UPSC Exam  >  UPSC Notes  >  History Optional for UPSC (Notes)  >  Political System of Harappa Civilization

Political System of Harappa Civilization | History Optional for UPSC (Notes) PDF Download

Introduction

Mortimer Wheeler characterized the Harappan civilization as "the most extensive political experiment before the Roman Empire." However, the specifics of this experiment are still uncertain and open to interpretation.

Warfare and Conflict

Compared to contemporary Mesopotamia and Egypt, the Harappan civilization appears to have weaker elements of warfare, conflict, and force.

  • Weapons are not prominently featured in the artifacts discovered at Harappan sites.
  • There are limited representations of conflict in the narrative reliefs on terracotta and faience tablets.

However, fortifications, particularly the impressive ones at sites like Dholavira, cannot be ignored.

Political Stability

  • The fact that the Harappan civilization endured for around 700 years with relatively unchanged artifacts, traditions, and symbols suggests a strong degree of political stability.
  • It is likely that various cities had groups of rulers responsible for maintaining city facilities such as walls, roads, drains, and public buildings.

Debate on Political System

  • Scholars debate the nature of the Harappan political system, focusing on whether a state existed and if so, what kind of state it was.
  • Views range from a centralized empire to a merchant oligarchy or a network of city-states.

Political System of Harappa Civilization | History Optional for UPSC (Notes)

Question for Political System of Harappa Civilization
Try yourself:
What is one of the factors that suggest a strong degree of political stability in the Harappan civilization?
View Solution

Different Views Regarding Harappan Political System

A Centralized Empire Ruled by Autocratic Priest-Kings

  • Representative Historians: Stuart Piggott and Mortimer Wheeler.

Arguments for this view:

  • Piggott (1950) proposed that the Harappan state was a centralized empire governed by priest-kings from the twin capitals of Mohenjodaro and Harappa.
  • This view was supported by features such as uniformity in material traits, a common script, standardized weights and measures, urban planning, and monumental public works.
  • The granaries at Mohenjodaro and Harappa were seen as evidence of the rulers' control over grain storage for times of scarcity.
  • Urban planning and public works implied the mobilization of a specialized labor force.
  • The lack of warfare between settlements suggested unity under a single rule.

Arguments Against This View

  • Walter A. Fairservis contended that the Harappans did not have an empire or even a state.
  • He pointed out the absence of evidence for priest-kings, slaves, standing armies, or court officials.
  • Fairservis argued that Mohenjodaro was a ceremonial center, not an administrative one.

Note: In ancient Mesopotamia and Egypt, rulers are depicted extensively in art and their power is proclaimed through monumental architecture. In contrast, the Harappan case is different. The stone bust labeled 'priest king' from Mohenjodaro and the damaged seated figure from Dholavira do not provide clear evidence of priest-kings. Large houses in Harappan sites do not match the idea of palaces, although some buildings on citadels might have served a similar function.

An Elaborate Village Administration

  • Representative Historian: Walter A. Fairservis.
  • Fairservis argued for the existence of an elaborate village administration in the Harappan civilization.
  • He acknowledged some degree of centralized control and class structure but emphasized that interdependence, religion, and tradition were the main regulators of social behavior.

Chiefdom State

  • Malik suggested that the Harappan polity was at the chiefdom stage, transitional between kinship society and civil state society, arguing against the idea of a strong, centralized state.

Recent Writings

  • Shereen F. Ratnagar(1991) suggested that the Harappan civilization was an empire based on archaeological evidence and cross-cultural parallels with early state societies.
  • Jim Shaffer(1982) viewed the civilization as a chiefdom with a well-established trade network, emphasizing the absence of royal tombs, palaces, and significant social differentiation seen in ancient Egypt and Mesopotamia.
  • Jacobson(1986) proposed that the Harappan state was early, characterized by a benevolent sovereign, a military component, and weak economic stratification.
  • G. L. Possehl(2003) emphasized the corporate character of Harappan society, suggesting governance by councils rather than kings.
  • J. M. Kenoyer(1998) proposed that the Harappan state comprised competing urban elites with different levels of control, with clan symbols represented by animals on seals.

Question for Political System of Harappa Civilization
Try yourself:
According to the different views on the Harappan political system, which historian proposed the idea of an elaborate village administration?
View Solution

Conclusion

  • While the Harappan civilization lacked the social and economic disparities seen in Egypt and Mesopotamia, it likely had a state structure, evidenced by communication systems, artifact standardization, labor mobilization for public works, and cultural homogeneity.
  • The civilization exhibited centralized control, though the nature of this centralization and the existence of an empire or interconnected states remain to be conclusively determined.
The document Political System of Harappa Civilization | History Optional for UPSC (Notes) is a part of the UPSC Course History Optional for UPSC (Notes).
All you need of UPSC at this link: UPSC
70 videos|815 docs

Top Courses for UPSC

FAQs on Political System of Harappa Civilization - History Optional for UPSC (Notes)

1. What were the key features of the Harappan political system?
Ans. The Harappan political system is believed to have been a form of urban governance characterized by centralized decision-making, with authority likely held by a ruling elite or a council. Archaeological evidence suggests that cities were well-planned with advanced drainage systems and standardized weights and measures, indicating a level of administrative control.
2. How did warfare and conflict influence the Harappan civilization?
Ans. Warfare and conflict may have impacted the Harappan civilization through resource competition, territorial disputes, and the defense of urban centers. Evidence of fortifications in some cities suggests a need for protection, although the extent of warfare remains debated among scholars, with some suggesting a relatively peaceful society.
3. What are the different views regarding the political organization of the Harappan society?
Ans. Scholars have proposed various theories about the Harappan political organization, ranging from a theocratic system led by priest-kings to more egalitarian structures. Some suggest a decentralized system with local leaders, while others advocate for a more centralized power structure based on archaeological findings of large public buildings and urban planning.
4. What recent writings have emerged regarding Harappan civilization's political system?
Ans. Recent writings increasingly emphasize interdisciplinary approaches, combining archaeology, anthropology, and historical analysis to understand the Harappan political system. Scholars have explored the role of trade, social stratification, and the impact of environmental changes, leading to new interpretations of the civilization's governance and social hierarchy.
5. How does the study of Harappan civilization contribute to our understanding of ancient political systems?
Ans. The study of the Harappan civilization provides insights into the complexity of ancient political systems, showcasing how urbanization, trade, and social organization can influence governance. It challenges traditional narratives of political development by highlighting the potential for advanced administrative practices in early societies, even in the absence of written records.
70 videos|815 docs
Download as PDF
Explore Courses for UPSC exam

Top Courses for UPSC

Signup for Free!
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days! Learn & Practice with 1000+ FREE Notes, Videos & Tests.
10M+ students study on EduRev
Related Searches

study material

,

practice quizzes

,

Political System of Harappa Civilization | History Optional for UPSC (Notes)

,

Semester Notes

,

shortcuts and tricks

,

ppt

,

Viva Questions

,

video lectures

,

Important questions

,

Previous Year Questions with Solutions

,

Exam

,

Extra Questions

,

Political System of Harappa Civilization | History Optional for UPSC (Notes)

,

Political System of Harappa Civilization | History Optional for UPSC (Notes)

,

mock tests for examination

,

Free

,

Sample Paper

,

Summary

,

pdf

,

Objective type Questions

,

MCQs

,

past year papers

;