The Hindu Editorial Analysis- 26th August 2023 | Current Affairs & Hindu Analysis: Daily, Weekly & Monthly - UPSC PDF Download

Concrete alliance

Why in News?

Prime Minister Narendra Modi called for the expansion of the five-nation grouping while addressing the opening plenary session of the 15th BRICS summit in Johannesburg.

Background

• The predecessor of BRICS (Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa) was BRIC (Brazil, Russia, India, and China) established by Goldman Sachs in 2006.
• BRIC was the acronym for the four countries, which were deemed to be at a similar stage of newly advanced economic development. Behind BRIC was the idea that China and India will, by 2050, be the world’s dominant suppliers of manufactured goods, while Brazil and Russia will become dominant as suppliers of raw materials.
• With the induction of South Africa in December 2010, BRIC became BRICS whose original aim was the establishment of an equitable, democratic and multi-polar world order.
• The BRICS mechanism aims to promote peace, security, development and cooperation. It also aims at contributing significantly to the development of humanity and establishing a more equitable and fairer world.
• Despite the five members’ divergent economic trajectories in the years since—with China and India having grown impressively while the other three saw weak growth—the BRICS group has made significant progress.
• Together, BRICS countries have 3.24 billion inhabitants—or 41 percent of the world population—and a combined gross domestic product (GDP) of $26 trillion, or 60 percent of the G7 countries’ combined GDP. However, on a purchasing power parity basis, BRICS countries’ GDP accounts for 5 percent of the global economy, overtaking the G7 share of 30.4 percent. Despite this, BRICS countries get only 15 percent of the voting power at the International Monetary Fund—a source of developing countries’ discontent over the governance of international financial institutions.
• The group’s achievements include the establishment of the New Development Bank (NDB) in 2015 with a total capital of $100 billion and paid-up capital of $50 billion equally subscribed by the five members. The bank funds sustainable development and infrastructure projects in member countries; NDB-funded projects in India include the Mumbai Metro rail, the Delhi-Meerut Regional Rapid Transit System and a number of renewable energy projects.

15th BRICS Summit

• The 2023 BRICS summit is the fifteenth ongoing annual BRICS summit, an international relations conference attended by the heads of state or heads of government of the five member states: Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa.
• South African President Cyril Ramaphosa also invited the leaders of 67 countries to the summit, including 53 other African Countries, Bangladesh, Bolivia, Indonesia and Iran.
• Discussions focus on spheres of political and socioeconomic coordination, in which member countries have identified business opportunities, economic complementarities, and areas of cooperation.
• As the Chair of BRICS, South Africa is focusing on the theme, ‘BRICS and Africa: Partnership for Mutually Accelerated Growth, Sustainable Development, and Inclusive Multilateralism’.
• This theme informs South Africa’s five priorities for 2023:
  • Developing a partnership towards an equitable just transition,
  • Including managing the risks associated with climate change;
  • Transforming education and skills development for the future;
  • Unlocking opportunities through the African continental free trade area;
  • Strengthening post-pandemic socioeconomic recovery and the attainment of the 2030 agenda on sustainable development; and strengthening multilateralism, including reform of global governance institutions and strengthening the meaningful participation of women in peace processes.

BRICS EXPANSION

• The BRICS brings together five of the largest developing countries in the world—Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa and represents 41 percent of the global population, 24 percent of the global GDP and 16 percent of the global trade.
• Several countries, including Argentina, Egypt, Indonesia, the UAE, Saudi Arabia, and others, are willing to join the bloc.

The proposition

• BRICS is considering expanding its membership, and a growing number of countries, mostly from the global South, have expressed interest in joining.
• Several countries including the United Arab Emirates, Saudi Arabia, Argentina, Iran, Egypt, Bahrain, Indonesia, and Kazakhstan have shown their willingness to join the BRICS.
• As per reports, more than 40 nations have indicated an interest in joining the bloc of major developing economies.
• Earlier in June, representatives from Iran, Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Cuba, the Democratic Republic of Congo, Comoros, Gabon, and Kazakhstan attended a meeting in Cape Town for so-called “Friends of BRICS” talks. Egypt, Argentina, Bangladesh, Guinea-Bissau, and Indonesia participated virtually.

The Need for Expansion

• An expansion of the BRICS bloc is under consideration since potential candidates - from Iran to Argentina – see one thing in common: a desire to level a global playing field. This is lacking because of the wealthy West's domination of international bodies, such as the United Nations, the International Monetary Fund or the World Bank. The list of grievances is long. Abusive trade practices. Punishing sanctions regimes. Perceived neglect of the development needs of poorer nations.
• Amid widespread dissatisfaction with the prevailing world order, the pledge of BRICS nations - currently Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa - to make the grouping a leading champion of the "Global South" has, found resonance.

Benefits of the BRICS Expansion plan and launching of BRICS currency

• Here are some of the benefits of the BRICS Expansion plan and launching of BRICS currency:

• The BRICS countries are working together to increase their economic cooperation.
• This could lead to increased trade, investment, and development.

• The BRICS countries are trying to reduce their reliance on the US dollar.
• This could give them more control over their own economies and reduce their vulnerability to US economic policies.

• The BRICS countries are working to increase their influence in the global economy. This could lead to increased trade, investment, and development for these countries.
• When we look at the broader aspect the BRICS Expansion plan and launching of a common currency are ambitious projects. However, they could have a significant impact on the global economy.
• If successful, these projects could lead to increased economic cooperation, reduced reliance on the US dollar, and increased influence for the BRICS countries in the global economy.

Benefits specific to India

• India is currently heavily dependent on the US dollar for its foreign trade and currency reserves.
• This makes India vulnerable to fluctuations in the value of the dollar, which can have a negative impact on India's economy.
• A BRICS currency would provide India with an alternative to the dollar, which would reduce its dependence on the US and make its economy more stable.

• A BRICS currency would make it easier for India to trade with other BRICS countries.
• This could lead to increased trade and investment between India and other BRICS countries, which would boost India's economy.

• The US has a history of using its financial power to exert political pressure on other countries.
• For example, the US has imposed sanctions on countries that do not cooperate with its sanctions on Iran.
• A BRICS currency would reduce India's vulnerability to this type of political pressure from the US.
• Overall, the expansion of BRICS and the launch of a new BRICS currency could have a number of positive benefits for India. These benefits include reduced dependence on the US dollar, increased trade and investment, and reduced political pressure from the US.

Challenges

• BRICS aspirants Argentina and Egypt, to name just two, are also members of the infamous “Coffee Club” (United for Consensus) —opposed to India’s membership in the UNSC. They also get a lot of support from China.
• China is looking at the potential expansion primarily through the lens of expanding its sphere of influence.
• China has been trying since 2017 to expand the group by including other countries to constitute a BRICS Plus framework. Its main motivation seems to be the transformation of BRICS into a China-centric bloc, entrap the new members with loans under its Belt and Road Initiative, export manufactured goods for which its markets in the West are contracting and demonstrate to the West that it is a leader of the Global South. China perceives that the economic performance of Brazil, Russia and South Africa has deteriorated; Russia is besieged by the Ukraine war; India is getting closer to the US-led groupings; and unless the BRICS expands with the inclusion of big developing countries, its global influence will wane.
• With the SCO and BRICS, China dominates the two most prominent “alternate” groupings — neither of which includes the US.
• The BRICS is a relatively young group; there are wide disparities in size, outlook and perceptions of its members about a multipolar world and restructuring of the global organs of power. The group has so far taken a non-confrontational stance and stayed away from the rivalry between the West and the China-Russia-Iran axis. Making the group too big would make decision-making more complicated and time-consuming.