Let G be a group of order 231. The number of elements of order 11 in G...
Well, if g has order 11 in G, then <g> is an order-11 subgroup of G, and so g is an element of a subgroup of G that has order 11. Since G has only one of these --- namely H --- we learn that every element of order 11 in G has to be in H. Since H only has 11 elements, this already tells us something: that there are at most 11 elements of order 11 in G. But we can do better than this. Since H is a subgroup, one of its elements is identity element of H (which has order 1, not 11). So in fact there are at most 10 elements of G that have order 11 --- namely, the ten non-identity elements of H.
But wait --- is it possible to prove that all of the non-identity elements of H have order 11? Yes it is --- by Lagrange's theorem. If g is in H, the order of g has to divide the order of H, which is 11, and since 11 is prime, this means that the order of g has to be either 1 or 11. The order of a nonidentity element of H can't be 1, so it has to be 11. Conclusion: every nonidentity element of H has order 11. Conclusion: the elements of order 11 in G are precisely the non-identity elements of the subgroup H, of which there are 10.
So G has 10 elements of order 11.
View all questions of this test
Let G be a group of order 231. The number of elements of order 11 in G...
Given: A group G of order 231
To find: The number of elements of order 11 in G
Approach:
- Use Sylow's theorems to understand the structure of G
- Determine the number of Sylow 11-subgroups in G
- Use the fact that every element of order 11 lies in a unique Sylow 11-subgroup
- Determine the number of elements of order 11 in each Sylow 11-subgroup
- Add up the number of elements of order 11 from all the Sylow 11-subgroups to get the total number of elements of order 11 in G
Solution:
Using Sylow's theorems:
- The prime factorization of 231 is 3 x 7 x 11
- The number of Sylow 11-subgroups in G is congruent to 1 modulo 11 and divides 3 x 7 = 21
- Thus, the number of Sylow 11-subgroups in G is either 1 or 21
If there is only one Sylow 11-subgroup:
- Let H be the unique Sylow 11-subgroup in G
- H has order 11, and thus has 10 elements of order 11 (since the identity element has order 1)
If there are 21 Sylow 11-subgroups:
- Let H be a Sylow 11-subgroup in G
- H has order 11, and thus has 10 elements of order 11 (since the identity element has order 1)
- Since every element of order 11 lies in a unique Sylow 11-subgroup, there are no repeated elements of order 11 among the 21 Sylow 11-subgroups
- Thus, there are a total of 21 x 10 = 210 elements of order 11 in G
Conclusion:
- The number of elements of order 11 in G is 10, if there is only one Sylow 11-subgroup
- The number of elements of order 11 in G is 210, if there are 21 Sylow 11-subgroups
- Since the number of Sylow 11-subgroups divides the order of G, 21 is not a possible number of Sylow 11-subgroups in a group of order 231
- Thus, the only possibility is that there is only one Sylow 11-subgroup in G, and the number of elements of order 11 is 10.