Features of Variable Annuities

Table of Contents
1. Investment Structure and Subaccounts
2. Accumulation Phase Features
3. Annuitization Phase Features
4. Death Benefit and Living Benefit Riders
5. Tax Treatment
6. Regulatory and Suitability Considerations
View more

Variable annuities are insurance contracts with investment features. They combine elements of insurance products and securities. Unlike fixed annuities, variable annuities allow contract owners to allocate premiums among various investment options called subaccounts. The contract value fluctuates based on the performance of chosen investments. Understanding their features is critical because they are regulated as both insurance products and securities.

1. Investment Structure and Subaccounts

1.1 Separate Account Structure

• Separate Account: This is an investment portfolio maintained separately from the insurance company's general account. Premium payments are allocated to this account.
• Segregation from General Account: Assets in the separate account are not subject to claims of the insurance company's general creditors. This provides investor protection in case of insurer insolvency.
• Registration Requirement: The separate account must be registered with the SEC as a Unit Investment Trust (UIT) or as a management company under the Investment Company Act of 1940.

1.2 Subaccount Investment Options

• Subaccounts: These are individual investment portfolios within the separate account. Each subaccount invests in a specific mutual fund or has a distinct investment objective (e.g., growth, income, balanced).
• Variety of Choices: Contract owners can typically choose from multiple subaccounts, including equity, bond, money market, and balanced portfolios.
• Switching Privileges: Contract owners can usually transfer funds among subaccounts without tax consequences. This is called reallocation or transfer. Some contracts limit the number of free transfers per year.
• Investment Risk: The contract owner bears the investment risk. Account value and payout amounts fluctuate based on subaccount performance. There is no guarantee of principal or returns (unless optional riders are purchased).

2. Accumulation Phase Features

2.1 Premium Payments

• Flexible Contributions: Variable annuities may accept single premium (one lump sum payment) or periodic premium payments (multiple contributions over time).
• Tax-Deferred Growth: Earnings within the separate account grow tax-deferred during the accumulation phase. No taxes are paid on capital gains, dividends, or interest until withdrawals begin.
• Non-Qualified vs. Qualified: Variable annuities can be purchased with after-tax dollars (non-qualified) or within retirement accounts like IRAs (qualified). Qualified annuities offer upfront tax deductions but redundant tax deferral.

2.2 Accumulation Unit Accounting

• Accumulation Units (AUs): During the accumulation phase, the contract value is measured in accumulation units. These represent the owner's proportional share of the subaccount.
• Unit Value Calculation: Accumulation unit value changes daily based on the performance of underlying investments. It is calculated by dividing the total value of the subaccount by the number of outstanding accumulation units.
• Purchase of AUs: When premiums are invested, they purchase accumulation units at the current unit value (typically calculated at the end of each business day).

2.3 Charges and Fees During Accumulation

• Mortality and Expense Risk Charge (M&E): This fee compensates the insurer for mortality risk and guarantees (typically 1.0%-1.5% annually). It is deducted from the separate account.
• Administrative Fees: Annual contract maintenance fees cover recordkeeping and administrative costs. These may be flat dollar amounts (e.g., $25-$50 per year) or percentage-based.
• Investment Management Fees: Subaccounts charge fees similar to mutual fund expense ratios (typically 0.5%-2.0% annually) for portfolio management.
• Surrender Charges: Early withdrawals during the surrender period (typically 5-10 years) trigger surrender charges. These are contingent deferred sales charges (CDSC) that decline over time. Example: 7% in year 1, declining to 0% after year 7.
• Front-End Loads: Some contracts charge sales loads when premiums are paid, though these are less common in variable annuities.

