All questions of The Tale of Melon City for Class 11 Exam

Defense of the Architect

The correct answer is option 'C': He made certain amendments to the plans.

Explanation:

The defense of the architect revolves around the idea that he made certain amendments to the plans. This suggests that the architect acknowledges that there were errors or issues with the original plans but took steps to rectify them.

Amendments to the Plans

Making amendments to the plans can be seen as a proactive measure taken by the architect to address any potential shortcomings in the design or construction process. By identifying the issues and making necessary changes, the architect demonstrates a commitment to correcting any mistakes and ensuring the integrity of the final structure.

Importance of Amending Plans

Amending plans is a common practice in the field of architecture. During the design and construction phase, it is not uncommon for unforeseen challenges or changes in the project requirements to arise. Architects are trained to adapt to these situations and modify the plans accordingly.

The architect's decision to make amendments shows a level of professionalism and responsibility. It indicates that the architect is aware of the issues and is taking the necessary steps to resolve them.

Other Possible Defenses

While option 'C' is the correct answer, it is worth mentioning the other options and explaining why they may not be the architect's defense:

a) The bricks' size was faulty: This defense would suggest that the issue lies with the materials used rather than the architect's design or decision-making process. However, it is the architect's responsibility to ensure that the materials used meet the required specifications.

b) The masons were responsible: Blaming the masons for any construction errors does not absolve the architect of their role in overseeing the project. The architect is responsible for providing clear instructions and supervising the construction process to ensure compliance with the design.

d) The arch was constructed incorrectly: If the architect claims that the arch was constructed incorrectly, it implies that there was a mistake in the execution of the design. However, it is the architect's responsibility to communicate the design specifications clearly to the construction team and ensure that the structure is built according to the plans.

In conclusion, the architect's defense lies in their ability to identify and address any issues by making amendments to the plans. This demonstrates professionalism, responsibility, and a commitment to rectifying any mistakes or shortcomings in the design or construction process.