M/s ABC Brothers, which was registered in the year 2000, has been following Straight Line Method (SLM) of depreciation. In the current year it changed its method from Straight Line to Written Down Value (WDV) Method, since such change would result in the additional depreciation of Rs. 200 lakhs as a result of which the firm would qualify to be declared as a sick industrial unit. The auditor raised objection to this change in the method of depreciation.The objection of the auditor is justified becausea)Change in the method of depreciation should be done only with the consent of the auditorb)Depreciation method can be changed only from WDV to SLM and not vice versac)Change in the method of depreciation should be done only if it is required by some statute or change would result in more appropriate presentation of financial statement or for compliance with the accounting standardd)Method of depreciation cannot be changed under any circumstancesCorrect answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer?

EduRev

All Courses

Explore Courses UPSC Exam UPSC Test Series Free Notes EduRev Infinity

Open App

CA Foundation Exam > CA Foundation Questions > M/s ABC Brothers, which was registered in the...

Join the Discussion on the App

a)
Change in the method of depreciation should be done only with the consent of the auditor
b)
Depreciation method can be changed only from WDV to SLM and not vice versa
c)
Change in the method of depreciation should be done only if it is required by some statute or change would result in more appropriate presentation of financial statement or for compliance with the accounting standard
d)
Method of depreciation cannot be changed under any circumstances

Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer?

FREE This question is part of

CA - CPT ICAI Model Test Paper - 1

Attempt Test

Attempt this Test

Most Upvoted Answer

M/s ABC Brothers, which was registered in the year 2000, has been foll...

Justification for the objection of the auditor regarding the change in the method of depreciation:

Reasons for objection:

a) Change in the method of depreciation should be done only with the consent of the auditor
b) Depreciation method can be changed only from WDV to SLM and not vice versa
c) Change in the method of depreciation should be done only if it is required by some statute or change would result in more appropriate presentation of financial statement or for compliance with the accounting standard
d) Method of depreciation cannot be changed under any circumstances

Justification:

The correct answer is option C, which states that the change in the method of depreciation should be done only if it is required by some statute or if the change would result in a more appropriate presentation of financial statements or compliance with the accounting standard. The auditor's objection is justified because:

1. Consent of the auditor: According to the Companies Act, 2013, any change in the method of depreciation should be done with the consent of the auditor. The auditor's objection is valid as the change has been made without obtaining the auditor's consent.

2. Permissible method of change: As per the accounting standards, a change in the method of depreciation can be made only if it is from WDV to SLM and not vice versa. Thus, the change made by the company is not permissible under the accounting standards.

3. Appropriate presentation of financial statements: The change in the method of depreciation should be made only if it results in a more appropriate presentation of financial statements. In this case, the change has been made solely to qualify as a sick industrial unit, which is not an appropriate reason for changing the method of depreciation.

Thus, the auditor's objection is justified as the change in the method of depreciation does not comply with the accounting standards and is not being made for appropriate reasons.

Answered by Freedom Institute · View profile

Attention CA Foundation Students!

To make sure you are not studying endlessly, EduRev has designed CA Foundation study material, with Structured Courses, Videos, & Test Series. Plus get personalized analysis, doubt solving and improvement plans to achieve a great score in CA Foundation.

Quantitative Aptitude for CA Foundation

Principles and Practice of Accounting

Business Laws for CA Foundation

Business Economics for CA Foundation

View all answers Start learning for free

< Previous Question Next Question >

Explore Courses for CA Foundation exam

Similar CA Foundation Doubts

B Limited has been charging depreciation on the straight line method. It charges a full year depreciation even if the machinery is utilized only for part of the year. An equipment which was purchased for Rs.3,50,000 now stands at Rs.2,97,500 after depreciating at the rate of 5% on a straight line basis. Now the company decides to change the method of depreciation with retrospective effect. The applicable reducing balance rate for this machinery would be 8% p.a. Assuming that before the effect of this change could be accounted, depreciation for the current year is already charged based on straight line method and is reflected in the depreciated value of Rs.2,97,500.Q. If 8% depreciation was charged by the reducing balance method, WDV at the end of 1st year is

View answer

B Ltd. has been charging depreciation on the straight line method. It charges a full year depreciation even if the machinery is utilized only for part of the year. An equipment which was purchased for Rs. 3,50,000 now stands at Rs. 2,97,500 after depreciating at the rate of 5% on a straight line basis. Now the company decides to change the method of depreciation with retrospective effect. The applicable reducing balance rate for this machinery would be 8% p.a. Assuming that before the effect of this change could be accounted, depreciation for the current year is already charged based on straight line method and is reflected in depreciated value of Rs. 2,97,500.If 8% depreciation was charged by the reducing balance method, WDV at the end of 2nd year is

