CLAT PG Exam  >  CLAT PG Notes  >  Public International Law  >  Cheat Sheet: International Human Rights Law

Cheat Sheet: International Human Rights Law

1. Foundation and Sources

1.1 Key Instruments

InstrumentDetails
Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR)Adopted by UN General Assembly on 10 December 1948; non-binding but customary international law; 30 articles covering civil, political, economic, social, cultural rights
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR)Adopted 1966, entered into force 1976; 53 articles; binding treaty; monitored by Human Rights Committee; Optional Protocols for individual complaints and abolition of death penalty
International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR)Adopted 1966, entered into force 1976; 31 articles; progressive realization of rights; monitored by Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights
Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW)Adopted 1979, entered into force 1981; 30 articles; monitored by CEDAW Committee
Convention Against Torture (CAT)Adopted 1984, entered into force 1987; defines torture; absolute prohibition; monitored by Committee Against Torture
Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC)Adopted 1989, entered into force 1990; most ratified treaty; 54 articles; defines child as person below 18 years
International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination (ICERD)Adopted 1965, entered into force 1969; first comprehensive human rights treaty; monitored by CERD Committee

1.2 Sources of International Human Rights Law

  • Treaties and conventions (primary binding source)
  • Customary international law (prohibition of torture, slavery, genocide, racial discrimination)
  • General principles of law recognized by civilized nations
  • Judicial decisions and teachings of publicists (subsidiary means)
  • Soft law instruments (declarations, resolutions, guidelines)
  • Jus cogens norms (peremptory norms from which no derogation permitted)

2. Categories of Human Rights

2.1 Civil and Political Rights

RightKey Elements
Right to LifeArticle 6 ICCPR; non-derogable; includes abolition movement for death penalty; prohibits arbitrary deprivation
Prohibition of TortureArticle 7 ICCPR; absolute prohibition; non-derogable; jus cogens; includes cruel, inhuman, degrading treatment
Prohibition of SlaveryArticle 8 ICCPR; non-derogable; jus cogens; includes servitude, forced labor
Right to Liberty and SecurityArticle 9 ICCPR; prohibits arbitrary arrest/detention; requires legal basis; habeas corpus
Fair Trial RightsArticle 14 ICCPR; independent tribunal; presumption of innocence; legal assistance; public hearing
Freedom of ExpressionArticle 19 ICCPR; includes freedom to seek, receive, impart information; subject to restrictions for national security, public order, public health/morals
Freedom of ReligionArticle 18 ICCPR; includes thought, conscience; freedom to manifest religion; non-derogable core
Right to PrivacyArticle 17 ICCPR; prohibits arbitrary interference with privacy, family, home, correspondence

2.2 Economic, Social and Cultural Rights

RightKey Elements
Right to WorkArticle 6 ICESCR; includes free choice of employment; just and favorable conditions; protection against unemployment
Right to EducationArticle 13 ICESCR; primary education compulsory and free; secondary and higher education progressively free; aims at full development of human personality
Right to HealthArticle 12 ICESCR; highest attainable standard of physical and mental health; includes access to healthcare facilities
Right to Adequate Standard of LivingArticle 11 ICESCR; includes adequate food, clothing, housing; continuous improvement of living conditions
Right to Social SecurityArticle 9 ICESCR; includes social insurance
Cultural RightsArticle 15 ICESCR; right to participate in cultural life; enjoy benefits of scientific progress; protection of intellectual property

2.3 Collective/Solidarity Rights

  • Right to self-determination (Article 1 ICCPR and ICESCR; both covenants)
  • Right to development (UN Declaration 1986)
  • Right to peace
  • Right to clean environment
  • Right to natural resources

3. State Obligations and Implementation

3.1 Nature of State Obligations

ObligationDescription
Obligation to RespectNegative obligation; state must refrain from interfering with enjoyment of rights
Obligation to ProtectState must prevent violations by third parties (non-state actors)
Obligation to FulfillPositive obligation; state must take legislative, administrative, budgetary, judicial measures to realize rights
Progressive RealizationApplies to ICESCR rights; states must take steps to maximum of available resources; no retrogression without justification
Immediate ObligationsNon-discrimination; taking steps toward realization; minimum core obligations

3.2 Treaty Monitoring Bodies

CommitteeFunction
Human Rights CommitteeMonitors ICCPR; examines state reports; individual communications under Optional Protocol 1; inter-state complaints
Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural RightsMonitors ICESCR; examines state reports; issues General Comments; individual communications under Optional Protocol
Committee Against TortureMonitors CAT; examines state reports; individual complaints; inquiry procedure; visits under Optional Protocol
CEDAW CommitteeMonitors CEDAW; examines state reports; individual communications and inquiry under Optional Protocol
Committee on the Rights of the ChildMonitors CRC; examines state reports; individual communications under Optional Protocol
CERD CommitteeMonitors ICERD; examines state reports; individual communications; early warning and urgent action procedures

