CAT Exam  >  CAT Questions  >   Directions: Analyse the given arguments and ... Start Learning for Free
Directions: Analyse the given arguments and answer the questions that follow
An automobile manufacturing and assembling unit, Mast Cars, opened its new factory in the outskirts of Gaongram 7 years back. They have a dedicated non-political labour union cell, which along with the ardent management of Mast Cars addresses all labour related issues and solves the grievances at the earliest. With high-quality products, services and excellent labour policies, Mast Cars has gained substantial popularity over a very small period of time.
Six months into the situation, the economy has bounced back to the normal and the automobile industry is experiencing higher demands than usual. Mast Cars recently received an order of 20,000-cylinder heads. For the timely completion of this order, a lot of contract labourers have been hired. Knowing about the emoluments and perks that a full-time labourer receives at Mast Cars, the contractual labourers started protests to have equal pay. On their demands being refused, a few workers sought to violence. They brutally hit a few full-time employees, set fire to 4 cars on the factory premises and damaged some machinery. Which of the following would be the most appropriate set of steps that the management at Mast Cars should take?
1. Immediately call the police to take control over the situation
2. Hold a meeting with the labour union and the agitated labourers to reach a consensus
3. Remove all contractual labourers with immediate effect
4. Agree to the demands and give equal emoluments to permanent and contractual labour
5. Shut the production till the mob is under control and the damages have been mitigated
  • a)
    2 and 5
  • b)
    1 and 3
  • c)
    2 and 3
  • d)
    1 and 5
Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer?
Most Upvoted Answer
Directions: Analyse the given arguments and answer the questions that...
Understanding the Situation
Mast Cars is facing a critical situation due to protests from contractual labourers demanding equal pay with full-time employees. The protests escalated into violence, causing damage to property and endangering the safety of employees.
Recommended Actions
To effectively address this issue, the management needs to consider both immediate safety concerns and longer-term resolutions.
1. Call the Police
- This action is necessary to restore order and ensure the safety of all employees and property.
- Police intervention can help prevent further violence and protect the factory from additional damage.
2. Shut Production Temporarily
- Stopping production allows the management to focus on resolving the conflict without the distraction of ongoing operations.
- It also ensures the safety of all employees, both full-time and contractual, while addressing the situation.
Inappropriate Actions
- Meeting with Labour Union (Option 2): While dialogue is essential, it should occur after ensuring safety and control over the situation to prevent further escalation.
- Removing Contractual Labourers (Option 3): This could worsen tensions and lead to more unrest.
- Agreeing to Demands (Option 4): Complying with demands without addressing the root cause may create long-term issues in labour relations.
Conclusion
The most appropriate steps for Mast Cars management are to call the police and shut down production until the situation is under control. This ensures immediate safety while paving the way for constructive dialogue with the labour union once peace is restored. Thus, the correct answer is option 'D'.
Free Test
Community Answer
Directions: Analyse the given arguments and answer the questions that...
Given that some contractual labourers have sorted to violence, it would not be very wise to hold a meeting with them, eliminating statement 2. Again, agreeing to their demands completely would be unfair to the permanent employees who have worked hard all through to be granted those emoluments. Removing all contractual labourers would be unfair to the ones who had no role to play in the violence, thus elimination 3. Statements 1 and 5 provide necessary measures that would help in getting control over the situation. However, we don't have any course of action that provides with a solution of how to deal with the situation thereafter, given the choices, option D is the best possible choice.
