Judiciary Exams Exam  >  Judiciary Exams Notes  >  Important Acts and Laws  >  Cheatsheet: The Principles of Equity with Special Reference to the Law of Trust and Specific Relief

Cheatsheet: The Principles of Equity with Special Reference to the Law of Trust and Specific Relief

1. Principles of Equity

1.1 Origin and Nature of Equity

ConceptDescription
EquityBody of rules developed by Court of Chancery to supplement and mitigate rigors of common law
Maxim: Equity follows the lawEquity supplements but does not supplant common law
Maxim: Equity aids the vigilantThose who sleep on their rights shall not be aided by equity
Maxim: Equity looks to intent rather than formSubstance prevails over form in equitable proceedings
Maxim: He who seeks equity must do equityClaimant must act fairly towards defendant
Maxim: He who comes to equity must come with clean handsParty with unclean hands cannot seek equitable relief
Maxim: Equity regards as done that which ought to be doneTreats obligations as if already performed when required by justice
Maxim: Where equities are equal, law prevailsWhen competing equitable claims are equal, legal title holder prevails
Maxim: Equity acts in personamEquity operates on the person, not on property directly

1.2 Application of Equity in India

  • Section 9, CPC: Courts shall grant all relief the plaintiff is entitled to even if not specifically claimed
  • Section 39, Specific Relief Act, 1963: Discretion to grant or refuse specific performance based on equity
  • Section 20, Specific Relief Act: Cancellation of instruments based on equitable grounds
  • Courts apply principles of justice, equity, and good conscience where statutes are silent

2. Law of Trust

2.1 Definition and Essential Elements

ElementDescription
Trust - Section 3, Indian Trusts Act, 1882Obligation annexed to ownership of property arising out of confidence reposed in and accepted by owner for benefit of another
Author of Trust/SettlorPerson who reposes or declares confidence
TrusteePerson who accepts confidence; legal owner of trust property
Beneficiary/Cestui que trustPerson for whose benefit trust is created; equitable owner
Trust PropertySubject matter of trust; must be specific and transferable
Trust InstrumentDocument creating the trust (deed, will, etc.)

2.2 Creation of Trust

2.2.1 Requirements for Valid Trust

  • Competent author - Section 7: Any person competent to contract
  • Clear intention to create trust - must be definite and certain
  • Lawful purpose - Section 4: Must not be forbidden by law, immoral, or defeat any law provision
  • Definite beneficiary - Section 9: Must be ascertainable except for charitable/religious trusts
  • Transfer of property to trustee - Section 5
  • Acceptance by trustee - Section 10: Express or implied

2.2.2 Mode of Creation - Section 5

TypeMode
Inter vivos trustBy non-testamentary instrument in writing signed by author with registration if immovable property exceeds Rs. 100
Testamentary trustBy will executed according to Indian Succession Act, 1925
Declaration of trustAuthor declares himself as trustee for beneficiary

2.3 Types of Trusts

TypeDescription
Private TrustCreated for benefit of one or more definite persons
Public/Charitable TrustFor public religious or charitable purposes; governed by specific state laws
Express TrustCreated by express declaration of author
Implied/Constructive TrustImposed by law on grounds of equity, fraud, or breach of confidence
Resulting TrustArises where beneficial interest reverts to settlor (purchase in name of another without intent to benefit)
Executed TrustNo further act required; beneficiary gets immediate interest
Executory TrustRequires further instrument for complete execution

2.4 Duties and Powers of Trustee

2.4.1 Duties - Sections 11-29

  • Section 11: Execute trust with reasonable diligence
  • Section 12: Allow inspection and give information to beneficiary
  • Section 13: Keep clear and accurate accounts
  • Section 14: Not profit from trust; no conflict of interest
  • Section 15: Not use trust property for own profit
  • Section 16: Duty not to delegate - delegatus non potest delegare (except for ministerial acts)
  • Section 17: Invest only in authorized securities unless otherwise empowered
  • Section 18: Duty of impartiality among beneficiaries
  • Section 20: Duty to keep trust property distinct from own property

2.4.2 Powers - Sections 30-53

  • Section 30: Sell trust property when necessary for payment of debts or investments
  • Section 31: Apply income for maintenance of minor beneficiary
  • Section 32: Insure trust property
  • Section 33: Compromise claims
  • Section 34: Give receipts and discharge obligations
  • Section 35: Power to lease for limited period (maximum 21 years for agricultural, 3 years for other purposes)

2.5 Rights and Liabilities of Trustee

2.6 Rights of Beneficiary

  • Section 56: Transfer beneficial interest subject to restrictions in trust instrument
  • Section 57: Inspect and take copies of trust documents
  • Section 58: Compel trustee to execute trust properly
  • Section 59: Follow trust property into hands of third party (tracing)
  • Section 60: Impound breach of trust proceeds
  • Section 61: Remove trustee for breach of trust
  • Section 62: Obtain accounts from trustee