View answer

B Limited has been charging depreciation on the straight line method. It charges a full year depreciation even if the machinery is utilized only for part of the year. An equipment which was purchased for Rs.3,50,000 now stands at Rs.2,97,500 after depreciating at the rate of 5% on a straight line basis. Now the company decides to change the method of depreciation with retrospective effect. The applicable reducing balance rate for this machinery would be 8% p.a. Assuming that before the effect of this change could be accounted, depreciation for the current year is already charged based on straight line method and is reflected in the depreciated value of Rs.2,97,500. The extra depreciation to be provided based on the changed method during the year is

View answer

B Limited has been charging depreciation on the straight line method. It charges a full year depreciation even if the machinery is utilized only for part of the year. An equipment which was purchased for Rs.3,50,000 now stands at Rs.2,97,500 after depreciating at the rate of 5% on a straight line basis. Now the company decides to change the method of depreciation with retrospective effect. The applicable reducing balance rate for this machinery would be 8% p.a. Assuming that before the effect of this change could be accounted, depreciation for the current year is already charged based on straight line method and is reflected in the depreciated value of Rs.2,97,500. Straight line depreciation per annum is

View answer

B Ltd. has been charging depreciation on the straight line method. It charges a full year depreciation even if the machinery is utilized only for part of the year. An equipment which was purchased for Rs. 3,50,000 now stands at Rs. 2,97,500 after depreciating at the rate of 5% on a straight line basis. Now the company decides to change the method of depreciation with retrospective effect. The applicable reducing balance rate for this machinery would be 8% p.a. Assuming that before the effect of this change could be accounted, depreciation for the current year is already charged based on straight line method and is reflected in depreciated value of Rs. 2,97,500.Number of years for which depreciation has been charged on this basis is

View answer

Top Courses for CA FoundationView all

Quantitative Aptitude for CA Foundation

Principles and Practice of Accounting

Business Laws for CA Foundation

Business Economics for CA Foundation

Mock Tests & Past Year Papers for CA Foundation

Top Courses for CA Foundation

View all

M/s ABC Brothers, which was registered in the year 2000, has been following Straight Line Method (SLM) of depreciation. In the current year it changed its method from Straight Line to Written Down Value (WDV) Method, since such change would result in the additional depreciation of Rs. 200 lakhs as a result of which the firm would qualify to be declared as a sick industrial unit. The auditor raised objection to this change in the method of depreciation.The objection of the auditor is justified becausea)Change in the method of depreciation should be done only with the consent of the auditorb)Depreciation method can be changed only from WDV to SLM and not vice versac)Change in the method of depreciation should be done only if it is required by some statute or change would result in more appropriate presentation of financial statement or for compliance with the accounting standardd)Method of depreciation cannot be changed under any circumstancesCorrect answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer?

Share with a Friend

Answer this doubt

Question Description
M/s ABC Brothers, which was registered in the year 2000, has been following Straight Line Method (SLM) of depreciation. In the current year it changed its method from Straight Line to Written Down Value (WDV) Method, since such change would result in the additional depreciation of Rs. 200 lakhs as a result of which the firm would qualify to be declared as a sick industrial unit. The auditor raised objection to this change in the method of depreciation.The objection of the auditor is justified becausea)Change in the method of depreciation should be done only with the consent of the auditorb)Depreciation method can be changed only from WDV to SLM and not vice versac)Change in the method of depreciation should be done only if it is required by some statute or change would result in more appropriate presentation of financial statement or for compliance with the accounting standardd)Method of depreciation cannot be changed under any circumstancesCorrect answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? for CA Foundation 2024 is part of CA Foundation preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the CA Foundation exam syllabus. Information about M/s ABC Brothers, which was registered in the year 2000, has been following Straight Line Method (SLM) of depreciation. In the current year it changed its method from Straight Line to Written Down Value (WDV) Method, since such change would result in the additional depreciation of Rs. 200 lakhs as a result of which the firm would qualify to be declared as a sick industrial unit. The auditor raised objection to this change in the method of depreciation.The objection of the auditor is justified becausea)Change in the method of depreciation should be done only with the consent of the auditorb)Depreciation method can be changed only from WDV to SLM and not vice versac)Change in the method of depreciation should be done only if it is required by some statute or change would result in more appropriate presentation of financial statement or for compliance with the accounting standardd)Method of depreciation cannot be changed under any circumstancesCorrect answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? covers all topics & solutions for CA Foundation 2024 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for M/s ABC Brothers, which was registered in the year 2000, has been following Straight Line Method (SLM) of depreciation. In the current year it changed its method from Straight Line to Written Down Value (WDV) Method, since such change would result in the additional depreciation of Rs. 200 lakhs as a result of which the firm would qualify to be declared as a sick industrial unit. The auditor raised objection to this change in the method of depreciation.The objection of the auditor is justified becausea)Change in the method of depreciation should be done only with the consent of the auditorb)Depreciation method can be changed only from WDV to SLM and not vice versac)Change in the method of depreciation should be done only if it is required by some statute or change would result in more appropriate presentation of financial statement or for compliance with the accounting standardd)Method of depreciation cannot be changed under any circumstancesCorrect answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer?.

