GMAT Exam > GMAT Questions > Eggplants are always purple. John bought a pu...
Start Learning for Free
Eggplants are always purple. John bought a purple vegetable. Therefore, it was an eggplant.
Q. Which of the following arguments contains reasoning most similar to the flawed reasoning in the above argument?
- a)Jenny always eats healthy. Salmon is a healthy food. Therefore, she eats salmon.
- b)Gambling is a risky hobby. Jamie likes taking risks. Therefore, she likes to gamble.
- c)Except for 2, prime numbers are always odd. The number 13 is odd. Therefore, it is prime.
- d)Rabbits are fast creatures. A fast creature ran by. Therefore, it may have been a rabbit.
- e)Bluebirds are not always blue. A brown bird was outside the window. Therefore, it may or may not have been a blue bird.
Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer?
Verified Answer
Eggplants are always purple. John bought a purple vegetable. Therefore...
In this argument, the flaw is framed in the following way:
X is always Y. A is Y. Therefore, A is X.
(Just because X is always Y does NOT mean that Y is always X.)
The flawed argument is therefore most like:
Except for 2, prime numbers are always odd. The number 13 is odd. Therefore, it is prime.
Here
x = prime numbers
Y = odd
A = 13
The structure of this argument is the same as the structure argument in:
Eggplants are always purple. John bought a purple vegetable. Therefore, it was an eggplant.
X= eggplants
Y = purple
A = purple vegetable
Most Upvoted Answer
Eggplants are always purple. John bought a purple vegetable. Therefore...
Similar Reasoning in Flawed Argument:
Flawed Argument:
Eggplants are always purple. John bought a purple vegetable. Therefore, it was an eggplant.
Explanation:
In the flawed argument, the conclusion is drawn based on the assumption that all purple vegetables are eggplants, which is not necessarily true.
Analysis of Options:
a) Jenny always eats healthy. Salmon is a healthy food. Therefore, she eats salmon.
This argument is similar to the flawed reasoning as it assumes that because Jenny always eats healthy, she must be eating salmon. Just like the flawed argument, it makes a generalization based on limited information.
b) Gambling is a risky hobby. Jamie likes taking risks. Therefore, she likes to gamble.
This argument is not as similar to the flawed reasoning as it does not make a generalization based on the characteristics of a single item. It is more about personal preferences rather than categorical statements.
c) Except for 2, prime numbers are always odd. The number 13 is odd. Therefore, it is prime.
This argument contains reasoning most similar to the flawed argument. It assumes that because a number is odd, it must be prime, which is not necessarily true.
d) Rabbits are fast creatures. A fast creature ran by. Therefore, it may have been a rabbit.
This argument is not similar to the flawed reasoning as it does not involve making a generalization based on the characteristics of a single item. It is more about making a guess based on a specific trait.
e) Bluebirds are not always blue. A brown bird was outside the window. Therefore, it may or may not have been a blue bird.
This argument is not similar to the flawed reasoning as it does not involve making a generalization based on the characteristics of a single item. It is more about the variability in the characteristics of a specific item.
Flawed Argument:
Eggplants are always purple. John bought a purple vegetable. Therefore, it was an eggplant.
Explanation:
In the flawed argument, the conclusion is drawn based on the assumption that all purple vegetables are eggplants, which is not necessarily true.
Analysis of Options:
a) Jenny always eats healthy. Salmon is a healthy food. Therefore, she eats salmon.
This argument is similar to the flawed reasoning as it assumes that because Jenny always eats healthy, she must be eating salmon. Just like the flawed argument, it makes a generalization based on limited information.
b) Gambling is a risky hobby. Jamie likes taking risks. Therefore, she likes to gamble.
This argument is not as similar to the flawed reasoning as it does not make a generalization based on the characteristics of a single item. It is more about personal preferences rather than categorical statements.
c) Except for 2, prime numbers are always odd. The number 13 is odd. Therefore, it is prime.
This argument contains reasoning most similar to the flawed argument. It assumes that because a number is odd, it must be prime, which is not necessarily true.
d) Rabbits are fast creatures. A fast creature ran by. Therefore, it may have been a rabbit.
This argument is not similar to the flawed reasoning as it does not involve making a generalization based on the characteristics of a single item. It is more about making a guess based on a specific trait.
e) Bluebirds are not always blue. A brown bird was outside the window. Therefore, it may or may not have been a blue bird.