2.7 Termination of Trust

AspectDetails
Right to indemnity - Section 44Reimbursement for expenses properly incurred in execution of trust
Right to lien - Section 46Lien on trust property for expenses and liabilities incurred
Right to payment - Section 48No right to remuneration unless provided in trust instrument
Liability for breach - Section 23Liable for loss caused by breach of trust; must make good the loss
Joint trustees - Section 24All must join; each liable for own acts and omissions only unless acting jointly
ModeDetails
Section 77: Purpose fulfilledTrust terminates when purpose is completely achieved
Section 78: Performance impossibleTermination when trust purpose becomes impossible or unlawful
Section 79: Destruction of propertyTrust ends if entire trust property is destroyed
Section 80: RevocationWhen power to revoke is reserved by author
Agreement of partiesAll beneficiaries and trustees agree to terminate if beneficiaries are sui juris
Court orderCourt may terminate on equitable grounds or changed circumstances

3. Specific Relief

3.1 Introduction to Specific Relief Act, 1963

ConceptDescription
Specific ReliefEquitable remedy requiring actual performance of obligation rather than damages
Application - Section 1Extends to whole of India; came into force on 1st March 1964
Section 2: Suit for compensationParty may combine or substitute claim for compensation with specific relief
Section 3: SavingsDoes not affect rights under other laws

3.2 Recovering Possession of Property - Sections 5-8

SectionProvision
Section 5Recovery of specific immovable property: Person entitled to possess may recover it from wrongful possessor
Section 6Suit by dispossessed owner: Person dispossessed otherwise than in due course of law may recover possession
Section 7Recovery of specific movable property: Owner may recover possession with or without damages
Section 8When relief not available: Cannot recover if property has passed to transferee for value in good faith

3.3 Specific Performance of Contracts - Sections 9-25

3.3.1 When Granted - Section 10

  • Contracts for transfer of immovable property: Court may direct specific performance
  • Amendment 2018: Changed from discretionary to mandatory subject to exceptions
  • No adequate remedy in damages available
  • Contract is in writing, registered, and signed by party against whom relief is sought

3.3.2 When Not Granted - Section 14

CircumstanceReason
14(1)(a)Compensation in money is adequate relief
14(1)(b)Contract runs into minute or numerous details or involves personal skill
14(1)(c)Contract is determinable in nature
14(1)(d)Performance involves violation of other legal provisions
14(1)(e)Contract is made for inadequate consideration
14(2)Contract contains negative covenant - injunction more appropriate

3.3.3 Who Can Obtain and Against Whom - Sections 15-16

  • Section 15: Any party to contract may obtain except persons with option to rescind, those who become incapable, or where contract is revocable/voidable at option of defendant
  • Section 16: Can be enforced against party to contract, representative in interest, person claiming through title arising after contract
  • Section 16(c): Cannot enforce against transferee for value without notice of original contract

3.3.4 Other Provisions

SectionProvision
Section 11Contracts not specifically enforceable: Where compensation is adequate, contract involves personal service or skill
Section 12Part performance of contracts relating to transfer of immovable property
Section 13Lessor and lessee rights: Lessee can enforce specific performance against lessor
Section 20Discretion regarding specific performance: Court considers conduct of parties
Section 21Power to award compensation in addition to or in substitution of specific performance
Section 22Time limit for suit: Within 3 years from date fixed for performance or if no date, from date of refusal to perform

3.4 Rectification of Instruments - Section 26

GroundDescription
Fraud or mutual mistake - Section 26(1)Court may rectify instrument to express real intention when fraud or mutual mistake causes deviation
Unilateral mistake - Section 26(2)Rectification when one party's mistake and other party's fraud/misrepresentation
LimitationsCannot rectify against bona fide purchaser for value without notice

3.5 Rescission of Contracts - Sections 27-30

SectionProvision
Section 27When rescission allowed: Voidable contracts, material alteration/breach, failure of consideration
Section 28Alternative to rescission: May insist on performance with compensation
Section 29When rescission refused: Third party rights created, substantial performance with minor breach
Section 30Court may order refund of benefits received under rescinded contract

3.6 Cancellation of Instruments - Sections 31-33

  • Section 31(1): Court may cancel voidable instruments or which have become void
  • Section 31(2): Person with limited interest may apply to cancel encumbrance on that interest
  • Section 32: Court may grant cancellation on equitable grounds even if no rescission
  • Section 33: Cancellation refused if third party rights in good faith created

3.7 Declaratory Decrees - Section 34

AspectDetails
Section 34(1)Person entitled to legal character, right to property, or declaration may obtain declaratory decree
ScopeDetermines status or right without consequential relief
Consequential reliefMay also claim consequential relief based on declaration
Bare declarationPure declaration without further relief permissible

3.8 Injunctions - Sections 36-42

3.8.1 Types of Injunctions

TypeDescription
Temporary/Interlocutory - Section 37(1)Granted during pendency of suit to preserve status quo
Perpetual - Section 37(2)Granted at hearing as final relief to prevent future breach
Mandatory Injunction - Section 37(3)Compels defendant to perform positive act to restore status quo
Prohibitory InjunctionRestrains defendant from doing particular act

