GMAT Exam > GMAT Questions > John: A study has identified that many soldie...
Start Learning for Free
John: A study has identified that many soldiers received less-than-honorable discharges from the army due to charges of misconduct that can actually be attributed to conditions such as PTSD and traumatic brain injury. This is a military practice that is unfair and must be avoided. The army must take responsibility for the same and stop discharging their soldiers dishonorably.
Christy: While it is true that it is unfair to the soldiers to be discharged so from the army, it has also been found that there are no sufficient measures or systems that have been created to identify whether the misconduct was due to trauma or due to other reasons. Moreover, to enforce discipline in the ranks, it is important for the army to follow a uniform rule for all the soldiers.
Which of the following statements can Christy further add to her argument?
- a)If there is no proper system, then the army should have developed a proper system by now.
- b)Complete elimination of dishonorable discharges would make it more difficult for the army to monitor and evaluate the soldiers.
- c)It is not the army’s fault that there has been no system developed to help those with PTSD
- d)Studies have also found that showing consideration for some soldiers has led to others taking advantage, indirectly promoting misconduct.
- e)There have been instances when the army has been able to identify the reasons for the misconduct and acted accordingly.
Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer?
| FREE This question is part of | Download PDF Attempt this Test |
Verified Answer
John: A study has identified that many soldiers received less-than-hon...
Step 1: Analyzing the Argument
John’s argument is that it is unfair of the army to dishonorably discharge people for misconduct when such conduct could have been because of PTSD. While Christy accepts that such dishonorable discharge is unfair, she believes that the army has to have a uniform rule and cannot act partial to some soldiers, especially when the cases of misconduct due to PTSD are not easily distinguishable from the rest.
John’s argument is that it is unfair of the army to dishonorably discharge people for misconduct when such conduct could have been because of PTSD. While Christy accepts that such dishonorable discharge is unfair, she believes that the army has to have a uniform rule and cannot act partial to some soldiers, especially when the cases of misconduct due to PTSD are not easily distinguishable from the rest.
Christy’s argument is not entirely contradictory to John’s. Therefore, in order to further strengthen her argument, the correct answer option cannot just talk about the fairness of the discharge but should address the uniformity in rules that she advocates.
Step 2: Eliminating Options
Option (A) is more of John’s response to Christy. Claiming that the army must have developed a system already, implies that the army has not done.
Option (B) discusses the importance of monitoring and evaluating the soldiers and states that to be the reason dishonourable discharges cannot be done away with. However, Christy’s argument is that there has to be uniformity in the rules adopted by the army. This option does not discuss uniformity at all and can be eliminated.
While Option (C) seems to be supporting the army, the discussion by Christy is not about who is to blame but about the impossibility of having different rules for different people. Moreover, the option only repeats the implication behind the first statement in Christy’s argument. The answer option therefore, does not add further to Christy’s reasoning.
Option (E) partially contradicts Christy’s argument. If the army has identified the reasons behind misconduct earlier, then it can do so again. Christy’s argument is that it is not possible to identify the reason and therefore, act accordingly. Furthermore, her argument is that even if able to identify the reason, it is better off to have uniformity in rules.
Option (D) further stresses on the need for uniformity in rules – so that there is no misconduct by the ranks. Option(D) therefore, strengthens Christy’s reasoning.
Option D is the correct answer.
Option (A) is more of John’s response to Christy. Claiming that the army must have developed a system already, implies that the army has not done.
Option (B) discusses the importance of monitoring and evaluating the soldiers and states that to be the reason dishonourable discharges cannot be done away with. However, Christy’s argument is that there has to be uniformity in the rules adopted by the army. This option does not discuss uniformity at all and can be eliminated.
While Option (C) seems to be supporting the army, the discussion by Christy is not about who is to blame but about the impossibility of having different rules for different people. Moreover, the option only repeats the implication behind the first statement in Christy’s argument. The answer option therefore, does not add further to Christy’s reasoning.
Option (E) partially contradicts Christy’s argument. If the army has identified the reasons behind misconduct earlier, then it can do so again. Christy’s argument is that it is not possible to identify the reason and therefore, act accordingly. Furthermore, her argument is that even if able to identify the reason, it is better off to have uniformity in rules.
