CLAT Exam > CLAT Questions > Directions: The question consists of two par...
Start Learning for Free
Directions: The question consists of two parts, one labelled as Principles and the other as Facts. You are to examine the principles and apply them to the given facts carefully and select the best option.
Principles:
1: Master is liable for the act of the employee/servant.
2: The husband or the wife is not responsible for any commission of wrong on each other.
Fact: H is a manager of a hotel belonging to X. Because of the negligence of H, a folding chair fell from the first floor to the ground floor, injuring receptionist of the hotel, named W, who is the wife of H. W asks for compensation from X and H.
Decide.
- a)Both X and H are responsible to compensate W.
- b)X is only responsible to compensate W.
- c)H is only responsible to compensate W.
- d)No one is responsible to compensate W.
Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?
Most Upvoted Answer
Directions: The question consists of two parts, one labelled as Princ...
Principles:
1. Master is liable for the act of the employee/servant.
2. The husband or the wife is not responsible for any commission of wrong on each other.
Facts:
H is a manager of a hotel belonging to X. Because of the negligence of H, a folding chair fell from the first floor to the ground floor, injuring the receptionist of the hotel named W, who is the wife of H. W asks for compensation from X and H.
Decision:
The correct answer is option 'B' - X is only responsible to compensate W.
Explanation:
Liability of the Master:
According to the principle of vicarious liability, the master (X) is liable for the acts of his employee/servant (H). In this case, H is the manager of the hotel, and the incident occurred because of his negligence. Therefore, X can be held responsible for the negligence of H.
Exception for Spouses:
However, the second principle states that the husband or wife is not responsible for any commission of wrong on each other. This means that even though H is the husband of W, he cannot be held responsible for the injury caused to W.
Application of Principles to Facts:
Based on the principles and facts given, the liability for the injury caused to W falls solely on X, the owner of the hotel. This is because H, as the employee/servant, is covered under the principle of vicarious liability, and X, as the master, is responsible for the acts of H. The fact that W is the wife of H does not change this liability.
Conclusion:
In conclusion, both principles apply to the given facts. As a result, X, the owner of the hotel, is responsible for compensating W, the injured receptionist. Therefore, the correct answer is option 'B' - X is only responsible to compensate W.
1. Master is liable for the act of the employee/servant.
2. The husband or the wife is not responsible for any commission of wrong on each other.
Facts:
H is a manager of a hotel belonging to X. Because of the negligence of H, a folding chair fell from the first floor to the ground floor, injuring the receptionist of the hotel named W, who is the wife of H. W asks for compensation from X and H.
Decision:
The correct answer is option 'B' - X is only responsible to compensate W.
Explanation:
Liability of the Master:
According to the principle of vicarious liability, the master (X) is liable for the acts of his employee/servant (H). In this case, H is the manager of the hotel, and the incident occurred because of his negligence. Therefore, X can be held responsible for the negligence of H.
Exception for Spouses:
However, the second principle states that the husband or wife is not responsible for any commission of wrong on each other. This means that even though H is the husband of W, he cannot be held responsible for the injury caused to W.
Application of Principles to Facts:
Based on the principles and facts given, the liability for the injury caused to W falls solely on X, the owner of the hotel. This is because H, as the employee/servant, is covered under the principle of vicarious liability, and X, as the master, is responsible for the acts of H. The fact that W is the wife of H does not change this liability.
Conclusion:
In conclusion, both principles apply to the given facts. As a result, X, the owner of the hotel, is responsible for compensating W, the injured receptionist. Therefore, the correct answer is option 'B' - X is only responsible to compensate W.
Free Test
FREE
| Start Free Test |
Community Answer
Directions: The question consists of two parts, one labelled as Princ...
Strictly following the principle, only X is responsible to compensate W. It is because of the negligence of the hotel authorities that a folding chair fell from the first floor to the ground floor and injured W. Also, it is immaterial that the injury occurred because of H, who is a part of hotel team. Moreover, the husband or the wife is not responsible for any commission of wrong on each other. Therefore, only X is liable to compensate W.
|
Explore Courses for CLAT exam
|
|
Similar CLAT Doubts
Top Courses for CLATView all
Directions: The question consists of two parts, one labelled as Principles and the other as Facts. You are to examine the principles and apply them to the given facts carefully and select the best option.Principles:1: Master is liable for the act of the employee/servant.2: The husband or the wife is not responsible for any commission of wrong on each other.Fact: H is a manager of a hotel belonging to X. Because of the negligence of H, a folding chair fell from the first floor to the ground floor, injuring receptionist of the hotel, named W, who is the wife of H. W asks for compensation from X and H.Decide.a)Both X and H are responsible to compensate W.b)X is only responsible to compensate W.c)H is only responsible to compensate W.d)No one is responsible to compensate W.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?