Explore Courses for CAT exam

Similar CAT Doubts

Directions: Read the passage and answer the questions independently of one another.Sham had moved to Chennai at the age of 22 in search of employment in the manufacturing sector. He had completed an industrial training course. Roto Manfacturing hired him after they noticed that he was sincere and that he worked hard. Within four years, he reached the position of a supervisor in the company and was leading a team of 25 workers. Sham’s uncle suggested to him that he start his own manufacturing firm as he had gained sufficient experience in the field. Sham was excited by the thought of running his own firm, and with some financial help from his uncle, he soon started his own manufacturing plant. He convinced a few trustworthy employees and colleagues from Roto Manufacturing to join him in this venture. The venture witnessed rapid growth and within two years, Sham began receiving orders from other countries as well. Sham began expanding the capacity of the unit and in three years’ time, the total number of employees working in his company had reached 600. Around the same time, Chennai was witnessing rapid development in the services industry. Because of this development, labourers were gradually shifting their jobs from the manufacturing sector to the more lucrative services sector as they received better salaries with relatively lower physical workloads. Gradually many of Sham’s employees began to leave the company resulting in a shortage of manpower at the plant. This in turn resulted in Sham not being able to meet the timelines on his projects causing increased customer dissatisfaction.Exisitng employees demanded higher wages to continue in the company. If Sham increases the wages, then his company would find it difficult to remain profitable. He is not able to recruit young people as they did not like the jobs in the manufacturing sector as the sector demanded more physical work.Sham receives a takeover offer from International Manufacturing(IM), a manufacturing conglomerate that wants to acquire his company and its assets. But the price they are offering is not competitive. What should be the immediate course of action for Sham?

Directions: Read the passage and answer the questions independently of one another.Sham had moved to Chennai at the age of 22 in search of employment in the manufacturing sector. He had completed an industrial training course. Roto Manufacturing hired him after they noticed that he was sincere and that he worked hard. Within four years, he reached the position of a supervisor in the company and was leading a team of 25 workers. Sham’s uncle suggested to him that he start his own manufacturing firm as he had gained sufficient experience in the field. Sham was excited by the thought of running his own firm, and with some financial help from his uncle, he soon started his own manufacturing plant. He convinced a few trustworthy employees and colleagues from Roto Manufacturing to join him in this venture. The venture witnessed rapid growth and within two years, Sham began receiving orders from other countries as well. Sham began expanding the capacity of the unit and in three years’ time, the total number of employees working in his company had reached 600. Around the same time, Chennai was witnessing rapid development in the services industry. Because of this development, labourers were gradually shifting their jobs from the manufacturing sector to the more lucrative services sector as they received better salaries with relatively lower physical workloads. Gradually many of Sham’s employees began to leave the company resulting in a shortage of manpower at the plant. This in turn resulted in Sham not being able to meet the timelines on his projects causing increased customer dissatisfaction.Existing employees demanded higher wages to continue in the company. If Sham increases the wages, then his company would find it difficult to remain profitable. He is not able to recruit young people as they did not like the jobs in the manufacturing sector as the sector demanded more physical work.Sham receives a takeover offer from International Manufacturing(IM), a manufacturing conglomerate that wants to acquire his company and its assets. But the price they are offering is not competitive. What should be the immediate course of action for Sham?

Directions: Read the passage and answer the questions independently of one another.Sham had moved to Chennai at the age of 22 in search of employment in the manufacturing sector. He had completed an industrial training course. Roto Manfacturing hired him after they noticed that he was sincere and that he worked hard. Within four years, he reached the position of a supervisor in the company and was leading a team of 25 workers. Sham’s uncle suggested to him that he start his own manufacturing firm as he had gained sufficient experience in the field. Sham was excited by the thought of running his own firm, and with some financial help from his uncle, he soon started his own manufacturing plant. He convinced a few trustworthy employees and colleagues from Roto Manufacturing to join him in this venture. The venture witnessed rapid growth and within two years, Sham began receiving orders from other countries as well. Sham began expanding the capacity of the unit and in three years’ time, the total number of employees working in his company had reached 600. Around the same time, Chennai was witnessing rapid development in the services industry. Because of this development, labourers were gradually shifting their jobs from the manufacturing sector to the more lucrative services sector as they received better salaries with relatively lower physical workloads. Gradually many of Sham’s employees began to leave the company resulting in a shortage of manpower at the plant. This in turn resulted in Sham not being able to meet the timelines on his projects causing increased customer dissatisfaction.Exisitng employees demanded higher wages to continue in the company. If Sham increases the wages, then his company would find it difficult to remain profitable. He is not able to recruit young people as they did not like the jobs in the manufacturing sector as the sector demanded more physical work.If you were Sham, what in your opinion would be the most appropriate action to get the company back on track?

