did the soldiers on both the sides want the war?how do you know? Relat...
Possible answer:
Did soldiers on both sides want the war?
It is likely that most soldiers on both sides did not want the war, but had to fight it as part of their duty or loyalty to their country or ruler. However, there may have been some soldiers who supported the war for various reasons, such as nationalism, revenge, or ideology.
Evidence from the text
"The Best Christmas Present in the World" by Michael Morpurgo does not explicitly state whether the soldiers wanted the war or not, but implies some clues based on the characters' words and actions:
- Jim Macpherson, the protagonist, feels that the war is pointless and destructive, and regrets the loss of his friend, who died in the trenches. He also empathizes with the German soldier's desire for peace and reconciliation, despite their former enmity.
- Hans Wolf, the German soldier, expresses his disillusionment with the war and his longing for his family and home. He also shares Jim's appreciation for the power of writing and the value of human connection.
- The narrator, who finds Jim's letter and investigates his story, seems to share Jim's perspective on the futility and tragedy of war, as well as the hope that people can learn from history and avoid repeating it.
Therefore, it is reasonable to assume that most soldiers on both sides did not want the war, as it caused them physical and emotional harm, separated them from their loved ones, and challenged their beliefs and values. However, some soldiers may have been more enthusiastic or committed to the war effort, depending on their personal motivations and circumstances.
Explanation of the text
"The Best Christmas Present in the World" is a story that explores the theme of war from a humanistic and historical perspective. Through the character of Jim Macpherson, a retired teacher who discovers a rusty tin box containing a letter from a British soldier to his wife during World War I, the story invites the reader to reflect on the meaning and consequences of war, as well as the power of communication and empathy. When Jim reads the letter, which describes a brief truce between British and German soldiers on Christmas Eve, he becomes curious about the identity and fate of the author, and decides to investigate his story. With the help of a German historian, who traces the soldier's name and unit, Jim learns that the soldier, whose name was Thomas, died soon after the truce, and that his wife never received his letter. However, Jim also discovers that Thomas's letter and his own research have inspired Hans Wolf, a German soldier who fought in the same area as Thomas, to seek Jim and offer him a Christmas present: a small carved angel that Hans had made during his captivity in a British prison camp. Jim and Hans share a moment of mutual recognition and respect, as they realize that they both have experienced the horrors and humanity of war, and that their common humanity transcends national and cultural boundaries. The story ends with Jim returning home, feeling grateful for the chance to honor Thomas's memory and to make a new friend, and with the hope that the world may one day learn from the lessons of the past and create a more peaceful and just future.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the question of whether soldiers on both sides wanted the war in "The Best Christmas Present in the World" is not directly answered, but can be inferred from the characters' attitudes and actions. Most soldiers probably did not want the war, but were forced to fight it for various
did the soldiers on both the sides want the war?how do you know? Relat...
The soldiers of both side to do not want the wire because they thought that the war is not a best way of resolving conflicts that the best way of resolving conflict is by plane games and sports in the example of this is in the Christmas morning they called out from the No Man's Land 'Happy Christmas Happy Christmas'.
To make sure you are not studying endlessly, EduRev has designed Class 8 study material, with Structured Courses, Videos, & Test Series. Plus get personalized analysis, doubt solving and improvement plans to achieve a great score in Class 8.