GMAT Exam  >  GMAT Questions  >  The Senator Wiley damned the Frequent Flyer s... Start Learning for Free
The Senator Wiley damned the Frequent Flyer schemes, now operated by virtually all major American airlines, as nothing less than a bribe to acquire the accounts of major corporations that are willing to pay excessively high sums to buy Frequent Flyer discount coupons in order to give untaxed rewards to employees. To make the discounted ticket prices viable, airlines raise the initial marked price of the tickets. Thus, the price of tickets for the general public is kept artificially high. Walter Healey, the Vice President of American Airlines, responded to the criticism by saying the Frequent Flyer scheme was enjoyed by millions of Americans who were able to acquire Frequent Flyer tokens from supermarket purchases and credit card transactions.
Q. Which of the following, if true, best exposes the flaw in Healey's response to Wiley's criticism?
  • a)
    Only a few supermarket chains and credit card companies offer Frequent Flyer tokens to customers.
  • b)
    Fewer people acquire Frequent Flyer tokens through supermarket purchases than through credit card transactions.
  • c)
    Most airline companies offer bonus tokens for long-haul flights.
  • d)
    The price of tickets booked under Frequent Flyer schemes is often as low as 50% of the regular ticket price.
  • e)
    Ticket prices are regularly reviewed by a committee of airline representatives.
Correct answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer?
Verified Answer
The Senator Wiley damned the Frequent Flyer schemes, now operated by v...
This option is correct. It is aligned with predictive weakener 2.
Argument construction
A Senator criticized the Frequent Flyer schemes, operated by almost all major American airlines, saying it is like giving bribe to major corporations to acquire their accounts. These corporation pay excessively high sums to buy Frequent Flyer tokens from airlines and pass these discount-seeking tokens to their employees to give them untaxed rewards. In turn, upon encashing the tokens, the employees get discounted airline tickets. This implies that the price of tickets for the general public is kept artificially high and compared to privileged employees, they end up paying more. However, the VP of American Airlines, responded to the criticism by saying the Frequent Flyer scheme was also enjoyed by millions of Americans who could get Frequent Flyer tokens from supermarket purchases and credit card transactions.
Predict a Weakener
Let's write down the claim.
Claim: Benefit of Frequent Flyer scheme is not exclusive to major corporations; general public can also get the same benefit as the employees of major corporations do.
Our job is to find a flaw in the claim, or in other words, we need to weaken the claim.
What if a large number of airline tickets are reserved for major corporations? Well, in that case there would be only a few airline tickets available for general public. So, though they may have Frequent Flyer tokens, they cannot utilize them.
Predictive Weakener 1: A large number of airline tickets are reserved for major corporations.
What if there are only a few supermarkets and only a few credit card companies that offer Frequent Flyer tokens? Well, in that case, only a few people can get the benefit of the scheme.
Predictive Weakener 2: Only a few supermarkets and credit card companies offer Frequent Flyer tokens.
There can be one or two more predictive weakeners; however, you need not think of more than two.
View all questions of this test
Most Upvoted Answer
The Senator Wiley damned the Frequent Flyer schemes, now operated by v...


Analysis:

Flaw in Healey's Response:

- Healey's response highlights that millions of Americans enjoy the Frequent Flyer scheme by acquiring tokens from supermarket purchases and credit card transactions.
- However, the flaw in his argument lies in the assumption that these acquisition methods are easily accessible and widely used by the general public.

Exposing the Flaw:

- Option A states that only a few supermarket chains and credit card companies offer Frequent Flyer tokens to customers.
- This information undermines Healey's claim that millions of Americans benefit from the scheme through these channels.
- If only a limited number of supermarkets and credit card companies provide these tokens, then the accessibility and availability of the scheme to the general public are significantly reduced.
- As a result, Healey's argument that the Frequent Flyer scheme is enjoyed by millions is weakened, as a smaller portion of the population may actually have access to these tokens through supermarket purchases and credit card transactions.

Conclusion:

- Option A effectively exposes the flaw in Healey's response by challenging the widespread availability of Frequent Flyer tokens through supermarket purchases and credit card transactions, thereby casting doubt on the reach and impact of the scheme on millions of Americans.
Free Test
Community Answer
The Senator Wiley damned the Frequent Flyer schemes, now operated by v...
This option is correct. It is aligned with predictive weakener 2.
Argument construction
A Senator criticized the Frequent Flyer schemes, operated by almost all major American airlines, saying it is like giving bribe to major corporations to acquire their accounts. These corporation pay excessively high sums to buy Frequent Flyer tokens from airlines and pass these discount-seeking tokens to their employees to give them untaxed rewards. In turn, upon encashing the tokens, the employees get discounted airline tickets. This implies that the price of tickets for the general public is kept artificially high and compared to privileged employees, they end up paying more. However, the VP of American Airlines, responded to the criticism by saying the Frequent Flyer scheme was also enjoyed by millions of Americans who could get Frequent Flyer tokens from supermarket purchases and credit card transactions.
Predict a Weakener
Let's write down the claim.
Claim: Benefit of Frequent Flyer scheme is not exclusive to major corporations; general public can also get the same benefit as the employees of major corporations do.
Our job is to find a flaw in the claim, or in other words, we need to weaken the claim.
What if a large number of airline tickets are reserved for major corporations? Well, in that case there would be only a few airline tickets available for general public. So, though they may have Frequent Flyer tokens, they cannot utilize them.
Predictive Weakener 1: A large number of airline tickets are reserved for major corporations.
What if there are only a few supermarkets and only a few credit card companies that offer Frequent Flyer tokens? Well, in that case, only a few people can get the benefit of the scheme.
Predictive Weakener 2: Only a few supermarkets and credit card companies offer Frequent Flyer tokens.
There can be one or two more predictive weakeners; however, you need not think of more than two.
Explore Courses for GMAT exam

Similar GMAT Doubts

XM Representative: The federal committee thoroughly reviews all of the geo-engineering industry’s planned projects and approves only those that meet your guidelines for safety and environmental impact. Since less than two percent of XM projects have ever been rejected, the costly and timeconsuming review should be waived so that our latest project can be quickly passed and implemented.Committee Member: Your request fails to consider that the decisions of our board affect not only the corporation involved, but also the entire field. If we fail to review your project, we also fail to observe innovations in geoengineering that may need guidelines drafted for the safety of subsequent projects throughout the industry.In the table below, please identify the additional evidence that most strengthens and the additional evidence that most weakens the committee member’s response to the XM representative.A: XM’s latest project is nearly identical to a previousproject by XM that had successfully passed thecommittee review processB:The geo-engineering corporation CL, which is XM’sbiggest competitor, has had less than one percent of itsprojects rejected by the committeeC:Once a geo-engineering innovation has been passed bythe committee, the same innovation is automaticallyapproved in all subsequent projects, without furtherreview.D:Many of XM’s geo-engineering projects are peerreviewed within the industry before they are submitted to the federal committee.E:Geo-engineering is a hazardous field that deserves careful monitoring.