3.8.2 When Granted - Section 38

  • Perpetual injunction to prevent breach of obligation existing in favor of applicant
  • When invasive act would cause injury not compensable in damages
  • When pecuniary compensation inadequate
  • Injury threatened is repetitive in nature
  • Defendant's wealth makes damages inadequate remedy

3.8.3 When Refused - Section 41

GroundExplanation
41(a)Conduct of plaintiff makes it inequitable to grant relief
41(b)Plaintiff has no personal interest in matter
41(c)Plaintiff has adequate alternative remedy
41(d)Conduct sought to be restrained is for public benefit
41(e)Application involves multiplicity of acts or continuous supervision
41(f)Injunction would cause greater hardship to defendant than benefit to plaintiff
41(g)Injunction prevents lawful exercise of possession
41(h)Equally effective relief can be obtained otherwise

3.8.4 Temporary Injunction

  • Section 37(1): Granted at any stage of suit
  • Order XXXIX, Rule 1-2, CPC: Prima facie case, balance of convenience, irreparable injury test
  • Section 41: Same limitations as perpetual injunction with necessary modifications
  • Duration: Until disposal of suit or further orders

3.8.5 Mandatory Injunction

  • Section 55 read with Order XXXIX, CPC: To restore things to position as of date of filing suit
  • Requires stronger case than prohibitory injunction
  • Court exercises caution; must be satisfied of urgent necessity

3.9 Other Provisions

SectionProvision
Section 39Perpetual injunction when refused: Where injunction would impede defendant's lawful acts without securing benefit to plaintiff
Section 40Damages in addition to injunction possible
Section 41A (Amendment 2018)Suit for infrastructure project delay: Compensation payable at 1% of contract value for each month of delay
Section 42Injunction to perform negative agreement enforceable if breach would produce injury not compensable

4. Interrelation of Equity, Trust, and Specific Relief

4.1 Application of Equitable Principles

  • Trusts are creatures of equity; trustees owe fiduciary duties based on equitable principles
  • Specific performance is equitable remedy requiring clean hands, readiness, and willingness
  • Discretion in granting specific relief guided by maxims of equity
  • Injunctions developed in equity to prevent unconscionable conduct
  • Constructive trusts imposed by equity to prevent unjust enrichment

4.2 Remedies Overlap

SituationRemedy
Breach of trustInjunction to restrain breach; specific performance to compel execution; rectification of trust deed
Trustee conflict of interestConstructive trust on profits; injunction against dealing
Transfer in breach of trustCancellation of transfer; recovery of property; declaration of rights
Charitable trust mismanagementInjunction; removal of trustee; appointment of new trustee

4.3 Equitable Defenses

  • Laches: Delay defeats equity; bars specific performance and injunctions
  • Acquiescence: Acceptance of breach bars equitable relief
  • Unclean hands: Plaintiff's misconduct bars relief under Section 41(a), SRA
  • Hardship: Balance of convenience and hardship considered under Section 41(f), SRA
  • Section 20, SRA: Court considers conduct, readiness, willingness in specific performance

5. Important Case Laws and Principles

5.1 Trust Principles

  • Intention to create trust must be clear and unambiguous
  • Three certainties: Certainty of intention, certainty of subject matter, certainty of objects
  • Trustee cannot purchase trust property - self-dealing rule
  • Fair-dealing rule: Trustee dealing with beneficiary must prove fairness
  • Doctrine of tracing: Follow trust property in hands of third parties unless bona fide purchaser for value without notice

5.2 Specific Performance Principles

  • Readiness and willingness essential - must be pleaded and proved
  • Time is essence: If stipulated, delay bars specific performance unless waived
  • Contract must be definite, complete, and certain in terms
  • Plaintiff must show ability to perform his part of contract
  • Amendment 2018: Shifted from discretionary to mandatory subject to exceptions

5.3 Injunction Principles

  • Prima facie case, balance of convenience, irreparable injury - three-fold test for temporary injunction
  • Irreparable injury: Injury not compensable in terms of money
  • Balance of convenience: Comparative mischief/inconvenience to both parties
  • Status quo: Position existing as of date of filing suit
  • Mandatory injunction requires stronger case and caution
  • No injunction against sovereign functions or statutory duties
The document Cheatsheet: The Principles of Equity with Special Reference to the Law of Trust and Specific Relief is a part of the Judiciary Exams Course Important Acts and Laws for Judiciary Exams.
All you need of Judiciary Exams at this link: Judiciary Exams
Explore Courses for Judiciary Exams exam
Get EduRev Notes directly in your Google search
Related Searches
Objective type Questions, Summary, mock tests for examination, Cheatsheet: The Principles of Equity with Special Reference to the Law of Trust and Specific Relief, Cheatsheet: The Principles of Equity with Special Reference to the Law of Trust and Specific Relief, Free, practice quizzes, pdf , Exam, Previous Year Questions with Solutions, Sample Paper, Extra Questions, ppt, MCQs, study material, video lectures, Semester Notes, Important questions, past year papers, Viva Questions, Cheatsheet: The Principles of Equity with Special Reference to the Law of Trust and Specific Relief, shortcuts and tricks;