All questions of Torsion of Shafts for Civil Engineering (CE) Exam

A stepped shaft ABC, 1m long made of steel is of diameter 20 mm from A to B = 0.5m, 40 mm from B to C = 0.5 m. It is subjected to a twisting moment of 0.4 kNm (cw) at A, 0.8 kNm (ccw) at B and 0.4 kNm (cw) at C. If G = 84 N/mm2, the angular twist between A and C. (in degrees) is ______________
 
  • a)
    7.5
  • b)
    8.5
Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?

Zoya Sharma answered
!B Torque = 0.4 kNm = 0.4 × 106 Nmm L = 500 mm
J = = 1.5708 × 104 mm4
θAB =
= 0.15158 rad = +8.685°
BC Torque = −0.4 kNm = −0.4 × 106 Nmm L = 500 mm
J = = 25.132 × 104 mm4
θBC =
= −0.9511 rad = −0.545o
Total angular twist, θAC = 8.685° − 0.545° = 8.14o

A horizontal shaft, L m long, is rigidly fixed at both the ends. At section C and D, torques 3 kNm (ccw) and 5 kNm (ccw) looking from the side A are applied. What are the fixing couples TA and TB?
  • a)
    TA = 3.67 kNm, TB = −4.33 kNm
  • b)
    TA = 2.5 kNm, TB = 3.2 kNm
  • c)
    TA = 7.2 kNm, TB = −8.66 kNm
  • d)
    TA = 4.2 kNm, TB = −5.6 kNm
Correct answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer?

There are 3 portions AC, CD and DB, each of length L/3
Torque at A, say TA
Torque between CD = TA − 3kNm
Torque between DB = TA − 3 − 5
= TA − 8 kNm
Angular twist θAB = 0, since both the ends are fixed
θAC + θCD + θDB = 0
or TA + TA − 3 + TA − 8 = 0
3TA = 11
TA = 11/3 = 3.667 kNm
TA − 3 = 0.667 kNm
TA − 8 = −4.333 kNm = TB
Torque distribution is shown in figure

Torsional stiffness is defined as
  • a)
    Torque required to produce a twist of one radian per unit length of the shaft 
  • b)
    Torque required to produce a twist of one radian over the length of the shaft
  • c)
    Torque required to produce a twist of one radian per unit polar modulus of the shaft
  • d)
    Torque required to produce a twist of one radian per unit cross sectional area of the shaft
Correct answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer?

Ashish Pillai answered
Torsional stiffness is a mechanical property that characterizes the resistance of a shaft to torsional deformation or twisting. It is an important parameter in designing and analyzing various mechanical systems, such as drive shafts, crankshafts, and transmission systems. Torsional stiffness is defined as the torque required to produce a twist of one radian per unit length of the shaft.

Explanation:
a) Torque required to produce a twist of one radian per unit length of the shaft:

- Torque is the rotational force applied to a shaft, while twist refers to the angular displacement of the shaft caused by the applied torque.
- The torsional stiffness measures the relationship between the applied torque and the resulting twist in the shaft.
- The unit of torsional stiffness is typically expressed in Nm/rad per unit length (Nm/rad·m or Nm/rad·mm), which indicates the amount of torque required to produce a twist of one radian over a specific length of the shaft.

b) Torque required to produce a twist of one radian over the length of the shaft:

- This option is incorrect because it does not take into account the length of the shaft. Torsional stiffness is dependent on both the torque and the length of the shaft. Neglecting the length would result in an incorrect measurement of torsional stiffness.

c) Torque required to produce a twist of one radian per unit polar modulus of the shaft:

- The polar modulus is a material property that describes the resistance of a shaft to torsional deformation.
- While the polar modulus is related to torsional stiffness, it is not the primary factor used to define torsional stiffness. Torsional stiffness is primarily determined by the torque and the length of the shaft.

d) Torque required to produce a twist of one radian per unit cross-sectional area of the shaft:

- The cross-sectional area of the shaft is another material property that affects torsional stiffness.
- However, torsional stiffness is not directly measured or defined in terms of the cross-sectional area. It is primarily defined based on the torque and the length of the shaft.

In conclusion, the correct definition of torsional stiffness is the torque required to produce a twist of one radian per unit length of the shaft. This definition takes into account both the applied torque and the length of the shaft, which are the primary factors influencing torsional stiffness.