Directions: Read the passage and answer the questions independently of one another.Sham had moved to Chennai at the age of 22 in search of employment in the manufacturing sector. He had completed an industrial training course. Roto Manufacturing hired him after they noticed that he was sincere and that he worked hard. Within four years, he reached the position of a supervisor in the company and was leading a team of 25 workers. Sham’s uncle suggested to him that he start his own manufacturing firm as he had gained sufficient experience in the field. Sham was excited by the thought of running his own firm, and with some financial help from his uncle, he soon started his own manufacturing plant. He convinced a few trustworthy employees and colleagues from Roto Manufacturing to join him in this venture. The venture witnessed rapid growth and within two years, Sham began receiving orders from other countries as well. Sham began expanding the capacity of the unit and in three years’ time, the total number of employees working in his company had reached 600. Around the same time, Chennai was witnessing rapid development in the services industry. Because of this development, labourers were gradually shifting their jobs from the manufacturing sector to the more lucrative services sector as they received better salaries with relatively lower physical workloads. Gradually many of Sham’s employees began to leave the company resulting in a shortage of manpower at the plant. This in turn resulted in Sham not being able to meet the timelines on his projects causing increased customer dissatisfaction.Existing employees demanded higher wages to continue in the company. If Sham increases the wages, then his company would find it difficult to remain profitable. He is not able to recruit young people as they did not like the jobs in the manufacturing sector as the sector demanded more physical work.If you were Sham, what in your opinion would be the most appropriate action to get the company back on track?

Directions: Analyse the given arguments and answer the questions that followAn automobile manufacturing and assembling unit, Mast Cars, opened its new factory in the outskirts of Gaongram 7 years back. They have a dedicated non-political labour union cell, which along with the ardent management of Mast Cars addresses all labour related issues and solves the grievances at the earliest. With high-quality products, services and excellent labour policies, Mast Cars has gained substantial popularity over a very small period of time.Six months into the situation, the economy has bounced back to the normal and the automobile industry is experiencing higher demands than usual. Mast Cars recently received an order of 20,000-cylinder heads. For the timely completion of this order, a lot of contract labourers have been hired. Knowing about the emoluments and perks that a full-time labourer receives at Mast Cars, the contractual labourers started protests to have equal pay. On their demands being refused, a few workers sought to violence. They brutally hit a few full-time employees, set fire to 4 cars on the factory premises and damaged some machinery. Which of the following would be the most appropriate set of steps that the management at Mast Cars should take?1. Immediately call the police to take control over the situation2. Hold a meeting with the labour union and the agitated labourers to reach a consensus3. Remove all contractual labourers with immediate effect4. Agree to the demands and give equal emoluments to permanent and contractual labour5. Shut the production till the mob is under control and the damages have been mitigateda)2 and 5b)1 and 3c)2 and 3d)1 and 5Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer?
