Notes: Identifying and Addressing the Talented | Child Development and Pedagogy for CTET Preparation - CTET & State TET PDF Download

A classroom comprises a variety of students, including the intelligent, slackers, talented, and gifted. To maintain a cohesive and effective classroom environment, a teacher must design their teaching methodology to address the specific needs of each type of learner. This approach incorporates sound teacher-education principles, highlighting their essential role in the teaching-learning process.

Specially-Abled Learners

Gifted and talented children, also known as specially-abled learners, represent a unique challenge in educational settings. Traditionally, classrooms have favored a one-size-fits-all approach, where all students receive the same instruction and assignments simultaneously. However, as classrooms become more diverse and inclusive, this method becomes less effective.

It is essential to differentiate instruction not only for learning disabled students but also for specially-abled learners. These students require identification and specialized pedagogical strategies to ensure their development proceeds optimally.

Understanding Specially-Abled Learners

In the past, gifted, talented, or creative children were primarily associated with high IQ. It was believed that these students were born with innate intelligence, identifiable by high grades and test scores, and capable of excelling universally. This viewpoint is evolving with the acceptance of Gardner’s theory of multiple intelligences.

According to this theory, there are various forms of giftedness beyond traditional measures. Teachers recognize that students can be 'smart' in different ways, not just through logical-mathematical and linguistic intelligence.

Historically, IQ tests and other standardized assessments focused on specific intelligences. However, educational practices are changing to incorporate all eight of Gardner’s intelligences into teaching methodologies.

Therefore, schools must become more discerning in identifying individual abilities and strengths, rather than assigning a general 'gifted' or 'talented' label.

Identifying Gifted and Talented Learners

To effectively meet the needs of gifted and talented learners, it is crucial to identify them by understanding their unique characteristics. Teacher observations often provide the best insights into identifying high-ability students. It's important to note that students gifted in Mathematics and/or Science may not excel in other subjects like music or art, which may affect their formal identification as gifted. Below are some indicators of mathematical and scientific giftedness:

Indicators of Mathematical Giftedness

• Unusual curiosity about numbers and mathematical information
• Ability to understand and apply ideas quickly
• High ability to see patterns and think abstractly
• Use of flexible and creative strategies and solutions
• Use of analytical, deductive, and inductive reasoning

Indicators of Scientific Giftedness

• Strong curiosity about objects and environments
• High interest in investigating scientific phenomena
• Tendency to make observations and ask questions
• Interest in collecting, sorting, and classifying objects
• Unusual ability to generate creative and valid explanations

Gifted and talented children typically have IQ levels ranging from 130 up to 200. They are classified into different levels of giftedness by various educational psychologists:

• Moderately gifted — IQ 130 – 144
• Highly gifted — IQ 145 – 159
• Exceptionally gifted — IQ 160 – 179
• Profoundly gifted — IQ 180+

Characteristics of Creative Learners

When suggesting activities for creative learners, teachers can make these activities more engaging by observing the following typical characteristics, as suggested by educational psychologist E.P. Torrance, and providing opportunities that align with each characteristic:

1. Fluency: The ability to produce a number of different ideas. Teachers can promote fluency by asking open-ended questions and encouraging exploration and experimentation.
2. Flexibility: The ability to approach situations and develop solutions from different perspectives. Teachers can foster flexibility by allowing learners to experiment and make mistakes, encouraging them to think 'out-of-the-box'.
3. Originality: The ability to have new or novel ideas. Teachers can promote originality by providing a variety of materials and experiences that stimulate children's imaginations and creativity.
4. Elaboration: The ability to extend ideas. Teachers can encourage elaboration by offering new ways of doing familiar activities, such as providing materials for children to use during play.

Understanding Giftedness and Talent

According to educational psychologists, 'giftedness' and 'talent' have distinct meanings. Gagne (1992) differentiates them in his Differentiating Model of Giftedness and Talent (DMGT). He defines giftedness as the possession and use of untrained and spontaneously expressed natural abilities (aptitudes or gifts) in at least one domain to a degree that places an individual among the top 10% of age peers.

