3/4th of weighted votes cast
One State VoteEach State has equal voting power of 1 vote
Nature of DecisionsRecommendations to Union and States

2.4 Functions and Powers

2.4.1 Core Functions (Article 279A(4))

  • Recommend taxes, cesses, surcharges to be subsumed in GST
  • Recommend goods and services that may be subjected to or exempted from GST
  • Recommend model GST laws, principles of levy, apportionment of IGST
  • Recommend threshold limits for GST registration
  • Recommend rates including floor rates with bands of GST
  • Recommend special rates for raising additional resources during natural calamities/disasters
  • Recommend special provisions for North-Eastern States, Jammu & Kashmir, Himachal Pradesh, Uttarakhand
  • Decide date for implementation of GST

2.4.2 Advisory Functions

  • Make recommendations on any dispute arising out of GST administration
  • Recommend measures for harmonization of GST law across Centre and States
  • Facilitate uniformity in GST implementation
  • Examine and recommend composition levy, reverse charge mechanism
  • Recommend place of supply rules

2.5 Organizational Structure

BodyFunction
GST Council SecretariatProvides administrative and technical support; headed by Secretary
Fitment CommitteeRecommends tax rates for goods and services
Law CommitteeDrafts GST laws and rules
IT Grievance Redressal CommitteeAddresses technical issues in GSTN portal
Group of Ministers (GoM)Constituted for specific issues - rate rationalization, real estate, casinos, etc.

2.6 Powers and Limitations

AspectDetails
Nature of RecommendationsRecommendatory, not binding on Parliament or State Legislatures
Legislative PowerNo legislative power; only makes recommendations
Judicial ReviewSubject to judicial review by Supreme Court and High Courts
ProcedureCouncil determines own procedure - Article 279A(6)
Binding NatureParliament and State Legislatures retain power to enact different provisions

2.7 Key Decisions and Recommendations

Meeting/DateKey Decision
1st Meeting (Sept 2016)Approved draft model GST law
14th Meeting (May 2017)Approved CGST, IGST, UTGST, GST Compensation Acts
14th Meeting (May 2017)Finalized four-tier rate structure: 5%, 12%, 18%, 28%
28th Meeting (July 2018)Reduced rates on various goods from 28% slab
31st Meeting (Dec 2018)Approved uniform GST rate on lottery at 28%
33rd Meeting (Feb 2019)Approved new rates for real estate sector - 1% and 5%
37th Meeting (Sept 2019)Approved rate rationalization on several items
45th Meeting (Sept 2021)Extended GST compensation cess levy beyond June 2022

2.8 Important Amendments and Notifications

  • Power to issue notifications based on Council recommendations vests with Central/State Governments
  • Rate changes effected through notifications under Section 9 CGST Act
  • Exemption notifications issued under Section 11 CGST Act
  • Council reviews revenue impact of rate changes periodically
  • Anti-profiteering mechanism established to ensure benefit of rate reduction passed to consumers

2.9 GST Council vs Union-State Relations

AspectPosition
Federal CooperationRepresents cooperative federalism model
Centre's Role1/3rd voting power; cannot impose decisions unilaterally
States' Role2/3rd voting power; collective voice of States decisive
Dispute ResolutionCouncil recommends; ultimate legislative power with Parliament/State Legislatures
Compensation to StatesCouncil recommended compensation for revenue loss for 5 years (2017-2022); extended till March 2026

2.10 Judicial Pronouncements on GST Council

CasePrinciple
Union of India v. Mohit Minerals (2022)Supreme Court held GST Council's recommendations are not binding; Parliament and State Legislatures retain legislative supremacy
Mohit Minerals PrincipleArticle 279A creates collaborative mechanism, not subordination; both Centre and States have independent taxation powers
Effect on Federal StructureGST Council's role is advisory; cannot override constitutional scheme of distribution of legislative powers

2.11 Secretariat and Administrative Support

  • GST Council Secretariat located in New Delhi
  • Secretary to GST Council - senior IRS officer
  • Provides research, analysis, and drafting support
  • Coordinates with State tax departments and CBIC
  • Maintains records of Council proceedings and decisions
  • Assists in implementation of Council recommendations

2.12 Special Features

FeatureDetails
Consensus BuildingCouncil operates on consensus model despite voting provisions; most decisions unanimous
Frequency of MeetingsNo fixed schedule; meets as required; met 49 times till 2023
TransparencyPress releases issued after meetings; recommendations made public
AccountabilityRecommendations subject to parliamentary and legislative scrutiny
FlexibilityCan constitute sub-committees and working groups for detailed examination
The document Cheat Sheet: Work contract in GST and GST Council is a part of the CLAT PG Course Tax Law.
All you need of CLAT PG at this link: CLAT PG

Top Courses for CLAT PG

Related Searches
Cheat Sheet: Work contract in GST and GST Council, past year papers, Sample Paper, Cheat Sheet: Work contract in GST and GST Council, MCQs, Summary, ppt, Previous Year Questions with Solutions, Semester Notes, Exam, Cheat Sheet: Work contract in GST and GST Council, pdf , mock tests for examination, shortcuts and tricks, Objective type Questions, study material, practice quizzes, Free, Viva Questions, Important questions, video lectures, Extra Questions;