Page 1
Credit: Shankar
In this chapter…
The challenge of nation-building, covered in the last chapter, was
accompanied by the challenge of instituting democratic politics. Thus,
electoral competition among political parties began immediately after
Independence. In this chapter, we look at the first decade of electoral
politics in order to understand
• the establishment of a system of free and fair elections;
• the domination of the Congress party in the years immediately
after Independence; and
• the emergence of opposition parties and their policies.
This famous sketch
by Shankar appeared
on the cover of his
collection – Don’t Spare
Me, Shankar. The
original sketch was
drawn in the context of
India’s China policy. But
this cartoon captures
the dual role of the
Congress during the era
of one-party dominance.
chap 2_PF.indd 26 9/6/2022 3:57:55 PM
2024-25
Page 2
Credit: Shankar
In this chapter…
The challenge of nation-building, covered in the last chapter, was
accompanied by the challenge of instituting democratic politics. Thus,
electoral competition among political parties began immediately after
Independence. In this chapter, we look at the first decade of electoral
politics in order to understand
• the establishment of a system of free and fair elections;
• the domination of the Congress party in the years immediately
after Independence; and
• the emergence of opposition parties and their policies.
This famous sketch
by Shankar appeared
on the cover of his
collection – Don’t Spare
Me, Shankar. The
original sketch was
drawn in the context of
India’s China policy. But
this cartoon captures
the dual role of the
Congress during the era
of one-party dominance.
chap 2_PF.indd 26 9/6/2022 3:57:55 PM
2024-25
Challenge of building democracy
You now have an idea of the difficult circumstances in which
independent India was born. You have read about the serious
challenge of nation-building that confronted the country right in the
beginning. Faced with such serious challenges, leaders in many other
countries of the world decided that their country could not afford
to have democracy. They said that national unity was their first
priority and that democracy will introduce differences and conflicts.
Therefore many of the countries that gained freedom from colonialism
experienced non-democratic rule. It took various forms: nominal
democracy but effective control by one leader, one party rule or direct
army rule. Non-democratic regimes always started with a promise of
restoring democracy very soon. But once they established themselves,
it was very difficult to dislodge them.
The conditions in India were not very different. But the leaders of
the newly independent India decided to take the more difficult path.
Any other path would have been surprising, for our freedom struggle
was deeply committed to the idea of democracy. Our leaders were
conscious of the critical role of politics in any democracy. They did not
see politics as a problem; they saw it as a way of solving the problems.
Every society needs to decide how it will govern and regulate itself.
There are always different policy alternatives to choose from. There
are different groups with different and conflicting aspirations. How
do we resolve these differences? Democratic politics is an answer to
this question. While competition and power are the two most visible
things about politics, the purpose of political activity is and should be
deciding and pursuing public interest. This is the route our leaders
decided to take.
Last year you studied how our Constitution was drafted.
You would remember that the Constitution was adopted on
26 November 1949 and signed on 24 January 1950 and it came into
effect on 26 January 1950. At that time the country was being ruled
by an interim government. It was now necessary to install the first
democratically elected government of the country. The Constitution
had laid down the rules, now the machine had to be put in place.
Initially it was thought that this was only a matter of a few months. The
Election Commission of India was set up in January 1950. Sukumar
Sen became the first Chief Election Commissioner. The country’s first
general elections were expected sometime in 1950 itself.
What’s so special
about our being a
democracy? Sooner
or later every country
has become a
democracy, isn’t it?
In India,….
…hero-worship, plays a part
in its politics unequalled
in magnitude by the part
it plays in the politics of
any other country….But in
politics, .. ..hero-worship is a
sure road to degradation and
eventual dictatorship.
Babasaheb Dr. B.R.
Ambedkar
Speech in Constituent
Assembly
25 November 1949
“
“
2
chapter
era of one-party
dominance
chap 2_PF.indd 27 9/6/2022 3:57:55 PM
2024-25
Page 3
Credit: Shankar
In this chapter…
The challenge of nation-building, covered in the last chapter, was
accompanied by the challenge of instituting democratic politics. Thus,
electoral competition among political parties began immediately after
Independence. In this chapter, we look at the first decade of electoral
politics in order to understand
• the establishment of a system of free and fair elections;
• the domination of the Congress party in the years immediately
after Independence; and
• the emergence of opposition parties and their policies.
