Last year, football player James McGuel faced severe criticism for his poor show that contributed significantly to OldFort Uniteds worst performance in the history of National Premier League Football Championship. Despite the fact that OldFort United has been winning many more games this year and that James McGuel is averaging more goals per game than last year, critics continue to doubt McGuels capability and are voting against his inclusion in the team for the next season of the championship.Which of the following statements most explains the paradox in the above argument?a)OldFort United has not been playing more matches this year.b)Football critics are often wrong in their predictions.c)OldFort Uniteds decision to hire Wayne Bruce has turned out well for the team as he is the leading scorer for the team this year.d)Many critics have raised questions about the actual nationality of James McGuel, making it likely that he will be excluded from the World Championship squad for the country.e)After last years poor showdown, OldFort United has been relegated from the premier league and is currently playing against weaker opponents.Correct answer is option 'E'. Can you explain this answer?

EduRev

All Courses

Explore Courses UPSC Exam UPSC Test Series Free Notes EduRev Infinity

Open App

GMAT Exam > GMAT Questions > Last year, football player James McGuel faced...

Join the Discussion on the App

Which of the following statements most explains the paradox in the above argument?

a)
OldFort United has not been playing more matches this year.
b)
Football critics are often wrong in their predictions.
c)
OldFort United’s decision to hire Wayne Bruce has turned out well for the team as he is the leading scorer for the team this year.
d)
Many critics have raised questions about the actual nationality of James McGuel, making it likely that he will be excluded from the World Championship squad for the country.
e)
After last year’s poor showdown, OldFort United has been relegated from the premier league and is currently playing against weaker opponents.

Correct answer is option 'E'. Can you explain this answer?

FREE This question is part of

Test: Paradox

Attempt Test

Attempt this Test

Verified Answer

Last year, football player James McGuel faced severe criticism for his...

Argument Analysis

Pre-Thinking

Paradox Clarification

Even though this year OU is winning more games and JM has been scoring more goals per game than last year, , critics are doubtful about JM’s capability and are voting against his inclusion in OU next year - two apparently conflicting situations amounting to a paradox.

Pre-Thinking Approach

Let’s see how we can explain the situation at hand. To do so, we will look at the logical structure and the paradoxical pieces of information. Then we’ll try to come up with instances which can explain the coexistence of the seemingly conflicting pieces of information.

Paradox – Critics are doubtful about JM’s performance even when he has been averaging more goals/game and OU has been winning many more games.

- Instance #1 – JM is performing better than last year but he still might be performing much worse than what is expected from him. E.g. let’s say he was brought into OU with an expectation that he’ll score 1 goal/game and he scored 0.2 goals/game last year. Then, even if he scores 0.4 goals/game (double of last year) he’ll still fall short of expectations and critics would want him to be replaced by a better player.
- Instance #2– The overall playing conditions for OU could have changed. E.g. a lot of star players of other teams might not be playing in NPL, making OU a comparatively stronger team with weaker opponents or perhaps OU itself is not playing in NPL but in a lower league in which its chances of winning are much higher. In both these cases, it is possible that there is no improvement in JM’s performance and, therefore, critics don’t want him in the next season.

With this understanding in mind, let's take a look at the option statements.

Answer Choices

OldFort United has not been playing more matches this year.

Incorrect - Irrelevant

This option is not relevant as the information about overall matches played is not required when the passage already talks about goals/match.

Football critics are often wrong in their predictions.

Incorrect - Irrelevant

This option is about whether critics’ predictions are right or wrong whereas we are interested in knowing why they are making these recommendations in the first place.

OldFort United’s decision to hire Wayne Bruce has turned out well for the team as he is the leading scorer for the team this year.

Incorrect - Irrelevant

This option is not relevant as it talks about another player and not JM.

Many critics have raised questions about the actual nationality of James McGuel, making it likely that he will be excluded from the World Championship squad for the country.

Incorrect - Irrelevant

This option is not relevant as it talks about a different issue (JM’s nationality) and not JM’s performance or the reasons for the critics’ opinion.

