Aeon Based RC- 3 | Verbal Ability (VA) & Reading Comprehension (RC) - CAT PDF Download

The preeminent Victorian portrait photographer Julia Margaret Cameron wrote that, when photographing important subjects, ‘my whole soul has endeavoured to do its duty towards them in recording the greatness of the inner as well as the features of the outer [subject].’ This statement reflects a common belief that a successful portrait captures the essence of the person being photographed. However, this idea warrants scrutiny, both artistically and philosophically.

Early photographs, like those by Cameron, required long exposure times, causing subjects to remain still for extended periods. This often resulted in a softness in the images due to slight movements, which Cameron considered a positive feature. Modern photography, despite faster shutter speeds, still captures light events over a period, not a single moment. This challenges the notion of capturing an exact moment in time.

Photographs are said to ‘capture’ scenes only in a highly attenuated sense. The world as seen through photographs is different from how we see it with our eyes. Photographers exercise significant control over the content and production of photographs, influencing the final image. This challenges the naive idea of ‘capturing’ a scene or a person.

The concept of capturing a person's essence in a photograph is also debatable. While it's uncontroversial that photographs can align with certain physiological and psychological characteristics, the idea of capturing the essence of a person is more complex. For instance, a photograph might capture a friend's typically happy and relaxed nature, but this is not guaranteed due to the constant movement of facial muscles.

Street photography, a genre that includes candid portraits, often doesn't require knowledge of the subject's typical behavior or essence. The interpretation of such photographs may not align with the reality at the time of capture, and this ignorance can be aesthetically enjoyable. This contrasts with AI-generated images, which lack the connection to real light events.

Photographs that present fictional narratives also challenge the idea of literal truthfulness. Artists like Cindy Sherman and Duane Michals use narrative structures in their series, which are not necessarily concerned with presenting the world in a veridical fashion.

The tendency to overvalue veridicality in photographs can be problematic, especially when moving from contexts like courtrooms or newspapers to artistic contexts. Artistic photographs are often non-veridical in important respects, and appreciating them involves understanding this aspect.

Critics like Richard Avedon and Diane Arbus have faced criticism for photographs that don't appear to look like the person photographed. However, this criticism overlooks the non-veridical nature of artistic photography. Instead of expecting photographs to align with individual self-conceptions, it's important to understand and appreciate the artistic intent and style.

Nan Goldin's work, which focuses on co-creation between subject and photographer, presents an alternative approach to portrait photography. This collaborative ideal, while attractive, is just one among many legitimate artistic ideals in photography.

Moral judgments of photographic artworks are complex and not solely dependent on collaboration between photographer and subject. The moral issues in photography often relate to how photographs represent individuals and groups, and whether they reinforce harmful stereotypes or dehumanize subjects.

In conclusion, the idea that photographs capture the essence of a person is problematic because no individual can be captured in a single story or image. While this fact doesn't undermine the artistic value of photographs, it's important to remember the limitations of storytelling in photography.
Q1: What was Julia Margaret Cameron's approach to portrait photography?
(a) Focusing solely on the outer appearance of the subject.
(b) Capturing the essence of the subject's character.
(c) Emphasizing the technical aspects of photography.
(d) Creating fictional narratives through her portraits.

  View Answer

Q2: How does modern photography challenge the notion of capturing an exact moment in time?
(a) By using AI-generated images.
(b) Due to the constant movement of facial muscles.
(c) Through the use of long exposure times.
(d) By capturing light events over a period, not a single moment.

  View Answer

Q3: What is a significant difference between street photography and AI-generated images?
(a) Street photography requires knowledge of the subject's typical behavior.
(b) AI-generated images lack connection to real light events.
(c) Street photography always aligns with the reality at the time of capture.
(d) AI-generated images are more aesthetically enjoyable.

  View Answer

Q4: Why is the criticism of Avedon and Arbus for not capturing the true likeness of their subjects considered misplaced?
(a) Because their work focuses on fictional narratives.
(b) Due to the non-veridical nature of artistic photography.
(c) They primarily use AI-generated images.
(d) Their photographs are always candid and unposed.

  View Answer

Q5: What does Nan Goldin's approach to portrait photography emphasize?
(a) The importance of capturing the essence of the subject.
(b) Co-creation between the subject and the photographer.
(c) The use of long exposure times.
(d) Focusing on the technical aspects of photography.

  View Answer

Q6: What is a key reason why the idea of photographs capturing a person's essence is problematic?
(a) Photographs can reinforce harmful stereotypes.
(b) No individual can be captured in a single story or image.
(c) The constant movement of facial muscles affects the outcome.
(d) The non-veridical nature of artistic photography.

  View Answer