This famous sketch
by Shankar appeared
on the cover of his
collection – Don’t Spare
Me, Shankar. The
original sketch was
drawn in the context of
India’s China policy. But
this cartoon captures
the dual role of the
Congress during the era
of one-party dominance.
chap 2_PF.indd 26 9/6/2022 3:57:55 PM
2024-25
Challenge of building democracy
You now have an idea of the difficult circumstances in which
independent India was born. You have read about the serious
challenge of nation-building that confronted the country right in the
beginning. Faced with such serious challenges, leaders in many other
countries of the world decided that their country could not afford
to have democracy. They said that national unity was their first
priority and that democracy will introduce differences and conflicts.
Therefore many of the countries that gained freedom from colonialism
experienced non-democratic rule. It took various forms: nominal
democracy but effective control by one leader, one party rule or direct
army rule. Non-democratic regimes always started with a promise of
restoring democracy very soon. But once they established themselves,
it was very difficult to dislodge them.
The conditions in India were not very different. But the leaders of
the newly independent India decided to take the more difficult path.
Any other path would have been surprising, for our freedom struggle
was deeply committed to the idea of democracy. Our leaders were
conscious of the critical role of politics in any democracy. They did not
see politics as a problem; they saw it as a way of solving the problems.
Every society needs to decide how it will govern and regulate itself.
There are always different policy alternatives to choose from. There
are different groups with different and conflicting aspirations. How
do we resolve these differences? Democratic politics is an answer to
this question. While competition and power are the two most visible
things about politics, the purpose of political activity is and should be
deciding and pursuing public interest. This is the route our leaders
decided to take.
Last year you studied how our Constitution was drafted.
You would remember that the Constitution was adopted on
26 November 1949 and signed on 24 January 1950 and it came into
effect on 26 January 1950. At that time the country was being ruled
by an interim government. It was now necessary to install the first
democratically elected government of the country. The Constitution
had laid down the rules, now the machine had to be put in place.
Initially it was thought that this was only a matter of a few months. The
Election Commission of India was set up in January 1950. Sukumar
Sen became the first Chief Election Commissioner. The country’s first
general elections were expected sometime in 1950 itself.
What’s so special
about our being a
democracy? Sooner
or later every country
has become a
democracy, isn’t it?
In India,….
…hero-worship, plays a part
in its politics unequalled
in magnitude by the part
it plays in the politics of
any other country….But in
politics, .. ..hero-worship is a
sure road to degradation and
eventual dictatorship.
Babasaheb Dr. B.R.
Ambedkar
Speech in Constituent
Assembly
25 November 1949
“
“
2
chapter
era of one-party
dominance
chap 2_PF.indd 27 9/6/2022 3:57:55 PM
2024-25
28 Politics in India sinc Independence
A cartoonist’s impression of the election committee formed by the Congress to choose party
candidates in 1951. On the committee, besides Nehru: Morarji Desai, Rafi Ahmed Kidwai,
Dr B.C. Roy, Kamaraj Nadar, Rajagopalachari, Jagjivan Ram, Maulana Azad, D.P. Mishra,
P.D. Tandon and Govind Ballabh Pant.
But the Election Commission discovered that it was not going to
be easy to hold a free and fair election in a country of India’s size.
Holding an election required delimitation or drawing the boundaries
of the electoral constituencies. It also required preparing the electoral
rolls, or the list of all the citizens eligible to vote. Both these tasks took
a lot of time. When the first draft of the rolls was published, it was
discovered that the names of nearly 40 lakh women were not recorded
in the list. They were simply listed as “wife of …” or “daughter of …”.
The Election Commission refused to accept these entries and ordered
a revision if possible and deletion if necessary. Preparing for the first
general election was a mammoth exercise. No election on this scale
had ever been conducted in the world before. At that time there
were 17 crore eligible voters, who had to elect about 3,200 MLAs and
489 Members of Lok Sabha. Only 15 per cent of these eligible voters
were literate. Therefore the Election Commission had to think of some
special method of voting. The Election Commission trained over 3
lakh officers and polling staff to conduct the elections.
