GMAT Exam > GMAT Questions > The red tramfish is an extremely rare species...
Start Learning for Free
The red tramfish is an extremely rare species of fish that can be found only in some of the lake shores of the Silver Lakes region. A recent study has found that the oil extracted from the bones of the red tramfish can be used to develop an extremely effective medicine for arthritis. Since this finding has led to a sudden interest in this fish, the locals fear that the species will soon be extinct.
Which of the following, if true, supports the idea that the fear of the locals may not be misplaced?
- a)It may not be possible to selectively catch red tramfish.
- b)The cost of extracting oil from the bones of the red tramfish is higher than the cost of artificially developing the same oil.
- c)The oil extracted from the bones of a single red tramfish is sufficient to produce more than four weeks of medication for an arthritis patient.
- d)At the levels at which the red tramfish is now being caught, the rate of reproduction of the fish is less than the rate of fishing.
- e)The proportion of population that is most affected by arthritis is expected to stay the same in the near future.
Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer?
Verified Answer
The red tramfish is an extremely rare species of fish that can be foun...
Pre-Thinking
Conclusion Clarification
The question stem asks us to support the idea that the fear of the locals may not be misplaced. In other words, we are to support the belief that the locals may be right in fearing that the species will soon be extinct.
Pre-Thinking Approach
To strengthen the conclusion, let’s look at the logical structure, focusing on linkages 1 and 2. We will try to come up with an assumption by understanding the condition under which the conclusion is falsified. The assumption then will be that condition does not exist and the conclusion can be strengthened by supporting this or any other assumption.
Linkage#1 & 2 – RT is a rare species and there is a sudden interest in it.
- Falsification Condition: Yes, RT could be caught extensively to produce the oil. But what if the rate at which it reproduces is significantly higher than the rate at which it will be caught. If this were true, then the conclusion will be falsified. Accordingly, a strengthener could say that:
- Instance: The rate at which RT reproduces is not higher than the rate at which it is being currently caught.
In the above scenario, the fear of the locals seem valid as surely if fishing RT at the above rate carries on then it is possible that the species may go extinct.
Linkage # 1 - RT is a rare species that can be found only in some of the lake shores of the Silver Lakes region.
- Strengthener : The fact that RT is a rare species and is naturally found only in a particular lake supports the locals’ fear. However, what if RT can be successfully bred in captivity? It could then be argued that their fear is not valid. Therefore, a possible strengthener could be to rule out this possibility.
- Instance: All attempts to breed RT in captivity have been unsuccessful so far and there is no breakthrough technology in sight that provides hope in the matter.
With this understanding in mind, let's take a look at the option statements.
Answer Choices
It may not be possible to selectively catch red tramfish.
Incorrect - Irrelevant
A
This option does not impact the conclusion in anyway as we do not know that whether people who have a sudden interest in RT will be interested in catching only RT or may prefer getting hold of other fish alongwith it.
B
The cost of extracting oil from the bones of the red tramfish is higher than the cost of artificially developing the same oil.
Incorrect - Irrelevant
Neither the choice nor the passage gives us any information to establish whether the cost of extracting oil is going to be a factor for the people interested in catching RT. Hence, the information here is completely irrelevant.
C
The oil extracted from the bones of a single red tramfish is sufficient to produce more than four weeks of medication for an arthritis patient.
Incorrect - Irrelevant
As we don’t know how the quantity of oil obtained from a red tramfish relates to its probability of going extinct, this option is not relevant.
D
At the levels at which the red tramfish is now being caught, the rate of reproduction of the fish is less than the rate of fishing.
Correct
This choice is written along the lines of our pre-thinking per Linkage #1 & 2.
E
The proportion of population that is most affected by arthritis is expected to stay the same in the near future.
Incorrect - Irrelevant
We cannot determine what impact the information given in this choice would have on the conclusion drawn by the locals. It doesn’t tell us whether the absolute number of people most affected by arthritis is expected to go up or not.
Most Upvoted Answer
The red tramfish is an extremely rare species of fish that can be foun...
This assumes that the RT cannot die any other way.
what if there is also a predator and now with the fact that they are being fished, their population can decline further.
there's insufficient information to make this conclusion
what if there is also a predator and now with the fact that they are being fished, their population can decline further.