Solutions for M/s ABC Brothers, which was registered in the year 2000, has been following Straight Line Method (SLM) of depreciation. In the current year it changed its method from Straight Line to Written Down Value (WDV) Method, since such change would result in the additional depreciation of Rs. 200 lakhs as a result of which the firm would qualify to be declared as a sick industrial unit. The auditor raised objection to this change in the method of depreciation.The objection of the auditor is justified becausea)Change in the method of depreciation should be done only with the consent of the auditorb)Depreciation method can be changed only from WDV to SLM and not vice versac)Change in the method of depreciation should be done only if it is required by some statute or change would result in more appropriate presentation of financial statement or for compliance with the accounting standardd)Method of depreciation cannot be changed under any circumstancesCorrect answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? in English & in Hindi are available as part of our courses for CA Foundation. Download more important topics, notes, lectures and mock test series for CA Foundation Exam by signing up for free.

Here you can find the meaning of M/s ABC Brothers, which was registered in the year 2000, has been following Straight Line Method (SLM) of depreciation. In the current year it changed its method from Straight Line to Written Down Value (WDV) Method, since such change would result in the additional depreciation of Rs. 200 lakhs as a result of which the firm would qualify to be declared as a sick industrial unit. The auditor raised objection to this change in the method of depreciation.The objection of the auditor is justified becausea)Change in the method of depreciation should be done only with the consent of the auditorb)Depreciation method can be changed only from WDV to SLM and not vice versac)Change in the method of depreciation should be done only if it is required by some statute or change would result in more appropriate presentation of financial statement or for compliance with the accounting standardd)Method of depreciation cannot be changed under any circumstancesCorrect answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? defined & explained in the simplest way possible. Besides giving the explanation of M/s ABC Brothers, which was registered in the year 2000, has been following Straight Line Method (SLM) of depreciation. In the current year it changed its method from Straight Line to Written Down Value (WDV) Method, since such change would result in the additional depreciation of Rs. 200 lakhs as a result of which the firm would qualify to be declared as a sick industrial unit. The auditor raised objection to this change in the method of depreciation.The objection of the auditor is justified becausea)Change in the method of depreciation should be done only with the consent of the auditorb)Depreciation method can be changed only from WDV to SLM and not vice versac)Change in the method of depreciation should be done only if it is required by some statute or change would result in more appropriate presentation of financial statement or for compliance with the accounting standardd)Method of depreciation cannot be changed under any circumstancesCorrect answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer?, a detailed solution for M/s ABC Brothers, which was registered in the year 2000, has been following Straight Line Method (SLM) of depreciation. In the current year it changed its method from Straight Line to Written Down Value (WDV) Method, since such change would result in the additional depreciation of Rs. 200 lakhs as a result of which the firm would qualify to be declared as a sick industrial unit. The auditor raised objection to this change in the method of depreciation.The objection of the auditor is justified becausea)Change in the method of depreciation should be done only with the consent of the auditorb)Depreciation method can be changed only from WDV to SLM and not vice versac)Change in the method of depreciation should be done only if it is required by some statute or change would result in more appropriate presentation of financial statement or for compliance with the accounting standardd)Method of depreciation cannot be changed under any circumstancesCorrect answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? has been provided alongside types of M/s ABC Brothers, which was registered in the year 2000, has been following Straight Line Method (SLM) of depreciation. In the current year it changed its method from Straight Line to Written Down Value (WDV) Method, since such change would result in the additional depreciation of Rs. 200 lakhs as a result of which the firm would qualify to be declared as a sick industrial unit. The auditor raised objection to this change in the method of depreciation.The objection of the auditor is justified becausea)Change in the method of depreciation should be done only with the consent of the auditorb)Depreciation method can be changed only from WDV to SLM and not vice versac)Change in the method of depreciation should be done only if it is required by some statute or change would result in more appropriate presentation of financial statement or for compliance with the accounting standardd)Method of depreciation cannot be changed under any circumstancesCorrect answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? theory, EduRev gives you an ample number of questions to practice M/s ABC Brothers, which was registered in the year 2000, has been following Straight Line Method (SLM) of depreciation. In the current year it changed its method from Straight Line to Written Down Value (WDV) Method, since such change would result in the additional depreciation of Rs. 200 lakhs as a result of which the firm would qualify to be declared as a sick industrial unit. The auditor raised objection to this change in the method of depreciation.The objection of the auditor is justified becausea)Change in the method of depreciation should be done only with the consent of the auditorb)Depreciation method can be changed only from WDV to SLM and not vice versac)Change in the method of depreciation should be done only if it is required by some statute or change would result in more appropriate presentation of financial statement or for compliance with the accounting standardd)Method of depreciation cannot be changed under any circumstancesCorrect answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? tests, examples and also practice CA Foundation tests.

Explore Courses for CA Foundation exam