It was not just the size of the country and the electorate that made
this election unusual. The first general election was also the first big
test of democracy in a poor and illiterate country. Till then democracy
had existed only in the prosperous countries, mainly in Europe and
North America, where nearly everyone was literate. By that time
many countries in Europe had not given voting rights to all women.
In this context India’s experiment with universal adult franchise
That was a good
decision. But what
about men who still
refer to a woman as
Mrs. Somebody, as if
she does not have a
name of her own?
Credit: Shankar, 20 May 1951
chap 2_PF.indd 28 9/6/2022 3:57:56 PM
2024-25
Page 4
Credit: Shankar
In this chapter…
The challenge of nation-building, covered in the last chapter, was
accompanied by the challenge of instituting democratic politics. Thus,
electoral competition among political parties began immediately after
Independence. In this chapter, we look at the first decade of electoral
politics in order to understand
• the establishment of a system of free and fair elections;
• the domination of the Congress party in the years immediately
after Independence; and
• the emergence of opposition parties and their policies.
This famous sketch
by Shankar appeared
on the cover of his
collection – Don’t Spare
Me, Shankar. The
original sketch was
drawn in the context of
India’s China policy. But
this cartoon captures
the dual role of the
Congress during the era
of one-party dominance.
chap 2_PF.indd 26 9/6/2022 3:57:55 PM
2024-25
Challenge of building democracy
You now have an idea of the difficult circumstances in which
independent India was born. You have read about the serious
challenge of nation-building that confronted the country right in the
beginning. Faced with such serious challenges, leaders in many other
countries of the world decided that their country could not afford
to have democracy. They said that national unity was their first
priority and that democracy will introduce differences and conflicts.
Therefore many of the countries that gained freedom from colonialism
experienced non-democratic rule. It took various forms: nominal
democracy but effective control by one leader, one party rule or direct
army rule. Non-democratic regimes always started with a promise of
restoring democracy very soon. But once they established themselves,
it was very difficult to dislodge them.
The conditions in India were not very different. But the leaders of
the newly independent India decided to take the more difficult path.
Any other path would have been surprising, for our freedom struggle
was deeply committed to the idea of democracy. Our leaders were
conscious of the critical role of politics in any democracy. They did not
see politics as a problem; they saw it as a way of solving the problems.
Every society needs to decide how it will govern and regulate itself.
There are always different policy alternatives to choose from. There
are different groups with different and conflicting aspirations. How
do we resolve these differences? Democratic politics is an answer to
this question. While competition and power are the two most visible
things about politics, the purpose of political activity is and should be
deciding and pursuing public interest. This is the route our leaders
decided to take.
Last year you studied how our Constitution was drafted.
You would remember that the Constitution was adopted on
26 November 1949 and signed on 24 January 1950 and it came into
effect on 26 January 1950. At that time the country was being ruled
by an interim government. It was now necessary to install the first
democratically elected government of the country. The Constitution
had laid down the rules, now the machine had to be put in place.
Initially it was thought that this was only a matter of a few months. The
Election Commission of India was set up in January 1950. Sukumar
Sen became the first Chief Election Commissioner. The country’s first
general elections were expected sometime in 1950 itself.
What’s so special
about our being a
democracy? Sooner
or later every country
has become a
democracy, isn’t it?
In India,….
…hero-worship, plays a part
in its politics unequalled
in magnitude by the part
it plays in the politics of
any other country….But in
politics, .. ..hero-worship is a
sure road to degradation and
eventual dictatorship.
Babasaheb Dr. B.R.
Ambedkar
Speech in Constituent
Assembly
25 November 1949
“
“
2
chapter
era of one-party
dominance
chap 2_PF.indd 27 9/6/2022 3:57:55 PM
2024-25
28 Politics in India sinc Independence
A cartoonist’s impression of the election committee formed by the Congress to choose party
candidates in 1951. On the committee, besides Nehru: Morarji Desai, Rafi Ahmed Kidwai,
Dr B.C. Roy, Kamaraj Nadar, Rajagopalachari, Jagjivan Ram, Maulana Azad, D.P. Mishra,
P.D. Tandon and Govind Ballabh Pant.
But the Election Commission discovered that it was not going to
be easy to hold a free and fair election in a country of India’s size.