3.3 Reporting Procedures

  • State parties submit periodic reports (initial report + periodic reports every 4-5 years)
  • Committee reviews report with state delegation (constructive dialogue)
  • Committee issues Concluding Observations with recommendations
  • Shadow/alternative reports by NGOs and NHRIs
  • Follow-up procedure for priority recommendations

4. UN Human Rights Mechanisms

4.1 Charter-Based Mechanisms

MechanismDetails
Human Rights CouncilEstablished 2006 replacing Commission on Human Rights; 47 members elected by General Assembly; based in Geneva
Universal Periodic Review (UPR)Reviews human rights record of all 193 UN member states every 4-5 years; three documents: state report, compilation by OHCHR, stakeholder information
Special ProceduresIndependent experts (Special Rapporteurs, Independent Experts, Working Groups); thematic or country mandates; conduct country visits; receive complaints; issue reports
Complaint Procedure1503 procedure; confidential; addresses consistent patterns of gross violations; filters through Working Groups

4.2 Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR)

  • Established 1993; principal UN human rights office
  • Coordinates UN human rights activities
  • Provides technical assistance to states
  • Supports treaty bodies and special procedures
  • Undertakes field operations and country offices

5. Regional Human Rights Systems

5.1 European System

ComponentDetails
European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR)Adopted 1950; 47 state parties (Council of Europe members); civil and political rights focus
European Court of Human RightsEstablished 1959; based in Strasbourg; individual applications after exhaustion of domestic remedies; judgments binding; supervised by Committee of Ministers
European Social CharterAdopted 1961, revised 1996; economic and social rights; collective complaints procedure

5.2 Inter-American System

ComponentDetails
American Convention on Human RightsAdopted 1969, entered into force 1978; 25 state parties; Organization of American States (OAS)
Inter-American Commission on Human RightsEstablished 1959; examines petitions; conducts country visits; issues reports; can refer cases to Court
Inter-American Court of Human RightsEstablished 1979; based in San José, Costa Rica; contentious jurisdiction (22 acceptances); advisory jurisdiction; reparations

5.3 African System

ComponentDetails
African Charter on Human and Peoples' RightsAdopted 1981, entered into force 1986; includes peoples' rights; duties alongside rights; African Union
African Commission on Human and Peoples' RightsEstablished 1987; based in Banjul, Gambia; examines state reports; communications; promotional mandate
African Court on Human and Peoples' RightsEstablished 2006; based in Arusha, Tanzania; contentious and advisory jurisdiction; merged with Court of Justice

5.4 Asian System

  • No comprehensive regional human rights treaty or court
  • ASEAN Intergovernmental Commission on Human Rights (AICHR) - established 2009; promotional mandate
  • SAARC mechanisms - limited human rights focus
  • Arab Charter on Human Rights - adopted 2004, entered into force 2008; Arab League; Arab Human Rights Committee

6. Special Protection Regimes

6.1 Refugees and Asylum

ElementDetails
1951 Refugee ConventionDefines refugee as person with well-founded fear of persecution based on race, religion, nationality, political opinion, membership of particular social group; 1967 Protocol removed temporal and geographical limitations
Principle of Non-RefoulementArticle 33; prohibition of return to territory where life/freedom threatened; customary international law; non-derogable
UNHCRUN High Commissioner for Refugees; established 1950; protection and assistance mandate; supervises Refugee Convention implementation

6.2 Women's Rights

  • CEDAW defines discrimination against women; requires states to eliminate discrimination in all spheres
  • Articles cover political rights, nationality, education, employment, health, marriage and family
  • General Recommendation 19 on violence against women
  • Beijing Declaration and Platform for Action 1995
  • UN Security Council Resolution 1325 on Women, Peace and Security

6.3 Children's Rights

PrincipleDetails
Best Interests of the ChildArticle 3 CRC; primary consideration in all actions concerning children
Non-DiscriminationArticle 2 CRC; rights apply to all children without discrimination
Right to Life, Survival and DevelopmentArticle 6 CRC; maximum extent possible
Respect for Views of the ChildArticle 12 CRC; right to be heard in proceedings affecting child
  • Optional Protocol on involvement of children in armed conflict
  • Optional Protocol on sale of children, child prostitution and child pornography
  • Optional Protocol on communications procedure

6.4 Minorities and Indigenous Peoples

InstrumentDetails
Article 27 ICCPRRights of ethnic, religious, linguistic minorities to enjoy culture, profess religion, use language
UN Declaration on MinoritiesAdopted 1992; right to participate in decisions affecting them
ILO Convention 169Indigenous and Tribal Peoples Convention 1989; binding treaty; consultation and participation rights
UN Declaration on Rights of Indigenous PeoplesAdopted 2007; right to self-determination; free, prior and informed consent; land and resource rights

