UPSC Exam  >  UPSC Notes  >  Indian Economy for UPSC CSE  >  Ramesh Singh Summary: Public Finance in India- 1

Ramesh Singh Summary: Public Finance in India- 1 | Indian Economy for UPSC CSE PDF Download

Introduction

  • Public finance encompasses all matters related to the management of public money, including government receipts, expenditures, borrowing, lending, and financial management.
  • It addresses how much of a country's resources the government should acquire for its own use and the efficiency with which these resources are utilized.
  • Referenced in ancient texts like the Arthashastra, public finance covers treasury management, revenue sources, accounts, and audits in detail.
    Public Finances Public Finances 
  • Post-World War II, the role of governments in the economy expanded significantly due to factors like the rise of the public sector and the provision of essential services such as law enforcement, defense, and public goods.
  • Experts and policymakers recognized that leaving all economic activities to the market (private sector) wouldn't suffice, especially in critical areas like national defense and security.

Budgeting

  • Budgeting entails the preparation of an annual financial statement outlining a government's income (revenue) and expenditure.
  • Originating from a British parliamentary practice dating back to the mid-18th century, the word "budget" is derived from the French word "bouger," meaning a leather bag from which financial documents were presented.
    Ramesh Singh Summary: Public Finance in India- 1 | Indian Economy for UPSC CSE
  • In modern times, budgeting is a standard practice for governments worldwide, akin to companies and organizations preparing financial statements.
  • In India, Article 112 of the Constitution mandates the presentation of an Annual Financial Statement, known as the Union Budget, before Parliament at the start of each fiscal year. This provision extends to the states as well.

Data in the Budget


The Union Budget presents three sets of data for each sector or sub-sector of the economy:
  1. Actual data of the preceding year (e.g., for the budget presented for 2022-23, actual data for 2021-22 is provided). Denoted by 'A' or left blank in Indian context.
  2. Provisional data of the current year (e.g., 2021-22), since the budget for the previous year (2020-21) is presented a year in advance. Shown as 'PE' in brackets.
  3. Budgetary estimates for the following year (e.g., 2022-23). Indicated with 'BE' in brackets.
  • Additional types of data found in government economic literature:
    1. Revised Estimate (RE): Offers a current estimation of either budgetary estimates (BEs) or provisional estimates (PEs), reflecting the contemporary situation.
    2. Quick Estimate (QE): A type of RE providing the latest situation, useful for future projections for sectors or sub-sectors. It's interim data.
    3. Advance Estimate (AE): Similar to QE but conducted in advance of the final stage, serving as interim data.
      Sectors of EconomySectors of Economy

Developmental and Non-developmental Expenditure

  • Government expenditure is divided into two categories: developmental and non-developmental.
  • Developmental expenditures include investments in productive endeavors like new factories, infrastructure projects, and transportation networks.
  • Non-developmental expenditures are consumptive and non-productive, covering items like salaries, pensions, interest payments, subsidies, and defense expenses.
  • This classification is no longer used in Indian public finance, replaced by the distinction between Plan and Non-Plan Expenditure.

Plan and Non-Plan Expenditure

  • Expenditures are categorized as either plan or non-plan.
  • Plan expenditures are asset-creating and productive, while non-plan expenditures are consumptive and non-productive.
  • In 1987-88, India transitioned from using developmental and non-developmental expenditure terms to plan and non-plan expenditures, following recommendations by the Sukhamoy Chakraborty Committee.
  • The Rangarajan Committee suggested further redefining plan and non-plan expenditures as capital and revenue expenditures to better align with outcomes and public expenditure management.

 Sukhamoy Chakraborty  Sukhamoy Chakraborty 

Analysis of the Situation


  • Many factors cast doubts on the efficacy and relevance of the fiscal instrument.
  • The division of Plan and Non-Plan expenditure poses problems such as:
    1. Plan Expenditure:
    Allocation between official and non-official expenditure creates prioritization challenges, especially during austerity measures for fiscal consolidation
  • Non-Plan expenditure often receives less attention even when crucial for economic development. For instance, budget provisions for the maintenance of essential facilities like hospitals and schools might suffer.
  • Review and implementation of schemes lack direct responsibility, with roles spread between the Ministry of Finance and the Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation.
  • Programs and schemes are not allowed to continue indefinitely across plan periods without independent evaluations, diluting the Ministry's role.
  • The introduction of Output and Outcome Budgeting by the central government in the 2005-06 Budget aimed to bring more scrutiny to Non-Plan expenditure. However, outcomes like expenditure on running schools and hospitals may not be adequately evaluated, revealing flaws in Plan and Non-Plan classifications.
  1. Revenue, Non-revenue, and Receipts:
  • Revenue: Any income or earnings for a firm or government.
  • Non-revenue: Money raised via borrowings, increasing financial liabilities.
  • Receipts: Every receiving or accrual of money to a government, including both revenue and non-revenue sources. Total receipts encompass all incomes and non-income accruals of a government.
  • The classification shift from the traditional "Plan and Non-Plan" to "Revenue and Capital" since the fiscal year 2017-18 announced in the Union Budget reflects ongoing changes in expenditure management.

