Andrew Manson's Initial Feeling about Marriages


Andrew Manson, a character in the novel "The Citadel" by A.J. Cronin, initially held a negative view of marriages. His belief was that all marriages were a dismal failure.

Explanation:

Andrew Manson's perspective on marriages can be understood by examining his personal experiences and observations throughout the novel.

1. Negative Experiences:

Andrew Manson was a young doctor who had witnessed several failed marriages among his patients. He had seen couples who were unhappy, unfulfilled, and trapped in loveless relationships. These negative experiences influenced his initial belief that marriages were a dismal failure.

2. Lack of Fulfillment:

Andrew Manson was an ambitious and passionate doctor who dedicated himself to his profession. He believed that marriages often hindered personal and professional growth. He saw how some of his colleagues, after getting married, were unable to fully pursue their careers or achieve their goals. This further reinforced his belief that marriages were overrated and could lead to a lack of personal fulfillment.

3. Limited Freedom and Independence:

Andrew Manson valued his freedom and independence. He believed that marriages often restricted individual freedoms and forced individuals to compromise on their desires and aspirations. This belief stemmed from observing how married couples had to make sacrifices and prioritize the needs of their partners and families over their own.

4. Failed Relationships:

Andrew Manson had personal experiences with failed relationships, including his own failed engagement. This personal setback contributed to his negative perception of marriages. He saw his failed relationship as evidence that marriages were prone to failure and could not guarantee long-term happiness and fulfillment.

Conclusion:

Based on his experiences and observations, Andrew Manson initially believed that all marriages were a dismal failure. However, as the story progresses, his perspective evolves, and he begins to question and reassess his beliefs about marriages and relationships.