The model of secularism followed in USA is different from the model of...
The following points explain why option A is the correct answer:
- In the USA, the government is strictly prohibited from interfering in religious matters, and there is a clear separation of church and state.
- On the other hand, in India, the government has the power to regulate religious institutions and can interfere in their affairs if deemed necessary.
- In the USA, religious establishments are given more autonomy and are free to operate independently.
- In contrast, in India, religious institutions are subject to government regulations and control, and their autonomy is limited.
- In the USA, there is no official state religion, and all religions are recognized equally.
The model of secularism followed in USA is different from the model of...
Differences in Secularism: USA vs. India
Secularism in the USA and India reflects distinct historical, cultural, and political contexts, particularly in terms of the degree of interference in religious affairs.
Degree of Interference in Religious Affairs
- In the USA, secularism is characterized by a strict separation between church and state. The First Amendment of the Constitution prohibits the government from establishing a religion or interfering in religious practices. This means that religious institutions operate independently without government intervention.
- In India, secularism allows for a more nuanced relationship between the state and religion. The Indian Constitution recognizes the role of religion in public life and permits the state to intervene in religious affairs, especially when it comes to ensuring social justice and protecting the rights of minorities. For example, laws governing marriage, inheritance, and religious practices may reflect intervention aimed at promoting equality and preventing discrimination.
Implications of This Difference
- The USA's approach fosters a neutral public sphere where religious beliefs are kept out of government policy, aiming to protect individual freedoms and prevent any form of religious dominance.
- In contrast, India's model acknowledges the pluralistic nature of its society, allowing the state to engage with religious communities to uphold democratic values and social harmony.
Conclusion
These differences illustrate how secularism adapts to the specific needs and historical contexts of a nation. In the USA, secularism emphasizes non-interference, while in India, it involves a degree of state engagement to protect minority rights and promote equality.
To make sure you are not studying endlessly, EduRev has designed UGC NET study material, with Structured Courses, Videos, & Test Series. Plus get personalized analysis, doubt solving and improvement plans to achieve a great score in UGC NET.