Stability of Two Oxidation States
Introduction:
The stability of oxidation states refers to the tendency of an element to exist in a particular oxidation state. Some elements can exist in multiple oxidation states, and the stability of these states depends on various factors such as electron configuration, ionization energy, and the nature of bonding.
Explanation:
In the given options, the correct representation of the stability of two oxidation states is option B, which states Mn2 and Mn3.
Mn2:
- The element manganese (Mn) has an atomic number of 25, and its electron configuration is [Ar] 3d5 4s2.
- Mn2 refers to the +2 oxidation state of manganese. In this state, two electrons are removed from the 4s orbital, leaving behind the electron configuration [Ar] 3d5.
- The 3d5 configuration is a half-filled or near-half-filled configuration, which is relatively stable due to the exchange energy and electron-electron repulsion effects.
- Hence, Mn2 is a stable oxidation state for manganese.
Mn3:
- Mn3 refers to the +3 oxidation state of manganese. In this state, three electrons are removed from the 4s and 3d orbitals, leaving behind the electron configuration [Ar] 3d4.
- The 3d4 configuration is also relatively stable as it is a half-filled configuration, similar to Mn2.
- Additionally, the removal of another electron from the 3d orbital results in the formation of a high-spin d4 configuration, which is energetically favorable.
- Therefore, Mn3 is also a stable oxidation state for manganese.
Other Options:
- Option A (Ti3 and Ti4): Titanium (Ti) has an atomic number of 22, and its electron configuration is [Ar] 3d2 4s2.
- Ti3 would require the removal of all four valence electrons, resulting in an unstable configuration.
- Ti4 would require the removal of all six valence electrons, resulting in an extremely unstable configuration.
- Option C (Fe2 and Fe3): Iron (Fe) has an atomic number of 26, and its electron configuration is [Ar] 3d6 4s2.
- Fe2 would require the removal of all six valence electrons, resulting in an unstable configuration.
- Fe3 would require the removal of all eight valence electrons, resulting in an extremely unstable configuration.
- Option D (Cu and Cu2): Copper (Cu) has an atomic number of 29, and its electron configuration is [Ar] 3d10 4s1.
- Cu is the most stable in its +1 oxidation state (Cu+), where it loses the 4s electron.
- Cu2 would require the removal of all ten valence electrons, resulting in an extremely unstable configuration.
Conclusion:
Based on the electron configurations and stability considerations, the correct representation of the stability of two oxidation states is option B, which states Mn2 and Mn3.