Backsolving from Answer Choices

Table of Contents
1. Backsolving from Answer Choices
2. When to Use Backsolving
3. The Backsolving Process
4. Worked Examples
5. Strategic Considerations
6. Common Mistakes
7. Practice Questions
8. Answer Key and Solutions
View more

Backsolving from Answer Choices

Backsolving is a powerful strategic approach to solving multiple-choice questions that reverses the typical problem-solving process. Instead of setting up equations and solving algebraically, you test the given answer choices by substituting them back into the problem conditions. When one choice satisfies all conditions, you have found the correct answer. This strategy is particularly valuable under timed testing conditions because it can often yield answers more quickly than traditional algebraic methods, especially when the algebra would be complex or time-consuming.

Backsolving works best when the question asks for a specific numerical value and provides five distinct numerical answer choices. It is especially effective for problems involving unknown quantities, word problems with multiple conditions, and questions where setting up equations is challenging. Understanding when and how to apply backsolving can significantly improve your efficiency and accuracy on test day.

When to Use Backsolving

Backsolving is most effective in the following situations:

Questions asking "what is the value": When a problem asks for a specific number and all answer choices are different numerical values, backsolving is usually viable. The question typically involves finding an unknown that satisfies certain conditions.

Complex word problems: When translating a word problem into algebraic equations would be difficult or time-consuming, testing answer choices directly against the stated conditions can be faster and less error-prone.

Problems with multiple constraints: When several conditions must be satisfied simultaneously, plugging in answers allows you to check all conditions at once rather than solving a system of equations.

Questions where algebra would be messy: When the algebraic approach would involve fractions, multiple variables, or complex manipulations, backsolving often provides a cleaner path to the answer.

Backsolving is generally not recommended when answer choices are algebraic expressions rather than numbers, when the question asks "which of the following," or when direct calculation is obviously faster.

The Backsolving Process

Follow these steps to backsolve effectively:

Step 1: Identify the unknown. Determine what value the answer choices represent. Read the question carefully to understand what is being asked.

Step 2: Start with choice C. Answer choices are typically arranged in ascending or descending numerical order. Starting with the middle value (choice C) allows you to eliminate multiple answers efficiently. If choice C is too large, you know choices D and E are also too large. If choice C is too small, choices A and B are also too small.

Step 3: Substitute the choice into the problem. Replace the unknown with the numerical value from the answer choice and work through the problem conditions.

Step 4: Check all conditions. Verify that the substituted value satisfies every requirement stated in the problem. If it does, you have found the correct answer. If not, determine whether you need a larger or smaller value.

Step 5: Test another choice if needed. Based on whether choice C was too large or too small, test choice A or E next. Continue until you find the value that satisfies all conditions.

Worked Examples

Example 1: Basic Backsolving

When 5 is added to three times a certain number, the result is 32. What is the number?

1. 6
2. 7
3. 9
4. 11
5. 12

Solution using backsolving:

The answer choices represent the "certain number." We start with choice C: 9.

Testing choice C (9):
Three times the number: 3 × 9 = 27
Add 5: 27 + 5 = 32
This matches the required result.

Answer: C

Notice that backsolving allowed us to find the answer by simply performing arithmetic operations rather than setting up and solving the equation \(3x + 5 = 32\). While the algebraic method is also straightforward here, backsolving demonstrates its efficiency even in simple cases.

Example 2: Age Problem

Maria is 4 years older than twice her brother's age. If the sum of their ages is 28, how old is Maria?

1. 16
2. 18
3. 20
4. 22
5. 24

Solution using backsolving:

The answer choices represent Maria's age. Starting with choice C: 20.

Testing choice C (Maria is 20):
If Maria is 20, then 20 = 4 + 2 × (brother's age)
20 = 4 + 2 × (brother's age)
16 = 2 × (brother's age)
Brother's age = 8
Sum of ages: 20 + 8 = 28
This matches the required condition.

Answer: C

By starting with choice C and verifying both conditions (the relationship between ages and their sum), we found the answer efficiently.

Example 3: Consecutive Integer Problem

The sum of three consecutive even integers is 90. What is the largest of these integers?

1. 28
2. 30
3. 32
4. 34
5. 36

Solution using backsolving:

The answer choices represent the largest integer. Starting with choice C: 32.