To identify gifted students effectively, teachers and schools should utilize multiple sources of data beyond grades and test scores:

• Teacher Observations: Teachers who build relationships with their students can identify high-ability students more accurately.
• Interviews with Students: Trained educational psychologists can identify gifted learners through direct interviews.
• Information from Parents: Parents often observe talents or giftedness in their children at home, which can inform identification.
• Portfolios of Student Work: These are particularly useful for identifying creative learners.

Addressing Specially Abled Learners in an Inclusive Classroom

Research indicates that learning is most effective when students' abilities and interests are stimulated by suitable challenges. This poses challenges for gifted students in inclusive classrooms where learners of all ability levels are present. Traditional curricula in Mathematics and Science, for instance, often lack depth and challenge for gifted students.

An effective strategy to engage such students is 'ability grouping':

Ability Grouping

• Heterogeneous Group: Groups of students with varied intellectual levels and interests, including gifted or talented children, are mixed together.
• Homogeneous Group: Groups of students with similar intellectual levels, including all gifted or talented children in a particular domain, are grouped together.

Sometimes, gifted students benefit from working with peers of similar abilities for challenges and extended learning opportunities. However, they also need to work in heterogeneous groups to learn from classmates and deepen their understanding by explaining concepts.

Pedagogy Strategies

An effective pedagogical approach to address gifted, talented, and creative learners in an inclusive classroom is Differentiated Instruction:

• Differentiated Instruction: This approach guides teachers in continuously learning about students' needs and interests, and using that knowledge to adjust content presentation and activities accordingly.

It's important to note that Differentiated Instruction does not mean grading gifted students harder or giving them extra work. Rather, it involves:

• Adapting content presentation and activities based on student knowledge.
• Allowing students to choose how they demonstrate their learning within given parameters.

Changing the Learning Environment

To support effective learning, the classroom environment can be adjusted by:

• Using activities that students can complete independently, such as journal entries or portfolio work.
• Involving students in creating classroom procedures and rules, which helps develop decision-making and planning skills.
• Creating assignment cards or other visual aids to support students in understanding and following instructions.

Differentiating Content

Various approaches are suggested for addressing the needs of gifted learners:

• Organizing the curriculum around major themes and ideas, increasing the abstractness and complexity of content, especially in Mathematics and Science.
• Adding variety to the content to keep it engaging and challenging.
• Providing advanced materials such as trade books, textbooks from higher classes, and other resources available in the school library.
• Designing content aligned with the higher levels of Bloom’s Taxonomy—analysis, synthesis, and evaluation—to enable deeper and more challenging learning.

Differentiating Processes

Common methods for engaging gifted and creative learners involve:

• Self-directed learning, where learners:
• 
  
  • Make decisions based on self-knowledge.
  • Take responsibility for completing work on time and at a high level.
  • Identify and articulate problems, then determine methods to solve them.
  • Evaluate their own work critically.
• Development through:
• 
  
  • Orientation to understand their abilities, skills, interests, and learning styles.
  • Enrichment activities involving a wide range of content areas, cultural activities, and field trips.
  • Seminars exploring topics of interest in small groups.
  • Individual development in problem-solving skills, goal setting, creativity, self-assessment, career knowledge, and interpersonal skills.

Differentiating Products

Gifted, talented, and creative learners should be encouraged to create complex products similar to those made by professionals:

• Products that require learners to stretch their abilities, extend their knowledge, and provide authentic and challenging learning experiences.
• For example, concluding a Science unit by creating a publication-ready 'product'—such as news articles, technical reports, letters, or drawings based on their inquiry findings—that requires them to transform information.
• Learners should collaborate with the teacher to develop criteria for assessing their work, as well as find and correct mistakes and verify their methods.