what does he mean by the phrase the key to their prison? Related: NCE...
Ans.
In The Last Lesson, the teacher M. Hamel told the students about the importance of a language in the lives of the people. He implicitly stated that a language always keep the people united. He encouraged them to fight unitedly to win their freedom from slavery. In the words of M. Hamel: “When a people are enslaved, as long as they hold fast to their language, it is as if they had the key to their prison.” In stating so M. Hamel is very much right.
There are examples in history where a conquered people who had held fast their language they could win back their freedom from their ruler. The biggest example in history is that of British on India who left the impact of English on us. History is replete with such examples of the races holding fast to their languages, that proved to be their keys to their prison. That is why, M. Hamel went on to say to his enslaved people of France in the school at the district of Alsace :
“We must guard it (the language) among us and never forget it.”
In other example, we can see that Spanish and Portuguese have been imposed on the people of Latin American countries.
This question is part of UPSC exam. View all Class 12 courses
what does he mean by the phrase the key to their prison? Related: NCE...
M Hamel is saying this so because he is very experienced by teaching French and knows the real attachment between language and freedom. He doesn't wants the people of Alsace and Lorrain to be slaved under the linguistic chauvinism that's why he's saying so, " We must guard it among us and never forget it"
what does he mean by the phrase the key to their prison? Related: NCE...
Introduction:
In the context of the NCERT Solution Chapter 1 - The Last Lesson from the Flamingo textbook, the phrase "the key to their prison" refers to the power of education and knowledge to liberate individuals from their limitations and narrow perspectives.
The Last Lesson:
"The Last Lesson" is a short story written by Alphonse Daudet, which revolves around the theme of the importance of education and the impact of language on cultural identity. The story is set in a small village in Alsace, which was recently annexed by Germany. As a result, the German language was imposed as the medium of instruction in schools, replacing French.
Understanding "the key to their prison":
1. Symbolic Representation: The phrase "the key to their prison" symbolizes the transformative power of education. Just as a key can unlock a prison cell and set a person free, education can liberate individuals from ignorance and narrow-mindedness.
2. Language as a Barrier: In the story, the protagonist, Franz, is deeply attached to his French language and culture. The imposition of the German language in school becomes a metaphorical "prison" for him and his classmates. They are trapped in a situation where they are unable to express themselves or connect with their own identity.
3. Loss of Cultural Identity: By taking away their native language, the German authorities aim to suppress the French cultural identity of the students. Franz and his classmates feel a sense of confinement, as they are cut off from their heritage and traditions.
4. The Power of Education: However, the phrase "the key to their prison" suggests that education can act as a liberating force. Even in the face of adversity, Franz's teacher, Mr. Hamel, demonstrates the importance of knowledge and learning. He emphasizes that language and education are not just academic subjects, but the essence of one's cultural identity and freedom.
5. Regret and Realization: Towards the end of the story, Franz regrets not having valued his French lessons before. The phrase "the key to their prison" represents the moment of realization for Franz and his classmates, as they understand the true significance of education and their cultural heritage.
Conclusion:
In the context of the NCERT Solution Chapter 1 - The Last Lesson, the phrase "the key to their prison" symbolizes the transformative power of education and knowledge. It represents the liberation of individuals from ignorance, language barriers, and the suppression of cultural identity. Through this story, Alphonse Daudet highlights the importance of valuing education and one's heritage, even in challenging circumstances.