All Courses
Explore Courses UPSC Exam UPSC Test Series Free Notes EduRev Infinity Get the App Login Join for Free
Sign in Open App
GMAT Exam  >  GMAT Questions  >  A film is more likely to have a complex story... Start Learning for Free
SaveJoin the Discussion on the App
A film is more likely to have a complex storyline when it is directed by a director who has won an Academy Award. Regardless of the awards won by the director, a film with a complex storyline is more likely to do badly at the box-office than a film with a story-line that is not complex. Since other causes of poor box-office performance are not related to the awards won by the director, there must be more films with poor box-office collections with Academy Award-winning directors than with directors who have not won any Academy Awards.The argument above is most vulnerable to which one of the following criticisms?
  • a)
    It ignores the fact that a film that does not do well on the box-office may eventually do well when broadcasted on TV.
  • b)
    It fails to consider a scenario in which the number of films directed by directors who have not won Academy Awards is significantly more than that directed by directors who have won Academy Awards.
  • c)
    It identifies one aspect of the films as the sole determinant of their box office performance without considering other possible aspects.
  • d)
    It fails to consider a scenario in which directors may be aware of the fact that a complex storyline may not translate into a successful box-office collection.
  • e)
    It fails to factor in the number of films with poor box-office collections that were directed by Academy Award-winning directors and that ultimately won critical acclaim.
Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?
FREE This question is part of
Download PDF Attempt Test
Download PDF Attempt this Test
Verified Answer
A film is more likely to have a complex storyline when it is directed ...
Argument Analysis
 
Pre-Thinking
Conclusion Clarification
The author concludes that total number of films with poor BO collections directed by AWDs would be greater than total number of films with poor BO collections directed by NAWDs. The conclusion is based on the fact that AWDs are more likely to direct a film with CS, and irrespective of the awards won by the director, films with CS are more likely to perform worse at box office than films without CS. All other factors behind poor performance of films at box office are unrelated to awards won by the directors.
 Pre-Thinking Approach
To pre-think a flaw in the reasoning, let’s see how we can falsify this conclusion.  To do so, we will look at the logical structure, focusing on linkage 1 and the conclusion.  We will understand the condition under which the conclusion is falsified. Thus, the flaw would show a logical gap in the author’s reasoning while reaching the conclusion.
Linkage#1 –
  • Falsification Condition:  What if the total number of films directed by NAWDs is significantly more than that directed by AWDs? In such a case, there may not be more films with poor BO collections with AWDs than with NAWDs.
  • Flaw:  The argument is vulnerable to the criticisms that there is an abrupt jump from the premises given to the conclusion drawn. The argument has arrived at the conclusion without comparing the actual total number of films made by Academy Award winning directors and the ones made by the rest of the directors.
To understand the same, please consider the following scenario:
 
With this pre-thinking in mind, let’s evaluate the answer choices.
Answer Choices
A
It ignores the fact that a film that does not do well on the box-office may eventually do well when broadcasted on TV.
Incorrect - No flaw
This statement is of no relevance to the argument since the argument is concerned with the performance of the films only at the box office.
B
It fails to consider a scenario in which the number of films directed by directors who have not won Academy Awards is significantly more than that directed by directors who have won Academy Awards.
Correct
This choice is written along the lines of our pre-thinking per Linkage #1. It points out that the argument does not compare the actual total number of films made by AWDs and NAWDs. If we see the pre-thinking example, we can notice that the author’s conclusion is incorrect for the particular scenario.
C
It identifies one aspect of the films as the sole determinant of their box office performance without considering other possible aspects.
Incorrect - No flaw
This statement is incorrect since the passage does talk about “other factors” besides a complex storyline that determine a film’s performance at the box office. The passage says that all other factors are not related to awards won by directors.
D
It fails to consider a scenario in which directors may be aware of the fact that a complex storyline may not translate into a successful box-office collection.
Incorrect - No flaw
The awareness of directors regarding the eventual box-office performance of their films is of no relevance to the author’s conclusion.
E
It fails to factor in the number of films with poor box-office collections that were directed by Academy Award-winning directors and that ultimately won critical acclaim.
Incorrect - No flaw
This statement is irrelevant since the author’s conclusion is concerned with only the box-office performance of such films.
View all questions of this test
< Previous Question Next Question >
Explore Courses for GMAT exam