Union Budget

  • The annual financial statement of the Government of India (GoI) is termed the Union Budget, following the practice outlined in Article 112.
  • Originating from the British tradition, the budgeting process in India has evolved to be technically similar to most budgets worldwide.
  • Broadly classified into two parts: A. Revenue Budget and B. Capital Budget, encompassing Revenue and Capital Receipts and Expenditures, respectively.

Revenue Budget

A. Revenue Receipts: Include all revenue receiving (tax and non-tax) of the government, categorized as:
  • Tax Revenue Receipts: Collections from direct and indirect taxes like income tax, corporate tax, GST, etc.
  • Non-Tax Revenue Receipts: Income from sources other than taxes, such as profits from public sector undertakings (PSUs), interests on loans, fiscal services, general services, fees, penalties, fines, and grants.
    Ramesh Singh Summary: Public Finance in India- 1 | Indian Economy for UPSC CSE
B. Revenue Expenditures:
  • Consist of all expenditures incurred by the government, which are consumptive and do not involve the creation of productive assets.
  • Items include interest payments, salaries, subsidies, defense expenses, postal deficits, law and order expenditures, and expenditures on social services like education, health, and poverty alleviation.
C. Revenue Deficit (RD)
  • Represents the balance of total revenue expenditures and total revenue receipts. If negative, it indicates a revenue surplus.
  • The effective management of revenue deficit ensures prudent fiscal policy and allows government spending in productive areas.

D. Effective Revenue Deficit

  • Introduced to capture the RD "excluding" revenue expenditures of the GoI used for asset creation, termed Government of India's Contributions to States and Union Territories (GoCAs).
  • GoCAs represent grants forwarded to States and UTs for centrally sponsored programs involving asset creation.
  • The concept of effective revenue deficit justifies higher RDs by highlighting that certain expenditures contribute to asset creation, aiming for a zero percent effective RD by 2017-18.
  • The government has set targets for effective revenue deficit, signaling fiscal prudence and efficient utilization of resources.
    Union Territories of IndiaUnion Territories of India

Capital Budget

  • Concerns about the management of capital receipts and expenditures by the government.
  • Indicates how capital is handled and where it is allocated.

A. Capital Receipts

  • Non-revenue receipts are directed towards investments and planned development.
  • Can be diverted to meet other financial needs due to rising revenue expenditure.
  • It includes:
    1. Loan Recovery: Money repaid to the government from past loans, both internal and external.
    2. Borrowings by the Government: Long-term loans acquired domestically and internationally.
    3. Other Receipts by the Government: Long-term accruals through schemes like PF, Postal Deposits, and government bonds.

B. Capital Expenditure

  • Allocations of capital by the government, covering various areas such as:
    1. Loan Disbursals by the Government: Loans provided internally and externally.
    2. Loan Repayments by the Government: Repayment of loans, comprising the capital portion.
    3. Plan Expenditure of the Government: Financing planned development and supporting state plans.Ramesh Singh Summary: Public Finance in India- 1 | Indian Economy for UPSC CSE
    4. Capital Expenditures on Defence: Funding for defense maintenance, equipment purchase, and modernization.
    5. General Services: Capital expenditure on services like railways, postal department, water supply, education, and rural extension.
    6. Other Liabilities of the Government: Repayment liabilities arising from other receipts.

C. Capital Deficit

  • Conceptually indicates a scarcity of capital required for government expenditure.
  • Represents the challenge of managing funds necessary for both revenue and capital expenditures.

D. Fiscal Deficit (FD)

  • Arises when total government expenditures exceed total receipts.
  • Indicates that the government is spending more than its income, considering all forms of government receipts.
  • Can be expressed quantitatively or as a percentage of GDP.
  • Rising FDs have been a concern, prompting fiscal consolidation efforts.

    Primary Deficit:
  • FD excluding interest liabilities for a year.
  • Indicates FD without considering interest payments, offering insights into expenditure patterns.
  • Helps in evaluating dependence on loans and potential expenditure cuts.
    Ramesh Singh Summary: Public Finance in India- 1 | Indian Economy for UPSC CSEPrimary Surplus:
  • Occurs when tax receipts exceed total expenditures excluding interest payments.
  • Indicates fiscal health and the government's capacity for revenue and capital expenditures.
  • Reflects the availability of fiscal space for government expenditure decisions.

    Monetised Deficit:
  • The deficit provided by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) to the government in a specific year.
  • Reflects the government's reliance on short and long-term borrowings for expenditure needs.
  • Despite changes in monetary policy, RBI continues to manage government securities.