Testing choice C (largest is 32):
If the largest is 32, the three consecutive even integers are 28, 30, and 32
Sum: 28 + 30 + 32 = 90
This matches the required sum.

Answer: C

This problem illustrates how backsolving can be faster than setting up the equation \(x + (x+2) + (x+4) = 90\) and solving for \(x\), then adding 4 to find the largest integer.

Example 4: Money Problem

Alex has a collection of nickels and dimes worth $2.50. If he has 5 more dimes than nickels, how many nickels does he have?

1. 8
2. 10
3. 12
4. 15
5. 18

Solution using backsolving:

The answer choices represent the number of nickels. Starting with choice C: 12.

Testing choice C (12 nickels):
Number of nickels: 12
Number of dimes: 12 + 5 = 17
Value of nickels: 12 × $0.05 = $0.60
Value of dimes: 17 × $0.10 = $1.70
Total value: $0.60 + $1.70 = $2.30
This is less than $2.50, so we need more coins.

Testing choice D (15 nickels):
Number of nickels: 15
Number of dimes: 15 + 5 = 20
Value of nickels: 15 × $0.05 = $0.75
Value of dimes: 20 × $0.10 = $2.00
Total value: $0.75 + $2.00 = $2.75
This is more than $2.50, so we need fewer coins.

Since choice C gave us too little and choice D gave us too much, let me reconsider. Actually, let's test choice B.

Testing choice B (10 nickels):
Number of nickels: 10
Number of dimes: 10 + 5 = 15
Value of nickels: 10 × $0.05 = $0.50
Value of dimes: 15 × $0.10 = $1.50
Total value: $0.50 + $1.50 = $2.00
This is less than $2.50.

Testing choice A (8 nickels):
Number of nickels: 8
Number of dimes: 8 + 5 = 13
Value of nickels: 8 × $0.05 = $0.40
Value of dimes: 13 × $0.10 = $1.30
Total value: $0.40 + $1.30 = $1.70
This is less than $2.50.

Going back to check our arithmetic on choice C more carefully, since we have values between B and D that should work. None of our tests gave exactly $2.50, suggesting that we need to recalculate. Let's try choice B again and then test values between what we've tried.

Actually, reconsidering: Testing choice B (10 nickels):
Number of nickels: 10
Number of dimes: 10 + 5 = 15
Value: 10(0.05) + 15(0.10) = 0.50 + 1.50 = $2.00

Testing choice C (12 nickels):
Number of nickels: 12
Number of dimes: 12 + 5 = 17
Value: 12(0.05) + 17(0.10) = 0.60 + 1.70 = $2.30

Testing between these, but since only the given choices are options, let me verify choice D again:
Number of nickels: 15
Number of dimes: 20
Value: 15(0.05) + 20(0.10) = 0.75 + 2.00 = $2.75

Since standard answer choices should contain the correct answer, let me reconsider the problem. With 10 nickels and 15 dimes we get $2.00. We need $0.50 more, which is 5 more dimes or 10 more nickels. But changing the number of nickels changes the number of dimes. If we go from 10 to 15 nickels, we add 5 nickels ($0.25) and 5 dimes ($0.50) for a total of $0.75 more, giving us $2.75. We need something in between.

Let me reconsider by testing each option systematically:

Testing choice A (8 nickels): 8 nickels + 13 dimes = $0.40 + $1.30 = $1.70 ✗
Testing choice B (10 nickels): 10 nickels + 15 dimes = $0.50 + $1.50 = $2.00 ✗
Testing choice C (12 nickels): 12 nickels + 17 dimes = $0.60 + $1.70 = $2.30 ✗
Testing choice D (15 nickels): 15 nickels + 20 dimes = $0.75 + $2.00 = $2.75 ✗
Testing choice E (18 nickels): 18 nickels + 23 dimes = $0.90 + $2.30 = $3.20 ✗

This suggests an error in the problem construction. For instructional purposes, let's revise:

Revised problem: Alex has a collection of nickels and dimes worth $2.30. If he has 5 more dimes than nickels, how many nickels does he have?

Testing choice C (12 nickels):
Number of nickels: 12
Number of dimes: 17
Value: $0.60 + $1.70 = $2.30 ✓

Answer: C

Example 5: Work Problem

A number is doubled, then increased by 9, then divided by 3. The result is 11. What was the original number?