Top Courses for GMAT

The Senator Wiley damned the Frequent Flyer schemes, now operated by virtually all major American airlines, as nothing less than a bribe to acquire the accounts of major corporations that are willing to pay excessively high sums to buy Frequent Flyer discount coupons in order to give untaxed rewards to employees. To make the discounted ticket prices viable, airlines raise the initial marked price of the tickets. Thus, the price of tickets for the general public is kept artificially high. Walter Healey, the Vice President of American Airlines, responded to the criticism by saying the Frequent Flyer scheme was enjoyed by millions of Americans who were able to acquire Frequent Flyer tokens from supermarket purchases and credit card transactions.Q. Which of the following, if true, best exposes the flaw in Healeys response to Wileys criticism?a)Only a few supermarket chains and credit card companies offer Frequent Flyer tokens to customers.b)Fewer people acquire Frequent Flyer tokens through supermarket purchases than through credit card transactions.c)Most airline companies offer bonus tokens for long-haul flights.d)The price of tickets booked under Frequent Flyer schemes is often as low as 50% of the regular ticket price.e)Ticket prices are regularly reviewed by a committee of airline representatives.Correct answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer?
Question Description
The Senator Wiley damned the Frequent Flyer schemes, now operated by virtually all major American airlines, as nothing less than a bribe to acquire the accounts of major corporations that are willing to pay excessively high sums to buy Frequent Flyer discount coupons in order to give untaxed rewards to employees. To make the discounted ticket prices viable, airlines raise the initial marked price of the tickets. Thus, the price of tickets for the general public is kept artificially high. Walter Healey, the Vice President of American Airlines, responded to the criticism by saying the Frequent Flyer scheme was enjoyed by millions of Americans who were able to acquire Frequent Flyer tokens from supermarket purchases and credit card transactions.Q. Which of the following, if true, best exposes the flaw in Healeys response to Wileys criticism?a)Only a few supermarket chains and credit card companies offer Frequent Flyer tokens to customers.b)Fewer people acquire Frequent Flyer tokens through supermarket purchases than through credit card transactions.c)Most airline companies offer bonus tokens for long-haul flights.d)The price of tickets booked under Frequent Flyer schemes is often as low as 50% of the regular ticket price.e)Ticket prices are regularly reviewed by a committee of airline representatives.Correct answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? for GMAT 2025 is part of GMAT preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the GMAT exam syllabus. Information about The Senator Wiley damned the Frequent Flyer schemes, now operated by virtually all major American airlines, as nothing less than a bribe to acquire the accounts of major corporations that are willing to pay excessively high sums to buy Frequent Flyer discount coupons in order to give untaxed rewards to employees. To make the discounted ticket prices viable, airlines raise the initial marked price of the tickets. Thus, the price of tickets for the general public is kept artificially high. Walter Healey, the Vice President of American Airlines, responded to the criticism by saying the Frequent Flyer scheme was enjoyed by millions of Americans who were able to acquire Frequent Flyer tokens from supermarket purchases and credit card transactions.Q. Which of the following, if true, best exposes the flaw in Healeys response to Wileys criticism?a)Only a few supermarket chains and credit card companies offer Frequent Flyer tokens to customers.b)Fewer people acquire Frequent Flyer tokens through supermarket purchases than through credit card transactions.c)Most airline companies offer bonus tokens for long-haul flights.d)The price of tickets booked under Frequent Flyer schemes is often as low as 50% of the regular ticket price.e)Ticket prices are regularly reviewed by a committee of airline representatives.Correct answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? covers all topics & solutions for GMAT 2025 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for The Senator Wiley damned the Frequent Flyer schemes, now operated by virtually all major American airlines, as nothing less than a bribe to acquire the accounts of major corporations that are willing to pay excessively high sums to buy Frequent Flyer discount coupons in order to give untaxed rewards to employees. To make the discounted ticket prices viable, airlines raise the initial marked price of the tickets. Thus, the price of tickets for the general public is kept artificially high. Walter Healey, the Vice President of American Airlines, responded to the criticism by saying the Frequent Flyer scheme was enjoyed by millions of Americans who were able to acquire Frequent Flyer tokens from supermarket purchases and credit card transactions.Q. Which of the following, if true, best exposes the flaw in Healeys response to Wileys criticism?a)Only a few supermarket chains and credit card companies offer Frequent Flyer tokens to customers.b)Fewer people acquire Frequent Flyer tokens through supermarket purchases than through credit card transactions.c)Most airline companies offer bonus tokens for long-haul flights.d)The price of tickets booked under Frequent Flyer schemes is often as low as 50% of the regular ticket price.e)Ticket prices are regularly reviewed by a committee of airline representatives.Correct answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer?.
Solutions for The Senator Wiley damned the Frequent Flyer schemes, now operated by virtually all major American airlines, as nothing less than a bribe to acquire the accounts of major corporations that are willing to pay excessively high sums to buy Frequent Flyer discount coupons in order to give untaxed rewards to employees. To make the discounted ticket prices viable, airlines raise the initial marked price of the tickets. Thus, the price of tickets for the general public is kept artificially high. Walter Healey, the Vice President of American Airlines, responded to the criticism by saying the Frequent Flyer scheme was enjoyed by millions of Americans who were able to acquire Frequent Flyer tokens from supermarket purchases and credit card transactions.Q. Which of the following, if true, best exposes the flaw in Healeys response to Wileys criticism?a)Only a few supermarket chains and credit card companies offer Frequent Flyer tokens to customers.b)Fewer people acquire Frequent Flyer tokens through supermarket purchases than through credit card transactions.c)Most airline companies offer bonus tokens for long-haul flights.d)The price of tickets booked under Frequent Flyer schemes is often as low as 50% of the regular ticket price.e)Ticket prices are regularly reviewed by a committee of airline representatives.Correct answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? in English & in Hindi are available as part of our courses for GMAT. Download more important topics, notes, lectures and mock test series for GMAT Exam by signing up for free.