Holding an election required delimitation or drawing the boundaries
of the electoral constituencies. It also required preparing the electoral
rolls, or the list of all the citizens eligible to vote. Both these tasks took
a lot of time. When the first draft of the rolls was published, it was
discovered that the names of nearly 40 lakh women were not recorded
in the list. They were simply listed as “wife of …” or “daughter of …”.
The Election Commission refused to accept these entries and ordered
a revision if possible and deletion if necessary. Preparing for the first
general election was a mammoth exercise. No election on this scale
had ever been conducted in the world before. At that time there
were 17 crore eligible voters, who had to elect about 3,200 MLAs and
489 Members of Lok Sabha. Only 15 per cent of these eligible voters
were literate. Therefore the Election Commission had to think of some
special method of voting. The Election Commission trained over 3
lakh officers and polling staff to conduct the elections.
It was not just the size of the country and the electorate that made
this election unusual. The first general election was also the first big
test of democracy in a poor and illiterate country. Till then democracy
had existed only in the prosperous countries, mainly in Europe and
North America, where nearly everyone was literate. By that time
many countries in Europe had not given voting rights to all women.
In this context India’s experiment with universal adult franchise
That was a good
decision. But what
about men who still
refer to a woman as
Mrs. Somebody, as if
she does not have a
name of her own?
Credit: Shankar, 20 May 1951
chap 2_PF.indd 28 9/6/2022 3:57:56 PM
2024-25
Era of One-party Dominance 29
Let’s re-search
Ask the elders in your family and neighbourhood about their
experience of participating in elections.
• Did anyone vote in the first or second general election? Who did
they vote for and why?
• Is there someone who has used all the three methods of voting?
Which one did they prefer?
• In which ways do they find the elections of those days different
from the present ones?
Changing methods of voting
These days we use an Electronic Voting Machine (EVM) to record voters’
preferences. But that is not how we started. In the first general election, it
was decided to place inside each polling booth a box for each candidate
with the election symbol of that candidate. Each voter was given a blank
ballot paper which they had to drop into the box of the candidate they
wanted to vote for. About 20 lakh steel boxes were used for this purpose.
A presiding officer from Punjab described how he
A sample of the
ballot paper
used from
the third to
the thirteenth
general
elections to Lok
Sabha
prepared the ballot boxes—“Each box had to have
its candidate’s symbol, both inside and outside it,
and outside on either side, had to be displayed the
name of the candidate in Urdu, Hindi and Punjabi
along with the number of the constituency, the
polling station and the polling booth. The paper
seal with the numerical description of the candidate,
signed by the presiding officer, had to be inserted in
the token frame and its window closed by its door
which had to be fixed in its place at the other end by means
of a wire. All this had to be done on the day previous to the
one fixed for polling. To fix symbols and labels the boxes
had first to be rubbed with sandpaper or a piece of brick. I
found that it took about five hours for six persons, including
my two daughters, to complete this work. All this was done
at my house.”
Electronic Voting
Machine
After the first two elections, this method was changed. Now the ballot paper
carried the names and symbols of all the candidates and the voter was required
to put a stamp on the name of the candidate they wanted to vote for. This method
worked for nearly forty years. Towards the end of 1990s the Election Commission
started using the EVM. By 2004 the entire country had shifted to the EVM.
chap 2_PF.indd 29 9/6/2022 3:57:56 PM
2024-25
Page 5
Credit: Shankar
In this chapter…
The challenge of nation-building, covered in the last chapter, was
accompanied by the challenge of instituting democratic politics. Thus,
electoral competition among political parties began immediately after
Independence. In this chapter, we look at the first decade of electoral
politics in order to understand
• the establishment of a system of free and fair elections;
• the domination of the Congress party in the years immediately
after Independence; and
• the emergence of opposition parties and their policies.
This famous sketch
by Shankar appeared
on the cover of his
collection – Don’t Spare
Me, Shankar. The
original sketch was
drawn in the context of
India’s China policy. But
this cartoon captures
the dual role of the
Congress during the era
of one-party dominance.
chap 2_PF.indd 26 9/6/2022 3:57:55 PM
2024-25
Challenge of building democracy
You now have an idea of the difficult circumstances in which
independent India was born. You have read about the serious
challenge of nation-building that confronted the country right in the
beginning. Faced with such serious challenges, leaders in many other
countries of the world decided that their country could not afford
to have democracy. They said that national unity was their first
priority and that democracy will introduce differences and conflicts.