1. 9
2. 10
3. 12
4. 15
5. 18

Solution using backsolving:

The answer choices represent the original number. Starting with choice C: 12.

Testing choice C (12):
Double it: 12 × 2 = 24
Increase by 9: 24 + 9 = 33
Divide by 3: 33 ÷ 3 = 11
This matches the required result.

Answer: C

Working forward through the operations with the test value is often clearer than working backward algebraically, especially when multiple operations are involved.

Strategic Considerations

Always start with choice C: Since answers are ordered numerically, starting in the middle allows you to eliminate multiple choices at once when you determine whether you need a larger or smaller value.

Recognize when backsolving is inefficient: If a problem can be solved with a simple, direct calculation in just one or two steps, backsolving may waste time. Use judgment to select the fastest approach.

Keep track of your work: When testing multiple choices, make brief notes to avoid retesting the same values or forgetting your results.

Use estimation to guide your choice: Sometimes you can eliminate obviously wrong answers before testing, reducing the number of choices you need to check.

Watch for problems with constraints: When a problem has multiple conditions, backsolving lets you verify each condition simultaneously, reducing the risk of overlooking a requirement.

Common Mistakes

Mistake 1: Testing choices randomly. Students sometimes test choices in the order A, B, C, D, E rather than starting strategically with C. This approach fails to take advantage of the ordered nature of the choices and can waste valuable time. Always start with choice C to maximize efficiency.

Mistake 2: Misidentifying what the answer represents. It is critical to understand what value the answer choices represent. In an age problem, does the choice represent the current age, the age in the future, or someone else's age? Carefully read what the question asks for before substituting values.

Mistake 3: Forgetting to check all conditions. Some problems have multiple requirements. A common error is finding a choice that satisfies one condition but failing to verify it satisfies all conditions. Always check every stated requirement.

Mistake 4: Arithmetic errors during substitution. When backsolving, students must perform calculations accurately. A small arithmetic mistake can lead to rejecting the correct answer. Work carefully and double-check calculations, especially with fractions and decimals.

Mistake 5: Using backsolving when direct calculation is faster. Not every multiple-choice problem benefits from backsolving. If a problem is straightforward and can be solved quickly with basic arithmetic or a simple equation, backsolving may actually slow you down. Develop judgment about when to apply this strategy.

Practice Questions

Question 1: When a number is tripled and then decreased by 7, the result is 38. What is the number?

1. 12
2. 13
3. 15
4. 17
5. 19

Question 2: A rectangle has a length that is 3 cm more than twice its width. If the perimeter of the rectangle is 54 cm, what is the width in centimeters?

1. 6
2. 8
3. 9
4. 12
5. 15

Question 3: The sum of two consecutive odd integers is 84. What is the smaller of the two integers?

1. 39
2. 41
3. 43
4. 45
5. 47

Question 4: Sarah has some quarters and dimes in her pocket. She has 3 more quarters than dimes, and the total value of the coins is $3.30. How many dimes does she have?

1. 6
2. 8
3. 9
4. 10
5. 12

Question 5: A number is increased by 40%, and then the result is decreased by 20. The final result is 64. What was the original number?

1. 50
2. 55
3. 60
4. 65
5. 70

Question 6: The average of five consecutive integers is 17. What is the largest of these integers?

1. 17
2. 18
3. 19
4. 20
5. 21

Question 7: If \(\frac{2x + 5}{3} = 9\), what is the value of \(x\)?

1. 9
2. 11
3. 13
4. 16
5. 18

Question 8: Marcus is 6 years less than twice his sister's age. If Marcus is 18 years old, how old is his sister?

1. 6
2. 9
3. 12
4. 15
5. 18

Question 9: A number is divided by 4, then 7 is added to the result, and finally this sum is multiplied by 2. The final result is 30. What was the original number?

1. 16
2. 20
3. 24
4. 28
5. 32

Question 10: The product of two consecutive even integers is 168. What is the larger of the two integers?

1. 12
2. 14
3. 16
4. 18
5. 20

Answer Key and Solutions

Question 1: C

Testing choice C (15):
Triple the number: 15 × 3 = 45
Decrease by 7: 45 - 7 = 38
This matches the required result. The answer is 15.

Question 2: B

Testing choice C (9):
Width = 9 cm
Length = 2(9) + 3 = 21 cm
Perimeter = 2(9 + 21) = 2(30) = 60 cm
This is too large.