Question Description
Directions: Analyse the given arguments and answer the questions that followAn automobile manufacturing and assembling unit, Mast Cars, opened its new factory in the outskirts of Gaongram 7 years back. They have a dedicated non-political labour union cell, which along with the ardent management of Mast Cars addresses all labour related issues and solves the grievances at the earliest. With high-quality products, services and excellent labour policies, Mast Cars has gained substantial popularity over a very small period of time.Six months into the situation, the economy has bounced back to the normal and the automobile industry is experiencing higher demands than usual. Mast Cars recently received an order of 20,000-cylinder heads. For the timely completion of this order, a lot of contract labourers have been hired. Knowing about the emoluments and perks that a full-time labourer receives at Mast Cars, the contractual labourers started protests to have equal pay. On their demands being refused, a few workers sought to violence. They brutally hit a few full-time employees, set fire to 4 cars on the factory premises and damaged some machinery. Which of the following would be the most appropriate set of steps that the management at Mast Cars should take?1. Immediately call the police to take control over the situation2. Hold a meeting with the labour union and the agitated labourers to reach a consensus3. Remove all contractual labourers with immediate effect4. Agree to the demands and give equal emoluments to permanent and contractual labour5. Shut the production till the mob is under control and the damages have been mitigateda)2 and 5b)1 and 3c)2 and 3d)1 and 5Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer? for CAT 2025 is part of CAT preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the CAT exam syllabus. Information about Directions: Analyse the given arguments and answer the questions that followAn automobile manufacturing and assembling unit, Mast Cars, opened its new factory in the outskirts of Gaongram 7 years back. They have a dedicated non-political labour union cell, which along with the ardent management of Mast Cars addresses all labour related issues and solves the grievances at the earliest. With high-quality products, services and excellent labour policies, Mast Cars has gained substantial popularity over a very small period of time.Six months into the situation, the economy has bounced back to the normal and the automobile industry is experiencing higher demands than usual. Mast Cars recently received an order of 20,000-cylinder heads. For the timely completion of this order, a lot of contract labourers have been hired. Knowing about the emoluments and perks that a full-time labourer receives at Mast Cars, the contractual labourers started protests to have equal pay. On their demands being refused, a few workers sought to violence. They brutally hit a few full-time employees, set fire to 4 cars on the factory premises and damaged some machinery. Which of the following would be the most appropriate set of steps that the management at Mast Cars should take?1. Immediately call the police to take control over the situation2. Hold a meeting with the labour union and the agitated labourers to reach a consensus3. Remove all contractual labourers with immediate effect4. Agree to the demands and give equal emoluments to permanent and contractual labour5. Shut the production till the mob is under control and the damages have been mitigateda)2 and 5b)1 and 3c)2 and 3d)1 and 5Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer? covers all topics & solutions for CAT 2025 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for Directions: Analyse the given arguments and answer the questions that followAn automobile manufacturing and assembling unit, Mast Cars, opened its new factory in the outskirts of Gaongram 7 years back. They have a dedicated non-political labour union cell, which along with the ardent management of Mast Cars addresses all labour related issues and solves the grievances at the earliest. With high-quality products, services and excellent labour policies, Mast Cars has gained substantial popularity over a very small period of time.Six months into the situation, the economy has bounced back to the normal and the automobile industry is experiencing higher demands than usual. Mast Cars recently received an order of 20,000-cylinder heads. For the timely completion of this order, a lot of contract labourers have been hired. Knowing about the emoluments and perks that a full-time labourer receives at Mast Cars, the contractual labourers started protests to have equal pay. On their demands being refused, a few workers sought to violence. They brutally hit a few full-time employees, set fire to 4 cars on the factory premises and damaged some machinery. Which of the following would be the most appropriate set of steps that the management at Mast Cars should take?1. Immediately call the police to take control over the situation2. Hold a meeting with the labour union and the agitated labourers to reach a consensus3. Remove all contractual labourers with immediate effect4. Agree to the demands and give equal emoluments to permanent and contractual labour5. Shut the production till the mob is under control and the damages have been mitigateda)2 and 5b)1 and 3c)2 and 3d)1 and 5Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer?.
