NCERT Summary: Stock Markets in India- 4

Table of Contents
1. Tax Reforms in India
2. Key Tax Concepts and Terms
3. Specific Instruments and Rules
4. Revenue Composition and Local Taxes
5. Direct Taxes Code (DTC) Bill, 2010
6. International Issues: Tax Treaties, Tax Havens and Exchange of Information
7. Conclusion and Policy Implications
View more

Tax Reforms in India

Since the beginning of the last decade, as part of the broader economic reform programme, India's taxation system has been subjected to continuous and comprehensive reform. The objectives of these reforms have been to maximize tax resources, improve international competitiveness of the Indian economy, reduce transaction and compliance costs, and correct the high-cost structure of the economy so that tax compliance increases, equity improves, and investment flows are encouraged.

Direct Tax Reforms

• Reduction and rationalisation of rates: income tax has been simplified with only three principal rates and the highest marginal rate at 30% (as part of reforms implemented since the late 1990s and early 2000s).
• Simplification of procedures for filing, assessment and refunds to reduce compliance cost and compliance time for taxpayers.
• Strengthening of tax administration to improve detection, assessment and recovery of taxes.
• Widening of the tax base to include more taxpayers and reduce exemptions that erode the base.
• Gradual withdrawal of selective exemptions and concessions that distort resource allocation.
• Introduction of Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT) to bring companies reporting low or no taxable income under the tax net (see section on MAT).
• Drafting and introduction of the Direct Taxes Code (DTC) of 2010 to replace the Income Tax Act, 1961 with the aim of consolidation, simplification and modernisation of direct tax law.

Indirect Tax Reforms

• Reduction in peak tariff rates: the peak customs duty declined substantially since liberalisation; peak customs duty was brought down to around 10% in subsequent years.
• Reduction in the number of duty and rate slabs to simplify the tariff structure.
• Progressive shift from specific duties (based on physical units) to ad valorem duties (based on value).
• Introduction of Value Added Tax (VAT) at the state level to replace cascading sales taxes and move to a tax-on-value-added system.
• Rollout of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) was planned to unify indirect taxes across the country (target dates and implementation details were developed after the period covered by earlier budgets).
• Extension and rationalisation of service tax coverage to a larger number of services at standardised rates.

Tax Expenditure

Tax expenditure refers to government revenue forgone because of exemptions, deductions and concessions in the tax law (applies to direct and indirect taxes). India's first presentation of tax expenditure estimates in the Union Budget was in 2006-07. The revenue foregone due to tax incentives in 2010-11 was estimated at Rs 5,60,276 crore.

Exemptions are often justified to promote balanced regional growth, disperse industries, neutralise locational disadvantages, and incentivise priority sectors such as infrastructure. However, exemptions can create long-lasting pressure groups. They may be warranted when they demonstrably increase aggregate investment and tax revenues, but unjustified or poorly designed exemptions distort resource allocation, reduce productivity, complicate the tax system, and increase litigation. Rationalising tax expenditures can free resources for social and infrastructure spending and help reduce the fiscal deficit. Use of sunset clauses is recommended for time-bound evaluation of such concessions.

Key Tax Concepts and Terms

Tax Incidence and Tax Burden

Tax incidence indicates on whom the tax is legally imposed (for example, an excise on producers or customs on importers). Tax burden refers to who actually bears the economic cost of the tax-this may be the producer, the consumer, workers, or another party, depending on market structure and price elasticity. For example, if the government raises tax on petrol, the legal incidence may be on oil companies but the burden may be passed to motorists as higher prices, or partly absorbed by firms through reduced margins.

Tax Base and Tax Rate

• Tax base is the aggregate value (income, consumption, wealth, transactions) on which a tax is levied. Broadening the tax base means bringing more transactions, goods, services or incomes into taxation.
• Tax rate is the percentage or amount applied to the tax base to compute tax due. Systems can combine narrow bases with high rates, or broad bases with lower rates.