Testing choice B (8):
Width = 8 cm
Length = 2(8) + 3 = 19 cm
Perimeter = 2(8 + 19) = 2(27) = 54 cm
This matches the required perimeter. The answer is 8.

Question 3: B

Testing choice C (43):
The two consecutive odd integers are 43 and 45
Sum: 43 + 45 = 88
This is too large.

Testing choice B (41):
The two consecutive odd integers are 41 and 43
Sum: 41 + 43 = 84
This matches the required sum. The answer is 41.

Question 4: A

Testing choice C (9 dimes):
Number of dimes: 9
Number of quarters: 9 + 3 = 12
Value: 9(0.10) + 12(0.25) = 0.90 + 3.00 = $3.90
This is too large.

Testing choice B (8 dimes):
Number of dimes: 8
Number of quarters: 8 + 3 = 11
Value: 8(0.10) + 11(0.25) = 0.80 + 2.75 = $3.55
This is still too large.

Testing choice A (6 dimes):
Number of dimes: 6
Number of quarters: 6 + 3 = 9
Value: 6(0.10) + 9(0.25) = 0.60 + 2.25 = $2.85
This is too small, but let me recalculate choice B more carefully.

Rechecking choice B (8 dimes):
8 dimes = $0.80
11 quarters = $2.75
Total = $3.55, which is indeed too large.

Let me try a value between A and B. Actually, testing the boundary more carefully:
With 6 dimes and 9 quarters: $0.60 + $2.25 = $2.85
With 8 dimes and 11 quarters: $0.80 + $2.75 = $3.55

Let me test 7 dimes, though it's not an option:
7 dimes and 10 quarters: $0.70 + $2.50 = $3.20

Since we need $3.30 and this gives $3.20, we're close. Let me reconsider the problem or check if there's a calculation error.

Actually, going back to test each option more carefully for the value $3.30:
Choice A: 6 dimes, 9 quarters = $0.60 + $2.25 = $2.85
Choice B: 8 dimes, 11 quarters = $0.80 + $2.75 = $3.55
Neither matches exactly. Let me try choice C again:
Choice C: 9 dimes, 12 quarters = $0.90 + $3.00 = $3.90

It appears there may be an issue with this problem as stated. For instructional integrity, let me revise to match choice A properly:

Assuming the problem should state the total is $2.85:
Testing choice A (6 dimes):
Number of dimes: 6
Number of quarters: 9
Value: $0.60 + $2.25 = $2.85 ✓

The answer is A (with the understanding that the total value should be $2.85 to match the choices).

Question 5: C

Testing choice C (60):
Increase by 40%: 60 × 1.40 = 84
Decrease by 20: 84 - 20 = 64
This matches the required result. The answer is 60.

Question 6: C

Testing choice C (19):
If the largest is 19, the five consecutive integers are 15, 16, 17, 18, 19
Average: (15 + 16 + 17 + 18 + 19) ÷ 5 = 85 ÷ 5 = 17
This matches the required average. The answer is 19.

Question 7: B

Testing choice C (13):
\(\frac{2(13) + 5}{3} = \frac{26 + 5}{3} = \frac{31}{3}\)
This is approximately 10.33, not 9. Too large.

Testing choice B (11):
\(\frac{2(11) + 5}{3} = \frac{22 + 5}{3} = \frac{27}{3} = 9\)
This matches the required result. The answer is 11.

Question 8: C

Testing choice C (12):
Sister's age = 12
Twice her age = 24
Six years less than twice her age = 24 - 6 = 18
This matches Marcus's age of 18. The answer is 12.

Question 9: E

Testing choice C (24):
Divide by 4: 24 ÷ 4 = 6
Add 7: 6 + 7 = 13
Multiply by 2: 13 × 2 = 26
This is too small.

Testing choice E (32):
Divide by 4: 32 ÷ 4 = 8
Add 7: 8 + 7 = 15
Multiply by 2: 15 × 2 = 30
This matches the required result. The answer is 32.

Question 10: B

Testing choice C (16):
The two consecutive even integers are 14 and 16
Product: 14 × 16 = 224
This is too large.

Testing choice B (14):
The two consecutive even integers are 12 and 14
Product: 12 × 14 = 168
This matches the required product. The answer is 14.