Question Description
Directions: The question consists of two parts, one labelled as Principles and the other as Facts. You are to examine the principles and apply them to the given facts carefully and select the best option.Principles:1: Master is liable for the act of the employee/servant.2: The husband or the wife is not responsible for any commission of wrong on each other.Fact: H is a manager of a hotel belonging to X. Because of the negligence of H, a folding chair fell from the first floor to the ground floor, injuring receptionist of the hotel, named W, who is the wife of H. W asks for compensation from X and H.Decide.a)Both X and H are responsible to compensate W.b)X is only responsible to compensate W.c)H is only responsible to compensate W.d)No one is responsible to compensate W.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? for CLAT 2025 is part of CLAT preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the CLAT exam syllabus. Information about Directions: The question consists of two parts, one labelled as Principles and the other as Facts. You are to examine the principles and apply them to the given facts carefully and select the best option.Principles:1: Master is liable for the act of the employee/servant.2: The husband or the wife is not responsible for any commission of wrong on each other.Fact: H is a manager of a hotel belonging to X. Because of the negligence of H, a folding chair fell from the first floor to the ground floor, injuring receptionist of the hotel, named W, who is the wife of H. W asks for compensation from X and H.Decide.a)Both X and H are responsible to compensate W.b)X is only responsible to compensate W.c)H is only responsible to compensate W.d)No one is responsible to compensate W.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? covers all topics & solutions for CLAT 2025 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for Directions: The question consists of two parts, one labelled as Principles and the other as Facts. You are to examine the principles and apply them to the given facts carefully and select the best option.Principles:1: Master is liable for the act of the employee/servant.2: The husband or the wife is not responsible for any commission of wrong on each other.Fact: H is a manager of a hotel belonging to X. Because of the negligence of H, a folding chair fell from the first floor to the ground floor, injuring receptionist of the hotel, named W, who is the wife of H. W asks for compensation from X and H.Decide.a)Both X and H are responsible to compensate W.b)X is only responsible to compensate W.c)H is only responsible to compensate W.d)No one is responsible to compensate W.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?.
Directions: The question consists of two parts, one labelled as Principles and the other as Facts. You are to examine the principles and apply them to the given facts carefully and select the best option.Principles:1: Master is liable for the act of the employee/servant.2: The husband or the wife is not responsible for any commission of wrong on each other.Fact: H is a manager of a hotel belonging to X. Because of the negligence of H, a folding chair fell from the first floor to the ground floor, injuring receptionist of the hotel, named W, who is the wife of H. W asks for compensation from X and H.Decide.a)Both X and H are responsible to compensate W.b)X is only responsible to compensate W.c)H is only responsible to compensate W.d)No one is responsible to compensate W.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? for CLAT 2025 is part of CLAT preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the CLAT exam syllabus. Information about Directions: The question consists of two parts, one labelled as Principles and the other as Facts. You are to examine the principles and apply them to the given facts carefully and select the best option.Principles:1: Master is liable for the act of the employee/servant.2: The husband or the wife is not responsible for any commission of wrong on each other.Fact: H is a manager of a hotel belonging to X. Because of the negligence of H, a folding chair fell from the first floor to the ground floor, injuring receptionist of the hotel, named W, who is the wife of H. W asks for compensation from X and H.Decide.a)Both X and H are responsible to compensate W.b)X is only responsible to compensate W.c)H is only responsible to compensate W.d)No one is responsible to compensate W.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? covers all topics & solutions for CLAT 2025 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for Directions: The question consists of two parts, one labelled as Principles and the other as Facts. You are to examine the principles and apply them to the given facts carefully and select the best option.Principles:1: Master is liable for the act of the employee/servant.2: The husband or the wife is not responsible for any commission of wrong on each other.Fact: H is a manager of a hotel belonging to X. Because of the negligence of H, a folding chair fell from the first floor to the ground floor, injuring receptionist of the hotel, named W, who is the wife of H. W asks for compensation from X and H.Decide.a)Both X and H are responsible to compensate W.b)X is only responsible to compensate W.c)H is only responsible to compensate W.d)No one is responsible to compensate W.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?.
