Class 11 Exam  >  Class 11 Questions  >  criticism of wealth Related: Wealth definiti... Start Learning for Free
Verified Answer
criticism of wealth Related: Wealth definition by Adam Smith (Classic...
Criticism:
The wealth definition has a number of defects. Economists like, Caryle and Morris claimed it a bastard and dismal science.
(i) Materialistic Concept:
According to wealth definition, wealth is the sole end of all human beings. However, in reality, wealth is not an end in itself. It is only a means and that too one of many means for man’s happiness and welfare. Thus, this definition was rejected.

(ii) Ambiguous:
The wealth definition is ambiguous, i.e., meaning is not clear. In earlier days wealth means only material goods like money, gold, silver, land, cattle, horse etc. which are visible. However, it ignores non-material goods like services of doctor, washer man, barber, teacher etc. All these immaterial goods are as good as wealth.

(iii) Narrow Scope:
This definition claims wealth as the only subject matter of Economics, hence it ignores the most fundamental concept viz. welfare. The definition is, therefore, incomplete and narrow.

(iv) Concept of Economic Man:
Smith’s definition is based on the concept of economic man. Marshall and Pigou believed that economic man who works for selfish ends alone is not found in real life. In practical life, man’s activities are not only influenced by selfish motives but also by moral, social and religious factors.

(v) Scarcity and Choice:
Smith’s definition ignores the two most important concepts of economics, i.e., scarcity and choice. In true sense, economic activities take place because not of goods and services satisfying human wants are scarce but they have several uses. Thus, the question of choice arises. In this way, this definition neglects both aspects.

(vi) Importance of Man ignored:
The definition gives unnecessary stress on wealth while importance’s of human beings are neglected. Actually, wealth is a mean to human welfare. Thus, its subject matter does not remain a social science.

(vii) Stagnant:
The main drawback of this definition is stagnant in nature. Some critics pointed out that the definition is static and based on deductive method.
This question is part of UPSC exam. View all Class 11 courses
Most Upvoted Answer
criticism of wealth Related: Wealth definition by Adam Smith (Classic...
1.greater emphasis on wealth 2. imagination of economic man 3. narrow and limited scope of economics
Community Answer
criticism of wealth Related: Wealth definition by Adam Smith (Classic...
Wealth Definition by Adam Smith (Classical Economist)

Adam Smith, a prominent figure in classical economics, defined wealth as the accumulation of material goods and resources that contribute to human well-being and prosperity. In his seminal work, "The Wealth of Nations," Smith emphasized the role of production, exchange, and consumption in creating and increasing wealth. He argued that a nation's wealth is not solely determined by the amount of gold and silver it possesses, but rather by the overall productivity and economic activities of its people.

Key Points:
- Definition of Wealth: Adam Smith viewed wealth as the accumulation of tangible and intangible resources that enhance human welfare and promote economic growth. This includes not only physical assets like land, buildings, and machinery but also intellectual capital, skills, and knowledge.

- Production and Exchange: Smith believed that the wealth of a nation is primarily generated through productive activities. He emphasized the importance of specialization and division of labor, which enable individuals to focus on specific tasks and increase productivity. Additionally, Smith recognized the significance of free trade and the exchange of goods and services in expanding wealth.

- Value and Price: Smith introduced the concept of the "labor theory of value," suggesting that the value of a product is determined by the amount of labor required to produce it. However, he acknowledged that market forces such as supply and demand ultimately dictate prices. Smith argued that a well-functioning market with minimal government intervention allows prices to reflect the true value of goods and services.

- Wealth Creation: According to Smith, wealth is not fixed or limited; rather, it can be created and increased through productive activities. He advocated for policies that promote entrepreneurship, innovation, and investment to stimulate economic growth and generate wealth. Smith believed that individuals pursuing their self-interest within a competitive market framework would lead to overall societal well-being and prosperity.

Criticism of Wealth Definition:
While Adam Smith's definition of wealth has had a significant influence on classical economics and the understanding of economic development, it has also faced criticism from various perspectives:

- Narrow Focus on Material Accumulation: Critics argue that Smith's definition places excessive emphasis on the accumulation of material goods, neglecting other dimensions of well-being, such as social relationships, environmental sustainability, and overall happiness. They contend that a narrow focus on material wealth can lead to societal inequality and neglect of important non-economic aspects of human life.

- Disregard for Distributional Issues: Smith's definition does not explicitly address issues of wealth distribution. Critics argue that unchecked pursuit of individual wealth can lead to a concentration of resources in the hands of a few, exacerbating income inequality and social divisions.

- Externalities and Environmental Impact: Smith's definition does not adequately account for negative externalities and environmental costs associated with wealth creation. Critics argue that unrestricted pursuit of wealth can lead to environmental degradation, resource depletion, and other negative consequences that undermine long-term well-being.

- Human-centric Approach: Smith's definition primarily focuses on the well-being of individuals and nations, disregarding the broader ecological and global context. Critics argue that a more holistic approach to wealth should consider the interconnectedness of ecosystems, global justice, and sustainable development.

Overall, while Adam Smith's definition of wealth has shaped economic thinking and policies, it has also faced criticism for
Attention Class 11 Students!
To make sure you are not studying endlessly, EduRev has designed Class 11 study material, with Structured Courses, Videos, & Test Series. Plus get personalized analysis, doubt solving and improvement plans to achieve a great score in Class 11.
Explore Courses for Class 11 exam

Top Courses for Class 11

criticism of wealth Related: Wealth definition by Adam Smith (Classical Economist)?
Question Description
criticism of wealth Related: Wealth definition by Adam Smith (Classical Economist)? for Class 11 2024 is part of Class 11 preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the Class 11 exam syllabus. Information about criticism of wealth Related: Wealth definition by Adam Smith (Classical Economist)? covers all topics & solutions for Class 11 2024 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for criticism of wealth Related: Wealth definition by Adam Smith (Classical Economist)?.
Solutions for criticism of wealth Related: Wealth definition by Adam Smith (Classical Economist)? in English & in Hindi are available as part of our courses for Class 11. Download more important topics, notes, lectures and mock test series for Class 11 Exam by signing up for free.
Here you can find the meaning of criticism of wealth Related: Wealth definition by Adam Smith (Classical Economist)? defined & explained in the simplest way possible. Besides giving the explanation of criticism of wealth Related: Wealth definition by Adam Smith (Classical Economist)?, a detailed solution for criticism of wealth Related: Wealth definition by Adam Smith (Classical Economist)? has been provided alongside types of criticism of wealth Related: Wealth definition by Adam Smith (Classical Economist)? theory, EduRev gives you an ample number of questions to practice criticism of wealth Related: Wealth definition by Adam Smith (Classical Economist)? tests, examples and also practice Class 11 tests.
Explore Courses for Class 11 exam

Top Courses for Class 11

Explore Courses
Signup for Free!
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days! Learn & Practice with 1000+ FREE Notes, Videos & Tests.
10M+ students study on EduRev