GMAT Exam  >  GMAT Questions  >  Following a major mishap, a pilgrim spot in t... Start Learning for Free
Following a major mishap, a pilgrim spot in the country had been kept closed for the past five years. Recently, a directive by the government has allowed the spot to be reopened for pilgrimage. Since the directive was first published in national newspapers, a huge rush of people, mostly in their early twenties, has been witnessed across the booking offices that have exclusive rights to offer tours to the spot. Clearly, this observation goes against the claim that such spots are most likely to attract pilgrims over the age of 50.
 Which of the following statements most demonstrates a flaw in the argument?
  • a)
    The author fails to consider that the number of tickets booked this year may differ from the number of pilgrims who travelled to the spot five years back.
  • b)
    The author fails to consider that the regional booking offices can also offer tickets to other pilgrim spots.
  • c)
    The author fails to distinguish between people who book tickets from the counters and the ones who travel.
  • d)
    The author fails to consider that the religious sentiments of the young generation can change in five years.
  • e)
    The author does not supply any information on the proportion of booked tickets that end up getting cancelled in the last moment.
Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer?
Verified Answer
Following a major mishap, a pilgrim spot in the country had been kept ...
Argument Analysis
Pre-Thinking
Conclusion Clarification
The conclusion states that this observation goes against the claim that such spots are most likely to attract pilgrims over the age of 50. The observation is that people in their early twenties are the ones making the reservations at the offices. 
Pre-Thinking Approach
Let’s see how we can find a flaw in the argument.  To do so, we will look at the logical structure, focusing on linkage 1 and the conclusion. Thus the way to look for a flaw in the argument is to understand whether the author uses sound logic to arrive at the conclusion.
Linkage#1Since the directive was first published in national newspapers, a huge rush of people, mostly in their early twenties, has been witnessed across the booking offices that have exclusive rights to offer tours to the spot.
But what if the people booking the tickets are different from the ones going on the pilgrimage? What if young people are booking tickets for their parents or grandparents? In other words, the author’s argument assumes that:
The people making the bookings are the ones going on the pilgrimage.
However, such an assumption is unwarranted. As stated earlier, it is possible that the young people observed at the booking offices were making reservations for elderly members of their families.
With this pre-thinking in mind, let’s evaluate the answer choices.
Answer Choices
The author fails to consider that the number of tickets booked this year may differ from the number of pilgrims who travelled to the spot five years back.
Incorrect - Irrelevant
There is no comparison between the two time-periods. Hence, this information is completely immaterial to the argument.
B
The author fails to consider that the regional booking offices can also offer tickets to other pilgrim spots.
Incorrect - Irrelevant
The author’s argument is not dependent on the number of tickets sold to one particular pilgrim spot but instead on the age-demographics of the people buying tickets at various booking offices.
C
The author fails to distinguish between people who book tickets from the counters and the ones who travel.
Correct
This option is written along the lines of our pre-thinking per linkage 1.
D
The author fails to consider that the religious sentiments of the young generation can change in five years.
Incorrect - Irrelevant
There is no comparison between the two time-periods. Hence, this information is completely immaterial to the argument. 
E
The author does not supply any information on the proportion of booked tickets that end up getting cancelled in the last moment.
Incorrect - Irrelevant
The proportion of booked tickets that get cancelled does not affect the conclusion of the argument. 