Similar GMAT Doubts

Disruptive innovators can hurt successful and immensely profitable incumbents that tend to ignore the markets most susceptible to disruptive innovations. Disruptive innovators offer technologically straightforward solutions consisting of off-the-shelf components put together in a product architecture that is often simpler, initially lower performing, and cheaper than established approaches. Considering disruptive technologies unprofitable, the executives at incumbents often ignored them at their own and companies peril. In 1981, the old 8 inch drives used in mini computers were vastly superior and much more profitable to the new 5.25 inch drives used in desktop computers. However, 8 inch drives were not affordable for the new desktop machines. Slowly, the makers of 5.25 inch drives improved the performance of the drives and moved the 8 inch drive companies that did not invest in the 5.25 inch technology out of the market as the latter could not compete on price. Similarly, digital cameras, when introduced in 1997 performed extremely poorly as compared to traditional film cameras. Consequently, many traditional film companies such as Kodak ignored this market only to be bankrupted by the rise of digital cameras a decade later.Leaders and strategists should be cautious while rejecting a technology that does not seem to be as high performing and hence not as profitable as their dominant technologies. A technology that initially provides low performance can drastically improve over time and often exceed the performance of the dominant technology at a much lower price-point, a scenario that could potentially bankrupt the incumbents who ignored the technology at their peril.The passage provides information in support of which of the following assertions?

Errors in the performance of repetitive or “boring” tasks—often attributed to a momentary lapse in concentration—can be serious in such activities as flying a passenger aircraft. Is there any method that would provide warning of such lapses—for example by monitoring brain activity? Researchers scanned the brains of volunteers performing a repetitive task. When the tasks were being performed correctly, the volunteers brains showed activity in cognitive-processing regions. However, these regions became less active several seconds before some errors were made, and another brain region, region X, became active. The researchers concluded that the monitoring of region X could provide warning of an impending error.Which of the following, if true, most supports the researchers conclusion?

Directions: Each of these sentence correction practice questions presents a sentence, some or all of which is underlined. Below the sentence you will find five ways of phrasing the underlined part. Option A always repeats the original phrasing, while the other four are different. Choose the answer that produces the most effective sentence based on the requirements of standard written English. Your answer should make the sentence clear, exact, and grammatically correct.Q. The Cluny Museum’s collection of medieval art, such as fifteenth-century tapestries and Gothic sculptures, that were displayed since 1843 is much more impressive when compared to the Metropolitan Museum’s medieval collection that, by and large, required more funding in order to compete on the international stage and not to concede its reputation as one of the world’s foremost museums.

