Power leads to dominance and reaches oppression and ends up in rebelli...
The lesson details a good account of two different girls living at distant places. Zitkala Sa is a native American. She is taken away from her mother forcibly because the white people want the native Indians to adopt their culture. Zitkala revolts the way the Indian girls were forced to wear dresses in an immodest way.
She was much perturbed that the brave shingled the long hair of the girls. According to her culture only the mourners or cowardice wear shingled hair. But she could do nothing when they took her bravely, tied in a chair and cut off her hair. But her spirit could not be suppressed.
On the other hand, Bama was a low-caste girl. She saw the upper caste people showing discrimination against the low caste people. They could not touch food and other items of the upper caste people. They had to work for them and bow their heads. Her spirit too revolted against this injustice. She could not understand this human treatment since all are human beings. She wanted honour for all. Her brother Annan told her that she could do away with these indignities if she worked hard. Bama studied hard and stood first in her class. Many people became her friends.
This question is part of UPSC exam. View all Class 12 courses
Power leads to dominance and reaches oppression and ends up in rebelli...
Introduction:
The statement that power leads to dominance, oppression, rebellion, and failure holds true in the case of the rebellion raised by Zitkala Sa. Zitkala Sa was a Native American woman who fought against the oppressive policies and assimilation efforts of the American government towards Native American children in the late 19th and early 20th centuries.
Power Leads to Dominance:
Zitkala Sa's rebellion was fueled by the power imbalance between the American government and Native American communities. The government had the power to enforce policies that aimed to assimilate Native American children into mainstream American society by separating them from their families and cultural heritage. This power gave the government dominance over the lives of Native American children.
Dominance Leads to Oppression:
The dominance exerted by the American government led to the oppression of Native American children, including Zitkala Sa. She was forcibly taken from her family and sent to a boarding school where she was prohibited from speaking her native language, practicing her cultural traditions, and was subjected to harsh discipline and cultural erasure. This oppression aimed to assimilate Native American children into the dominant American culture.
Oppression Leads to Rebellion:
The oppressive conditions faced by Zitkala Sa and other Native American children eventually led to rebellion. Zitkala Sa defied the school's rules by secretly practicing her native traditions, organizing resistance among her peers, and expressing her opposition through her writings. She understood that rebellion was necessary to preserve her identity and fight against the oppressive assimilation efforts.
Rebellion Ends in Failure:
Despite Zitkala Sa's courageous rebellion, it ultimately ended in failure. The American government's power and dominance were too strong to overcome. Zitkala Sa's efforts to resist assimilation were met with punishment and further oppression. The boarding school system continued to operate, and Native American children continued to suffer the loss of their cultural identity.
Conclusion:
In the case of Zitkala Sa's rebellion, the statement that power leads to dominance, oppression, rebellion, and failure is true. The American government's power and dominance over Native American communities led to the oppression of Native American children, which in turn fueled rebellion. However, despite their brave resistance, the rebellion ultimately failed to overturn the oppressive assimilation policies. This serves as a poignant example of how power can perpetuate a cycle of dominance, oppression, rebellion, and ultimately, failure.