View all questions of this test
Explore Courses for GMAT exam

Top Courses for GMAT

Question Description
Following a major mishap, a pilgrim spot in the country had been kept closed for the past five years. Recently, a directive by the government has allowed the spot to be reopened for pilgrimage. Since the directive was first published in national newspapers, a huge rush of people, mostly in their early twenties, has been witnessed across the booking offices that have exclusive rights to offer tours to the spot. Clearly, this observation goes against the claim that such spots are most likely to attract pilgrims over the age of 50.Which of the following statements most demonstrates a flaw in the argument?a)The author fails to consider that the number of tickets booked this year may differ from the number of pilgrims who travelled to the spot five years back.b)The author fails to consider that the regional booking offices can also offer tickets to other pilgrim spots.c)The author fails to distinguish between people who book tickets from the counters and the ones who travel.d)The author fails to consider that the religious sentiments of the young generation can change in five years.e)The author does not supply any information on the proportion of booked tickets that end up getting cancelled in the last moment.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? for GMAT 2025 is part of GMAT preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the GMAT exam syllabus. Information about Following a major mishap, a pilgrim spot in the country had been kept closed for the past five years. Recently, a directive by the government has allowed the spot to be reopened for pilgrimage. Since the directive was first published in national newspapers, a huge rush of people, mostly in their early twenties, has been witnessed across the booking offices that have exclusive rights to offer tours to the spot. Clearly, this observation goes against the claim that such spots are most likely to attract pilgrims over the age of 50.Which of the following statements most demonstrates a flaw in the argument?a)The author fails to consider that the number of tickets booked this year may differ from the number of pilgrims who travelled to the spot five years back.b)The author fails to consider that the regional booking offices can also offer tickets to other pilgrim spots.c)The author fails to distinguish between people who book tickets from the counters and the ones who travel.d)The author fails to consider that the religious sentiments of the young generation can change in five years.e)The author does not supply any information on the proportion of booked tickets that end up getting cancelled in the last moment.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? covers all topics & solutions for GMAT 2025 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for Following a major mishap, a pilgrim spot in the country had been kept closed for the past five years. Recently, a directive by the government has allowed the spot to be reopened for pilgrimage. Since the directive was first published in national newspapers, a huge rush of people, mostly in their early twenties, has been witnessed across the booking offices that have exclusive rights to offer tours to the spot. Clearly, this observation goes against the claim that such spots are most likely to attract pilgrims over the age of 50.Which of the following statements most demonstrates a flaw in the argument?a)The author fails to consider that the number of tickets booked this year may differ from the number of pilgrims who travelled to the spot five years back.b)The author fails to consider that the regional booking offices can also offer tickets to other pilgrim spots.c)The author fails to distinguish between people who book tickets from the counters and the ones who travel.d)The author fails to consider that the religious sentiments of the young generation can change in five years.e)The author does not supply any information on the proportion of booked tickets that end up getting cancelled in the last moment.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer?.
Solutions for Following a major mishap, a pilgrim spot in the country had been kept closed for the past five years. Recently, a directive by the government has allowed the spot to be reopened for pilgrimage. Since the directive was first published in national newspapers, a huge rush of people, mostly in their early twenties, has been witnessed across the booking offices that have exclusive rights to offer tours to the spot. Clearly, this observation goes against the claim that such spots are most likely to attract pilgrims over the age of 50.Which of the following statements most demonstrates a flaw in the argument?a)The author fails to consider that the number of tickets booked this year may differ from the number of pilgrims who travelled to the spot five years back.b)The author fails to consider that the regional booking offices can also offer tickets to other pilgrim spots.c)The author fails to distinguish between people who book tickets from the counters and the ones who travel.d)The author fails to consider that the religious sentiments of the young generation can change in five years.e)The author does not supply any information on the proportion of booked tickets that end up getting cancelled in the last moment.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? in English & in Hindi are available as part of our courses for GMAT. Download more important topics, notes, lectures and mock test series for GMAT Exam by signing up for free.