Tax Shelters, Avoidance and Evasion

Tax shelters are legal techniques to reduce or defer tax liabilities by investing under provisions that grant tax concessions. Tax avoidance is the lawful use of existing provisions to minimise taxes. Tax evasion is unlawful: under-reporting income, creating fictitious deductions, or concealing transactions. Avoidance is legally permissible though sometimes contrary to public policy; evasion is punishable.

Hidden or Implicit Taxes

Hidden taxes (implicit taxes) are embedded in prices of goods and services-indirect taxes being the most common example. Import duties, sales taxes and excise duties are often concealed in retail prices and thus are implicit taxes borne by consumers.

Proportional, Progressive and Regressive Taxes

• Proportional tax: tax as a percentage of income is constant across income levels (flat tax).
• Progressive tax: the tax rate rises with income; higher-income individuals pay a larger share of their income as tax, which reduces incidence on the poor.
• Regressive tax: the tax rate falls as income rises; such taxes place a heavier relative burden on lower-income groups (examples include certain flat indirect taxes).

Ad Valorem

Ad valorem means "according to value." Taxes on property, customs duties expressed as a percentage of value, and value-based excise duties are ad valorem taxes. Luxury goods are often subject to higher ad valorem rates than ordinary goods.

Excise Duty and Customs Duty

• Excise duty: a tax on the manufacture of goods within the country.
• Customs duty: a tax on goods when they are imported into or exported out of a country. Peak customs duty has been reduced substantially since liberalisation and was cited at around 10% in the period summarised here.

Negative Income Tax

Negative income tax is a concept where the government provides income support to persons or families below a defined income threshold. In practice, targeted subsidies or transfers to the poor operate like negative income taxation: the government pays money to those with incomes below the threshold.

Octroi

Octroi is a tax on the entry of goods into a local area. Under Entry 52 of the State List (VII Schedule) octroi was a revenue source for many urban local bodies. It faced criticism as an obsolete and inefficient mechanism because it required stoppage of vehicles at check posts, obstructed traffic flow, wasted business hours and fuel, and increased transaction costs. Many jurisdictions have since replaced octroi with other local taxes or state-level local body grants.

Tax Buoyancy and Tax Elasticity

• Tax buoyancy measures the percentage change in tax revenue resulting from a given percentage change in national income; it captures responsiveness of tax collections to economic growth (rate changes and coverage changes included).
• Tax elasticity measures the percentage change in tax revenue in response to a change in tax rates or the extension of coverage; elasticity isolates the effect of policy changes rather than growth of the base.

Tax Stability

Tax stability refers to the predictability and continuity of tax policy. Stable tax systems reduce uncertainty for government budgeting and for private-sector planning; frequent changes increase compliance costs and undermine long-term decisions.

Pigovian Tax

Pigovian taxes are levied to correct negative externalities: costs imposed on third parties by economic activity. Examples include pollution taxes, carbon taxes, and other environmental levies. The tax aims to internalise external costs so that prices reflect the full social cost of the activity.

Tobin Tax

Tobin tax was proposed by economist James Tobin as a small levy on all foreign exchange transactions. Its objectives are to reduce short-term speculative flows ("hot money"), reduce exchange rate volatility and raise revenue for development or exchange rate stabilisation. The Tobin tax is typically defined to be applied on both acquisition and sale of foreign exchange. It is effective only with broad international acceptance; otherwise transactions may shift to jurisdictions without the tax.

Specific Instruments and Rules

Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT)

A company's tax liability is normally computed under the Income Tax Act, while companies also prepare book profits under the Companies Act. Some firms used deductions and provisions to report little or no taxable income while reporting book profits and distributing dividends. These were known as "zero tax" companies. To ensure such companies contribute at least a minimum tax, MAT was introduced in 1996. Under MAT, companies are required to pay tax at a minimum rate on book profits. The rate cited for 2011-12 in the summary was 18.5%. Under proposals in the Direct Taxes Code, MAT was proposed at 20% of book profits.