there's insufficient information to make this conclusion
|
Explore Courses for GMAT exam
|
|
Top Courses for GMATView all
Question Description
The red tramfish is an extremely rare species of fish that can be found only in some of the lake shores of the Silver Lakes region. A recent study has found that the oil extracted from the bones of the red tramfish can be used to develop an extremely effective medicine for arthritis. Since this finding has led to a sudden interest in this fish, the locals fear that the species will soon be extinct.Which of the following, if true, supports the idea that the fear of the locals may not be misplaced?a)It may not be possible to selectively catch red tramfish.b)The cost of extracting oil from the bones of the red tramfish is higher than the cost of artificially developing the same oil.c)The oil extracted from the bones of a single red tramfish is sufficient to produce more than four weeks of medication for an arthritis patient.d)At the levels at which the red tramfish is now being caught, the rate of reproduction of the fish is less than the rate of fishing.e)The proportion of population that is most affected by arthritis is expected to stay the same in the near future.Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer? for GMAT 2025 is part of GMAT preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the GMAT exam syllabus. Information about The red tramfish is an extremely rare species of fish that can be found only in some of the lake shores of the Silver Lakes region. A recent study has found that the oil extracted from the bones of the red tramfish can be used to develop an extremely effective medicine for arthritis. Since this finding has led to a sudden interest in this fish, the locals fear that the species will soon be extinct.Which of the following, if true, supports the idea that the fear of the locals may not be misplaced?a)It may not be possible to selectively catch red tramfish.b)The cost of extracting oil from the bones of the red tramfish is higher than the cost of artificially developing the same oil.c)The oil extracted from the bones of a single red tramfish is sufficient to produce more than four weeks of medication for an arthritis patient.d)At the levels at which the red tramfish is now being caught, the rate of reproduction of the fish is less than the rate of fishing.e)The proportion of population that is most affected by arthritis is expected to stay the same in the near future.Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer? covers all topics & solutions for GMAT 2025 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for The red tramfish is an extremely rare species of fish that can be found only in some of the lake shores of the Silver Lakes region. A recent study has found that the oil extracted from the bones of the red tramfish can be used to develop an extremely effective medicine for arthritis. Since this finding has led to a sudden interest in this fish, the locals fear that the species will soon be extinct.Which of the following, if true, supports the idea that the fear of the locals may not be misplaced?a)It may not be possible to selectively catch red tramfish.b)The cost of extracting oil from the bones of the red tramfish is higher than the cost of artificially developing the same oil.c)The oil extracted from the bones of a single red tramfish is sufficient to produce more than four weeks of medication for an arthritis patient.d)At the levels at which the red tramfish is now being caught, the rate of reproduction of the fish is less than the rate of fishing.e)The proportion of population that is most affected by arthritis is expected to stay the same in the near future.Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer?.
The red tramfish is an extremely rare species of fish that can be found only in some of the lake shores of the Silver Lakes region. A recent study has found that the oil extracted from the bones of the red tramfish can be used to develop an extremely effective medicine for arthritis. Since this finding has led to a sudden interest in this fish, the locals fear that the species will soon be extinct.Which of the following, if true, supports the idea that the fear of the locals may not be misplaced?a)It may not be possible to selectively catch red tramfish.b)The cost of extracting oil from the bones of the red tramfish is higher than the cost of artificially developing the same oil.c)The oil extracted from the bones of a single red tramfish is sufficient to produce more than four weeks of medication for an arthritis patient.d)At the levels at which the red tramfish is now being caught, the rate of reproduction of the fish is less than the rate of fishing.e)The proportion of population that is most affected by arthritis is expected to stay the same in the near future.Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer? for GMAT 2025 is part of GMAT preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the GMAT exam syllabus. Information about The red tramfish is an extremely rare species of fish that can be found only in some of the lake shores of the Silver Lakes region. A recent study has found that the oil extracted from the bones of the red tramfish can be used to develop an extremely effective medicine for arthritis. Since this finding has led to a sudden interest in this fish, the locals fear that the species will soon be extinct.Which of the following, if true, supports the idea that the fear of the locals may not be misplaced?a)It may not be possible to selectively catch red tramfish.b)The cost of extracting oil from the bones of the red tramfish is higher than the cost of artificially developing the same oil.c)The oil extracted from the bones of a single red tramfish is sufficient to produce more than four weeks of medication for an arthritis patient.d)At the levels at which the red tramfish is now being caught, the rate of reproduction of the fish is less than the rate of fishing.e)The proportion of population that is most affected by arthritis is expected to stay the same in the near future.Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer? covers all topics & solutions for GMAT 2025 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for The red tramfish is an extremely rare species of fish that can be found only in some of the lake shores of the Silver Lakes region. A recent study has found that the oil extracted from the bones of the red tramfish can be used to develop an extremely effective medicine for arthritis. Since this finding has led to a sudden interest in this fish, the locals fear that the species will soon be extinct.Which of the following, if true, supports the idea that the fear of the locals may not be misplaced?a)It may not be possible to selectively catch red tramfish.b)The cost of extracting oil from the bones of the red tramfish is higher than the cost of artificially developing the same oil.c)The oil extracted from the bones of a single red tramfish is sufficient to produce more than four weeks of medication for an arthritis patient.d)At the levels at which the red tramfish is now being caught, the rate of reproduction of the fish is less than the rate of fishing.e)The proportion of population that is most affected by arthritis is expected to stay the same in the near future.Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer?.
Solutions for The red tramfish is an extremely rare species of fish that can be found only in some of the lake shores of the Silver Lakes region. A recent study has found that the oil extracted from the bones of the red tramfish can be used to develop an extremely effective medicine for arthritis. Since this finding has led to a sudden interest in this fish, the locals fear that the species will soon be extinct.Which of the following, if true, supports the idea that the fear of the locals may not be misplaced?a)It may not be possible to selectively catch red tramfish.b)The cost of extracting oil from the bones of the red tramfish is higher than the cost of artificially developing the same oil.c)The oil extracted from the bones of a single red tramfish is sufficient to produce more than four weeks of medication for an arthritis patient.d)At the levels at which the red tramfish is now being caught, the rate of reproduction of the fish is less than the rate of fishing.e)The proportion of population that is most affected by arthritis is expected to stay the same in the near future.Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer? in English & in Hindi are available as part of our courses for GMAT.