Top Courses for GMATView all

Top Courses for GMAT

A film is more likely to have a complex storyline when it is directed by a director who has won an Academy Award. Regardless of the awards won by the director, a film with a complex storyline is more likely to do badly at the box-office than a film with a story-line that is not complex. Since other causes of poor box-office performance are not related to the awards won by the director, there must be more films with poor box-office collections with Academy Award-winning directors than with directors who have not won any Academy Awards.The argument above is most vulnerable to which one of the following criticisms?a)It ignores the fact that a film that does not do well on the box-office may eventually do well when broadcasted on TV.b)It fails to consider a scenario in which the number of films directed by directors who have not won Academy Awards is significantly more than that directed by directors who have won Academy Awards.c)It identifies one aspect of the films as the sole determinant of their box office performance without considering other possible aspects.d)It fails to consider a scenario in which directors may be aware of the fact that a complex storyline may not translate into a successful box-office collection.e)It fails to factor in the number of films with poor box-office collections that were directed by Academy Award-winning directors and that ultimately won critical acclaim.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?
Question Description
A film is more likely to have a complex storyline when it is directed by a director who has won an Academy Award. Regardless of the awards won by the director, a film with a complex storyline is more likely to do badly at the box-office than a film with a story-line that is not complex. Since other causes of poor box-office performance are not related to the awards won by the director, there must be more films with poor box-office collections with Academy Award-winning directors than with directors who have not won any Academy Awards.The argument above is most vulnerable to which one of the following criticisms?a)It ignores the fact that a film that does not do well on the box-office may eventually do well when broadcasted on TV.b)It fails to consider a scenario in which the number of films directed by directors who have not won Academy Awards is significantly more than that directed by directors who have won Academy Awards.c)It identifies one aspect of the films as the sole determinant of their box office performance without considering other possible aspects.d)It fails to consider a scenario in which directors may be aware of the fact that a complex storyline may not translate into a successful box-office collection.e)It fails to factor in the number of films with poor box-office collections that were directed by Academy Award-winning directors and that ultimately won critical acclaim.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? for GMAT 2024 is part of GMAT preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the GMAT exam syllabus. Information about A film is more likely to have a complex storyline when it is directed by a director who has won an Academy Award. Regardless of the awards won by the director, a film with a complex storyline is more likely to do badly at the box-office than a film with a story-line that is not complex. Since other causes of poor box-office performance are not related to the awards won by the director, there must be more films with poor box-office collections with Academy Award-winning directors than with directors who have not won any Academy Awards.The argument above is most vulnerable to which one of the following criticisms?a)It ignores the fact that a film that does not do well on the box-office may eventually do well when broadcasted on TV.b)It fails to consider a scenario in which the number of films directed by directors who have not won Academy Awards is significantly more than that directed by directors who have won Academy Awards.c)It identifies one aspect of the films as the sole determinant of their box office performance without considering other possible aspects.d)It fails to consider a scenario in which directors may be aware of the fact that a complex storyline may not translate into a successful box-office collection.e)It fails to factor in the number of films with poor box-office collections that were directed by Academy Award-winning directors and that ultimately won critical acclaim.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? covers all topics & solutions for GMAT 2024 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for A film is more likely to have a complex storyline when it is directed by a director who has won an Academy Award. Regardless of the awards won by the director, a film with a complex storyline is more likely to do badly at the box-office than a film with a story-line that is not complex. Since other causes of poor box-office performance are not related to the awards won by the director, there must be more films with poor box-office collections with Academy Award-winning directors than with directors who have not won any Academy Awards.The argument above is most vulnerable to which one of the following criticisms?a)It ignores the fact that a film that does not do well on the box-office may eventually do well when broadcasted on TV.b)It fails to consider a scenario in which the number of films directed by directors who have not won Academy Awards is significantly more than that directed by directors who have won Academy Awards.c)It identifies one aspect of the films as the sole determinant of their box office performance without considering other possible aspects.d)It fails to consider a scenario in which directors may be aware of the fact that a complex storyline may not translate into a successful box-office collection.e)It fails to factor in the number of films with poor box-office collections that were directed by Academy Award-winning directors and that ultimately won critical acclaim.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?.
Solutions for A film is more likely to have a complex storyline when it is directed by a director who has won an Academy Award. Regardless of the awards won by the director, a film with a complex storyline is more likely to do badly at the box-office than a film with a story-line that is not complex. Since other causes of poor box-office performance are not related to the awards won by the director, there must be more films with poor box-office collections with Academy Award-winning directors than with directors who have not won any Academy Awards.The argument above is most vulnerable to which one of the following criticisms?a)It ignores the fact that a film that does not do well on the box-office may eventually do well when broadcasted on TV.b)It fails to consider a scenario in which the number of films directed by directors who have not won Academy Awards is significantly more than that directed by directors who have won Academy Awards.c)It identifies one aspect of the films as the sole determinant of their box office performance without considering other possible aspects.d)It fails to consider a scenario in which directors may be aware of the fact that a complex storyline may not translate into a successful box-office collection.e)It fails to factor in the number of films with poor box-office collections that were directed by Academy Award-winning directors and that ultimately won critical acclaim.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? in English & in Hindi are available as part of our courses for GMAT. Download more important topics, notes, lectures and mock test series for GMAT Exam by signing up for free.