Therefore many of the countries that gained freedom from colonialism
experienced non-democratic rule. It took various forms: nominal
democracy but effective control by one leader, one party rule or direct
army rule. Non-democratic regimes always started with a promise of
restoring democracy very soon. But once they established themselves,
it was very difficult to dislodge them.
The conditions in India were not very different. But the leaders of
the newly independent India decided to take the more difficult path.
Any other path would have been surprising, for our freedom struggle
was deeply committed to the idea of democracy. Our leaders were
conscious of the critical role of politics in any democracy. They did not
see politics as a problem; they saw it as a way of solving the problems.
Every society needs to decide how it will govern and regulate itself.
There are always different policy alternatives to choose from. There
are different groups with different and conflicting aspirations. How
do we resolve these differences? Democratic politics is an answer to
this question. While competition and power are the two most visible
things about politics, the purpose of political activity is and should be
deciding and pursuing public interest. This is the route our leaders
decided to take.
Last year you studied how our Constitution was drafted.
You would remember that the Constitution was adopted on
26 November 1949 and signed on 24 January 1950 and it came into
effect on 26 January 1950. At that time the country was being ruled
by an interim government. It was now necessary to install the first
democratically elected government of the country. The Constitution
had laid down the rules, now the machine had to be put in place.
Initially it was thought that this was only a matter of a few months. The
Election Commission of India was set up in January 1950. Sukumar
Sen became the first Chief Election Commissioner. The country’s first
general elections were expected sometime in 1950 itself.
What’s so special
about our being a
democracy? Sooner
or later every country
has become a
democracy, isn’t it?
In India,….
…hero-worship, plays a part
in its politics unequalled
in magnitude by the part
it plays in the politics of
any other country….But in
politics, .. ..hero-worship is a
sure road to degradation and
eventual dictatorship.
Babasaheb Dr. B.R.
Ambedkar
Speech in Constituent
Assembly
25 November 1949
“
“
2
chapter
era of one-party
dominance
chap 2_PF.indd 27 9/6/2022 3:57:55 PM
2024-25
28 Politics in India sinc Independence
A cartoonist’s impression of the election committee formed by the Congress to choose party
candidates in 1951. On the committee, besides Nehru: Morarji Desai, Rafi Ahmed Kidwai,
Dr B.C. Roy, Kamaraj Nadar, Rajagopalachari, Jagjivan Ram, Maulana Azad, D.P. Mishra,
P.D. Tandon and Govind Ballabh Pant.
But the Election Commission discovered that it was not going to
be easy to hold a free and fair election in a country of India’s size.
Holding an election required delimitation or drawing the boundaries
of the electoral constituencies. It also required preparing the electoral
rolls, or the list of all the citizens eligible to vote. Both these tasks took
a lot of time. When the first draft of the rolls was published, it was
discovered that the names of nearly 40 lakh women were not recorded
in the list. They were simply listed as “wife of …” or “daughter of …”.
The Election Commission refused to accept these entries and ordered
a revision if possible and deletion if necessary. Preparing for the first
general election was a mammoth exercise. No election on this scale
had ever been conducted in the world before. At that time there
were 17 crore eligible voters, who had to elect about 3,200 MLAs and
489 Members of Lok Sabha. Only 15 per cent of these eligible voters
were literate. Therefore the Election Commission had to think of some
special method of voting. The Election Commission trained over 3
lakh officers and polling staff to conduct the elections.
It was not just the size of the country and the electorate that made
this election unusual. The first general election was also the first big
test of democracy in a poor and illiterate country. Till then democracy
had existed only in the prosperous countries, mainly in Europe and
North America, where nearly everyone was literate. By that time
many countries in Europe had not given voting rights to all women.
In this context India’s experiment with universal adult franchise
That was a good
decision. But what
about men who still
refer to a woman as
Mrs. Somebody, as if
she does not have a
name of her own?
Credit: Shankar, 20 May 1951
chap 2_PF.indd 28 9/6/2022 3:57:56 PM
2024-25
Era of One-party Dominance 29
Let’s re-search
Ask the elders in your family and neighbourhood about their
experience of participating in elections.
