What is disadvantage of Indian constitution?
Disadvantages of Indian Constitution
There are several disadvantages of the Indian Constitution that have been recognized by scholars and experts over the years. Some of these disadvantages are:
1. Lack of Clarity
The Indian Constitution is criticized for its lack of clarity in certain areas. For example, the Constitution does not clearly define the powers and responsibilities of various government institutions, leading to confusion and conflict.
2. Lengthy and Complex
The Indian Constitution is one of the longest and most complex in the world. With over 448 articles and 12 schedules, it can be difficult to understand and navigate, even for legal experts.
3. Rigid Amendments Process
The process for amending the Indian Constitution is extremely rigid, requiring the approval of two-thirds of the Parliament and half of the state legislatures. This has led to difficulty in making necessary changes to the Constitution in a timely manner.
4. Lack of Accountability
The Constitution does not clearly outline the mechanisms for holding government officials accountable for their actions. As a result, corruption and abuse of power remain major issues in India.
5. Inadequate Representation
While the Constitution guarantees certain rights and protections to all citizens, some groups, such as women and minorities, may not be adequately represented in government institutions or protected under the law.
Overall, while the Indian Constitution has many positive attributes, it is not without its flaws. These disadvantages can make it difficult for the government to effectively govern and for citizens to fully exercise their rights and freedoms.
What is disadvantage of Indian constitution?
a) The Constitution is comprehensive and in fact too comprehensive. Some provisions seem too redundant to be considered a part of the Constitution.
b) There is a strong bias towards the centre in our federal structure. Recent case of Uttarakhand's govt being toppled to set in President's rule is a glaring example.
c) Privileges of the Parliament and State Legislatures are left upon then to decide which has not been codified till date. Though one doesn't expect such a provision to be enumerated in the Constitution, but Indian scenario might entail one such provision.
d) The Constitution is too bulky and too complex for a layman to understand. In fact it is considered a paradise of lawyers. This happened because our Constituent Assembly comprised of a very high number of eminent lawyers.
e) There is a high degree of protection to civil servants accorded under Art 311. This provision is more misused and abused than being used.
f) Anglo Indian community doesn't really require 2 seats in Lok Sabha anymore. The fears of 1950s are certainly gone and this provision may be repealed to uphold Right to Equality.
To make sure you are not studying endlessly, EduRev has designed Class 8 study material, with Structured Courses, Videos, & Test Series. Plus get personalized analysis, doubt solving and improvement plans to achieve a great score in Class 8.