After last year’s poor showdown, OldFort United has been relegated from the premier league and is currently playing against weaker opponents.

Correct

This choice is written along the lines of our pre-thinking per Instance #2.

View all questions of this test

View all answers Start learning for free

< Previous Question Next Question >

Explore Courses for GMAT exam

Similar GMAT Doubts

Last year, football player James McGuel faced severe criticism for his poor show that contributed significantly to OldFort United’s worst performance in the history of National Premier League Football Championship. Despite the fact that OldFort United has been winning many more games this year and that James McGuel is averaging more goals per game than last year, critics continue to doubt McGuel’s capability and are voting against his inclusion in the team for the next season of the championship.Which of the following statements most explains the paradox in the above argument?

View answer

Struthers College has built its reputation for academic excellence largely on significant contributions from wealthy alumni who are avid fans of the school’s football team. Although the team has won more national championships over the years than any other team in its division, this year it did not even win the division title, and so Struthers College can expect to see a decline in alumni contributions next year.The above argument relies on which of the following assumptions about Struthers College?

View answer

Marketing Analyst: Traditionally, introducing a new consumer product contributes to the diversity of a company’s product mix and results in an overall increase in revenues and profits. However, our launch of a new brand of soft drinks, Cool Breeze, planned for the end of this fiscal year, will almost certainly reduce rather than increase the company’s profits. Since we already offer a line of chilled refreshments that are very similar to Cool Breeze, the launch of the new drink is likely to cannibalize our current sales rather than attract new customers. Additionally, since the costs of producing Cool Breeze are higher than those of the other chilled refreshments, a large part of our current sales will be replaced with lower-margin revenues.In the argument above, which of the following statements best describes the role played by each portion in boldface?

View answer

Corporate Officer:Last year was an unusually poor one for our chemical division, which has traditionally contributed about 60 percent of the corporations profits. It is therefore encouraging that there is the following evidence that the pharmaceutical division is growing stronger: it contributed 45 percent of the corporations profits, up from 20 percent the previous year.On the basis of the facts stated, which of the following is the best critique of the evidence presented above?

View answer

Read the passage and answer the question given below.All available research points to the fact that music education can significantly bolster students academic skills, particularly when this education is imposed during early childhood. The most notable academic improvement associated with music education, surprisingly, occurs in affected students performance in mathematics. A recent study, which compared students in school districts all around the world, found that students who began receiving music education in kindergarten scored significantly higher on standardized math tests than did those who began after third grade. Those students who began in third grade, in turn, scored significantly higher than did those who received no music education at all. In fact, correlation studies attempting to link several different factors to higher math test scores have found music education to be the most significant of these factors.Q. What is the authors main point?

View answer

Top Courses for GMATView all

GMAT Focus Edition Mock Test Series 2024

Quantitative for GMAT

Crash Course for GMAT

Data Insights for GMAT

100 RCs for GMAT

Top Courses for GMAT

View all

Last year, football player James McGuel faced severe criticism for his poor show that contributed significantly to OldFort United’s worst performance in the history of National Premier League Football Championship. Despite the fact that OldFort United has been winning many more games this year and that James McGuel is averaging more goals per game than last year, critics continue to doubt McGuel’s capability and are voting against his inclusion in the team for the next season of the championship.Which of the following statements most explains the paradox in the above argument?a)OldFort United has not been playing more matches this year.b)Football critics are often wrong in their predictions.c)OldFort United’s decision to hire Wayne Bruce has turned out well for the team as he is the leading scorer for the team this year.d)Many critics have raised questions about the actual nationality of James McGuel, making it likely that he will be excluded from the World Championship squad for the country.e)After last year’s poor showdown, OldFort United has been relegated from the premier league and is currently playing against weaker opponents.Correct answer is option 'E'. Can you explain this answer?