6.5 Persons with Disabilities

  • Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD) - adopted 2006, entered into force 2008
  • Paradigm shift from medical to social model
  • Principles: respect for dignity, non-discrimination, full participation, accessibility
  • Reasonable accommodation requirement
  • Article 12 - equal recognition before law; legal capacity
  • Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities monitors implementation

7. Limitations and Derogations

7.1 Limitations on Rights

ConceptDetails
Permissible LimitationsMust be prescribed by law; pursue legitimate aim (national security, public order, public health/morals, rights of others); necessary in democratic society; proportionate
Three-Part Test1) Provided by law; 2) Legitimate aim; 3) Necessary and proportionate
Margin of AppreciationDiscretion given to states in applying Convention; varies by right and context; developed by European Court

7.2 Derogations

ElementDetails
Article 4 ICCPRDerogation permitted in time of public emergency threatening life of nation; measures must be strictly required; must not be inconsistent with other international law obligations
Non-Derogable RightsArticle 4(2) ICCPR: right to life, freedom from torture, slavery, imprisonment for debt, retroactive criminal law, right to recognition as person, freedom of thought/conscience/religion
Notification RequirementState must inform UN Secretary-General of derogation, provisions derogated from, reasons
ProportionalityMeasures must be proportionate to emergency; temporal limitation; safeguard against abuse

8. Remedies and Enforcement

8.1 Individual Complaints Procedures

RequirementDetails
Exhaustion of Domestic RemediesMust exhaust available and effective domestic remedies before international complaint; exceptions: undue delay, no prospect of success
Victim RequirementComplainant must be victim of violation; can be potential victim; representatives can submit on behalf
Temporal JurisdictionViolation must occur after treaty entered into force for state; continuing violations exception
Ratione MateriaeComplaint must concern rights protected by treaty
AdmissibilityNot anonymous; not abuse of right; not same matter before another international body; not manifestly ill-founded

8.2 Remedies

  • Restitution (restoration to original position)
  • Compensation (monetary damages for pecuniary and non-pecuniary harm)
  • Rehabilitation (medical, psychological care)
  • Satisfaction (apology, acknowledgment, guarantee of non-repetition)
  • Guarantees of non-repetition (legislative, administrative reforms)
  • Views/decisions of treaty bodies not formally binding but authoritative interpretations
  • Regional court judgments binding and enforceable

8.3 Enforcement Challenges

  • No compulsory jurisdiction over states without consent
  • Reliance on state cooperation and good faith implementation
  • Political will and resource constraints
  • Lack of enforcement mechanisms for treaty body decisions
  • Regional court supervision mechanisms (Committee of Ministers for ECHR)

9. International Humanitarian Law Interface

9.1 Relationship with IHL

AspectDetails
ApplicabilityHuman rights law applies at all times (peace and armed conflict); IHL applies in armed conflict; both can apply simultaneously (lex specialis principle)
ICJ Nuclear Weapons Advisory OpinionRight to life does not cease in armed conflict; determined by lex specialis (IHL) in hostilities
Derogation vs. IHLStates can derogate from some human rights in emergency but must comply with IHL in armed conflict
Non-Derogable CoreOverlap: prohibition of torture, arbitrary killing, slavery continue even in armed conflict

9.2 Armed Conflict Protections

  • Geneva Conventions 1949 and Additional Protocols apply in armed conflicts
  • Common Article 3 (non-international armed conflicts) - minimum protections overlap with human rights
  • Prohibition of torture, cruel treatment, outrages upon personal dignity
  • Fair trial guarantees for criminal prosecutions
  • Human rights treaties continue to bind states during occupation

10. Contemporary Issues

10.1 Terrorism and Human Rights

  • Balance between security measures and human rights protection
  • Prohibition of torture absolute - no exception for terrorism (A and Others v. UK)
  • Fair trial rights must be maintained
  • Prolonged detention without trial violates Article 9 ICCPR
  • UN Global Counter-Terrorism Strategy emphasizes human rights compliance
  • Special Rapporteur on promotion and protection of human rights while countering terrorism

10.2 Business and Human Rights

ElementDetails
UN Guiding PrinciplesEndorsed 2011; three pillars: state duty to protect, corporate responsibility to respect, access to remedy
State DutyProtect against human rights abuses by third parties including business; through regulation, policy, adjudication
Corporate ResponsibilityRespect human rights; avoid causing or contributing to adverse impacts; due diligence; remediate impacts
Access to RemedyJudicial mechanisms, state-based non-judicial mechanisms, operational-level grievance mechanisms