Book profit refers to profit as shown in accounts (not always matched to taxable income) and includes unrealised gains such as appreciation in asset values until realised.

Presumptive Taxation

Presumptive taxation uses indirect or simplified methods to estimate tax liability for categories of taxpayers (for example, small traders or certain professionals) who may not maintain formal accounts or whose accounts are unreliable. The law creates a legal presumption that income is at least a prescribed amount. India introduced a presumptive tax regime for traders in the early 1990s; the scheme saw limited success and some provisions were later adjusted.

Laffer Curve

The Laffer Curve, developed by Arthur Laffer, illustrates a theoretical relationship between tax rates and tax revenue. It shows that starting from a zero tax rate, revenue increases as tax rates rise, but beyond a certain rate further increases reduce revenue as economic activity and compliance fall. Debates on the Laffer Curve influenced policy discussions when income tax rates and slabs were reduced in India around 1997-98.

Inverted Duty Structure

An inverted duty structure occurs when import duty on raw materials is higher than on finished products. This makes domestic manufacturing uncompetitive relative to imports. An example cited is compact fluorescent lamps (CFLs), where higher duties on inputs relative to finished bulbs harmed domestic producers.

Dividend Distribution Tax and Withholding Tax

• Dividend Distribution Tax: companies distributing dividends are required to pay tax on the amount distributed.
• Withholding tax (TDS): taxes deducted at source from payments such as salaries, interest, contractor payments and professional fees to ensure collection at the point of payment.

Capital Gains Tax and Wealth Tax

• Capital gains tax: tax on gains from sale of assets (land, shares, etc.). In the period described, long-term capital gains treatment depended on asset class and holding period: for many assets long-term status required three years' holding, while for listed securities long-term was one year. For listed shares, long-term capital gains were exempt under the regime then in force; short-term capital gains on shares were taxed at 15%.
• Wealth tax: levied on specified non-productive assets such as residential houses (beyond exemptions), urban land, jewellery, bullion and motor cars; it is a tax on accumulated wealth above prescribed limits.

Securities Transaction Tax (STT)

Securities Transaction Tax was introduced in the Union Budget 2004-05. It is levied on the value of securities transactions executed on recognised stock exchanges in India. STT was introduced partly to compensate revenue lost from abolition of certain capital gains tax provisions and to simplify taxation of equity transactions.

Transfer Pricing

Transfer pricing refers to pricing of goods, services or intangible assets in transactions between related entities (for example, a multinational enterprise and its subsidiary). The international standard is the arm's length principle: related-party transactions should be priced as if the parties were unrelated. Manipulation of transfer prices can shift profits to low-tax jurisdictions and erode the tax base of higher-tax countries. Therefore, governments enforce transfer-pricing rules and documentation to ensure appropriate taxation. Tightening transfer-pricing norms reduces tax avoidance and base erosion.

Revenue Composition and Local Taxes

Rupee Comes Like This

A useful illustration of revenue composition states that a substantial share of government receipts comes from borrowing and that interest payments absorb a large share of expenditure. The example breakdown provided is:

• 29 paise of every rupee of government receipts come from borrowings and other debt;
• 22 paise come from corporation tax;
• 12 paise from income tax;
• 10 paise from customs duties;
• 10 paise from excise duties;
• 10 paise from non-tax revenue;
• 6 paise from service tax;
• 1 paise from non-debt capital receipts.

Cess

Cess is an additional levy collected over and above the base tax. It differs from a surcharge in that cess collections are typically earmarked for a specific purpose (for example, education cess), whereas surcharges are general and may be used for any purpose.

Direct Taxes Code (DTC) Bill, 2010

The Direct Taxes Code Bill, 2010 aimed to consolidate and replace the Income Tax Act, 1961 and the Wealth Tax Act, 1957. The Bill sought to simplify and modernise direct tax law, widen the individual tax slabs while lowering rates, and remove many corporate exemptions (some to be grandfathered).

