CA Foundation Exam > CA Foundation Questions > Can you explain the answer of this question b...
Start Learning for Free
Can you explain the answer of this question below:
X purchased papers from Y and resold them to Z, who found that the papers were infected with white ants and returned them to X. Can X return the goods to Y?
- A:No
- B:Yes
- C:Z has to return directly
- D:None of the above
The answer is a.
Most Upvoted Answer
Can you explain the answer of this question below:X purchased papers f...
The seller can always claim the benefit of doctrine of Caveat Emptor i.e. let the buyer be aware.
If at the time of purchasing goods from X, Z pointed out that they were infected with white ants so Z can return them to X as he had been beware and diligent.
On the other hand X had already purchased the goods from Y and did not make any complain about the papers being infected .
Therefore, X cannot now return the goods to Y.
Free Test
FREE
| Start Free Test |
Community Answer
Can you explain the answer of this question below:X purchased papers f...
Answer:
No, X cannot return the goods to Y.
Explanation:
There are certain principles of sale of goods that apply to this situation. One of the important principles is that of caveat emptor, which means "buyer beware". This principle implies that the buyer is responsible for checking the goods before buying them and cannot hold the seller responsible for any defects or problems found after the sale.
In this case, X purchased the papers from Y and resold them to Z without checking them for defects. Z found that the papers were infected with white ants and returned them to X. Since X did not check the papers before reselling them, they cannot hold Y responsible for the defect. Therefore, X cannot return the goods to Y.
Another principle that applies to this situation is that of privity of contract, which means that only the parties to a contract can enforce its terms. Y and X had a contract of sale, and Z and X had a contract of sale. Y and Z did not have a contract of sale, so Z cannot directly return the goods to Y.
In conclusion, since X cannot hold Y responsible for the defect and Z cannot directly return the goods to Y, X has to bear the loss and cannot return the goods to Y.
No, X cannot return the goods to Y.
Explanation:
There are certain principles of sale of goods that apply to this situation. One of the important principles is that of caveat emptor, which means "buyer beware". This principle implies that the buyer is responsible for checking the goods before buying them and cannot hold the seller responsible for any defects or problems found after the sale.
In this case, X purchased the papers from Y and resold them to Z without checking them for defects. Z found that the papers were infected with white ants and returned them to X. Since X did not check the papers before reselling them, they cannot hold Y responsible for the defect. Therefore, X cannot return the goods to Y.
Another principle that applies to this situation is that of privity of contract, which means that only the parties to a contract can enforce its terms. Y and X had a contract of sale, and Z and X had a contract of sale. Y and Z did not have a contract of sale, so Z cannot directly return the goods to Y.
In conclusion, since X cannot hold Y responsible for the defect and Z cannot directly return the goods to Y, X has to bear the loss and cannot return the goods to Y.
|
Explore Courses for CA Foundation exam
|
|
Similar CA Foundation Doubts
Top Courses for CA FoundationView all
Can you explain the answer of this question below:X purchased papers from Y and resold them to Z, who found that the papers were infected with white ants and returned them to X. Can X return the goods to Y?A:NoB:YesC:Z has to return directlyD:None of the aboveThe answer is a.
Question Description
Can you explain the answer of this question below:X purchased papers from Y and resold them to Z, who found that the papers were infected with white ants and returned them to X. Can X return the goods to Y?A:NoB:YesC:Z has to return directlyD:None of the aboveThe answer is a. for CA Foundation 2025 is part of CA Foundation preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the CA Foundation exam syllabus. Information about Can you explain the answer of this question below:X purchased papers from Y and resold them to Z, who found that the papers were infected with white ants and returned them to X. Can X return the goods to Y?A:NoB:YesC:Z has to return directlyD:None of the aboveThe answer is a. covers all topics & solutions for CA Foundation 2025 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for Can you explain the answer of this question below:X purchased papers from Y and resold them to Z, who found that the papers were infected with white ants and returned them to X. Can X return the goods to Y?A:NoB:YesC:Z has to return directlyD:None of the aboveThe answer is a..
Can you explain the answer of this question below:X purchased papers from Y and resold them to Z, who found that the papers were infected with white ants and returned them to X. Can X return the goods to Y?A:NoB:YesC:Z has to return directlyD:None of the aboveThe answer is a. for CA Foundation 2025 is part of CA Foundation preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the CA Foundation exam syllabus. Information about Can you explain the answer of this question below:X purchased papers from Y and resold them to Z, who found that the papers were infected with white ants and returned them to X. Can X return the goods to Y?A:NoB:YesC:Z has to return directlyD:None of the aboveThe answer is a. covers all topics & solutions for CA Foundation 2025 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for Can you explain the answer of this question below:X purchased papers from Y and resold them to Z, who found that the papers were infected with white ants and returned them to X. Can X return the goods to Y?A:NoB:YesC:Z has to return directlyD:None of the aboveThe answer is a..
Solutions for Can you explain the answer of this question below:X purchased papers from Y and resold them to Z, who found that the papers were infected with white ants and returned them to X. Can X return the goods to Y?A:NoB:YesC:Z has to return directlyD:None of the aboveThe answer is a. in English & in Hindi are available as part of our courses for CA Foundation.
Download more important topics, notes, lectures and mock test series for CA Foundation Exam by signing up for free.
Here you can find the meaning of Can you explain the answer of this question below:X purchased papers from Y and resold them to Z, who found that the papers were infected with white ants and returned them to X. Can X return the goods to Y?A:NoB:YesC:Z has to return directlyD:None of the aboveThe answer is a. defined & explained in the simplest way possible. Besides giving the explanation of
Can you explain the answer of this question below:X purchased papers from Y and resold them to Z, who found that the papers were infected with white ants and returned them to X. Can X return the goods to Y?A:NoB:YesC:Z has to return directlyD:None of the aboveThe answer is a., a detailed solution for Can you explain the answer of this question below:X purchased papers from Y and resold them to Z, who found that the papers were infected with white ants and returned them to X. Can X return the goods to Y?A:NoB:YesC:Z has to return directlyD:None of the aboveThe answer is a. has been provided alongside types of Can you explain the answer of this question below:X purchased papers from Y and resold them to Z, who found that the papers were infected with white ants and returned them to X. Can X return the goods to Y?A:NoB:YesC:Z has to return directlyD:None of the aboveThe answer is a. theory, EduRev gives you an
ample number of questions to practice Can you explain the answer of this question below:X purchased papers from Y and resold them to Z, who found that the papers were infected with white ants and returned them to X. Can X return the goods to Y?A:NoB:YesC:Z has to return directlyD:None of the aboveThe answer is a. tests, examples and also practice CA Foundation tests.
|
|
Explore Courses for CA Foundation exam
|
|
Signup for Free!
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days! Learn & Practice with 1000+ FREE Notes, Videos & Tests.
|
© EduRev
|
Education Revolution
|
|
Signup to see your scores
go up
within 7 days!
within 7 days!
Takes less than 10 seconds to signup