Option (D) further stresses on the need for uniformity in rules – so that there is no misconduct by the ranks. Option(D) therefore, strengthens Christy’s reasoning.
Option D is the correct answer.
Most Upvoted Answer
John: A study has identified that many soldiers received less-than-hon...
Analysis:
D: Studies have also found that showing consideration for some soldiers has led to others taking advantage, indirectly promoting misconduct.
Explanation:
- By adding this statement, Christy is highlighting a potential consequence of completely eliminating dishonorable discharges.
- It brings attention to the fact that if the army shows too much leniency towards soldiers with PTSD or other conditions, it may inadvertently encourage misconduct in other soldiers who do not have valid reasons for their behavior.
- This argument underscores the importance of maintaining a balance between compassion for soldiers dealing with mental health issues and the need for discipline within the military ranks.
D: Studies have also found that showing consideration for some soldiers has led to others taking advantage, indirectly promoting misconduct.
Explanation:
- By adding this statement, Christy is highlighting a potential consequence of completely eliminating dishonorable discharges.
- It brings attention to the fact that if the army shows too much leniency towards soldiers with PTSD or other conditions, it may inadvertently encourage misconduct in other soldiers who do not have valid reasons for their behavior.
- This argument underscores the importance of maintaining a balance between compassion for soldiers dealing with mental health issues and the need for discipline within the military ranks.
Attention GMAT Students!
To make sure you are not studying endlessly, EduRev has designed GMAT study material, with Structured Courses, Videos, & Test Series. Plus get personalized analysis, doubt solving and improvement plans to achieve a great score in GMAT.
|
Explore Courses for GMAT exam
|
|
Similar GMAT Doubts
Top Courses for GMATView all
John: A study has identified that many soldiers received less-than-honorable discharges from the army due to charges of misconduct that can actually be attributed to conditions such as PTSD and traumatic brain injury. This is a military practice that is unfair and must be avoided. The army must take responsibility for the same and stop discharging their soldiers dishonorably.Christy: While it is true that it is unfair to the soldiers to be discharged so from the army, it has also been found that there are no sufficient measures or systems that have been created to identify whether the misconduct was due to trauma or due to other reasons. Moreover, to enforce discipline in the ranks, it is important for the army to follow a uniform rule for all the soldiers.Which of the following statements can Christy further add to her argument?a)If there is no proper system, then the army should have developed a proper system by now.b)Complete elimination of dishonorable discharges would make it more difficult for the army to monitor and evaluate the soldiers.c)It is not the army’s fault that there has been no system developed to help those with PTSDd)Studies have also found that showing consideration for some soldiers has led to others taking advantage, indirectly promoting misconduct.e)There havebeen instances when the army has been able to identify the reasons for the misconduct and acted accordingly.Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer?
Question Description
John: A study has identified that many soldiers received less-than-honorable discharges from the army due to charges of misconduct that can actually be attributed to conditions such as PTSD and traumatic brain injury. This is a military practice that is unfair and must be avoided. The army must take responsibility for the same and stop discharging their soldiers dishonorably.Christy: While it is true that it is unfair to the soldiers to be discharged so from the army, it has also been found that there are no sufficient measures or systems that have been created to identify whether the misconduct was due to trauma or due to other reasons. Moreover, to enforce discipline in the ranks, it is important for the army to follow a uniform rule for all the soldiers.Which of the following statements can Christy further add to her argument?a)If there is no proper system, then the army should have developed a proper system by now.b)Complete elimination of dishonorable discharges would make it more difficult for the army to monitor and evaluate the soldiers.c)It is not the army’s fault that there has been no system developed to help those with PTSDd)Studies have also found that showing consideration for some soldiers has led to others taking advantage, indirectly promoting misconduct.e)There havebeen instances when the army has been able to identify the reasons for the misconduct and acted accordingly.Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer? for GMAT 2024 is part of GMAT preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the GMAT exam syllabus. Information about John: A study has identified that many soldiers received less-than-honorable discharges from the army due to charges of misconduct that can actually be attributed to conditions such as PTSD and traumatic brain injury. This is a military practice that is unfair and must be avoided. The army must take responsibility for the same and stop discharging their soldiers dishonorably.Christy: While it is true that it is unfair to the soldiers to be discharged so from the army, it has also been found that there are no sufficient measures or systems that have been created to identify whether the misconduct was due to trauma or due to other reasons. Moreover, to enforce discipline in the ranks, it is important for the army to follow a uniform rule for all the soldiers.Which of the following statements can Christy further add to her argument?a)If there is no proper system, then the army should have developed a proper system by now.b)Complete elimination of dishonorable discharges would make it more difficult for the army to monitor and evaluate the soldiers.c)It is not the army’s fault that there has been no system developed to help those with PTSDd)Studies have also found that showing consideration for some soldiers has led to others taking advantage, indirectly promoting misconduct.e)There havebeen instances when the army has been able to identify the reasons for the misconduct and acted accordingly.Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer? covers all topics & solutions for GMAT 2024 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for John: A study has identified that many soldiers received less-than-honorable discharges from the army due to charges of misconduct that can actually be attributed to conditions such as PTSD and traumatic brain injury. This is a military practice that is unfair and must be avoided. The army must take responsibility for the same and stop discharging their soldiers dishonorably.Christy: While it is true that it is unfair to the soldiers to be discharged so from the army, it has also been found that there are no sufficient measures or systems that have been created to identify whether the misconduct was due to trauma or due to other reasons. Moreover, to enforce discipline in the ranks, it is important for the army to follow a uniform rule for all the soldiers.Which of the following statements can Christy further add to her argument?a)If there is no proper system, then the army should have developed a proper system by now.b)Complete elimination of dishonorable discharges would make it more difficult for the army to monitor and evaluate the soldiers.c)It is not the army’s fault that there has been no system developed to help those with PTSDd)Studies have also found that showing consideration for some soldiers has led to others taking advantage, indirectly promoting misconduct.e)There havebeen instances when the army has been able to identify the reasons for the misconduct and acted accordingly.Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer?.
John: A study has identified that many soldiers received less-than-honorable discharges from the army due to charges of misconduct that can actually be attributed to conditions such as PTSD and traumatic brain injury. This is a military practice that is unfair and must be avoided. The army must take responsibility for the same and stop discharging their soldiers dishonorably.Christy: While it is true that it is unfair to the soldiers to be discharged so from the army, it has also been found that there are no sufficient measures or systems that have been created to identify whether the misconduct was due to trauma or due to other reasons. Moreover, to enforce discipline in the ranks, it is important for the army to follow a uniform rule for all the soldiers.Which of the following statements can Christy further add to her argument?a)If there is no proper system, then the army should have developed a proper system by now.b)Complete elimination of dishonorable discharges would make it more difficult for the army to monitor and evaluate the soldiers.c)It is not the army’s fault that there has been no system developed to help those with PTSDd)Studies have also found that showing consideration for some soldiers has led to others taking advantage, indirectly promoting misconduct.e)There havebeen instances when the army has been able to identify the reasons for the misconduct and acted accordingly.Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer? for GMAT 2024 is part of GMAT preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the GMAT exam syllabus. Information about John: A study has identified that many soldiers received less-than-honorable discharges from the army due to charges of misconduct that can actually be attributed to conditions such as PTSD and traumatic brain injury. This is a military practice that is unfair and must be avoided. The army must take responsibility for the same and stop discharging their soldiers dishonorably.Christy: While it is true that it is unfair to the soldiers to be discharged so from the army, it has also been found that there are no sufficient measures or systems that have been created to identify whether the misconduct was due to trauma or due to other reasons. Moreover, to enforce discipline in the ranks, it is important for the army to follow a uniform rule for all the soldiers.Which of the following statements can Christy further add to her argument?a)If there is no proper system, then the army should have developed a proper system by now.b)Complete elimination of dishonorable discharges would make it more difficult for the army to monitor and evaluate the soldiers.c)It is not the army’s fault that there has been no system developed to help those with PTSDd)Studies have also found that showing consideration for some soldiers has led to others taking advantage, indirectly promoting misconduct.e)There havebeen instances when the army has been able to identify the reasons for the misconduct and acted accordingly.Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer? covers all topics & solutions for GMAT 2024 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for John: A study has identified that many soldiers received less-than-honorable discharges from the army due to charges of misconduct that can actually be attributed to conditions such as PTSD and traumatic brain injury. This is a military practice that is unfair and must be avoided. The army must take responsibility for the same and stop discharging their soldiers dishonorably.Christy: While it is true that it is unfair to the soldiers to be discharged so from the army, it has also been found that there are no sufficient measures or systems that have been created to identify whether the misconduct was due to trauma or due to other reasons. Moreover, to enforce discipline in the ranks, it is important for the army to follow a uniform rule for all the soldiers.Which of the following statements can Christy further add to her argument?a)If there is no proper system, then the army should have developed a proper system by now.b)Complete elimination of dishonorable discharges would make it more difficult for the army to monitor and evaluate the soldiers.c)It is not the army’s fault that there has been no system developed to help those with PTSDd)Studies have also found that showing consideration for some soldiers has led to others taking advantage, indirectly promoting misconduct.e)There havebeen instances when the army has been able to identify the reasons for the misconduct and acted accordingly.Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer?.