Main Provisions (as presented)

• Personal income: widening of income tax slabs and removal of certain exemptions; proposals included taxing income between Rs 2 lakh and Rs 5 lakh at 10%, between Rs 5 lakh and Rs 10 lakh at 20%, and income above Rs 10 lakh at 30%.
• Business and corporate income: many corporate exemptions removed or grandfathered; companies taxed at 30% of business income.
• Foreign companies: subject to an additional branch-profits tax (proposed at 15% in the Bill).
• Non-profit organisations: proposed tax rate of 15% on certain incomes.
• Capital gains: removal of the short-term/long-term distinction for most assets except securities listed on recognised stock exchanges.
• Wealth tax: exemption limit proposed to increase from Rs 15 lakh to Rs 1 crore.
• MAT: proposed at 20% of book profits under the Bill.
• General Anti-Avoidance Rules (GAAR): introduction of provisions to enable tax authorities to treat arrangements primarily designed to obtain tax benefits as impermissible.

Key Issues and Analysis

The Draft Direct Taxes Code, 2009, sought to simplify legislation and widen the tax base; the 2010 Bill reversed some of those draft provisions. The Bill retained certain personal exemptions while removing most corporate exemptions, effectively increasing the share of corporate taxes in total revenue. Concerns raised included:

• Possible increase in compliance burden: the Bill required separate computation of income for different business units of the same taxpayer and granted wide discretionary powers under GAAR without detailed procedural guidance.
• Retention of Dividend Distribution Tax and Securities Transaction Tax, which are levied at uniform rates and undermine progressivity.
• Uncertainty around the definition of a foreign company's place of effective management for tax residency rules, which could affect taxation of foreign enterprises operating in India.

Tax Administration and Appellate Authorities

The apex administrative authority for direct taxes is the Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT). The Bill proposed strengthening administrative powers to prevent tax avoidance and increasing certain penalties, along with enhanced powers to determine impermissible arrangements under GAAR. Clear guidelines and procedural safeguards are important to balance anti-avoidance objectives with taxpayer rights.

International Issues: Tax Treaties, Tax Havens and Exchange of Information

Tax Havens

Tax havens are jurisdictions that levy negligible or no taxes and often provide secrecy and minimal exchange of tax information. Typical features include nil or nominal taxes, lack of effective exchange of tax information with foreign authorities, no requirement for substantive local presence, and active promotion as offshore financial centres. Examples mentioned in international lists include Switzerland, Singapore, Cayman Islands, Monaco, Luxembourg and Hong Kong. At the time summarised, about 45 territories were blacklisted by the OECD for having harmful tax practices and banking secrecy; such jurisdictions faced the threat of financial retaliation and pressure for greater transparency.

India-Mauritius Tax Treaty and Treaty Shopping

India and Mauritius have a Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA) that historically exempted capital gains arising to a Mauritian resident company from taxation in India. More than 40% of foreign investment into India was routed via Mauritius, and authorities raised concerns that such flows included treaty shopping-investments routed through Mauritius to take advantage of the DTAA and avoid Indian capital gains tax.

India engaged in negotiations to revise DTAAs and to conclude Tax Information Exchange Agreements (TIEAs) with identified tax havens to improve sharing of tax-relevant information and to curb round-tripping and evasion. These measures aimed to prevent artificial flow of investments used primarily to avoid tax rather than genuine economic activity.

Conclusion and Policy Implications

India's tax reforms seek to modernise the tax system, broaden the base, reduce distortions, improve compliance and administration, and make taxation more efficient and equitable. Important policy trade-offs include balancing simplification with revenue adequacy, progressivity with competitiveness, and anti-avoidance measures with certainty for taxpayers. Continued emphasis on transparency, exchange of information with other jurisdictions, and periodic review of special concessions can help strengthen the revenue base while supporting economic growth and equity objectives.