3. Annuitization Phase Features

3.1 Conversion to Annuity Units

• Annuitization: This is the process of converting the accumulated value into a stream of periodic payments. It marks the transition from accumulation to payout phase.
• Annuity Units (AUs): Upon annuitization, accumulation units are converted into annuity units. The number of annuity units remains fixed for life.
• Annuity Unit Value: The value of each annuity unit fluctuates based on separate account performance. Payment amounts vary with changes in annuity unit value.
• Assumed Interest Rate (AIR): This is the projected growth rate used to calculate initial payments. Typical AIR is 3%-5%. If actual returns exceed AIR, payments increase; if returns fall below AIR, payments decrease.

3.2 Payout Options

• Life Annuity (Straight Life): Payments continue for the annuitant's lifetime only. Highest periodic payment but no beneficiary protection. Payments stop at death.
• Life Annuity with Period Certain: Payments continue for life, but guaranteed for a minimum period (e.g., 10 or 20 years). If death occurs during the period certain, beneficiary receives remaining payments.
• Joint and Last Survivor: Payments continue as long as either of two annuitants (typically spouses) is alive. Payments stop only after both die. Lower payment amount than single life.
• Unit Refund: If the annuitant dies before recovering the initial investment (in annuity units), the beneficiary receives the remaining value in a lump sum.

3.3 Payment Characteristics

• Variable Payments: Unlike fixed annuities, payment amounts fluctuate based on investment performance. This provides inflation protection potential but introduces payment uncertainty.
• First Payment Calculation: Determined by the accumulated value, payout option selected, annuitant's age and sex (if permitted), and the AIR.
• Subsequent Payments: Compared to AIR each period. If separate account return > AIR, payment increases. If return < air,="" payment="" decreases.="" if="" return="AIR," payment="" stays="" the="">

4. Death Benefit and Living Benefit Riders

4.1 Standard Death Benefit

• Death Benefit Guarantee: Variable annuities typically guarantee that upon death during accumulation phase, the beneficiary receives the greater of: (a) current account value, or (b) total premiums paid minus withdrawals.
• Beneficiary Protection: This protects beneficiaries from market losses. If the contract owner dies when account value is below premiums paid, the beneficiary still receives the premium amount.
• Payout to Beneficiary: Death benefits are typically paid as a lump sum, though some contracts offer payout options to beneficiaries.

4.2 Enhanced Death Benefit Riders

• Step-Up Death Benefit: The death benefit is periodically reset to the current account value if it exceeds the previous level. For example, reset annually on contract anniversary. This locks in gains.
• Earnings Enhancement Benefit: Death benefit equals premiums paid plus a percentage of earnings (e.g., premiums plus 40% of gains).
• Cost: Enhanced death benefits require additional fees, typically adding 0.15%-0.50% annually to total contract costs.

4.3 Living Benefit Riders

• Guaranteed Minimum Income Benefit (GMIB): Guarantees a minimum annuity payout level regardless of account performance, if the contract is annuitized after a specified waiting period (e.g., 10 years).
• Guaranteed Minimum Withdrawal Benefit (GMWB): Allows withdrawal of a guaranteed amount (e.g., total premiums paid) over time, even if account value drops to zero. Typically allows annual withdrawals of 5%-7% of benefit base.
• Guaranteed Minimum Accumulation Benefit (GMAB): Guarantees the contract value will equal at least a specified amount (often total premiums) after a set period (e.g., 10 years), regardless of investment performance.
• Guaranteed Lifetime Withdrawal Benefit (GLWB): Provides guaranteed income for life without requiring annuitization. Allows withdrawal of a specified percentage annually for life, even if account value is depleted.
• Rider Costs: Living benefit riders add significant costs, typically 0.25%-1.50% annually, depending on the guarantee level.

5. Tax Treatment

5.1 Tax Deferral During Accumulation

• Tax-Deferred Growth: All earnings (interest, dividends, capital gains) accumulate tax-free during the accumulation phase. No annual tax reporting of gains is required.
• No Step-Up in Basis: Unlike securities held until death, variable annuities do not receive a step-up in cost basis at death. Beneficiaries must pay income tax on accumulated gains.

