CA Foundation Exam  >  CA Foundation Questions  >  Mr. R wrote a letter to Mr. Q asking them to ... Start Learning for Free
Mr. R wrote a letter to Mr. Q asking them to tell at what rate they are selling Alfonso mangos, Mr. Q replied that the current rate is Rs.500/dozen, Mr. R replied, please send 10 dozens of mangos and attached a cheque of required amount, Mr. R upon receipt of the cheque replied that the stock of Mangos is over and he is not in position to supply the mangos, can Mr. R file suit against Mr. Q for non fulfilment of order. Is there a binding contact between Q and R?
Most Upvoted Answer
Mr. R wrote a letter to Mr. Q asking them to tell at what rate they ar...
Answer:


Binding Contract


  • For a contract to be binding, there must be an offer, acceptance, consideration, and intention to create a legal relationship.

  • Mr. R wrote a letter to Mr. Q asking for the rate at which Alfonso mangos are being sold, which can be considered an offer.

  • Mr. Q replied that the current rate is Rs. 500/dozen, which can be considered an acceptance of the offer.

  • Mr. R replied with an order of 10 dozens of mangos and an attached cheque, which can be considered a consideration.

  • Therefore, there is a binding contract between Mr. R and Mr. Q.



Non-Fulfilment of Order


  • Mr. R sent a cheque for the required amount, but Mr. Q replied that the stock of Mangos is over and he is not in a position to supply the mangos.

  • This can be considered a breach of contract by Mr. Q as he was unable to fulfil his obligation under the contract.

  • Therefore, Mr. R can file a suit against Mr. Q for non-fulfilment of the order.



Conclusion


  • There is a binding contract between Mr. R and Mr. Q, and Mr. R can file a suit against Mr. Q for non-fulfilment of the order.

Community Answer
Mr. R wrote a letter to Mr. Q asking them to tell at what rate they ar...
This Case Law is related to Harvey Vs Facie
An Statement of price is not an offer
Hence Mr.R cannot file a suit against Mr .Q for non fullfillment of order
because MrQ just quoted the price .and this doesn't create any offer
Explore Courses for CA Foundation exam

Similar CA Foundation Doubts

Mr. R wrote a letter to Mr. Q asking them to tell at what rate they are selling Alfonso mangos, Mr. Q replied that the current rate is Rs.500/dozen, Mr. R replied, please send 10 dozens of mangos and attached a cheque of required amount, Mr. R upon receipt of the cheque replied that the stock of Mangos is over and he is not in position to supply the mangos, can Mr. R file suit against Mr. Q for non fulfilment of order. Is there a binding contact between Q and R?
Question Description
Mr. R wrote a letter to Mr. Q asking them to tell at what rate they are selling Alfonso mangos, Mr. Q replied that the current rate is Rs.500/dozen, Mr. R replied, please send 10 dozens of mangos and attached a cheque of required amount, Mr. R upon receipt of the cheque replied that the stock of Mangos is over and he is not in position to supply the mangos, can Mr. R file suit against Mr. Q for non fulfilment of order. Is there a binding contact between Q and R? for CA Foundation 2025 is part of CA Foundation preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the CA Foundation exam syllabus. Information about Mr. R wrote a letter to Mr. Q asking them to tell at what rate they are selling Alfonso mangos, Mr. Q replied that the current rate is Rs.500/dozen, Mr. R replied, please send 10 dozens of mangos and attached a cheque of required amount, Mr. R upon receipt of the cheque replied that the stock of Mangos is over and he is not in position to supply the mangos, can Mr. R file suit against Mr. Q for non fulfilment of order. Is there a binding contact between Q and R? covers all topics & solutions for CA Foundation 2025 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for Mr. R wrote a letter to Mr. Q asking them to tell at what rate they are selling Alfonso mangos, Mr. Q replied that the current rate is Rs.500/dozen, Mr. R replied, please send 10 dozens of mangos and attached a cheque of required amount, Mr. R upon receipt of the cheque replied that the stock of Mangos is over and he is not in position to supply the mangos, can Mr. R file suit against Mr. Q for non fulfilment of order. Is there a binding contact between Q and R?.
Solutions for Mr. R wrote a letter to Mr. Q asking them to tell at what rate they are selling Alfonso mangos, Mr. Q replied that the current rate is Rs.500/dozen, Mr. R replied, please send 10 dozens of mangos and attached a cheque of required amount, Mr. R upon receipt of the cheque replied that the stock of Mangos is over and he is not in position to supply the mangos, can Mr. R file suit against Mr. Q for non fulfilment of order. Is there a binding contact between Q and R? in English & in Hindi are available as part of our courses for CA Foundation. Download more important topics, notes, lectures and mock test series for CA Foundation Exam by signing up for free.
Here you can find the meaning of Mr. R wrote a letter to Mr. Q asking them to tell at what rate they are selling Alfonso mangos, Mr. Q replied that the current rate is Rs.500/dozen, Mr. R replied, please send 10 dozens of mangos and attached a cheque of required amount, Mr. R upon receipt of the cheque replied that the stock of Mangos is over and he is not in position to supply the mangos, can Mr. R file suit against Mr. Q for non fulfilment of order. Is there a binding contact between Q and R? defined & explained in the simplest way possible. Besides giving the explanation of Mr. R wrote a letter to Mr. Q asking them to tell at what rate they are selling Alfonso mangos, Mr. Q replied that the current rate is Rs.500/dozen, Mr. R replied, please send 10 dozens of mangos and attached a cheque of required amount, Mr. R upon receipt of the cheque replied that the stock of Mangos is over and he is not in position to supply the mangos, can Mr. R file suit against Mr. Q for non fulfilment of order. Is there a binding contact between Q and R?, a detailed solution for Mr. R wrote a letter to Mr. Q asking them to tell at what rate they are selling Alfonso mangos, Mr. Q replied that the current rate is Rs.500/dozen, Mr. R replied, please send 10 dozens of mangos and attached a cheque of required amount, Mr. R upon receipt of the cheque replied that the stock of Mangos is over and he is not in position to supply the mangos, can Mr. R file suit against Mr. Q for non fulfilment of order. Is there a binding contact between Q and R? has been provided alongside types of Mr. R wrote a letter to Mr. Q asking them to tell at what rate they are selling Alfonso mangos, Mr. Q replied that the current rate is Rs.500/dozen, Mr. R replied, please send 10 dozens of mangos and attached a cheque of required amount, Mr. R upon receipt of the cheque replied that the stock of Mangos is over and he is not in position to supply the mangos, can Mr. R file suit against Mr. Q for non fulfilment of order. Is there a binding contact between Q and R? theory, EduRev gives you an ample number of questions to practice Mr. R wrote a letter to Mr. Q asking them to tell at what rate they are selling Alfonso mangos, Mr. Q replied that the current rate is Rs.500/dozen, Mr. R replied, please send 10 dozens of mangos and attached a cheque of required amount, Mr. R upon receipt of the cheque replied that the stock of Mangos is over and he is not in position to supply the mangos, can Mr. R file suit against Mr. Q for non fulfilment of order. Is there a binding contact between Q and R? tests, examples and also practice CA Foundation tests.
Explore Courses for CA Foundation exam

Top Courses for CA Foundation

Explore Courses
Signup for Free!
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days! Learn & Practice with 1000+ FREE Notes, Videos & Tests.
10M+ students study on EduRev