10.3 Digital Rights

  • Right to privacy in digital age - mass surveillance concerns
  • Freedom of expression online - same rights online as offline (UN Resolution 2012)
  • Access to internet as human right - Special Rapporteur reports
  • Data protection and personal information
  • Arbitrary or unlawful interference with privacy violates Article 17 ICCPR

10.4 Climate Change and Human Rights

  • Human Rights Council Resolution 2008 recognizing climate change implications for human rights
  • Impacts on rights to life, health, food, water, housing
  • Special Rapporteur on human rights and environment
  • State obligations include mitigation, adaptation, procedural rights (information, participation)
  • Climate migrants and displacement concerns
  • Paris Agreement 2015 preamble recognizes human rights obligations

11. Key Principles

11.1 Fundamental Principles

PrincipleDescription
UniversalityHuman rights belong to all human beings regardless of status; UDHR affirms universal character
InalienabilityCannot be taken away except in specific situations according to due process
IndivisibilityCivil, political, economic, social, cultural rights equally important; cannot be separated
InterdependenceFulfillment of one right depends on fulfillment of others
Non-Discrimination and EqualityRights apply without distinction of race, color, sex, language, religion, political opinion, national/social origin, property, birth, other status

11.2 Equality and Non-Discrimination

ConceptDetails
Formal EqualityEqual treatment under law; same rules apply to all
Substantive EqualityEqual outcomes; addresses structural disadvantage; affirmative action permitted
Direct DiscriminationDifferential treatment based on protected ground
Indirect DiscriminationNeutral rule with disproportionate impact on protected group
Intersectional DiscriminationDiscrimination based on multiple grounds simultaneously

12. Important Cases and Jurisprudence

12.1 International Court of Justice

CaseSignificance
Barcelona Traction (1970)Introduced concept of erga omnes obligations; human rights violations concern all states
Nicaragua v. USA (1986)Human rights violations in armed conflict; applicability of human rights law and IHL
Wall Advisory Opinion (2004)Human rights law applies in occupied territory; self-determination; proportionality
Genocide Convention (Bosnia) (2007)State responsibility for genocide; duty to prevent; effective control test

12.2 Human Rights Committee Views

CasePrinciple
Toonen v. AustraliaSexual orientation discrimination; privacy rights; criminalization of homosexuality violates ICCPR
General Comment No. 31Nature of general legal obligation; state responsibility for private actors; effective remedies
Concluding ObservationsAuthoritative interpretation of obligations; recommendations for compliance

12.3 European Court of Human Rights

CasePrinciple
Soering v. UK (1989)Extradition to face death penalty may violate Article 3; real risk test
Chahal v. UK (1996)Absolute prohibition of torture; no balancing with national security
Osman v. UK (1998)Positive obligation to protect life; operational duty when authorities knew or ought to have known of real and immediate risk
Pretty v. UK (2002)Right to life does not include right to die; prohibition of inhuman treatment
A and Others v. UK (2009)Indefinite detention of terrorism suspects without charge violates Article 5; proportionality

13. India and International Human Rights Law

13.1 Constitutional Provisions

  • Fundamental Rights (Part III) align with international human rights standards
  • Article 21 (right to life and personal liberty) - expansive interpretation includes dignity
  • Article 14 (equality before law) corresponds to non-discrimination principle
  • Article 51(c) - Directive Principle directs state to foster respect for international law and treaty obligations

13.2 Treaty Status

TreatyStatus
ICCPRRatified 1979; no Optional Protocol acceptance for individual complaints
ICESCRRatified 1979
CEDAWRatified 1993; reservations to Articles 5(a), 16(1), 16(2) withdrawn 2014
CRCRatified 1992
ICERDRatified 1968
CATNot ratified; signed but not ratified

13.3 Domestic Application

  • Dualist approach - treaties require domestic legislation for enforcement
  • Supreme Court uses international law for interpretation of fundamental rights
  • Vishaka v. State of Rajasthan (1997) - applied CEDAW to formulate guidelines on sexual harassment
  • Jolly George Varghese (1980) - incorporated Article 11 ICCPR (no imprisonment for debt)
  • National Human Rights Commission established 1993 under Protection of Human Rights Act
The document Cheat Sheet: International Human Rights Law is a part of the CLAT PG Course Public International Law.
All you need of CLAT PG at this link: CLAT PG
Explore Courses for CLAT PG exam
Get EduRev Notes directly in your Google search
Related Searches
Summary, Important questions, Free, Semester Notes, Exam, MCQs, video lectures, Cheat Sheet: International Human Rights Law, Viva Questions, Sample Paper, practice quizzes, Previous Year Questions with Solutions, Cheat Sheet: International Human Rights Law, Extra Questions, Objective type Questions, mock tests for examination, shortcuts and tricks, past year papers, pdf , Cheat Sheet: International Human Rights Law, study material, ppt;