DoYou approve of MRS dorling at of not returning the things to the rig...
No, Mrs Dorling’s cold, inhuman and unfriendly behaviour towards the narrator can’t be justified. She even refused to recognize the narrator. She didn’t mention about the belongings of the narrator’s mother. The narrator reminded her that she was the daughter of Mrs S. Mrs Dorling regretted that she could do nothing for her. She even refused to talk to her.
This question is part of UPSC exam. View all Class 11 courses
DoYou approve of MRS dorling at of not returning the things to the rig...
Mrs. Dorling's Decision on Returning the Things to the Rightful Owner
Mrs. Dorling's decision not to return the things to the rightful owner, Mrs. S's daughter, is not ethically justifiable. This decision goes against principles of honesty, fairness, and empathy. Let's delve into the reasons supporting this argument.
Importance of Honesty and Fairness
Honesty and fairness are fundamental values in any society. It is important to respect the rights of others and act with integrity. By not returning the belongings to the rightful owner, Mrs. Dorling is exhibiting a lack of honesty and fairness. These values should guide our actions and decisions, ensuring justice is served to everyone involved.
Empathy and Compassion
Empathy and compassion play a vital role in our interactions with others. By empathizing with Mrs. S's daughter, Mrs. Dorling would understand the emotional distress she might be experiencing due to the loss of her belongings. Returning the items would not only alleviate her distress but also demonstrate kindness and compassion. It is important to consider the feelings and well-being of others, especially in situations where they have suffered a loss.
Setting a Positive Example
As a responsible member of society, Mrs. Dorling should set a positive example for others to follow. By returning the belongings to the rightful owner, she would demonstrate the importance of honesty and fairness to those around her, including her own children. This act would encourage others to act ethically and foster a sense of trust within the community.
Karma and Consequences
The concept of karma suggests that our actions have consequences. By not returning the belongings, Mrs. Dorling may face negative consequences in the long run. Her decision goes against the principles of karma, which dictate that our actions determine the nature of the consequences we face in the future. It is wise to act in accordance with ethical values to ensure a positive outcome.
Conclusion
In conclusion, Mrs. Dorling's decision not to return the belongings to the rightful owner is not ethically justifiable. Honesty, fairness, empathy, setting a positive example, and the concept of karma all support the idea that returning the items to Mrs. S's daughter is the right course of action. It is crucial for individuals to act in accordance with ethical principles in order to foster a just and compassionate society.
To make sure you are not studying endlessly, EduRev has designed Class 11 study material, with Structured Courses, Videos, & Test Series. Plus get personalized analysis, doubt solving and improvement plans to achieve a great score in Class 11.