    Deficit and Surplus Budget:
  • Deficit Budget: Proposed when expenditures exceed receipts, indicating spending beyond means.
  • Surplus Budget: Proposed when expenditures are less than receipts, symbolizing a lower concern towards development.
  • Governments usually avoid presenting surplus budgets due to ongoing development needs.

Deficit Financing

  • The act/process of financing a deficit budget by a government.
  • Involves financial policies enacted by the government to sustain deficits.
  • Initially used in public finance in the early 1930s in the United States.
  • Adopted by governments worldwide and also seen in corporate financial management strategies.

Need of Deficit Financing

  • Emerged in the late 1920s when governments needed to spend more money than expected earnings.
  • Necessary to achieve desired levels of growth and development.
  • Aims to realize socio-political goals by allowing more expenditure with less income and receipts.
  • Extra money spent above income is expected to be reimbursed once growth occurs.
    Ramesh Singh Summary: Public Finance in India- 1 | Indian Economy for UPSC CSE

Means of Deficit Financing

  1. External Aids:
    • The best option, even with soft interest or interest-free.
    • Provides sustainable budget support, as seen in India's borrowing from the IMF.
  2. External Grants:
    • Preferable but often comes with conditions.
    • Not extensively utilized due to attached conditions.
  3. External Borrowings:
    • Favorable if loans are cheap and long-term.
    • Brings foreign currency, beneficial for developmental requirements.
  4. Internal Borrowings:
    • Third, preferred route but impacts investment prospects and expenditure patterns.
    • Can lead to economic stagnation or slowdown if extensively utilized.
      Economic StagnationEconomic Stagnation
  5. Printing Currency:
    • Last resort for governments.
    • Increases inflation and government expenditures.
    • Creates a vicious cycle of currency printing and inflation.

Composition of Fiscal Deficit

  • Focuses on the expenditure composition of governments.
  • Optimal composition:
    1. Fiscal deficit with surplus revenue budget or zero-revenue expenditure.
    2. Higher capital expenditures and lower revenue expenditures ideal for deficit financing.
  • Less favorable compositions:
    1. Majority of deficit financing is directed towards revenue expenditures.
    2. Lack of judicious mix between plan and non-plan expenditures.
  • Third World economies often overlook favorable composition, leading to higher deficits and non-revenue expenditures.
The document Ramesh Singh Summary: Public Finance in India- 1 | Indian Economy for UPSC CSE is a part of the UPSC Course Indian Economy for UPSC CSE.
All you need of UPSC at this link: UPSC
140 videos|315 docs|136 tests

Top Courses for UPSC

FAQs on Ramesh Singh Summary: Public Finance in India- 1 - Indian Economy for UPSC CSE

1. What is the concept of budgeting?
Ans. Budgeting is the process of creating a plan for how to spend and manage money. It involves estimating and allocating financial resources to different activities, projects, or departments within an organization or government.
2. What is the Union Budget in India?
Ans. The Union Budget in India is the annual financial statement presented by the Government of India in Parliament. It outlines the government's revenue and expenditure for the upcoming fiscal year and provides details on various schemes, policies, and initiatives.
3. What is deficit financing?
Ans. Deficit financing refers to the practice of a government spending more money than it receives in revenue. This leads to a budget deficit, which is usually financed by borrowing from external sources, such as issuing government bonds or obtaining loans from international institutions.
4. Who is Ramesh Singh and what is his contribution to the field of public finance in India?
Ans. Ramesh Singh is an Indian economist and author known for his book "Public Finance in India." His book provides an in-depth analysis of public finance concepts and their application in the Indian context. It is widely used as a reference book for students, researchers, and policymakers in the field of public finance.
5. How does deficit financing impact the economy?
Ans. Deficit financing can have both positive and negative impacts on the economy. On the positive side, it can stimulate economic growth by increasing government spending and investment. However, it can also lead to inflation, an increase in interest rates, and higher government debt, which can have long-term negative effects on the economy.
140 videos|315 docs|136 tests
Download as PDF
Explore Courses for UPSC exam

Top Courses for UPSC

Signup for Free!
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days! Learn & Practice with 1000+ FREE Notes, Videos & Tests.
10M+ students study on EduRev
Related Searches

past year papers

,

Exam

,

mock tests for examination

,

Free

,

pdf

,

Extra Questions

,

Summary

,

Previous Year Questions with Solutions

,

video lectures

,

study material

,

MCQs

,

Ramesh Singh Summary: Public Finance in India- 1 | Indian Economy for UPSC CSE

,

Semester Notes

,

practice quizzes

,

Ramesh Singh Summary: Public Finance in India- 1 | Indian Economy for UPSC CSE

,

ppt

,

Viva Questions

,

Objective type Questions

,

Important questions

,

Ramesh Singh Summary: Public Finance in India- 1 | Indian Economy for UPSC CSE

,

Sample Paper

,

shortcuts and tricks

;