Possible response:

The Geese and the Creeper: A Closer Look

Overview

In Chapter 2 of the CBSE Class 5 English textbook, we meet the geese again as they prepare to migrate to a warmer place. However, one of them gets entangled in a creeper that has grown around a tree. The other geese try to help but fail, until a wise bird suggests a solution. In this response, we will focus on the doubt raised by the question, which is whether the geese and the wise bird failed to see the creeper growing.

The Geese's Perspective

From the story, we can infer that the geese did not notice the creeper growing around the tree before they landed there. This is because they were focused on finding food and water, and did not pay attention to the surroundings. Moreover, they may not have encountered a creeper like that before, and therefore did not know how to avoid it. Once one of the geese got trapped, the others tried to pull it out, but their efforts only made the situation worse. This shows that they were not aware of the danger of the creeper, and did not have a plan to deal with it.

The Wise Bird's Perspective

The wise bird, on the other hand, did not seem to notice the creeper either, at least not explicitly. The story does not mention the bird warning the geese about the creeper, or advising them to avoid the tree. Instead, the bird observes the geese struggling and offers a creative solution, which involves all the geese flying together while holding a stick in their beaks, so that the trapped goose can be lifted up. This solution shows that the bird has knowledge and experience that the geese lack, and can think outside the box to solve a problem. However, it does not necessarily mean that the bird knew about the creeper beforehand.

Possible Conclusion

In conclusion, it is possible that both the geese and the wise bird did not see the creeper growing around the tree. This does not mean that they are completely ignorant or careless, but rather that they have different priorities and perspectives. The geese focus on survival needs such as food and water, while the wise bird focuses on wisdom and problem-solving. The story teaches us that we can learn from both approaches, and that cooperation and creativity can overcome obstacles.

L didn.t know