Solutions for John: A study has identified that many soldiers received less-than-honorable discharges from the army due to charges of misconduct that can actually be attributed to conditions such as PTSD and traumatic brain injury. This is a military practice that is unfair and must be avoided. The army must take responsibility for the same and stop discharging their soldiers dishonorably.Christy: While it is true that it is unfair to the soldiers to be discharged so from the army, it has also been found that there are no sufficient measures or systems that have been created to identify whether the misconduct was due to trauma or due to other reasons. Moreover, to enforce discipline in the ranks, it is important for the army to follow a uniform rule for all the soldiers.Which of the following statements can Christy further add to her argument?a)If there is no proper system, then the army should have developed a proper system by now.b)Complete elimination of dishonorable discharges would make it more difficult for the army to monitor and evaluate the soldiers.c)It is not the army’s fault that there has been no system developed to help those with PTSDd)Studies have also found that showing consideration for some soldiers has led to others taking advantage, indirectly promoting misconduct.e)There havebeen instances when the army has been able to identify the reasons for the misconduct and acted accordingly.Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer? in English & in Hindi are available as part of our courses for GMAT.
Download more important topics, notes, lectures and mock test series for GMAT Exam by signing up for free.
Here you can find the meaning of John: A study has identified that many soldiers received less-than-honorable discharges from the army due to charges of misconduct that can actually be attributed to conditions such as PTSD and traumatic brain injury. This is a military practice that is unfair and must be avoided. The army must take responsibility for the same and stop discharging their soldiers dishonorably.Christy: While it is true that it is unfair to the soldiers to be discharged so from the army, it has also been found that there are no sufficient measures or systems that have been created to identify whether the misconduct was due to trauma or due to other reasons. Moreover, to enforce discipline in the ranks, it is important for the army to follow a uniform rule for all the soldiers.Which of the following statements can Christy further add to her argument?a)If there is no proper system, then the army should have developed a proper system by now.b)Complete elimination of dishonorable discharges would make it more difficult for the army to monitor and evaluate the soldiers.c)It is not the army’s fault that there has been no system developed to help those with PTSDd)Studies have also found that showing consideration for some soldiers has led to others taking advantage, indirectly promoting misconduct.e)There havebeen instances when the army has been able to identify the reasons for the misconduct and acted accordingly.Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer? defined & explained in the simplest way possible. Besides giving the explanation of
John: A study has identified that many soldiers received less-than-honorable discharges from the army due to charges of misconduct that can actually be attributed to conditions such as PTSD and traumatic brain injury. This is a military practice that is unfair and must be avoided. The army must take responsibility for the same and stop discharging their soldiers dishonorably.Christy: While it is true that it is unfair to the soldiers to be discharged so from the army, it has also been found that there are no sufficient measures or systems that have been created to identify whether the misconduct was due to trauma or due to other reasons. Moreover, to enforce discipline in the ranks, it is important for the army to follow a uniform rule for all the soldiers.Which of the following statements can Christy further add to her argument?a)If there is no proper system, then the army should have developed a proper system by now.b)Complete elimination of dishonorable discharges would make it more difficult for the army to monitor and evaluate the soldiers.c)It is not the army’s fault that there has been no system developed to help those with PTSDd)Studies have also found that showing consideration for some soldiers has led to others taking advantage, indirectly promoting misconduct.e)There havebeen instances when the army has been able to identify the reasons for the misconduct and acted accordingly.Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer?, a detailed solution for John: A study has identified that many soldiers received less-than-honorable discharges from the army due to charges of misconduct that can actually be attributed to conditions such as PTSD and traumatic brain injury. This is a military practice that is unfair and must be avoided. The army must take responsibility for the same and stop discharging their soldiers dishonorably.Christy: While it is true that it is unfair to the soldiers to be discharged so from the army, it has also been found that there are no sufficient measures or systems that have been created to identify whether the misconduct was due to trauma or due to other reasons. Moreover, to enforce discipline in the ranks, it is important for the army to follow a uniform rule for all the soldiers.Which of the following statements can Christy further add to her argument?a)If there is no proper system, then the army should have developed a proper system by now.b)Complete elimination of dishonorable discharges would make it more difficult for the army to monitor and evaluate the soldiers.c)It is not the army’s fault that there has been no system developed to help those with PTSDd)Studies have also found that showing consideration for some soldiers has led to others taking advantage, indirectly promoting misconduct.e)There havebeen instances when the army has been able to identify the reasons for the misconduct and acted accordingly.Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer? has been provided alongside types of John: A study has identified that many soldiers received less-than-honorable discharges from the army due to charges of misconduct that can actually be attributed to conditions such as PTSD and traumatic brain injury. This is a military practice that is unfair and must be avoided. The army must take responsibility for the same and stop discharging their soldiers dishonorably.Christy: While it is true that it is unfair to the soldiers to be discharged so from the army, it has also been found that there are no sufficient measures or systems that have been created to identify whether the misconduct was due to trauma or due to other reasons. Moreover, to enforce discipline in the ranks, it is important for the army to follow a uniform rule for all the soldiers.Which of the following statements can Christy further add to her argument?a)If there is no proper system, then the army should have developed a proper system by now.b)Complete elimination of dishonorable discharges would make it more difficult for the army to monitor and evaluate the soldiers.c)It is not the army’s fault that there has been no system developed to help those with PTSDd)Studies have also found that showing consideration for some soldiers has led to others taking advantage, indirectly promoting misconduct.e)There havebeen instances when the army has been able to identify the reasons for the misconduct and acted accordingly.Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer? theory, EduRev gives you an
ample number of questions to practice John: A study has identified that many soldiers received less-than-honorable discharges from the army due to charges of misconduct that can actually be attributed to conditions such as PTSD and traumatic brain injury. This is a military practice that is unfair and must be avoided. The army must take responsibility for the same and stop discharging their soldiers dishonorably.Christy: While it is true that it is unfair to the soldiers to be discharged so from the army, it has also been found that there are no sufficient measures or systems that have been created to identify whether the misconduct was due to trauma or due to other reasons. Moreover, to enforce discipline in the ranks, it is important for the army to follow a uniform rule for all the soldiers.Which of the following statements can Christy further add to her argument?a)If there is no proper system, then the army should have developed a proper system by now.b)Complete elimination of dishonorable discharges would make it more difficult for the army to monitor and evaluate the soldiers.c)It is not the army’s fault that there has been no system developed to help those with PTSDd)Studies have also found that showing consideration for some soldiers has led to others taking advantage, indirectly promoting misconduct.e)There havebeen instances when the army has been able to identify the reasons for the misconduct and acted accordingly.Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer? tests, examples and also practice GMAT tests.
|
|
Explore Courses for GMAT exam
|
|
Suggested Free Tests
Signup for Free!
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days! Learn & Practice with 1000+ FREE Notes, Videos & Tests.
|
© EduRev
|
Education Revolution
|
|
Signup to see your scores
go up within 7 days!
Access 1000+ FREE Docs, Videos and Tests
Takes less than 10 seconds to signup