Share with a Friend

Answer this doubt

Question Description
Last year, football player James McGuel faced severe criticism for his poor show that contributed significantly to OldFort United’s worst performance in the history of National Premier League Football Championship. Despite the fact that OldFort United has been winning many more games this year and that James McGuel is averaging more goals per game than last year, critics continue to doubt McGuel’s capability and are voting against his inclusion in the team for the next season of the championship.Which of the following statements most explains the paradox in the above argument?a)OldFort United has not been playing more matches this year.b)Football critics are often wrong in their predictions.c)OldFort United’s decision to hire Wayne Bruce has turned out well for the team as he is the leading scorer for the team this year.d)Many critics have raised questions about the actual nationality of James McGuel, making it likely that he will be excluded from the World Championship squad for the country.e)After last year’s poor showdown, OldFort United has been relegated from the premier league and is currently playing against weaker opponents.Correct answer is option 'E'. Can you explain this answer? for GMAT 2024 is part of GMAT preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the GMAT exam syllabus. Information about Last year, football player James McGuel faced severe criticism for his poor show that contributed significantly to OldFort United’s worst performance in the history of National Premier League Football Championship. Despite the fact that OldFort United has been winning many more games this year and that James McGuel is averaging more goals per game than last year, critics continue to doubt McGuel’s capability and are voting against his inclusion in the team for the next season of the championship.Which of the following statements most explains the paradox in the above argument?a)OldFort United has not been playing more matches this year.b)Football critics are often wrong in their predictions.c)OldFort United’s decision to hire Wayne Bruce has turned out well for the team as he is the leading scorer for the team this year.d)Many critics have raised questions about the actual nationality of James McGuel, making it likely that he will be excluded from the World Championship squad for the country.e)After last year’s poor showdown, OldFort United has been relegated from the premier league and is currently playing against weaker opponents.Correct answer is option 'E'. Can you explain this answer? covers all topics & solutions for GMAT 2024 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for Last year, football player James McGuel faced severe criticism for his poor show that contributed significantly to OldFort United’s worst performance in the history of National Premier League Football Championship. Despite the fact that OldFort United has been winning many more games this year and that James McGuel is averaging more goals per game than last year, critics continue to doubt McGuel’s capability and are voting against his inclusion in the team for the next season of the championship.Which of the following statements most explains the paradox in the above argument?a)OldFort United has not been playing more matches this year.b)Football critics are often wrong in their predictions.c)OldFort United’s decision to hire Wayne Bruce has turned out well for the team as he is the leading scorer for the team this year.d)Many critics have raised questions about the actual nationality of James McGuel, making it likely that he will be excluded from the World Championship squad for the country.e)After last year’s poor showdown, OldFort United has been relegated from the premier league and is currently playing against weaker opponents.Correct answer is option 'E'. Can you explain this answer?.

Solutions for Last year, football player James McGuel faced severe criticism for his poor show that contributed significantly to OldFort United’s worst performance in the history of National Premier League Football Championship. Despite the fact that OldFort United has been winning many more games this year and that James McGuel is averaging more goals per game than last year, critics continue to doubt McGuel’s capability and are voting against his inclusion in the team for the next season of the championship.Which of the following statements most explains the paradox in the above argument?a)OldFort United has not been playing more matches this year.b)Football critics are often wrong in their predictions.c)OldFort United’s decision to hire Wayne Bruce has turned out well for the team as he is the leading scorer for the team this year.d)Many critics have raised questions about the actual nationality of James McGuel, making it likely that he will be excluded from the World Championship squad for the country.e)After last year’s poor showdown, OldFort United has been relegated from the premier league and is currently playing against weaker opponents.Correct answer is option 'E'. Can you explain this answer? in English & in Hindi are available as part of our courses for GMAT. Download more important topics, notes, lectures and mock test series for GMAT Exam by signing up for free.