5.2 Taxation of Withdrawals

• LIFO Accounting (Last In, First Out): Withdrawals are treated as earnings first, then principal (for non-qualified contracts). Earnings are taxed as ordinary income, not capital gains.
• Ordinary Income Tax: All distributions are taxed at ordinary income rates, which can be higher than long-term capital gains rates (maximum 37% vs. 20%).
• 10% Early Withdrawal Penalty: Withdrawals before age 59½ are subject to a 10% IRS penalty tax on the taxable portion, in addition to ordinary income tax. Exceptions exist for death, disability, or substantially equal periodic payments (SEPP).

5.3 Taxation of Annuity Payments

• Exclusion Ratio (Non-Qualified): Each payment is partly tax-free return of principal and partly taxable earnings. The exclusion ratio determines the tax-free portion based on the investment in the contract divided by expected return.
• Fully Taxable (Qualified): For qualified annuities (purchased with pre-tax dollars in IRAs), 100% of each payment is taxable as ordinary income.
• 1035 Exchange: Variable annuities can be exchanged for another annuity contract tax-free under IRC Section 1035. This allows movement between contracts without triggering taxes, though surrender charges may still apply.

6. Regulatory and Suitability Considerations

6.1 Dual Regulatory Framework

• Securities Regulation: Variable annuities are regulated as securities because returns are tied to separate account performance. They must be registered with the SEC under the Securities Act of 1933.
• Insurance Regulation: They are also insurance products regulated by state insurance departments. Issuers must be licensed insurers.
• Prospectus Requirement: A prospectus must be delivered to investors at or before the sale. The prospectus discloses fees, risks, investment options, and contract features.
• Representative Licensing: Only registered representatives with both securities licenses (Series 6 or 7) and state insurance licenses can sell variable annuities.

6.2 Suitability and Sales Practice Rules

• Suitability Obligation: FINRA Rule 2330 requires representatives to have a reasonable basis to believe the variable annuity is suitable based on the customer's financial situation, needs, and investment objectives.
• Suitability Factors: Age, investment experience, financial situation, tax status, investment objectives, risk tolerance, liquidity needs, and time horizon must be considered.
• Unsuitability Red Flags: Variable annuities are generally unsuitable for customers needing liquidity within the surrender period, elderly investors with short time horizons, or those already holding annuities in qualified accounts (redundant tax deferral).
• Principal Review: A principal must review and approve each variable annuity transaction, typically within seven business days.
• Replacement Transactions: Replacing an existing annuity (exchange via Section 1035) requires special disclosure and principal review. Replacements often trigger new surrender periods and may not benefit the customer.

6.3 Common Student Mistakes

• Trap Alert - Tax Treatment: Variable annuity earnings are taxed as ordinary income, NOT capital gains. Many students incorrectly assume favorable capital gains treatment applies.
• Trap Alert - Qualified Annuities: Purchasing a variable annuity inside an IRA provides redundant tax deferral (the IRA already defers taxes). This is generally unsuitable unless specific features like death benefits justify the added costs.
• Trap Alert - AIR Comparison: If the separate account return equals the AIR, the annuity payment stays the same (not increases). Payments increase only when returns exceed AIR.
• Trap Alert - Death During Annuitization: Once annuitized under a straight life option, no death benefit is payable. The contract ends at death with no value to beneficiaries. Death benefits apply only during accumulation or with period certain/refund options.
• Trap Alert - Surrender Charges: Surrender charges apply to withdrawals exceeding the free withdrawal amount (typically 10%-15% annually), not to all withdrawals. Partial withdrawals within the free amount avoid surrender charges.

Variable annuities offer tax-deferred growth and lifetime income potential but come with complexity, high costs, and surrender charges. They combine investment risk with insurance features through separate account structures and various optional riders. Proper understanding of their investment mechanics, fee structures, tax treatment, and regulatory requirements is essential. These products are most suitable for long-term investors seeking tax deferral and guaranteed income who can tolerate investment risk and liquidity restrictions. Always evaluate suitability based on individual client circumstances and compare total costs against potential benefits.