Download more important topics, notes, lectures and mock test series for GMAT Exam by signing up for free.
Here you can find the meaning of The red tramfish is an extremely rare species of fish that can be found only in some of the lake shores of the Silver Lakes region. A recent study has found that the oil extracted from the bones of the red tramfish can be used to develop an extremely effective medicine for arthritis. Since this finding has led to a sudden interest in this fish, the locals fear that the species will soon be extinct.Which of the following, if true, supports the idea that the fear of the locals may not be misplaced?a)It may not be possible to selectively catch red tramfish.b)The cost of extracting oil from the bones of the red tramfish is higher than the cost of artificially developing the same oil.c)The oil extracted from the bones of a single red tramfish is sufficient to produce more than four weeks of medication for an arthritis patient.d)At the levels at which the red tramfish is now being caught, the rate of reproduction of the fish is less than the rate of fishing.e)The proportion of population that is most affected by arthritis is expected to stay the same in the near future.Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer? defined & explained in the simplest way possible. Besides giving the explanation of
The red tramfish is an extremely rare species of fish that can be found only in some of the lake shores of the Silver Lakes region. A recent study has found that the oil extracted from the bones of the red tramfish can be used to develop an extremely effective medicine for arthritis. Since this finding has led to a sudden interest in this fish, the locals fear that the species will soon be extinct.Which of the following, if true, supports the idea that the fear of the locals may not be misplaced?a)It may not be possible to selectively catch red tramfish.b)The cost of extracting oil from the bones of the red tramfish is higher than the cost of artificially developing the same oil.c)The oil extracted from the bones of a single red tramfish is sufficient to produce more than four weeks of medication for an arthritis patient.d)At the levels at which the red tramfish is now being caught, the rate of reproduction of the fish is less than the rate of fishing.e)The proportion of population that is most affected by arthritis is expected to stay the same in the near future.Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer?, a detailed solution for The red tramfish is an extremely rare species of fish that can be found only in some of the lake shores of the Silver Lakes region. A recent study has found that the oil extracted from the bones of the red tramfish can be used to develop an extremely effective medicine for arthritis. Since this finding has led to a sudden interest in this fish, the locals fear that the species will soon be extinct.Which of the following, if true, supports the idea that the fear of the locals may not be misplaced?a)It may not be possible to selectively catch red tramfish.b)The cost of extracting oil from the bones of the red tramfish is higher than the cost of artificially developing the same oil.c)The oil extracted from the bones of a single red tramfish is sufficient to produce more than four weeks of medication for an arthritis patient.d)At the levels at which the red tramfish is now being caught, the rate of reproduction of the fish is less than the rate of fishing.e)The proportion of population that is most affected by arthritis is expected to stay the same in the near future.Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer? has been provided alongside types of The red tramfish is an extremely rare species of fish that can be found only in some of the lake shores of the Silver Lakes region. A recent study has found that the oil extracted from the bones of the red tramfish can be used to develop an extremely effective medicine for arthritis. Since this finding has led to a sudden interest in this fish, the locals fear that the species will soon be extinct.Which of the following, if true, supports the idea that the fear of the locals may not be misplaced?a)It may not be possible to selectively catch red tramfish.b)The cost of extracting oil from the bones of the red tramfish is higher than the cost of artificially developing the same oil.c)The oil extracted from the bones of a single red tramfish is sufficient to produce more than four weeks of medication for an arthritis patient.d)At the levels at which the red tramfish is now being caught, the rate of reproduction of the fish is less than the rate of fishing.e)The proportion of population that is most affected by arthritis is expected to stay the same in the near future.Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer? theory, EduRev gives you an
ample number of questions to practice The red tramfish is an extremely rare species of fish that can be found only in some of the lake shores of the Silver Lakes region. A recent study has found that the oil extracted from the bones of the red tramfish can be used to develop an extremely effective medicine for arthritis. Since this finding has led to a sudden interest in this fish, the locals fear that the species will soon be extinct.Which of the following, if true, supports the idea that the fear of the locals may not be misplaced?a)It may not be possible to selectively catch red tramfish.b)The cost of extracting oil from the bones of the red tramfish is higher than the cost of artificially developing the same oil.c)The oil extracted from the bones of a single red tramfish is sufficient to produce more than four weeks of medication for an arthritis patient.d)At the levels at which the red tramfish is now being caught, the rate of reproduction of the fish is less than the rate of fishing.e)The proportion of population that is most affected by arthritis is expected to stay the same in the near future.Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer? tests, examples and also practice GMAT tests.
|
|
Explore Courses for GMAT exam
|
|
Signup for Free!
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days! Learn & Practice with 1000+ FREE Notes, Videos & Tests.
|
© EduRev
|
Education Revolution
|
|
Signup on EduRev and stay on top of your study goals
10M+ students crushing their study goals daily