Here you can find the meaning of Last year, football player James McGuel faced severe criticism for his poor show that contributed significantly to OldFort United’s worst performance in the history of National Premier League Football Championship. Despite the fact that OldFort United has been winning many more games this year and that James McGuel is averaging more goals per game than last year, critics continue to doubt McGuel’s capability and are voting against his inclusion in the team for the next season of the championship.Which of the following statements most explains the paradox in the above argument?a)OldFort United has not been playing more matches this year.b)Football critics are often wrong in their predictions.c)OldFort United’s decision to hire Wayne Bruce has turned out well for the team as he is the leading scorer for the team this year.d)Many critics have raised questions about the actual nationality of James McGuel, making it likely that he will be excluded from the World Championship squad for the country.e)After last year’s poor showdown, OldFort United has been relegated from the premier league and is currently playing against weaker opponents.Correct answer is option 'E'. Can you explain this answer? defined & explained in the simplest way possible. Besides giving the explanation of Last year, football player James McGuel faced severe criticism for his poor show that contributed significantly to OldFort United’s worst performance in the history of National Premier League Football Championship. Despite the fact that OldFort United has been winning many more games this year and that James McGuel is averaging more goals per game than last year, critics continue to doubt McGuel’s capability and are voting against his inclusion in the team for the next season of the championship.Which of the following statements most explains the paradox in the above argument?a)OldFort United has not been playing more matches this year.b)Football critics are often wrong in their predictions.c)OldFort United’s decision to hire Wayne Bruce has turned out well for the team as he is the leading scorer for the team this year.d)Many critics have raised questions about the actual nationality of James McGuel, making it likely that he will be excluded from the World Championship squad for the country.e)After last year’s poor showdown, OldFort United has been relegated from the premier league and is currently playing against weaker opponents.Correct answer is option 'E'. Can you explain this answer?, a detailed solution for Last year, football player James McGuel faced severe criticism for his poor show that contributed significantly to OldFort United’s worst performance in the history of National Premier League Football Championship. Despite the fact that OldFort United has been winning many more games this year and that James McGuel is averaging more goals per game than last year, critics continue to doubt McGuel’s capability and are voting against his inclusion in the team for the next season of the championship.Which of the following statements most explains the paradox in the above argument?a)OldFort United has not been playing more matches this year.b)Football critics are often wrong in their predictions.c)OldFort United’s decision to hire Wayne Bruce has turned out well for the team as he is the leading scorer for the team this year.d)Many critics have raised questions about the actual nationality of James McGuel, making it likely that he will be excluded from the World Championship squad for the country.e)After last year’s poor showdown, OldFort United has been relegated from the premier league and is currently playing against weaker opponents.Correct answer is option 'E'. Can you explain this answer? has been provided alongside types of Last year, football player James McGuel faced severe criticism for his poor show that contributed significantly to OldFort United’s worst performance in the history of National Premier League Football Championship. Despite the fact that OldFort United has been winning many more games this year and that James McGuel is averaging more goals per game than last year, critics continue to doubt McGuel’s capability and are voting against his inclusion in the team for the next season of the championship.Which of the following statements most explains the paradox in the above argument?a)OldFort United has not been playing more matches this year.b)Football critics are often wrong in their predictions.c)OldFort United’s decision to hire Wayne Bruce has turned out well for the team as he is the leading scorer for the team this year.d)Many critics have raised questions about the actual nationality of James McGuel, making it likely that he will be excluded from the World Championship squad for the country.e)After last year’s poor showdown, OldFort United has been relegated from the premier league and is currently playing against weaker opponents.Correct answer is option 'E'. Can you explain this answer? theory, EduRev gives you an ample number of questions to practice Last year, football player James McGuel faced severe criticism for his poor show that contributed significantly to OldFort United’s worst performance in the history of National Premier League Football Championship. Despite the fact that OldFort United has been winning many more games this year and that James McGuel is averaging more goals per game than last year, critics continue to doubt McGuel’s capability and are voting against his inclusion in the team for the next season of the championship.Which of the following statements most explains the paradox in the above argument?a)OldFort United has not been playing more matches this year.b)Football critics are often wrong in their predictions.c)OldFort United’s decision to hire Wayne Bruce has turned out well for the team as he is the leading scorer for the team this year.d)Many critics have raised questions about the actual nationality of James McGuel, making it likely that he will be excluded from the World Championship squad for the country.e)After last year’s poor showdown, OldFort United has been relegated from the premier league and is currently playing against weaker opponents.Correct answer is option 'E'. Can you explain this answer? tests, examples and also practice GMAT tests.

Explore Courses for GMAT exam