Here you can find the meaning of A film is more likely to have a complex storyline when it is directed by a director who has won an Academy Award. Regardless of the awards won by the director, a film with a complex storyline is more likely to do badly at the box-office than a film with a story-line that is not complex. Since other causes of poor box-office performance are not related to the awards won by the director, there must be more films with poor box-office collections with Academy Award-winning directors than with directors who have not won any Academy Awards.The argument above is most vulnerable to which one of the following criticisms?a)It ignores the fact that a film that does not do well on the box-office may eventually do well when broadcasted on TV.b)It fails to consider a scenario in which the number of films directed by directors who have not won Academy Awards is significantly more than that directed by directors who have won Academy Awards.c)It identifies one aspect of the films as the sole determinant of their box office performance without considering other possible aspects.d)It fails to consider a scenario in which directors may be aware of the fact that a complex storyline may not translate into a successful box-office collection.e)It fails to factor in the number of films with poor box-office collections that were directed by Academy Award-winning directors and that ultimately won critical acclaim.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? defined & explained in the simplest way possible. Besides giving the explanation of A film is more likely to have a complex storyline when it is directed by a director who has won an Academy Award. Regardless of the awards won by the director, a film with a complex storyline is more likely to do badly at the box-office than a film with a story-line that is not complex. Since other causes of poor box-office performance are not related to the awards won by the director, there must be more films with poor box-office collections with Academy Award-winning directors than with directors who have not won any Academy Awards.The argument above is most vulnerable to which one of the following criticisms?a)It ignores the fact that a film that does not do well on the box-office may eventually do well when broadcasted on TV.b)It fails to consider a scenario in which the number of films directed by directors who have not won Academy Awards is significantly more than that directed by directors who have won Academy Awards.c)It identifies one aspect of the films as the sole determinant of their box office performance without considering other possible aspects.d)It fails to consider a scenario in which directors may be aware of the fact that a complex storyline may not translate into a successful box-office collection.e)It fails to factor in the number of films with poor box-office collections that were directed by Academy Award-winning directors and that ultimately won critical acclaim.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?, a detailed solution for A film is more likely to have a complex storyline when it is directed by a director who has won an Academy Award. Regardless of the awards won by the director, a film with a complex storyline is more likely to do badly at the box-office than a film with a story-line that is not complex. Since other causes of poor box-office performance are not related to the awards won by the director, there must be more films with poor box-office collections with Academy Award-winning directors than with directors who have not won any Academy Awards.The argument above is most vulnerable to which one of the following criticisms?a)It ignores the fact that a film that does not do well on the box-office may eventually do well when broadcasted on TV.b)It fails to consider a scenario in which the number of films directed by directors who have not won Academy Awards is significantly more than that directed by directors who have won Academy Awards.c)It identifies one aspect of the films as the sole determinant of their box office performance without considering other possible aspects.d)It fails to consider a scenario in which directors may be aware of the fact that a complex storyline may not translate into a successful box-office collection.e)It fails to factor in the number of films with poor box-office collections that were directed by Academy Award-winning directors and that ultimately won critical acclaim.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? has been provided alongside types of A film is more likely to have a complex storyline when it is directed by a director who has won an Academy Award. Regardless of the awards won by the director, a film with a complex storyline is more likely to do badly at the box-office than a film with a story-line that is not complex. Since other causes of poor box-office performance are not related to the awards won by the director, there must be more films with poor box-office collections with Academy Award-winning directors than with directors who have not won any Academy Awards.The argument above is most vulnerable to which one of the following criticisms?a)It ignores the fact that a film that does not do well on the box-office may eventually do well when broadcasted on TV.b)It fails to consider a scenario in which the number of films directed by directors who have not won Academy Awards is significantly more than that directed by directors who have won Academy Awards.c)It identifies one aspect of the films as the sole determinant of their box office performance without considering other possible aspects.d)It fails to consider a scenario in which directors may be aware of the fact that a complex storyline may not translate into a successful box-office collection.e)It fails to factor in the number of films with poor box-office collections that were directed by Academy Award-winning directors and that ultimately won critical acclaim.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? theory, EduRev gives you an ample number of questions to practice A film is more likely to have a complex storyline when it is directed by a director who has won an Academy Award. Regardless of the awards won by the director, a film with a complex storyline is more likely to do badly at the box-office than a film with a story-line that is not complex. Since other causes of poor box-office performance are not related to the awards won by the director, there must be more films with poor box-office collections with Academy Award-winning directors than with directors who have not won any Academy Awards.The argument above is most vulnerable to which one of the following criticisms?a)It ignores the fact that a film that does not do well on the box-office may eventually do well when broadcasted on TV.b)It fails to consider a scenario in which the number of films directed by directors who have not won Academy Awards is significantly more than that directed by directors who have won Academy Awards.c)It identifies one aspect of the films as the sole determinant of their box office performance without considering other possible aspects.d)It fails to consider a scenario in which directors may be aware of the fact that a complex storyline may not translate into a successful box-office collection.e)It fails to factor in the number of films with poor box-office collections that were directed by Academy Award-winning directors and that ultimately won critical acclaim.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? tests, examples and also practice GMAT tests.
Explore Courses for GMAT exam

Top Courses for GMAT

Explore Courses

Suggested Free Tests

Signup for Free!
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days! Learn & Practice with 1000+ FREE Notes, Videos & Tests.
10M+ students study on EduRev
Get App
© EduRev
Education Revolution
Follow Us
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days!
Access 1000+ FREE Docs, Videos and Tests
Takes less than 10 seconds to signup