Solutions for Directions: Analyse the given arguments and answer the questions that followAn automobile manufacturing and assembling unit, Mast Cars, opened its new factory in the outskirts of Gaongram 7 years back. They have a dedicated non-political labour union cell, which along with the ardent management of Mast Cars addresses all labour related issues and solves the grievances at the earliest. With high-quality products, services and excellent labour policies, Mast Cars has gained substantial popularity over a very small period of time.Six months into the situation, the economy has bounced back to the normal and the automobile industry is experiencing higher demands than usual. Mast Cars recently received an order of 20,000-cylinder heads. For the timely completion of this order, a lot of contract labourers have been hired. Knowing about the emoluments and perks that a full-time labourer receives at Mast Cars, the contractual labourers started protests to have equal pay. On their demands being refused, a few workers sought to violence. They brutally hit a few full-time employees, set fire to 4 cars on the factory premises and damaged some machinery. Which of the following would be the most appropriate set of steps that the management at Mast Cars should take?1. Immediately call the police to take control over the situation2. Hold a meeting with the labour union and the agitated labourers to reach a consensus3. Remove all contractual labourers with immediate effect4. Agree to the demands and give equal emoluments to permanent and contractual labour5. Shut the production till the mob is under control and the damages have been mitigateda)2 and 5b)1 and 3c)2 and 3d)1 and 5Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer? in English & in Hindi are available as part of our courses for CAT. Download more important topics, notes, lectures and mock test series for CAT Exam by signing up for free.
Here you can find the meaning of Directions: Analyse the given arguments and answer the questions that followAn automobile manufacturing and assembling unit, Mast Cars, opened its new factory in the outskirts of Gaongram 7 years back. They have a dedicated non-political labour union cell, which along with the ardent management of Mast Cars addresses all labour related issues and solves the grievances at the earliest. With high-quality products, services and excellent labour policies, Mast Cars has gained substantial popularity over a very small period of time.Six months into the situation, the economy has bounced back to the normal and the automobile industry is experiencing higher demands than usual. Mast Cars recently received an order of 20,000-cylinder heads. For the timely completion of this order, a lot of contract labourers have been hired. Knowing about the emoluments and perks that a full-time labourer receives at Mast Cars, the contractual labourers started protests to have equal pay. On their demands being refused, a few workers sought to violence. They brutally hit a few full-time employees, set fire to 4 cars on the factory premises and damaged some machinery. Which of the following would be the most appropriate set of steps that the management at Mast Cars should take?1. Immediately call the police to take control over the situation2. Hold a meeting with the labour union and the agitated labourers to reach a consensus3. Remove all contractual labourers with immediate effect4. Agree to the demands and give equal emoluments to permanent and contractual labour5. Shut the production till the mob is under control and the damages have been mitigateda)2 and 5b)1 and 3c)2 and 3d)1 and 5Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer? defined & explained in the simplest way possible. Besides giving the explanation of Directions: Analyse the given arguments and answer the questions that followAn automobile manufacturing and assembling unit, Mast Cars, opened its new factory in the outskirts of Gaongram 7 years back. They have a dedicated non-political labour union cell, which along with the ardent management of Mast Cars addresses all labour related issues and solves the grievances at the earliest. With high-quality products, services and excellent labour policies, Mast Cars has gained substantial popularity over a very small period of time.Six months into the situation, the economy has bounced back to the normal and the automobile industry is experiencing higher demands than usual. Mast Cars recently received an order of 20,000-cylinder heads. For the timely completion of this order, a lot of contract labourers have been hired. Knowing about the emoluments and perks that a full-time labourer receives at Mast Cars, the contractual labourers started protests to have equal pay. On their demands being refused, a few workers sought to violence. They brutally hit a few full-time employees, set fire to 4 cars on the factory premises and damaged some machinery. Which of the following would be the most appropriate set of steps that the management at Mast Cars should take?1. Immediately call the police to take control over the situation2. Hold a meeting with the labour union and the agitated labourers to reach a consensus3. Remove all contractual labourers with immediate effect4. Agree to the demands and give equal emoluments to permanent and contractual labour5. Shut the production till the mob is under control and the damages have been mitigateda)2 and 5b)1 and 3c)2 and 3d)1 and 5Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer?, a detailed solution for Directions: Analyse the