This argument is not similar to the flawed reasoning as it does not involve making a generalization based on the characteristics of a single item. It is more about the variability in the characteristics of a specific item.
|
Explore Courses for GMAT exam
|
|
Similar GMAT Doubts
Top Courses for GMATView all
Eggplants are always purple. John bought a purple vegetable. Therefore, it was an eggplant.Q. Which of the following arguments contains reasoning most similar to the flawed reasoning in the above argument?a)Jenny always eats healthy. Salmon is a healthy food. Therefore, she eats salmon.b)Gambling is a risky hobby. Jamie likes taking risks. Therefore, she likes to gamble.c)Except for 2, prime numbers are always odd. The number 13 is odd. Therefore, it is prime.d)Rabbits are fast creatures. A fast creature ran by. Therefore, it may have been a rabbit.e)Bluebirds are not always blue. A brown bird was outside the window. Therefore, it may or may not have been a blue bird.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer?
Question Description
Eggplants are always purple. John bought a purple vegetable. Therefore, it was an eggplant.Q. Which of the following arguments contains reasoning most similar to the flawed reasoning in the above argument?a)Jenny always eats healthy. Salmon is a healthy food. Therefore, she eats salmon.b)Gambling is a risky hobby. Jamie likes taking risks. Therefore, she likes to gamble.c)Except for 2, prime numbers are always odd. The number 13 is odd. Therefore, it is prime.d)Rabbits are fast creatures. A fast creature ran by. Therefore, it may have been a rabbit.e)Bluebirds are not always blue. A brown bird was outside the window. Therefore, it may or may not have been a blue bird.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? for GMAT 2025 is part of GMAT preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the GMAT exam syllabus. Information about Eggplants are always purple. John bought a purple vegetable. Therefore, it was an eggplant.Q. Which of the following arguments contains reasoning most similar to the flawed reasoning in the above argument?a)Jenny always eats healthy. Salmon is a healthy food. Therefore, she eats salmon.b)Gambling is a risky hobby. Jamie likes taking risks. Therefore, she likes to gamble.c)Except for 2, prime numbers are always odd. The number 13 is odd. Therefore, it is prime.d)Rabbits are fast creatures. A fast creature ran by. Therefore, it may have been a rabbit.e)Bluebirds are not always blue. A brown bird was outside the window. Therefore, it may or may not have been a blue bird.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? covers all topics & solutions for GMAT 2025 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for Eggplants are always purple. John bought a purple vegetable. Therefore, it was an eggplant.Q. Which of the following arguments contains reasoning most similar to the flawed reasoning in the above argument?a)Jenny always eats healthy. Salmon is a healthy food. Therefore, she eats salmon.b)Gambling is a risky hobby. Jamie likes taking risks. Therefore, she likes to gamble.c)Except for 2, prime numbers are always odd. The number 13 is odd. Therefore, it is prime.d)Rabbits are fast creatures. A fast creature ran by. Therefore, it may have been a rabbit.e)Bluebirds are not always blue. A brown bird was outside the window. Therefore, it may or may not have been a blue bird.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer?.
Eggplants are always purple. John bought a purple vegetable. Therefore, it was an eggplant.Q. Which of the following arguments contains reasoning most similar to the flawed reasoning in the above argument?a)Jenny always eats healthy. Salmon is a healthy food. Therefore, she eats salmon.b)Gambling is a risky hobby. Jamie likes taking risks. Therefore, she likes to gamble.c)Except for 2, prime numbers are always odd. The number 13 is odd. Therefore, it is prime.d)Rabbits are fast creatures. A fast creature ran by. Therefore, it may have been a rabbit.e)Bluebirds are not always blue. A brown bird was outside the window. Therefore, it may or may not have been a blue bird.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? for GMAT 2025 is part of GMAT preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the GMAT exam syllabus. Information about Eggplants are always purple. John bought a purple vegetable. Therefore, it was an eggplant.Q. Which of the following arguments contains reasoning most similar to the flawed reasoning in the above argument?a)Jenny always eats healthy. Salmon is a healthy food. Therefore, she eats salmon.b)Gambling is a risky hobby. Jamie likes taking risks. Therefore, she likes to gamble.c)Except for 2, prime numbers are always odd. The number 13 is odd. Therefore, it is prime.d)Rabbits are fast creatures. A fast creature ran by. Therefore, it may have been a rabbit.e)Bluebirds are not always blue. A brown bird was outside the window. Therefore, it may or may not have been a blue bird.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? covers all topics & solutions for GMAT 2025 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for Eggplants are always purple. John bought a purple vegetable. Therefore, it was an eggplant.Q. Which of the following arguments contains reasoning most similar to the flawed reasoning in the above argument?a)Jenny always eats healthy. Salmon is a healthy food. Therefore, she eats salmon.b)Gambling is a risky hobby. Jamie likes taking risks. Therefore, she likes to gamble.c)Except for 2, prime numbers are always odd. The number 13 is odd. Therefore, it is prime.d)Rabbits are fast creatures. A fast creature ran by. Therefore, it may have been a rabbit.e)Bluebirds are not always blue. A brown bird was outside the window. Therefore, it may or may not have been a blue bird.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer?.