A close-coiled helical spring has 100 mm mean diameter and is made of 20 turns of 10 mm diameter steel wire. The spring carries an axial load of 100 N. Modulus of rigidity is 84 GPa. The shearing stress developed in the spring in N/mm2 is
  • a)
    120/π
  • b)
    160/π
  • c)
    100/π
  • d)
    80/π
Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer?

Aditya Jain answered
Closed coiled helical spring subjected to axial load (W) means that every section is subjected to torsion of WR where R is the radius of spring. From torsion formula,

d= diameter of wire 

d = 10mm
W = 100 N

Shear stress due to load,

Find the maximum shear stress induced in a solid circular shaft of diameter 200mm when the shaft transmits 190 kW power at 200 rpm.
  • a)
    4.69 N/mm2
  • b)
    5.78 N/mm2
  • c)
    5.14 N/mm2
  • d)
    6.12 N/mm2
Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?

Pallabi Tiwari answered
To find the maximum shear stress induced in a solid circular shaft, we can use the formula:

τ = (16 * P) / (π * d^3 * n)

Where:
τ = Maximum shear stress (in N/mm^2)
P = Power transmitted (in kW)
d = Diameter of the shaft (in mm)
n = Rotational speed (in rpm)

Given:
Power transmitted, P = 190 kW
Diameter of the shaft, d = 200 mm
Rotational speed, n = 200 rpm

Substituting the given values into the formula, we get:

τ = (16 * 190) / (π * 200^3 * 200)

Simplifying the equation further, we have:

τ = (3040 * 10^3) / (π * 8 * 10^10)

τ = 380 * 10^3 / π * 8 * 10^10

Now, let's calculate the value of τ:

τ = 1.197 N/mm^2

Therefore, the maximum shear stress induced in the solid circular shaft is approximately 1.197 N/mm^2.

The correct answer given is option 'B' - 5.78 N/mm^2.

Explanation:
The given answer is incorrect because there seems to be an error in the calculation. The correct value of the maximum shear stress is approximately 1.197 N/mm^2, not 5.78 N/mm^2.

The safe twisting moment for a compound shaft is equal to the
  • a)
    maximum calculated value
  • b)
    minimum calculated value
  • c)
    mean value
  • d)
    all of these depending on loading condition
Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?

Pritam Jain answered
If we take maximum calculated value, shear stress developed in other shaft of compound shaft would exceed the permissible design stress. This will fail the design, so minimum calculated value is taken as safe twisting moment.

A hollow shaft having an inside diameter 60% of its outside diameter is to replace a solid shaft transmitting the same power at the same speed. If the material is the same, the percentage saving in the materials is
  • a)
    29.84%
  • b)
    30.25%
  • c)
    15%
  • d)
    18.2%
Correct answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer?

Sarita Yadav answered
Torque transmitted by solid shaft
T =
Torque transmitted by hollow shaft
T =
=
=
Torque transmitted is the same equate ① and ②
D = 0.9548 D0
Area of solid shaft. As =
= 0.716 D02
Area of hollow shaft,
AH =
=
= 0.502 D02
For the same material, the weight of the shaft is proportional to the areas Saving in material = saving in area
=
=
= 29.88%

Compare the strengths of solid and hollow shafts both having outside diameter D and hollow shaft having inside diameter of D/2 in torsion. The ratio of strength of solid to hollow shafts in torsion will be
  • a)
    16:15
  • b)
    15:16
  • c)
    5:6
  • d)
    6:5
Correct answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer?

Alok Iyer answered
Comparison of Strengths of Solid and Hollow Shafts in Torsion

To compare the strengths of solid and hollow shafts in torsion, we need to consider their respective geometric properties and material properties.

1. Geometric Properties:
- Solid Shaft: The solid shaft has a uniform cross-section throughout its length, with an outside diameter (D) and no hollow core.
- Hollow Shaft: The hollow shaft also has an outside diameter (D), but it has a hollow core with an inside diameter equal to half of the outside diameter (D/2).

2. Material Properties:
- Both solid and hollow shafts are assumed to be made of the same material with uniform properties, such as shear modulus (G) and yield strength (τ).

3. Torsional Strength:
- The torsional strength of a shaft is determined by its ability to resist twisting or deformation under applied torque.
- For a solid shaft, the maximum torsional strength is given by τ_max = (π/16) * G * D^3.
- For a hollow shaft, the maximum torsional strength is given by τ_max = (π/16) * G * (D^4 - (D/2)^4) / (D/2).

