Why is the definition of democracy as "rule by the people" considered ...
The definition of democracy as "rule by the people" is considered inadequate because it does not address the type of elections held. This definition might include governments that hold elections but do not meet other democratic criteria, such as fair and free elections. Therefore, while the basic idea of people ruling is central, the specifics of how elections are conducted and how power is exercised are crucial for a fuller understanding of democracy.
View all questions of this test
Why is the definition of democracy as "rule by the people" considered ...
Understanding the Inadequacy of "Rule by the People"
The phrase "rule by the people" is often used to define democracy, but it fails to capture the complexities of different governmental systems. Here’s why option 'B' is correct:
Types of Elections Matter
- Nature of Elections: The definition does not specify the nature of elections held in a democracy. Different systems can claim to be democratic while having vastly different election processes.
- Free and Fair Elections: In a true democracy, elections should be free, fair, and competitive. Many governments may hold elections but manipulate them, undermining the democratic essence.
Variety of Electoral Systems
- Electoral Methods: Democracies can employ various electoral methods (e.g., first-past-the-post, proportional representation) that significantly affect how representative the government is of the people's will.
- Frequency of Elections: The frequency and accessibility of elections also play a crucial role. A country may hold regular elections, but if they are not open or fair, the government may not genuinely reflect the people's choice.
Conclusion
In summary, while "rule by the people" sounds democratic, it does not adequately differentiate governments based on how elections are conducted. Understanding the type of elections—whether they are fair, free, and representative—is crucial for distinguishing between true democracies and those that merely claim to be democratic.
To make sure you are not studying endlessly, EduRev has designed Class 9 study material, with Structured Courses, Videos, & Test Series. Plus get personalized analysis, doubt solving and improvement plans to achieve a great score in Class 9.