X agrees to sell to Y “one hundred tons of oil”. State the position of this agreement in the following cases.Q.If X, who is a dealer in coconut oil only, decides to sell @ Rs. 10,000/ton.a)Valid contractb)Void contractc)Voidable contractd)Uncertain contractCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer?

Question

X agrees to sell to Y &#8220;one hundred tons of oil&#8221;. State the position of this agreement in the following cases.Q.If X, who is a dealer in coconut oil only, decides to sell @ Rs. 10,000/ton.a)Valid contractb)Void contractc)Voidable contractd)Uncertain contractCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer?

Answer

In the question it is clearly mentioned that X is dealer of COCONUT OIL only.
so while making contract it is known that the oil which X will sell will be Coconut oil.
so the contract is valid.

Answer

The position of the agreement between X and Y, where X agrees to sell 'one hundred tons of oil' to Y, in the given case is a valid contract. Here's why:
1. Offer and Acceptance:
- X, the dealer in coconut oil, has made an offer to sell one hundred tons of oil to Y.
- Y has accepted this offer by agreeing to buy the oil.
2. Intention to Create Legal Relations:
- Both X and Y have entered into this agreement with the intention to create a legally binding contract.
3. Consensus ad Idem:
- There is a clear consensus between X and Y regarding the subject matter of the contract, i.e., one hundred tons of oil.
- The terms of the agreement are sufficiently certain and agreed upon by both parties.
4. Lawful Consideration:
- The consideration for the contract is the price of Rs. 10,000 per ton.
- This consideration is lawful and valuable.
5. Capacity to Contract:
- Both X and Y are assumed to have the legal capacity to enter into a contract.
- There is no indication of any incapacity or legal impediments in the given case.
6. Legal Formalities:
- There are no specific legal formalities required for this type of contract.
- The contract does not mention any specific requirements for its validity.
Based on these factors, it can be concluded that the agreement between X and Y is a valid contract. Both parties have willingly entered into the agreement with a clear understanding of the terms and conditions.

Answer

Valid contract

A valid contract is an agreement that satisfies all the essential elements required for a legally binding contract. Let's analyze the given case to determine if the agreement between X and Y is a valid contract.

Offer and Acceptance:
- X, the dealer in coconut oil, has clearly expressed their intention to sell 100 tons of oil to Y.
- Y has accepted the offer by agreeing to purchase the oil.

Legal Capacity:
- Both X and Y are assumed to have the legal capacity to enter into a contract, as no information is provided to suggest otherwise.

Consideration:
- The consideration in this case is the price of the oil, which is Rs. 10,000 per ton.
- X agrees to sell the oil, and Y agrees to pay the specified amount.

Lawful Object:
- The object of the agreement, i.e., the purchase and sale of oil, is lawful and does not violate any legal provisions.

Free Consent:
- There is no information provided to suggest any coercion, undue influence, fraud, misrepresentation, or mistake that would affect the free consent of either party.

Certainty:
- The quantity of oil to be sold, i.e., 100 tons, is clearly specified in the agreement.
- The price per ton, i.e., Rs. 10,000, is also clearly stated.

Formalities:
- No specific formalities are required for this type of contract, and there is no mention of any specific formalities in the given case.

Based on the analysis of the essential elements of a valid contract, it can be concluded that the agreement between X and Y is a valid contract. Both parties have expressed their intention to enter into a legally binding agreement, and all the essential elements of a contract are present. Therefore, the correct answer is option 'A' - a valid contract.

Similar CA Foundation Doubts

R contracts to sell his car to S for rs.7 lakhs and s agrees to pay on delivery.once the car is delivered to S and S pays rs.7 lakhs,contract comes to an end .this is called?

Some case studies relating to this cbhapter Related: Nature of Contracts (Part-1) - The Indian Contract Act 1872?

When an inferior right accruing to a party in a contract merges into a superior right accruing to the same party, then

Law of contract (

Top Courses for CA FoundationView all

Quantitative Aptitude for CA Foundation

Principles and Practice of Accounting

Business Laws for CA Foundation

Business Economics for CA Foundation

Mock Tests & Past Year Papers for CA Foundation

Top Courses for CA Foundation

Top Courses for CA Foundation

Suggested Free Tests

Related Content

CA Foundation Courses

Other Courses

How To Prepare?

Other Exams

Company