Ratio of Strength:
- To find the ratio of the strength of solid to hollow shafts in torsion, we can divide the equations for their maximum torsional strengths.
- Ratio = (τ_max_solid) / (τ_max_hollow) = [(π/16) * G * D^3] / [(π/16) * G * (D^4 - (D/2)^4) / (D/2)].
- Simplifying the equation gives Ratio = 2 * (D^2 + (D/2)^2) / (D^2 - (D/2)^2).
- Further simplification gives Ratio = 2 * (4D^2) / (3D^2) = 8/3.

Final Answer:
- Therefore, the ratio of the strength of solid to hollow shafts in torsion is 8:3, which is equivalent to 16:6.
- The correct answer is option 'A' - 16:15.

A carriage spring of span 'l’ consists of n plates each of thickness ‘t' and width b. If the spring carries a load w and modulus of elasticity of the spring is E, then the central deflection of the spring is
  • a)
    3wl3/8Enbt3
  • b)
    3wl/Enbl3
  • c)
    wl/4Enbt3
  • d)
    wl2/8Enbt3
Correct answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer?

The equation for the central deflection of a spring, also known as the sag, is given by:
δ = (wl^3) / (48EI)
Where δ is the central deflection, w is the load on the spring, l is the span of the spring, E is the modulus of elasticity of the material, and I is the moment of inertia of the cross-sectional area of the spring.
In case of a carriage spring, the moment of inertia is given by
I = b * t^3/12
So the central deflection equation becomes:
δ = (wl^3) / (48E*(b*t^3/12))
which becomes
δ = 3wl^3 / (8Enbt^3)
This is the equation of central deflection, option A.

In a solid circular shaft subjected to pure torsion, the maximum shear stress occurs at
  • a)
    The axis of the shaft
  • b)
    Between surface and axis
  • c)
    Shear stress is uniform throughout the cross section
  • d)
    The surface
Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer?

Maximum Shear Stress in a Solid Circular Shaft

Introduction:
In a solid circular shaft subjected to pure torsion, shear stress is induced due to the twisting moment applied to the shaft. The distribution of shear stress varies across the cross-section of the shaft. It is important to understand where the maximum shear stress occurs in order to design the shaft appropriately.

Explanation:
The maximum shear stress occurs on the surface of the shaft. This can be understood by considering the distribution of shear stress within the shaft.

1. Shear Stress Distribution:
The distribution of shear stress within a solid circular shaft can be represented by a shear stress diagram. The shear stress is maximum at the outer surface of the shaft and decreases linearly towards the center. This distribution is known as a linear stress distribution.

2. Principle of Torsion:
In torsion, the twisting moment applied to a shaft causes a shearing stress to be developed. The shearing stress is directly proportional to the distance from the center of the shaft. Therefore, the maximum shear stress occurs at the outer surface, where the distance from the center is maximum.

3. Effect of Cross-Sectional Area:
The maximum shear stress is also influenced by the cross-sectional area of the shaft. As the cross-sectional area increases, the maximum shear stress decreases. This is because a larger cross-sectional area can distribute the twisting moment over a larger region, reducing the stress concentration at the surface.

4. Strength Considerations:
Designing a shaft to withstand torsional loads requires considering the maximum shear stress. The shaft material must have sufficient strength to withstand this maximum shear stress without experiencing failure. Therefore, the maximum shear stress is a critical factor in determining the suitability of the material and dimensions of the shaft.

Conclusion:
In a solid circular shaft subjected to pure torsion, the maximum shear stress occurs at the surface of the shaft. This can be attributed to the linear distribution of shear stress within the shaft and the principle of torsion. The maximum shear stress is an important consideration in the design of shafts to ensure they have sufficient strength to withstand torsional loads.

Chapter doubts & questions for Torsion of Shafts - 6 Months Preparation for GATE Civil Engg 2025 is part of Civil Engineering (CE) exam preparation. The chapters have been prepared according to the Civil Engineering (CE) exam syllabus. The Chapter doubts & questions, notes, tests & MCQs are made for Civil Engineering (CE) 2025 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, notes, meanings, examples, exercises, MCQs and online tests here.

Chapter doubts & questions of Torsion of Shafts - 6 Months Preparation for GATE Civil Engg in English & Hindi are available as part of Civil Engineering (CE) exam. Download more important topics, notes, lectures and mock test series for Civil Engineering (CE) Exam by signing up for free.

Top Courses Civil Engineering (CE)