Here you can find the meaning of Following a major mishap, a pilgrim spot in the country had been kept closed for the past five years. Recently, a directive by the government has allowed the spot to be reopened for pilgrimage. Since the directive was first published in national newspapers, a huge rush of people, mostly in their early twenties, has been witnessed across the booking offices that have exclusive rights to offer tours to the spot. Clearly, this observation goes against the claim that such spots are most likely to attract pilgrims over the age of 50.Which of the following statements most demonstrates a flaw in the argument?a)The author fails to consider that the number of tickets booked this year may differ from the number of pilgrims who travelled to the spot five years back.b)The author fails to consider that the regional booking offices can also offer tickets to other pilgrim spots.c)The author fails to distinguish between people who book tickets from the counters and the ones who travel.d)The author fails to consider that the religious sentiments of the young generation can change in five years.e)The author does not supply any information on the proportion of booked tickets that end up getting cancelled in the last moment.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? defined & explained in the simplest way possible. Besides giving the explanation of Following a major mishap, a pilgrim spot in the country had been kept closed for the past five years. Recently, a directive by the government has allowed the spot to be reopened for pilgrimage. Since the directive was first published in national newspapers, a huge rush of people, mostly in their early twenties, has been witnessed across the booking offices that have exclusive rights to offer tours to the spot. Clearly, this observation goes against the claim that such spots are most likely to attract pilgrims over the age of 50.Which of the following statements most demonstrates a flaw in the argument?a)The author fails to consider that the number of tickets booked this year may differ from the number of pilgrims who travelled to the spot five years back.b)The author fails to consider that the regional booking offices can also offer tickets to other pilgrim spots.c)The author fails to distinguish between people who book tickets from the counters and the ones who travel.d)The author fails to consider that the religious sentiments of the young generation can change in five years.e)The author does not supply any information on the proportion of booked tickets that end up getting cancelled in the last moment.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer?, a detailed solution for Following a major mishap, a pilgrim spot in the country had been kept closed for the past five years. Recently, a directive by the government has allowed the spot to be reopened for pilgrimage. Since the directive was first published in national newspapers, a huge rush of people, mostly in their early twenties, has been witnessed across the booking offices that have exclusive rights to offer tours to the spot. Clearly, this observation goes against the claim that such spots are most likely to attract pilgrims over the age of 50.Which of the following statements most demonstrates a flaw in the argument?a)The author fails to consider that the number of tickets booked this year may differ from the number of pilgrims who travelled to the spot five years back.b)The author fails to consider that the regional booking offices can also offer tickets to other pilgrim spots.c)The author fails to distinguish between people who book tickets from the counters and the ones who travel.d)The author fails to consider that the religious sentiments of the young generation can change in five years.e)The author does not supply any information on the proportion of booked tickets that end up getting cancelled in the last moment.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? has been provided alongside types of Following a major mishap, a pilgrim spot in the country had been kept closed for the past five years. Recently, a directive by the government has allowed the spot to be reopened for pilgrimage. Since the directive was first published in national newspapers, a huge rush of people, mostly in their early twenties, has been witnessed across the booking offices that have exclusive rights to offer tours to the spot. Clearly, this observation goes against the claim that such spots are most likely to attract pilgrims over the age of 50.Which of the following statements most demonstrates a flaw in the argument?a)The author fails to consider that the number of tickets booked this year may differ from the number of pilgrims who travelled to the spot five years back.b)The author fails to consider that the regional booking offices can also offer tickets to other pilgrim spots.c)The author fails to distinguish between people who book tickets from the counters and the ones who travel.d)The author fails to consider that the religious sentiments of the young generation can change in five years.e)The author does not supply any information on the proportion of booked tickets that end up getting cancelled in the last moment.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? theory, EduRev gives you an ample number of questions to practice Following a major mishap, a pilgrim spot in the country had been kept closed for the past five years. Recently, a directive by the government has allowed the spot to be reopened for pilgrimage. Since the directive was first published in national newspapers, a huge rush of people, mostly in their early twenties, has been witnessed across the booking offices that have exclusive rights to offer tours to the spot. Clearly, this observation goes against the claim that such spots are most likely to attract pilgrims over the age of 50.Which of the following statements most demonstrates a flaw in the argument?a)The author fails to consider that the number of tickets booked this year may differ from the number of pilgrims who travelled to the spot five years back.b)The author fails to consider that the regional booking offices can also offer tickets to other pilgrim spots.c)The author fails to distinguish between people who book tickets from the counters and the ones who travel.d)The author fails to consider that the religious sentiments of the young generation can change in five years.e)The author does not supply any information on the proportion of booked tickets that end up getting cancelled in the last moment.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? tests, examples and also practice GMAT tests.
Explore Courses for GMAT exam

Top Courses for GMAT

Explore Courses
Signup for Free!
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days! Learn & Practice with 1000+ FREE Notes, Videos & Tests.
10M+ students study on EduRev