Solutions for Eggplants are always purple. John bought a purple vegetable. Therefore, it was an eggplant.Q. Which of the following arguments contains reasoning most similar to the flawed reasoning in the above argument?a)Jenny always eats healthy. Salmon is a healthy food. Therefore, she eats salmon.b)Gambling is a risky hobby. Jamie likes taking risks. Therefore, she likes to gamble.c)Except for 2, prime numbers are always odd. The number 13 is odd. Therefore, it is prime.d)Rabbits are fast creatures. A fast creature ran by. Therefore, it may have been a rabbit.e)Bluebirds are not always blue. A brown bird was outside the window. Therefore, it may or may not have been a blue bird.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? in English & in Hindi are available as part of our courses for GMAT.
Download more important topics, notes, lectures and mock test series for GMAT Exam by signing up for free.
Here you can find the meaning of Eggplants are always purple. John bought a purple vegetable. Therefore, it was an eggplant.Q. Which of the following arguments contains reasoning most similar to the flawed reasoning in the above argument?a)Jenny always eats healthy. Salmon is a healthy food. Therefore, she eats salmon.b)Gambling is a risky hobby. Jamie likes taking risks. Therefore, she likes to gamble.c)Except for 2, prime numbers are always odd. The number 13 is odd. Therefore, it is prime.d)Rabbits are fast creatures. A fast creature ran by. Therefore, it may have been a rabbit.e)Bluebirds are not always blue. A brown bird was outside the window. Therefore, it may or may not have been a blue bird.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? defined & explained in the simplest way possible. Besides giving the explanation of
Eggplants are always purple. John bought a purple vegetable. Therefore, it was an eggplant.Q. Which of the following arguments contains reasoning most similar to the flawed reasoning in the above argument?a)Jenny always eats healthy. Salmon is a healthy food. Therefore, she eats salmon.b)Gambling is a risky hobby. Jamie likes taking risks. Therefore, she likes to gamble.c)Except for 2, prime numbers are always odd. The number 13 is odd. Therefore, it is prime.d)Rabbits are fast creatures. A fast creature ran by. Therefore, it may have been a rabbit.e)Bluebirds are not always blue. A brown bird was outside the window. Therefore, it may or may not have been a blue bird.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer?, a detailed solution for Eggplants are always purple. John bought a purple vegetable. Therefore, it was an eggplant.Q. Which of the following arguments contains reasoning most similar to the flawed reasoning in the above argument?a)Jenny always eats healthy. Salmon is a healthy food. Therefore, she eats salmon.b)Gambling is a risky hobby. Jamie likes taking risks. Therefore, she likes to gamble.c)Except for 2, prime numbers are always odd. The number 13 is odd. Therefore, it is prime.d)Rabbits are fast creatures. A fast creature ran by. Therefore, it may have been a rabbit.e)Bluebirds are not always blue. A brown bird was outside the window. Therefore, it may or may not have been a blue bird.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? has been provided alongside types of Eggplants are always purple. John bought a purple vegetable. Therefore, it was an eggplant.Q. Which of the following arguments contains reasoning most similar to the flawed reasoning in the above argument?a)Jenny always eats healthy. Salmon is a healthy food. Therefore, she eats salmon.b)Gambling is a risky hobby. Jamie likes taking risks. Therefore, she likes to gamble.c)Except for 2, prime numbers are always odd. The number 13 is odd. Therefore, it is prime.d)Rabbits are fast creatures. A fast creature ran by. Therefore, it may have been a rabbit.e)Bluebirds are not always blue. A brown bird was outside the window. Therefore, it may or may not have been a blue bird.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? theory, EduRev gives you an
ample number of questions to practice Eggplants are always purple. John bought a purple vegetable. Therefore, it was an eggplant.Q. Which of the following arguments contains reasoning most similar to the flawed reasoning in the above argument?a)Jenny always eats healthy. Salmon is a healthy food. Therefore, she eats salmon.b)Gambling is a risky hobby. Jamie likes taking risks. Therefore, she likes to gamble.c)Except for 2, prime numbers are always odd. The number 13 is odd. Therefore, it is prime.d)Rabbits are fast creatures. A fast creature ran by. Therefore, it may have been a rabbit.e)Bluebirds are not always blue. A brown bird was outside the window. Therefore, it may or may not have been a blue bird.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? tests, examples and also practice GMAT tests.
|
|
Explore Courses for GMAT exam
|
|
Signup for Free!
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days! Learn & Practice with 1000+ FREE Notes, Videos & Tests.
|
© EduRev
|
Education Revolution
|
|
Signup to see your scores
go up within 7 days!
Access 1000+ FREE Docs, Videos and Tests
Takes less than 10 seconds to signup