Movable and Immovable Property | Civil Law for Judiciary Exams PDF Download

Property

• Property encompasses all rights held by individuals, with the exception of personal rights that define their status.
• The concept of property, as clarified in the Raichand v. Dattarya case, is adaptable and subject to change.
• To make decisions about property clearer, it is first divided into movable and immovable categories, each regulated by its own specific laws.
  

Definition of Movable Property

• Movable property is defined in Section 3 (36) of the General Clauses Act as property that can be moved, excluding immovable property.
• Under Section 2 (9) of the Registration Act, 1908, movable property includes standing timber, growing crops, grass, fruits, and other properties that are not immovable.
• Crops such as vegetables and fruits, which need to be harvested, are considered movable. Timber is also seen as movable once it is cut from the land, while fruit-bearing trees are regarded as immovable until they are harvested.
• Section 22 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) defines movable property as all tangible property except land and items permanently attached to it. Items fixed to the land can become movable if they are detached.
• The Transfer of Property Act does not provide a specific definition of movable property, as it primarily focuses on the transfer of immovable property through various means such as sale, mortgage, lease, gifts, or claims.

Legal Definitions of Movable Property in India

• General Clauses Act, 1897 (Section 3(36)): Movable property includes all property that is not classified as immovable property.
• Registration Act, 1908 (Section 2(9)): Movable property consists of all assets that are not immovable, including standing timber, growing crops, and grass.
• Indian Penal Code, 1860 (Section 22): Movable property refers to corporeal assets that can be seen and touched – such as money, machinery, and buildings – provided they are not attached to the land.
• Sales of Goods Act, 1930 (Section 2(7)): Movable property includes stock, shares, crops, and grass, as well as things attached to the land that can be severed. However, it does not include actionable claims or money.
• Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (Section 3): Movable property includes standing timber, growing crops, or grass – as these are not considered part of immovable property.

Key Characteristics of Movable Property

• Tangible and Transportable:  Movable property consists of items that can be owned and easily relocated from one place to another without losing their functionality.
• Not Fixed to Land: These items are not permanently attached to the land and do not become an integral part of any land or building.
• Transfer of Ownership is Simpler: Transferring ownership of movable property, whether through buying, selling, or inheriting, involves fewer legal procedures compared to immovable property.
• Variety of Assets Included: Movable property encompasses a wide range of items such as stocks, shares, machinery, vehicles, furniture, jewellery, and cash.
• Regulated by Various Laws: Different laws in India, including the Sales of Goods Act, 1930, and the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, define and govern movable property.

Definition of Immovable Property

Immovable property refers to assets that are fixed in place and cannot be relocated. This category includes land, buildings, and any permanent structures that are attached to the land. Unlike movable property, such as furniture or vehicles, which can be easily transported, immovable property is integral to its location.

Examples of Immovable Property:

• Land: This encompasses any area of ground, regardless of whether it is developed or undeveloped.
• Buildings and Houses: This includes all types of structures situated on the land, whether they are residential, commercial, or industrial in nature.
• Trees and Plants: These are considered immovable property when they are permanently fixed to the ground, such as fruit-bearing trees in an orchard.
• Fixtures: This refers to items that are permanently attached to a property, such as wells, fences, or underground pipelines.

Legal Definitions of Immovable Property in India

• General Clauses Act, 1897 (Section 3(26)): Immovable property includes land, benefits arising from it, and objects attached to the earth that cannot be severed
• Registration Act, 1908 (Section 2(6)): Immovable property refers to assets permanently fastened to the earth – such as land, lights, ferries, and fisheries. However, it excludes standing timber, growing crops, and grass.
• Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (Section 3): Immovable property does not include standing timber, growing crops, or grass, distinguishing it from movable assets

Key Characteristics of Immovable Property

• Permanently Attached to Land: Immovable properties are things like land, buildings, and structures that are fixed to the land and can’t be moved without causing damage. 
• Long-term Asset: These properties are strong and durable, usually becoming more valuable over time. They play a crucial role in building wealth. 
• Restricted Transferability: Transferring ownership of immovable assets is different from movable ones. It requires legal paperwork, registration, and approvals from the government. 
• Benefits Arising from Land: Rights associated with land, such as leases, easements, and natural resources like minerals or water bodies, are part of immovable property. 
• Governed by Multiple Laws: Immovable property in India is regulated by various laws, including the General Clauses Act of 1897, the Registration Act of 1908, and the Transfer of Property Act of 1882. 

Key Difference Between Movable and Immovable Property

Understanding the difference between these types is essential for legal compliance, taxation, and financial planning. This classification determines ownership rights, transfer processes, taxation structures, and legal obligations – making it an essential consideration for buyers, sellers, and investors.

Important Case Laws dealing with Movable and Immovable Property

The distinction between movable and immovable property is not always clear-cut, leading to various legal interpretations.

• Smt. Shantabai v. State of Bombay: The court ruled that the right to enter land, cut wood, and extract resources for a specific period constitutes an interest arising from land, thus categorizing it as immovable property.
• Anand Bahera v. Province of Orissa: It was determined that profits derived directly from the land are considered movable property. For example, the right to fish in a lake and graze cattle on land are deemed immovable property due to their direct connection to the land.
• Idea of Annexation: This concept plays a crucial role in distinguishing between movable and immovable property. If an item is affixed to the land in a way that removing it would cause damage, it is considered immovable property. Intent and permanence of attachment are key factors.
• Bamdev v. Manorma: Equipment, even if fixed in the ground, may still be classified as movable property if it is intended for temporary use and enjoyment rather than as a permanent fixture of the land.
• Duncans Industries Ltd. v. State of UP: The intention of the owner regarding the permanence of equipment fixation determines whether it is movable or immovable property. In this case, the equipment was considered immovable due to its long-term installation and integration with the land.
• Judicially Recognized Properties: Certain properties have been judicially recognized as either movable or immovable, such as the right to collect rent, hereditary offices, buildings, and interests in immovable property.
• Classification and Importance: The distinction between movable and immovable property holds significant legal weight, impacting ownership rights, transactions, and individual status.

Conclusion