Class 11 Exam  >  Class 11 Questions  >  Describe Andrew's dilemma between his obligat... Start Learning for Free
Describe Andrew's dilemma between his obligation and desire as brought out in the extract
Verified Answer
Describe Andrew's dilemma between his obligation and desire as brought...
The dilemma before the doctor was whether to save the mother first or her child. The dilemma was so urgent that he couldn’t solve it consciously. Instinctively, he gave the child to the nurse and turned his attention to Susan Morgan. She lay collapsed, almost pulseless. It took him only an instant to inject the medicine. After a few minutes of feverish efforts he succeeded in saving Susan Morgan.
This question is part of UPSC exam. View all Class 11 courses
Most Upvoted Answer
Describe Andrew's dilemma between his obligation and desire as brought...
Andrew's Dilemma: Obligation vs. Desire

Introduction:
In the extract "Birth" from Chapter 2 of the NCERT Solutions for Class 11 English, Andrew finds himself torn between his obligation and desire. This dilemma arises when he is invited to a party by the Anglicist missionary, Reverend Stephen. Andrew is a devout Christian and feels obliged to attend the party due to his religious beliefs. However, he also desires to spend time with his family and celebrate his son's birthday.

Obligation to Attend the Party:
1. Andrew's religious beliefs: Andrew is a devout Christian and has a deep sense of duty towards his faith. He believes that attending the party organized by the Reverend is his obligation as a committed Christian.
2. Pressure from the community: The invitation from the Reverend is significant as he is a well-respected figure in the community. Andrew feels obligated to attend the party to avoid any negative consequences or judgment from the community.

Desire to Spend Time with Family:
1. Importance of family: Andrew values his family and cherishes the time spent with them. He desires to be present for his son's birthday celebration and create lasting memories with his loved ones.
2. Limited time with family: Due to his busy work schedule, Andrew does not get many opportunities to spend quality time with his family. He feels a strong desire to prioritize his family's happiness and be with them on this special occasion.

The Conflict:
1. Moral conflict: Andrew finds himself torn between his obligation to attend the party and his desire to be with his family. He understands that attending the party might make him appear more committed to his faith, but it would mean missing out on celebrating his son's birthday.
2. Emotional dilemma: Andrew experiences conflicting emotions as he wants to honor his religious obligations, but he also wants to fulfill his role as a loving father and husband. This conflict creates a dilemma within him, causing distress and confusion.

Conclusion:
Andrew's dilemma between his obligation and desire highlights the internal struggle he faces. The extract brings to light the complex nature of decision-making when faced with conflicting responsibilities. This conflict between obligation and desire is a relatable theme that explores the challenges individuals face in balancing their various roles and responsibilities.
Attention Class 11 Students!
To make sure you are not studying endlessly, EduRev has designed Class 11 study material, with Structured Courses, Videos, & Test Series. Plus get personalized analysis, doubt solving and improvement plans to achieve a great score in Class 11.
Explore Courses for Class 11 exam

Top Courses for Class 11

Describe Andrew's dilemma between his obligation and desire as brought out in the extract Related: NCERT Solutions Chapter 2 - Birth, Class 11, English
Question Description
Describe Andrew's dilemma between his obligation and desire as brought out in the extract Related: NCERT Solutions Chapter 2 - Birth, Class 11, English for Class 11 2024 is part of Class 11 preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the Class 11 exam syllabus. Information about Describe Andrew's dilemma between his obligation and desire as brought out in the extract Related: NCERT Solutions Chapter 2 - Birth, Class 11, English covers all topics & solutions for Class 11 2024 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for Describe Andrew's dilemma between his obligation and desire as brought out in the extract Related: NCERT Solutions Chapter 2 - Birth, Class 11, English.
Solutions for Describe Andrew's dilemma between his obligation and desire as brought out in the extract Related: NCERT Solutions Chapter 2 - Birth, Class 11, English in English & in Hindi are available as part of our courses for Class 11. Download more important topics, notes, lectures and mock test series for Class 11 Exam by signing up for free.
Here you can find the meaning of Describe Andrew's dilemma between his obligation and desire as brought out in the extract Related: NCERT Solutions Chapter 2 - Birth, Class 11, English defined & explained in the simplest way possible. Besides giving the explanation of Describe Andrew's dilemma between his obligation and desire as brought out in the extract Related: NCERT Solutions Chapter 2 - Birth, Class 11, English, a detailed solution for Describe Andrew's dilemma between his obligation and desire as brought out in the extract Related: NCERT Solutions Chapter 2 - Birth, Class 11, English has been provided alongside types of Describe Andrew's dilemma between his obligation and desire as brought out in the extract Related: NCERT Solutions Chapter 2 - Birth, Class 11, English theory, EduRev gives you an ample number of questions to practice Describe Andrew's dilemma between his obligation and desire as brought out in the extract Related: NCERT Solutions Chapter 2 - Birth, Class 11, English tests, examples and also practice Class 11 tests.
Explore Courses for Class 11 exam

Top Courses for Class 11

Explore Courses
Signup for Free!
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days! Learn & Practice with 1000+ FREE Notes, Videos & Tests.
10M+ students study on EduRev