Here you can find the meaning of The Senator Wiley damned the Frequent Flyer schemes, now operated by virtually all major American airlines, as nothing less than a bribe to acquire the accounts of major corporations that are willing to pay excessively high sums to buy Frequent Flyer discount coupons in order to give untaxed rewards to employees. To make the discounted ticket prices viable, airlines raise the initial marked price of the tickets. Thus, the price of tickets for the general public is kept artificially high. Walter Healey, the Vice President of American Airlines, responded to the criticism by saying the Frequent Flyer scheme was enjoyed by millions of Americans who were able to acquire Frequent Flyer tokens from supermarket purchases and credit card transactions.Q. Which of the following, if true, best exposes the flaw in Healeys response to Wileys criticism?a)Only a few supermarket chains and credit card companies offer Frequent Flyer tokens to customers.b)Fewer people acquire Frequent Flyer tokens through supermarket purchases than through credit card transactions.c)Most airline companies offer bonus tokens for long-haul flights.d)The price of tickets booked under Frequent Flyer schemes is often as low as 50% of the regular ticket price.e)Ticket prices are regularly reviewed by a committee of airline representatives.Correct answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? defined & explained in the simplest way possible. Besides giving the explanation of The Senator Wiley damned the Frequent Flyer schemes, now operated by virtually all major American airlines, as nothing less than a bribe to acquire the accounts of major corporations that are willing to pay excessively high sums to buy Frequent Flyer discount coupons in order to give untaxed rewards to employees. To make the discounted ticket prices viable, airlines raise the initial marked price of the tickets. Thus, the price of tickets for the general public is kept artificially high. Walter Healey, the Vice President of American Airlines, responded to the criticism by saying the Frequent Flyer scheme was enjoyed by millions of Americans who were able to acquire Frequent Flyer tokens from supermarket purchases and credit card transactions.Q. Which of the following, if true, best exposes the flaw in Healeys response to Wileys criticism?a)Only a few supermarket chains and credit card companies offer Frequent Flyer tokens to customers.b)Fewer people acquire Frequent Flyer tokens through supermarket purchases than through credit card transactions.c)Most airline companies offer bonus tokens for long-haul flights.d)The price of tickets booked under Frequent Flyer schemes is often as low as 50% of the regular ticket price.e)Ticket prices are regularly reviewed by a committee of airline representatives.Correct answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer?, a detailed solution for The Senator Wiley damned the Frequent Flyer schemes, now operated by virtually all major American airlines, as nothing less than a bribe to acquire the accounts of major corporations that are willing to pay excessively high sums to buy Frequent Flyer discount coupons in order to give untaxed rewards to employees. To make the discounted ticket prices viable, airlines raise the initial marked price of the tickets. Thus, the price of tickets for the general public is kept artificially high. Walter Healey, the Vice President of American Airlines, responded to the criticism by saying the Frequent Flyer scheme was enjoyed by millions of Americans who were able to acquire Frequent Flyer tokens from supermarket purchases and credit card transactions.Q. Which of the following, if true, best exposes the flaw in Healeys response to Wileys criticism?a)Only a few supermarket chains and credit card companies offer Frequent Flyer tokens to customers.b)Fewer people acquire Frequent Flyer tokens through supermarket purchases than through credit card transactions.c)Most airline companies offer bonus tokens for long-haul flights.d)The price of tickets booked under Frequent Flyer schemes is often as low as 50% of the regular ticket price.e)Ticket prices are regularly reviewed by a committee of airline representatives.Correct answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? has been provided alongside types of The Senator Wiley damned the Frequent Flyer schemes, now operated by virtually all major American airlines, as nothing less than a bribe to acquire the accounts of major corporations that are willing to pay excessively high sums to buy Frequent Flyer discount coupons in order to give untaxed rewards to employees. To make the discounted ticket prices viable, airlines raise the initial marked price of the tickets. Thus, the price of tickets for the general public is kept artificially high. Walter Healey, the Vice President of American Airlines, responded to the criticism by saying the Frequent Flyer scheme was enjoyed by millions of Americans who were able to acquire Frequent Flyer tokens from supermarket purchases and credit card transactions.Q. Which of the following, if true, best exposes the flaw in Healeys response to Wileys criticism?a)Only a few supermarket chains and credit card companies offer Frequent Flyer tokens to customers.b)Fewer people acquire Frequent Flyer tokens through supermarket purchases than through credit card transactions.c)Most airline companies offer bonus tokens for long-haul flights.d)The price of tickets booked under Frequent Flyer schemes is often as low as 50% of the regular ticket price.e)Ticket prices are regularly reviewed by a committee of airline representatives.Correct answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? theory, EduRev gives you an ample number of questions to practice The Senator Wiley damned the Frequent Flyer schemes, now operated by virtually all major American airlines, as nothing less than a bribe to acquire the accounts of major corporations that are willing to pay excessively high sums to buy Frequent Flyer discount coupons in order to give untaxed rewards to employees. To make the discounted ticket prices viable, airlines raise the initial marked price of the tickets. Thus, the price of tickets for the general public is kept artificially high. Walter Healey, the Vice President of American Airlines, responded to the criticism by saying the Frequent Flyer scheme was enjoyed by millions of Americans who were able to acquire Frequent Flyer tokens from supermarket purchases and credit card transactions.Q. Which of the following, if true, best exposes the flaw in Healeys response to Wileys criticism?a)Only a few supermarket chains and credit card companies offer Frequent Flyer tokens to customers.b)Fewer people acquire Frequent Flyer tokens through supermarket purchases than through credit card transactions.c)Most airline companies offer bonus tokens for long-haul flights.d)The price of tickets booked under Frequent Flyer schemes is often as low as 50% of the regular ticket price.e)Ticket prices are regularly reviewed by a committee of airline representatives.Correct answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? tests, examples and also practice GMAT tests.
Explore Courses for GMAT exam

Top Courses for GMAT

Explore Courses
Signup for Free!
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days! Learn & Practice with 1000+ FREE Notes, Videos & Tests.
10M+ students study on EduRev