Daily Editorial Analysis- 1st September, 2022 | Current Affairs & Hindu Analysis: Daily, Weekly & Monthly - UPSC PDF Download

Since The Hindu is not published today due to holiday yesterday, we have provided The Editorial Analysis of The Indian Express for today. 

Power And Its Discontents 

Why in News?

Recently, the Electricity (Amendment) Bill 2022 was introduced in Parliament amid protests and later sent to the standing committee for further deliberation.

• Many power engineers protested the Bill across the country, in states like Tamil Nadu, Telangana, Rajasthan, and others.

What is the Electricity (Amendment) Bill 2022?

• About:
  • The Electricity Amendment Bill, 2022 aims at giving multiple players open access to distribution networks of power suppliers and also allowing consumers to choose any service provider.
• Implication:
  • The Bill seeks to amend Electricity Act 2003:
    (i) To facilitate the use of distribution networks by all licensees, under provisions of non-discriminatory "open access” with the objective of enabling competition, enhancing efficiency of distribution licensees for improving services to consumers and ensuring sustainability of the power sector.
    (ii) To facilitate non-discriminatory open access to the distribution network of a distribution licensee.
    (iii) To make provisions vis-à-vis graded revision in tariff over a year besides mandatory fixing of maximum ceiling and minimum tariff by the appropriate commission.

What are the Protestor's Arguments Against the Bill?

• Federal Structure:
  • The Constitution lists ‘Electricity’ as Item 38 of List III (Concurrent) of the Seventh Schedule, so both the Central and state governments have the power to make laws on this subject.
    (i) With the proposed amendments, the federal structure of Indian polity, a part of the ‘basic structure’ of the Constitution of India, is being violated.
• Electricity Subsidy:
  • Free power for farmers and Below Poverty Line population will go away eventually.
• Differential Distribution:
  • Only government discoms or distribution companies will have universal power supply obligations.

How will this Bill impact the Power Employees & Consumers?

• Monopoly of Private Players:
  • It will lead to a major loss for government distribution companies, eventually helping to establish the monopoly of a few private parties in the country’s power sector.
• Operational Issue:
  • About 80% of the cost of supply is on account of power purchase, which will be the same for all distribution licensees operating in an area.
  • Having different retailers will open a plethora of operational issues.
  • By bringing in more retailers or distribution licensees, the quality of service or price is not going to be any different.
• Hit on Consumers:
  • As per a report of UK auditors, due to adoption of such faulty models the consumers had to pay in excess of 2.6 billion pounds.
    (i) The cost of such transfers was charged to the ordinary consumer.
    (ii) While the private companies failed, consumers were hit the most.

What is the Government’s Rationale for the Bill?

• Government has maintained that no provision in the bill reduces powers of the states to regulate the power distribution sector, payment of power subsidy.
• The government has indicated that multiple discoms can already exist in the same area and the bill only simplifies the process to ensure that competition leads to better operations and service.
• The government has maintained that it had consulted every state and many associations in writing, including a separate written assurance to the Agriculture Ministry, that there is nothing anti-farmer in the bill.

Way Forward

• Being a subject of Concurrent List of Indian Constitution, recommendations from states should be taken into consideration for effective implementation of the provisions of the bill.
• Provision related to subsidies should be put up in an elaborate manner to eliminate any scope of confusion/ conflict.
• Regulations for private players should be brought in to avoid differential distribution.