Solutions for Directions: The question consists of two parts, one labelled as Principles and the other as Facts. You are to examine the principles and apply them to the given facts carefully and select the best option.Principles:1: Master is liable for the act of the employee/servant.2: The husband or the wife is not responsible for any commission of wrong on each other.Fact: H is a manager of a hotel belonging to X. Because of the negligence of H, a folding chair fell from the first floor to the ground floor, injuring receptionist of the hotel, named W, who is the wife of H. W asks for compensation from X and H.Decide.a)Both X and H are responsible to compensate W.b)X is only responsible to compensate W.c)H is only responsible to compensate W.d)No one is responsible to compensate W.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? in English & in Hindi are available as part of our courses for CLAT.
Download more important topics, notes, lectures and mock test series for CLAT Exam by signing up for free.
Here you can find the meaning of Directions: The question consists of two parts, one labelled as Principles and the other as Facts. You are to examine the principles and apply them to the given facts carefully and select the best option.Principles:1: Master is liable for the act of the employee/servant.2: The husband or the wife is not responsible for any commission of wrong on each other.Fact: H is a manager of a hotel belonging to X. Because of the negligence of H, a folding chair fell from the first floor to the ground floor, injuring receptionist of the hotel, named W, who is the wife of H. W asks for compensation from X and H.Decide.a)Both X and H are responsible to compensate W.b)X is only responsible to compensate W.c)H is only responsible to compensate W.d)No one is responsible to compensate W.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? defined & explained in the simplest way possible. Besides giving the explanation of
Directions: The question consists of two parts, one labelled as Principles and the other as Facts. You are to examine the principles and apply them to the given facts carefully and select the best option.Principles:1: Master is liable for the act of the employee/servant.2: The husband or the wife is not responsible for any commission of wrong on each other.Fact: H is a manager of a hotel belonging to X. Because of the negligence of H, a folding chair fell from the first floor to the ground floor, injuring receptionist of the hotel, named W, who is the wife of H. W asks for compensation from X and H.Decide.a)Both X and H are responsible to compensate W.b)X is only responsible to compensate W.c)H is only responsible to compensate W.d)No one is responsible to compensate W.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?, a detailed solution for Directions: The question consists of two parts, one labelled as Principles and the other as Facts. You are to examine the principles and apply them to the given facts carefully and select the best option.Principles:1: Master is liable for the act of the employee/servant.2: The husband or the wife is not responsible for any commission of wrong on each other.Fact: H is a manager of a hotel belonging to X. Because of the negligence of H, a folding chair fell from the first floor to the ground floor, injuring receptionist of the hotel, named W, who is the wife of H. W asks for compensation from X and H.Decide.a)Both X and H are responsible to compensate W.b)X is only responsible to compensate W.c)H is only responsible to compensate W.d)No one is responsible to compensate W.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? has been provided alongside types of Directions: The question consists of two parts, one labelled as Principles and the other as Facts. You are to examine the principles and apply them to the given facts carefully and select the best option.Principles:1: Master is liable for the act of the employee/servant.2: The husband or the wife is not responsible for any commission of wrong on each other.Fact: H is a manager of a hotel belonging to X. Because of the negligence of H, a folding chair fell from the first floor to the ground floor, injuring receptionist of the hotel, named W, who is the wife of H. W asks for compensation from X and H.Decide.a)Both X and H are responsible to compensate W.b)X is only responsible to compensate W.c)H is only responsible to compensate W.d)No one is responsible to compensate W.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? theory, EduRev gives you an
ample number of questions to practice Directions: The question consists of two parts, one labelled as Principles and the other as Facts. You are to examine the principles and apply them to the given facts carefully and select the best option.Principles:1: Master is liable for the act of the employee/servant.2: The husband or the wife is not responsible for any commission of wrong on each other.Fact: H is a manager of a hotel belonging to X. Because of the negligence of H, a folding chair fell from the first floor to the ground floor, injuring receptionist of the hotel, named W, who is the wife of H. W asks for compensation from X and H.Decide.a)Both X and H are responsible to compensate W.b)X is only responsible to compensate W.c)H is only responsible to compensate W.d)No one is responsible to compensate W.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? tests, examples and also practice CLAT tests.
|
|
Explore Courses for CLAT exam
|
|
Signup for Free!
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days! Learn & Practice with 1000+ FREE Notes, Videos & Tests.
|
© EduRev
|
Education Revolution
|
|
Signup to see your scores
go up within 7 days!
Access 1000+ FREE Docs, Videos and Tests
Takes less than 10 seconds to signup