• Did anyone vote in the first or second general election? Who did
they vote for and why?
• Is there someone who has used all the three methods of voting?
Which one did they prefer?
• In which ways do they find the elections of those days different
from the present ones?
Changing methods of voting
These days we use an Electronic Voting Machine (EVM) to record voters’
preferences. But that is not how we started. In the first general election, it
was decided to place inside each polling booth a box for each candidate
with the election symbol of that candidate. Each voter was given a blank
ballot paper which they had to drop into the box of the candidate they
wanted to vote for. About 20 lakh steel boxes were used for this purpose.
A presiding officer from Punjab described how he
A sample of the
ballot paper
used from
the third to
the thirteenth
general
elections to Lok
Sabha
prepared the ballot boxes—“Each box had to have
its candidate’s symbol, both inside and outside it,
and outside on either side, had to be displayed the
name of the candidate in Urdu, Hindi and Punjabi
along with the number of the constituency, the
polling station and the polling booth. The paper
seal with the numerical description of the candidate,
signed by the presiding officer, had to be inserted in
the token frame and its window closed by its door
which had to be fixed in its place at the other end by means
of a wire. All this had to be done on the day previous to the
one fixed for polling. To fix symbols and labels the boxes
had first to be rubbed with sandpaper or a piece of brick. I
found that it took about five hours for six persons, including
my two daughters, to complete this work. All this was done
at my house.”
Electronic Voting
Machine
After the first two elections, this method was changed. Now the ballot paper
carried the names and symbols of all the candidates and the voter was required
to put a stamp on the name of the candidate they wanted to vote for. This method
worked for nearly forty years. Towards the end of 1990s the Election Commission
started using the EVM. By 2004 the entire country had shifted to the EVM.
chap 2_PF.indd 29 9/6/2022 3:57:56 PM
2024-25
30 Politics in India sinc Independence
appeared very bold and risky. An Indian editor called it “the
biggest gamble in history”. Organiser, a magazine, wrote
that Jawaharlal Nehru “would live to confess the failure
of universal adult franchise in India”. A British member of
the Indian Civil Service claimed that “a future and more
enlightened age will view with astonishment the absurd farce
of recording the votes of millions of illiterate people”.
The elections had to be postponed twice and finally held
from October 1951 to February 1952. But this election is
referred to as the 1952 election since most parts of the
country voted in January 1952. It took six months for
the campaigning, polling and counting to be completed.
Elections were competitive – there were on an average more
than four candidates for each seat. The level of participation
was encouraging — more than half the eligible voters turned
out to vote on the day of elections. When the results were
declared these were accepted as fair even by the losers.
The Indian experiment had proved the critics wrong. The
Times of India held that the polls have “confounded all those
sceptics who thought the introduction of adult franchise
too risky an experiment in this country”. The Hindustan
Times claimed that “there is universal agreement that the
Indian people have conducted themselves admirably in the
largest experiment in democratic elections in the history of
the world”. Observers outside India were equally impressed.
India’s general election of 1952 became a landmark in the
history of democracy all over the world. It was no longer
possible to argue that democratic elections could not be held
in conditions of poverty or lack of education. It proved that
democracy could be practiced anywhere in the world.
Maulana Abul Kalam
Azad (1888-1958):
original name — Abul
Kalam Mohiyuddin
Ahmed; scholar of
Islam; freedom fighter
and Congress leader;
proponent of Hindu-
Muslim unity; opposed
to Partition; member of
Constituent Assembly;
Education Minister in
the first cabinet of free
India.
Congress dominance in the first three
general elections
The results of the first general election did not surprise anyone. The
Indian National Congress was expected to win this election. The
Congress party, as it was popularly known, had inherited the legacy
of the national movement. It was the only party then to have an
organisation spread all over the country. And finally, in Jawaharlal
Nehru, the party had the most popular and charismatic leader in
Indian politics. He led the Congress campaign and toured through
the country. When the final results were declared, the extent of the
victory of the Congress did surprise many. The party won 364 of the
489 seats in the first Lok Sabha and finished way ahead of any other
challenger. The Communist Party of India that came next in terms
of seats won only 16 seats. The state elections were held with the
chap 2_PF.indd 30 9/6/2022 3:57:56 PM
2024-25
Read More