CLAT PG Exam  >  CLAT PG Notes  >  Law of Contracts  >  Cheat Sheet: Contingent Contracts

Cheat Sheet: Contingent Contracts

1. Definition and Essential Elements

1.1 Definition

ProvisionDetails
Section 31A contingent contract is a contract to do or not to do something, if some event, collateral to such contract, does or does not happen
NaturePerformance depends upon happening or non-happening of a future uncertain event

1.2 Essential Elements

  • There must be a valid contract to do or not to do something
  • Performance must be conditional upon happening or non-happening of an event
  • The event must be collateral to the contract (not the performance itself)
  • The event must be uncertain
  • The event must be future (except as per Section 32)

1.3 Collateral Event

CharacteristicExplanation
MeaningEvent is incidental or subsidiary to the contract, not the very act agreed to be performed
TestEvent must be independent of the parties' will and distinct from the contractual obligation itself

2. Types of Contingent Contracts

2.1 Based on Happening of Event

TypeDescription
Section 31 - Contingent on happeningContract dependent upon happening of uncertain future event; becomes void if event becomes impossible
Section 32 - Contingent on non-happeningContract dependent upon non-happening of uncertain future event; becomes void if event happens or becomes certain to happen

2.2 Based on Time Element

SectionDescription
Section 33Contingent on happening of specified event within fixed time; becomes void if event does not happen before expiry of time or becomes impossible before time expires
Section 34Contingent on non-happening of specified event within fixed time; enforced when time expires if event has not happened, or when event becomes impossible before time expires

2.3 Special Cases

SectionProvision
Section 35Contingent contract to do or not to do anything if impossible event happens - void ab initio, whether or not fact of impossibility known to parties
Section 36Contracts contingent on impossible events (non-happening) become enforceable when event becomes impossible

3. Enforcement and Voidability Rules

3.1 When Contingent Contracts Become Enforceable

SituationResult
Event dependent upon happens (Section 31)Contract becomes enforceable
Event dependent upon does not happen (Section 32)Contract becomes enforceable when event becomes impossible
Event does not happen within fixed time (Section 34)Contract enforced when time expires if event has not happened
Event becomes impossible within fixed time (Section 34)Contract enforced when event becomes impossible before time expires

3.2 When Contingent Contracts Become Void

SituationResult
Event becomes impossible (Section 31)Contract becomes void
Event happens or becomes certain (Section 32)Contract becomes void
Event does not happen before expiry (Section 33)Contract becomes void
Event becomes impossible before time expires (Section 33)Contract becomes void
Event itself impossible (Section 35)Void ab initio

4. Distinction from Other Concepts

4.1 Wagering Agreements vs Contingent Contracts

Contingent ContractWagering Agreement
Valid and enforceable (if conditions met)Void under Section 30
Real interest exists in subject matterNo real interest; mere bet on event outcome
Event is collateral to contractEvent is the essence of agreement
Not necessarily mutual chance of gain/lossMutual chance of gain and loss essential

4.2 Voidable Contracts vs Contingent Contracts

BasisDistinction
EnforceabilityContingent contracts become enforceable on happening/non-happening of event; voidable contracts are enforceable unless rescinded by aggrieved party
ConditionContingent contracts have external uncertain event; voidable contracts involve consent issues (coercion, undue influence, fraud, misrepresentation)
NatureContingency is about future performance; voidability relates to formation defect

4.3 Conditional Contracts vs Contingent Contracts

  • All contingent contracts are conditional, but not all conditional contracts are contingent
  • Contingent contract: condition relates to collateral event outside the contract
  • Conditional contract (non-contingent): condition may relate to performance itself or an act that is part of the contractual obligation

5. Special Provisions and Applications

5.1 Section 32 - Contracts Dependent on Non-Happening

AspectDetails
ConditionPerformance conditional upon non-happening of uncertain future event
Becomes void whenEvent happens OR event becomes certain that it will happen
Becomes enforceable whenEvent becomes impossible

5.2 Impossibility of Event

TypeEffect
Subsequent impossibility (Section 31)Contract becomes void when event becomes impossible after formation
Initial impossibility (Section 35)Contract void ab initio if dependent on impossible event happening
Within fixed time (Section 33)Contract void if event becomes impossible before time expires

5.3 Relationship with Section 56 (Frustration)

  • Sections 31-36 deal with agreed contingencies incorporated in contract
  • Section 56 deals with supervening impossibility or frustration not contemplated by parties
  • Both render contract void/unenforceable but operate on different grounds
  • Contingent contracts: parties have expressly agreed performance depends on event
  • Frustration: unforeseen supervening event makes performance impossible or radically different

6. Key Case Law Principles

6.1 Important Judicial Interpretations

PrincipleApplication
Collateral event testEvent must be independent and not the very act of performance agreed upon
Certainty requirementFor Section 32, event must become certain to happen, not merely probable
Knowledge irrelevantUnder Section 35, contract void even if parties unaware of impossibility at formation
Future conduct of living personContingency based on future conduct of living person not impossible until person dies or time expires

6.2 Practical Applications

  • Insurance contracts: payment contingent on happening of insured event
  • Indemnity contracts: performance contingent on loss occurring
  • Contracts for sale of property: completion contingent on obtaining permits/clearances
  • Employment contracts: bonus payment contingent on achieving targets
  • Real estate: sale contingent on obtaining loan approval or satisfactory inspection

7. Examination Points

7.1 Critical Distinctions to Remember

CompareKey Difference
Sections 31 and 32Section 31: dependent on happening; Section 32: dependent on non-happening
Sections 33 and 34Section 33: happening within fixed time; Section 34: non-happening within fixed time
Sections 35 and 36Section 35: impossible event happening (void ab initio); Section 36: impossible event non-happening (enforceable when impossible)
Contingent vs WageringContingent has real interest and is valid; wagering has no interest and is void

7.2 Common Exam Scenarios

  • Identify whether contract is contingent and which section applies
  • Determine when contingent contract becomes enforceable or void
  • Distinguish contingent contracts from wagering agreements
  • Apply time-bound contingencies (Sections 33-34)
  • Analyze impossibility scenarios (Sections 35-36)
  • Determine collateral nature of event

7.3 Section-Wise Summary

SectionQuick Reference
31Happening of event → enforceable; impossible → void
32Non-happening of event → enforceable when impossible; if happens → void
33Happening within time → enforceable; not happen/impossible before time → void
34Non-happening within time → enforceable when time expires; impossible before time → enforceable
35Impossible event happening → void ab initio
36Impossible event non-happening → enforceable when impossible
The document Cheat Sheet: Contingent Contracts is a part of the CLAT PG Course Law of Contracts.
All you need of CLAT PG at this link: CLAT PG
Explore Courses for CLAT PG exam
Get EduRev Notes directly in your Google search
Related Searches
pdf , Exam, Cheat Sheet: Contingent Contracts, ppt, Summary, Previous Year Questions with Solutions, study material, Free, past year papers, MCQs, Objective type Questions, Semester Notes, Important questions, mock tests for examination, video lectures, shortcuts and tricks, Viva Questions, Cheat Sheet: Contingent Contracts, Sample Paper, Cheat Sheet: Contingent Contracts, practice quizzes, Extra Questions;