given arguments and answer the questions that followAn automobile manufacturing and assembling unit, Mast Cars, opened its new factory in the outskirts of Gaongram 7 years back. They have a dedicated non-political labour union cell, which along with the ardent management of Mast Cars addresses all labour related issues and solves the grievances at the earliest. With high-quality products, services and excellent labour policies, Mast Cars has gained substantial popularity over a very small period of time.Six months into the situation, the economy has bounced back to the normal and the automobile industry is experiencing higher demands than usual. Mast Cars recently received an order of 20,000-cylinder heads. For the timely completion of this order, a lot of contract labourers have been hired. Knowing about the emoluments and perks that a full-time labourer receives at Mast Cars, the contractual labourers started protests to have equal pay. On their demands being refused, a few workers sought to violence. They brutally hit a few full-time employees, set fire to 4 cars on the factory premises and damaged some machinery. Which of the following would be the most appropriate set of steps that the management at Mast Cars should take?1. Immediately call the police to take control over the situation2. Hold a meeting with the labour union and the agitated labourers to reach a consensus3. Remove all contractual labourers with immediate effect4. Agree to the demands and give equal emoluments to permanent and contractual labour5. Shut the production till the mob is under control and the damages have been mitigateda)2 and 5b)1 and 3c)2 and 3d)1 and 5Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer? has been provided alongside types of Directions: Analyse the given arguments and answer the questions that followAn automobile manufacturing and assembling unit, Mast Cars, opened its new factory in the outskirts of Gaongram 7 years back. They have a dedicated non-political labour union cell, which along with the ardent management of Mast Cars addresses all labour related issues and solves the grievances at the earliest. With high-quality products, services and excellent labour policies, Mast Cars has gained substantial popularity over a very small period of time.Six months into the situation, the economy has bounced back to the normal and the automobile industry is experiencing higher demands than usual. Mast Cars recently received an order of 20,000-cylinder heads. For the timely completion of this order, a lot of contract labourers have been hired. Knowing about the emoluments and perks that a full-time labourer receives at Mast Cars, the contractual labourers started protests to have equal pay. On their demands being refused, a few workers sought to violence. They brutally hit a few full-time employees, set fire to 4 cars on the factory premises and damaged some machinery. Which of the following would be the most appropriate set of steps that the management at Mast Cars should take?1. Immediately call the police to take control over the situation2. Hold a meeting with the labour union and the agitated labourers to reach a consensus3. Remove all contractual labourers with immediate effect4. Agree to the demands and give equal emoluments to permanent and contractual labour5. Shut the production till the mob is under control and the damages have been mitigateda)2 and 5b)1 and 3c)2 and 3d)1 and 5Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer? theory, EduRev gives you an ample number of questions to practice Directions: Analyse the given arguments and answer the questions that followAn automobile manufacturing and assembling unit, Mast Cars, opened its new factory in the outskirts of Gaongram 7 years back. They have a dedicated non-political labour union cell, which along with the ardent management of Mast Cars addresses all labour related issues and solves the grievances at the earliest. With high-quality products, services and excellent labour policies, Mast Cars has gained substantial popularity over a very small period of time.Six months into the situation, the economy has bounced back to the normal and the automobile industry is experiencing higher demands than usual. Mast Cars recently received an order of 20,000-cylinder heads. For the timely completion of this order, a lot of contract labourers have been hired. Knowing about the emoluments and perks that a full-time labourer receives at Mast Cars, the contractual labourers started protests to have equal pay. On their demands being refused, a few workers sought to violence. They brutally hit a few full-time employees, set fire to 4 cars on the factory premises and damaged some machinery. Which of the following would be the most appropriate set of steps that the management at Mast Cars should take?1. Immediately call the police to take control over the situation2. Hold a meeting with the labour union and the agitated labourers to reach a consensus3. Remove all contractual labourers with immediate effect4. Agree to the demands and give equal emoluments to permanent and contractual labour5. Shut the production till the mob is under control and the damages have been mitigateda)2 and 5b)1 and 3c)2 and 3d)1 and 5Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer? tests, examples and also practice CAT tests.
Explore Courses for CAT exam

Top Courses for CAT

Explore Courses
Signup for Free!
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days! Learn & Practice with 1000+ FREE Notes, Videos & Tests.
10M+ students study on EduRev